Michigan 20, Northwestern 17 Comment Count

Adam Schnepp September 29th, 2018 at 10:05 PM

[Fuller]

It’s not just that they came back to win, it's how quickly things turned in the beginning. Michigan had the braggadocio to take the ball after winning the coin toss; they were then hit squarely in the face, took a nasty shot to the body, then took another one to the face. These were not the kind of hits that come together over a long stretch to wear someone down. These were the kind that rock you to your core, that are designed to get you to pack it in and move on.

They didn’t, though. It took those three shots to jar much productivity out of Michigan, which gained –1, 1, and 21 yards on its first three drives. But on the fourth drive, Michigan was able to find success with both the conventional (a handoff to Ben Mason on 3rd-and-1, Karan Higdon’s violent running up the middle) and the bizarre (a play featuring jet action with Ambry Thomas followed by a faked handoff to Higdon and a flipped ball to Donovan Peoples-Jones on an end around, which resulted in DPJ outrunning The Gaz up the sideline and 25 yards).

That drive didn’t do much to cleanse the palate, as both teams played hot potato with offensive futility on the next four drives. Northwestern’s offensive line had difficulties throughout the game, particularly with heart-consuming Chase Winovich and his defensive line compatriots. The line pushed Northwestern to 3rd-and-13 on their fourth drive only to be granted a fresh set of downs on a Lavert Hill hold. That fresh set didn’t matter, as it ended with Winovich running down a play from the backside and Winovich bulling back a lineman and diving at the legs of Clayton Thorson as Kwtiy Paye unloaded on him.

Michigan, which ended the day with 11 penalties for 100 yards, saw 4th-and-3 from Northwestern’s 41 on their fifth drive turn into 4th-and-8 when Zach Gentry moved early. On their next drive, a 15-yard Shea Patterson run was wiped out on a Jon Runyan hold, flipping 1st-and-10 to 2nd-and-20. Nico Collins caught a quick pass from Patterson and ended up with 17 of the 20 necessary yards, but he stayed in bounds, allowing the clock to dwindle. Collins caught a pass on the next play as well, but his toe was out of bounds and Michigan’s chance to cap the half with optimism went out with it.

Until Pat Fitzgerald stepped up to the plate, that is. Fitzgerald wasted two of his timeouts trying to…ice Will Hart? Maybe? No, that’s not a thing. He wasted the timeouts anyhow, ran one play after receiving the ball, then let the clock run out, giving Michigan the biggest, best gift you could ever get Don Brown: halftime.

43185850360_eac7d3f21f_z.jpg

[Fuller]

Northwestern had the ball six times in the second half. On those six drives, they scored zero points. In the third quarter, they ran the ball seven times for two yards and passed two times for 22 yards. In the fourth quarter, they rushed five times for –11 yards and passed four times for 43 yards. Brown and his safeties adjusted to Fitzgerald’s All Slants offense while the defensive line continued its dominance irrespective of personnel; Rashan Gary was injured in the third quarter, and his absence opened the door for increased rotation from some of the younger linemen. Kwity Paye looked capable, generating pressure often and finishing with two TFLs and two sacks. Michael Dwumfour flashed his Hurstian first step a few times and found himself flushing Thorson into converging teammates on third down on Northwestern’s next-to-last drive. Josh Uche also finished with two TFLs and two sacks, including the one that sealed the game.

Michigan did not have the lead until the four-minute mark in the fourth quarter, with two third-quarter Nordin field goals keeping them within striking distance. Then, on Michigan’s tenth drive, Shea Patterson started to look like himself. Patterson’s throws looked hurried and slightly off their typical dead-on placement until he hit Zach Gentry for 13 yards on an out to the sideline and again for 22 yards later with a ball that arrived just before the Northwestern defensive back’s hands. Karan Higdon took care of the rest, bouncing for a yard to the Northwestern five-yard and then running into the end zone almost untouched on the next play; he finished with 115 yards on 30 carries.

30061238187_d8a0779615_z.jpg

[Barron]

Higdon was a key component of Michigan’s final drive, taking a second-and-10 carry five yards, then seeing a cutback lane on the next play that he hit hard only to come up a yard short. Michigan let the clock run down to 46 seconds, took a timeout, and sent the offense back onto the field. An attempt to draw Northwestern offside proved futile, however, and Michigan took the delay of game penalty in order to punt.

Northwestern’s panic offense found some success, completing passes of nine, 10, and 15 yards to move from their own 15-yard line to almost midfield. Then, on 2nd-and-10, Winovich found himself the recipient of a double team, while Uche bent the corner on the opposite side and wrapped up Thorson with form that had to make defensive line coaches around the country smile. The clock ran out, and Michigan escaped with the slim lead they took all game to build.

There will be another football with a winning score placed in the glass display case at Schembechler Hall, but that doesn’t leave Michigan without much work to do. The offense looked out of sync most of the evening, with receivers sometimes seeming to not anticipate the ball coming their way. Receivers also flubbed opportunities to eek out extra yards or run out of bounds and stop the clock. The defense, for as much work as they were able to do at halftime, will be looking once again at how to stop quick slants.

