Friday Recruitin' Joins the #FreeArnett Movement Comment Count

Ace

I am officially back from vacation and gearing up for the stretch run to Signing Day 2012. Usual request: please contact me via email or Twitter (or leave a comment) with any suggestions, tips, or links you think should show up in the next recruiting roundup.

#FreeArnett

Remember DeAnthony Arnett, the 2011 four-star receiver from Saginaw who ultimately decided to attend Tennessee? He's looking to transfer close to home to be with his ailing father, who—according to a statement released by Arnett himself—has had two recent heart attacks and undergone dialysis. Arnett was strongly considering both Michigan and Michigan State during the recruiting process, and ideally he'd like to join one of those two programs while helping his family deal with his father's health issues.

Simple, right? Not in the SEC. Here's some epic scumbaggery courtesy of Tennessee coach Derek Dooley (quoted from Arnett's statement):

Coach Dooley has singled two programs that I can’t get an unconditional release to and they are the University of Michigan and Michigan State University.

He told me I can attend any Mid American Conference school I want and if I wanted to attend either The University of Michigan or Michigan State University I would have to pay for school instead of be on scholarship. I don’t know what’s next. My family can’t afford to pay for school, but my father’s poor health isn’t a good enough excuse for me to attend a BCS school close to home.

Therefore as a student athlete I feel coach Dooley is trying to hinder my success by not allowing me to compete at a BCS level and neglecting the fact my father is severely ill.

Tennessee's rationale is that they have "a policy of not releasing players to schools Tennessee plays or recruits against," according to a school spokesman. That same spokesman said that UT is not denying Arnett the opportunity to play FBS-level football, which is technically true, but have you ever watched the MAC? To say this goes against all moral and rational reasoning and instead sits firmly in the realm of petty absurdity is putting it lightly. MaizePages even adds hypocrisy to the list of Tennessee missteps in handling this situation:

What's worse is that Dooley's decision, with the assumed support of the athletic department and University president given their silence on the issue, also represents the height of hypocricy. The Vols benefited from a similar situation just a few years ago. In 2007, hoops star Tyler Smith was granted a full release by Iowa so he could be closer to his family since his father was battling cancer. Smith, who grew up a Vols fan, also requested and received a waiver from the NCAA not to sit out a season due to "extenuating family circumstances." Iowa did what was right for the student-athlete; Bruce Pearl and Tennessee happily took him in.

Yes, Michigan could really use a receiver of Arnett's abilities—he recorded 24 catches as a true freshman this season—but this is about what's right, not what could benefit the Wolverines on the field. Arnett could go to U-M or MSU next year regardless of Tennessee granting a waiver if his family paid his way through his first year at school, but he made it clear in his statement that isn't an option. Instead, he can either hope an appeal to Tennessee allows him to transfer to a Big Ten school without losing his scholarship for a season, or he'll likely be forced to transfer to a MAC school in order to be close to his family. The situation is especially unfortunate considering that not only are Michigan and MSU the two schools with the best football programs for Arnett, but they're the two FBS schools in the state with the best academics as well.

#FreeArnett

Just No Stomping, Mr. Garnett

Sam Webb's latest DetNews feature is on Josh Garnett, who talks about an on-field mean streak that he had to tone down after spending his junior year "just looking for a fight" on every play. Though he's chilled out a little between the lines, Garnett still says he's "like [Ndamukong] Suh, but on offense," which sounds pretty awesome to me. Here's the blue-chip OL prospect on how he could fit in along the offensive line:

"I think I'll play wherever I need to go first — tackle, guard, or center," Garnett said when asked to describe his game. "Athletically the coaches are telling me I (am capable of) definitely playing those spots. I do think guard is where I'm going to be able to excel the most. I've got big lower legs, I've got great technique, and good hands. I'm good at hand fighting so I think at guard I can use my abilities to come down on linebackers pretty tough and pull around those corners on a lot of those power plays."

Garnett will decide between Michigan, Notre Dame, and Stanford at the end of January—he decided against taking a visit to Miami this month—and he's leaving the logistics of his announcement up to his twin sister. That choice will come sometime after his official visit to Stanford, which is slated for the weekend of the 14th.

As for others along the O-line, Alex Kozan is considering taking a fifth official visit ($, info in header) to either Oklahoma or Oregon—his previous officials have been to Iowa, Ohio State, Michigan, and Auburn. Meanwhile, Jordan Diamond is "not close" to a decision ($, info in header), and he has yet to narrow his list of schools from a final eight.