And then there were the penalties. Minus the phantom holding call on Karan Higdon (!), Michigan gave away field position, ended drives, and breathed life into Northwestern by way of mental miscues. The silver lining in the sloppiness is that Michigan will not only get an opportunity to work on those things from the friendly confines of Michigan Stadium next Saturday afternoon, but they will get an opportunity to work on them with their larger goals still intact.

Comments

schreibee

September 30th, 2018 at 5:03 PM ^

ND's QB also made amazing throws we didn't think he could make in the 1st Q.

His ass is benched now! 

Don Brown does what he does until you beat it, and THEN he adjusts & stuffs it.

Saying they should be prepared for plays teams have never run before, executed at a level they've never demonstrated they're capable of is asking a BIT much, No?!

M-jed

September 30th, 2018 at 11:15 AM ^

This is the exact opposite of the hand wringing done last week when UM intercepted a pass that would’ve gone for a TD if not tipped. Michigan doesn’t dictate everything and sometimes players make plays. It’s ok that NW played really well for a while before succumbing to a better D. I agree, though, that we can’t spot better teams such a big lead. 

bluebloodedfan

September 30th, 2018 at 1:23 AM ^

Every team has to adjust to what the other team is trying to do. They had two weeks to prepare for us and were resting their seasons hope on this game while rallying around Larkin’s retirement. I expected them to scheme hard. The fact remains he made the adjustments and we won. Sour grapes are not quite as sour when we win... cause we like won and stuff 

1VaBlue1

September 30th, 2018 at 9:11 AM ^

NW had a bye last week, so they spent two full weeks getting ready to beat Michigan.  The fact that they came up with something that only worked for ONE quarter is very good news.  Yeah, not much of an offense, but their defense is better than decent and it played well.  They were primed and emotional for this game.  Larkin's retirement announcement wasn't made in a vacuum, NW probably had all two weeks to setup with Moten.  It surprised us, not them.

Robbie Moore

September 30th, 2018 at 11:21 AM ^

Why are adjustments necessary in the first place? Because, maybe, there is another team on the field? Who have decent coaches who can do a good job of scheming? Who have decent players who can execute? 

What the hell is game management if not adjusting to changing circumstances? Any smart fan could manage a game clock. Seriously. But very few coaches can adjust on the fly to things happening differently than expected. THAT is great game management.

kehnonymous

September 29th, 2018 at 10:21 PM ^

We all complain about the toxicity of snowflake threads.... I wonder if we made a Snowflake - Refs thread, would it a) capture all the collective toxicity and keep it contained or b) create a critical mass of toxicity that devours the entire multiverse?

stephenrjking

September 29th, 2018 at 10:22 PM ^

The boxing analogy about the beginning of the game is interesting.

Michigan has a road problem. I'm not one of those guys that tries to find some ethereal force that has affected Michigan on the road for umpteen million years; yes, quality road wins have been tough to come by. But the issue we can address is the Harbaugh regime.

And Michigan opens most road games in the Harbaugh regime by leading with their chin. Arms to the sides, lead feet, the whole bit.

It's not universal, but it's a problem. In both road games this season Michigan's offense has been disjointed early, and the defense has been just rough enough to give up three scores. In both games the team adjusted, fought, and clawed its way back into the game. The defense downloaded the opponent, and the offense was able to make just enough hay to put the game into balance in the fourth quarter.

It's not that the game plan is bad or that the players are choking, but they seem genuinely a bit taken aback by the challenges of playing on the road. Ambry, for example, running out the opening kick, unprepared for how much slower and sloppier Northwestern's field is. Shea Patterson getting great protection (!) and bugging out early anyway. Sean Mckeon dropping an easy catch. Just the first kick runback and the bad offensive possession gave Northwestern great field position which they capitalized on. 

The only road game that I can remember in the Harbaugh regime that wasn't a disappointment was against Rutgers. Which, c'mon, it's Rutgers. And maaaaaybe OSU in 2016 (some bad plays aside, the team came to play from the gun, and the worst plays were made by a guy sitting on the bench at UCLA). Even wins like MSU in 2016 were way closer than they should have been. Iowa was a disaster. 

I hate to say this, but I kind of admire Brian Kelly's effort to address road game issues by throwing weird variables into practice. We made fun of it when we read the article, and I think some of the ideas are bizarre, but the principle is not: Teach the team to deal with unusual, unpredictable events and keep executing. 