One piece of big news to come in over the break is that four-star cornerback and current Penn State commit Armani Reeves will take an official visit to Michigan ($, info in header), though the visit hasn't yet been finalized:

"He'll visit Penn State January 13, so we have a few weekends after that we could probably get, though the basketball schedule is kind of crazy. We definitely want to get him out there. What we've done is keep in contact with the schools that have shown most the interest in him, Michigan, Notre Dame and Ohio State. Michigan is a definite visit, Ohio State or Notre Dame, it will be one or the other."

It sounds like the Wolverines are in the best position to land Reeves should he decide to back out of his Penn State commitment. With the PSU coaching search looking like it could extend close to signing day, that seems like a very good possibility.

Happy trails to a pair of tight ends as Taylor McNamara committed to Oklahoma and former M commit Pharaoh Brown pledged to Oregon this week. Boston College commit Sam Grant appears to be the last viable option at tight end, and Michigan could actually be helped by McNamara's choice to go to Oklahoma, as that was one of the schools from whom Grant had recently received major interest recently.

The EEs Have Landed

As expected, three recruits from Michigan's class of 2012 have enrolled early, and it sounds like they're on campus and ready to start classes:

It appears at least three 2012 Michigan football recruits have enrolled early at the university.

There are listings for a Jarrod Arthur Lee Wilson, Joseph Daniel Bolden and Kaleb Stefon Ringer in Michigan's online directory of current students.

Those first and last names match three verbal commitments to Michigan, although a school spokesman said Thursday the program likely will not verify they are with the team until the start of winter classes.

This ensures that Michigan will be able to backdate those three players to the 2011 class and take 28 recruits in 2012.

From a recent local newspaper article, we find out senior (and sophomore) year stats for Michigan's most recent commit, receiver Jehu Chesson:

Chesson has been one of the area's top wide receivers the past two seasons. After grabbing 23 catches for 402 yards and four scores as a sophomore, Chesson had 53 receptions for 605 yards and scored 11 total touchdowns as a junior and had 53 catches for 757 yards and eight total touchdowns this fall.

Those catch totals are consistent, to say the least, and while he had fewer touchdowns as a senior, the increased yards per catch (from 11.4 to 14.3) indicates Chesson is improving after the catch.

Quickly: James Ross is named as Rivals.com's first-team All-American middle linebacker for 2011, while several commits make 247's Best of the Midwest list.

Tuley-Tillman Goes From Unknown to Blue-Chip

247Sports updated their class of 2013 rankings (I know, that was fast), and the top-ranked new arrival to their Top247 is none other than Peoria (IL) Manual OT Logan Tuley-Tillman, who went from unranked to the #38 overall player in the class (the article lists him at #37, but he's one spot lower when you click over to the rankings). For a full list of where Michigan offerees now stand, check out Touch the Banner.

Quickly, because this post is getting lengthy: Cass Tech corner Jourdan Lewis has Michigan at the top of his list, though he's yet to receive an offer ($, info in header); top-ranked TE Adam Breneman is looking to visit Michigan for a junior day or spring practice ($, info in header); the Wolverines offered a pair of Louisville (KY) Trinity prospects in WR James Quick and DE Jason Hatcher ($, info in header); four-star LB/S Su'a Cravens is already planning to take an official visit to Michigan during his senior season ($, info in header); TomVH profiles Good Counsel DB Kendall Fuller ($); and Sam Webb interviews Highland (UT) head coach Brody Benson, coach of 2012 commit Sione Houma and 2014 DT Bryan Mone, who received Michigan's first offer to a member of the current sophomore class ($).

Comments

AAB

December 30th, 2011 at 1:38 PM ^

If Arnett were Tennessee's coach, he could go to any school in the country that offered him a job and start coaching tomorrow (like, for example, Derek Dooley did in 2010 when he left Louisiana Tech to take the job at UT).  But because he's a student, he has to either play in the MAC or sit out a year, pay his own way, and lose a year of eligibility?    

Quite the double-standard you got there, NCAA.  

Wolverine 73

December 30th, 2011 at 1:56 PM ^

I certainly hope that future recruits keep in mind the attitude of the Tennessee coaches when they choose their schools.  How any school would opt to screw a kid under these circumstances is mind-boggling.

Needs

December 30th, 2011 at 2:07 PM ^

Didn't Dooley do this with Bryce Brown, who he wouldn't release to K State, and some other guy, who he required to transfer some arbitrary distance from UT?

Dude has rejection issues.

JimLahey

December 30th, 2011 at 2:07 PM ^

Arnett needs to create a big stink about this. If anything will work, it will be scaring Tenn with negative publicity that will affect future recruiting efforts.

Hair Raid Offense

December 30th, 2011 at 2:07 PM ^

Not letting Arnett transfer is complete horse shit. I live in Tennessee and most people down here think that Dooley is an ass-hat and needs to go, and only got the job in the first place because of his dad. Maybe Danny O'Brien will reconsider his commitment to Tennessee after hearing about this crap

remdog

December 30th, 2011 at 2:10 PM ^

typical example of unethical NCAA rules.  This is far worse than any "illegal" infraction committed at Ohio State, USC or elsewhere.  Restraining somebody from being close to their sick father - despicable.