The Michigan team we've just seen fought well. They've got guts and some talent. But they need to be better to win our big road games. Good from the getgo. 

socalwolverine1

September 30th, 2018 at 12:38 AM ^

"Michigan has a road problem."  Thank you for saying this. Not that it's an epiphany for anyone who has been paying attention. We fucking suck on the road, and that's 100% on the coaching staff. The first half play calling is ALWAYS ultra conservative, like we're just trying to probe the defense (as if we haven't already heavily scouted them, FFS), and instead of actually trying to aggressively score points, we just dick around until we've dug a big hole.    

blue90

September 29th, 2018 at 10:23 PM ^

Not the best game :/ We are still struggling against inferior opponents for some reason and I can’t figure it out.  I think Pep isn’t all that great and we are bogged down a bit by the fact that harbaugh is so insistent on his ways and refuses to change but I still believe in him though not in Pep. We need to be WAY less conservative. Where was DJP, we need more from a sophomore receiver who was a 5 star. Higdon was his usual awesome self and the refs sucked but what’s new? Hopefully we improve greatly in the next two weeks because that three game stretch is gonna be difficult. Hoping we get 2/3 but we’ll see.

massblue

September 29th, 2018 at 10:25 PM ^

I don’t understand all the negativity. NW is a good team despite their record. Their QB was and is still considered an NFL prospect. NW had two weeks to prepare and save their season. Still, we ended up with 376 yards of offense and a W while shutting them down almost completely.  This was a good win. 

blue90

September 29th, 2018 at 10:30 PM ^

They have an incorrectly assessed nfl QB who probs won’t see any playing time in the pros and mind you, nothing else, literally but one good d-end.  They are not a good team, if you think NW is a good team, you gotta watch more football buddy. I give them a bit of cred for having two weeks to prepare but this game should have been 30-10ish.  We got ALOT of work to do to have a change against Wisky, PSU and OSU.

Stringer Bell

September 29th, 2018 at 10:40 PM ^

They have a legitimately good, top 25 defense that had 2 weeks to prepare for us.  In that context, putting up almost 400 yards (which would've easily surpassed 400 if not for the McKeon drop and egregious Higdon holding call) and almost 200 yards rushing is an encouraging performance.  Biggest thing IMO is our inability to defend slant routes, that must get cleaned up.

blue90

September 29th, 2018 at 10:50 PM ^

NW defense averages 380, we got 376, they are 1-2, now 1-3, if we're okay beating this kind of team 20-17 then we aren't going to get far.  The top programs are good because they accept nothing but the best. If we accept 20-17 as a "good" win then we will never get anywhere. Good win, bad win, whatever. My main point still stands, we have A FAR way to go to beat Wisky, PSU, and OSU, a very far way.

GarMoe

September 30th, 2018 at 5:53 AM ^

Yes, it comes down to what we’re willing to accept as a solid game from the team.  Pointing out that it was less than stellar, brings out concern trolls attacking anyone who expresses the opinion that we need improvement(s).  I’d rather hear those providing constructive criticism - fully accurate or not - rather than the snowflakes (often via insults) claiming everything went great and anyone expressing differently are uninformed idiots.  

Amaznbluedoc

September 29th, 2018 at 11:01 PM ^

This year’s NW is not a good team but Fitz has a way of beating Power 5 teams.   Yes, the officiating was terrible but if M were dominant, it shouldn’t matter.  Again we were sloppy, undisciplined, and underwhelming on O.  NW’s D is middling, a hair better statistically than Wastern.  Power O calls need to stop.  Receivers need to get separation.  Excuses need to stop.

I’m watching Ohio and PisSU and there is no way at this rate do I see us beating these teams.  We supposedly have 4&5* kids but with this coaching staff they don’t seem to be making the incremental improvements week to week.  Sure there are some standouts like Winovich but the team just doesn’t seem to materialize as a unit.

BlindTiger

September 29th, 2018 at 11:36 PM ^

I largely agree but disagree in that I think the defense is a unit.  If there is a concern there I think it's actually the corners, which were supposed to be a strength. 

Oline is the biggest concern area still.  The protection was actually pretty good for Patterson, but they were getting blown off the ball and Higdon had way too many 1 and 2 yard carries as a result. I liked what I saw out of Shea as the game progressed, but he was not comfortable early and it showed. 

Still, they gutted out a tough win on the road coming back from down 17. Plenty of work to do as it doesn't get easier from here.

Reader71

September 29th, 2018 at 11:01 PM ^

Without pulling up the chart, I don’t recall giving them many short fields. Our offense in the first half was weak, but the punt game was strong. No turnovers. Short field doesn’t apply here, as far as I can recall.

But their defense is pretty good. Not good enough to explain our weakness on third- and fourth-and-short. I didn’t hate our line today, except on a few short yardage downs.

Muttley

September 30th, 2018 at 12:49 AM ^

The first three NW drives followed:

 

M 4th & 11 at MICH 16

(14:54 - 1st) Will Hart punt for 56 yds, punt out-of-bounds at the Nwest 44 , Riley Lees returns for 16 yds to the Nwest 44.  (NW drives for TD)

M 4th & 9 at MICH 15

(10:17 - 1st) Will Hart punt for 54 yds , Riley Lees returns for 5 yds to the Nwest 36. (NW drives for FG)

M 4th & 1 at NW 48

(2:17 - 1st) Karan Higdon run for no gain to the Nwest 48.  (NW drives for TD)