This would not be possible if the NCAA wasn't allowed to be an unconstitutional monopoly which routinely tramples on the basic human rights of student-athletes.

GoWings2008

December 30th, 2011 at 2:14 PM ^

but they're not restraining him from being close to his father, just limiting his options for which team he can play for.  Truly a fine line, but in their screwed up minds, its their way of keeping him from going somewhere he'll probably have a better college career.

champswest

December 30th, 2011 at 2:14 PM ^

could a kid ever play for a school that treats him like that.  The NCAA should have an appeal process with override authority in cases such as this one.

Sounds like a mass media campaign is in order.

Elmer

December 30th, 2011 at 2:15 PM ^

I can understand if Michigan was on UT's schedule, but the rule against any school they recruit against is non-sense.  If anything, Arnett going to UM would eliminate one slot in our 2013 class.

I would say it' a stupid move by Dooley since he won't be able to land another kid from Michigan, but he'll be fired before it matters.

 

denardogasm

December 30th, 2011 at 2:25 PM ^

There really is no way to describe how stupid and short sighted this is on Dooley's part.  Arnett is leaving regardless of what decision they make about releasing him, especially after this nonsense, and the only thing denying it achieves is hurting their recruiting against the Michigan schools by revealing him to be a huge asshole.  Not letting Arnett go to a school they compete against can only succeed in making them look worse than that school.  Really foolish.  It's easy to see why UT is so bad.

Jon Benke

December 30th, 2011 at 2:21 PM ^

I think Joshua Garnett goes blue!

Getting Reeves on campus is going to be huge, and I can't wait to see how Yuri Wright's recruitment heats up .. once he visits.

kevin holt

December 30th, 2011 at 2:24 PM ^

Let's examine this for a second.

First of all, recruiting is a volatile game with regard to PR. This will give Tennessee a great setback when recruits consider the policy. Other schools can use it against them very easily. It doesn't look good, because, well... it's not.

Second, the policy itself makes no sense. If they are keeping a player away from teams they recruit against, it actually proves the opposite of true. It makes sense for teams you play against, but recruit? Wouldn't you rather Michigan, for example, fill their need of a receiver? Otherwise, they'll be recruiting against Tennessee for a receiver next cycle, because the need hasn't been filled. If they allow him to transfer to Michigan, though, then that's one less school to recruit against next cycle because they will be going after different positions. It seems (slightly) logical at face value, and there are many factors, but in reality it's backwards.

The more important point is the first one, though. This is complete unveiled bullshit, and recruits won't like it (they better not).

True Blue Grit

December 30th, 2011 at 2:25 PM ^

the SEC coaches wallow in while technically staying within NCAA rules.  Conditional releases like this should not be allowed.  At a minimum, there should be a swift appeal process with the NCAA where an athlete can receive a speedy decision.  But I think that in the long run, dickish decisions like Dooley's end up hurting their program  a lot more than any competitive short-term affects (which in this case are a figment of Dooley's imagination).  If I were a Tennessee fan or alum, I'd be pissed at Dooley for making their program look bad.  Hopefully, this story will get national airtime. 

unWavering

December 30th, 2011 at 2:29 PM ^

Tennessee's rationale is that they have "a policy of not releasing players to schools Tennessee plays or recruits against"

The funny thing is that right now Tennessee is more likely to recruit against and play against MAC schools.

bing24

December 30th, 2011 at 4:47 PM ^

I was thinking the same thing...They're more likely to play Central or Wastern in a bowl than ever seeing UM or sparty.

I'm hoping to see this blow up in UT's face and make them look worse than they are.

Side Note: CFB is just an ugly beast right now. The levels of shadiness & hypocrisy are insane.

Kilgore Trout

December 30th, 2011 at 2:32 PM ^

Question about early enrollees.  Am I correct in saying that if UM eventually takes 28 in this class (dating three to last year) they cannot take any early enrollees next year?  Or, would they be limited to 25 next year between early enrollees and fall enrollees because there's no room to back date them?

WolvinLA2

December 30th, 2011 at 3:07 PM ^

The 2013 class will have a hard cap of 25 assuming we fill this class to 28. As others have mentioned, we probably won't have 25 to give anyway, but EEs won't be an issue since we can't back date them to a full class.

MGoGoGo

December 30th, 2011 at 2:42 PM ^

Does anyone have any ideas on ways to pressure Tennessee or the NCAA regarding Arnett?  Looks like the story already ran on ESPN.com. Any way to publicize it to potential Tennessee recruits?

Erik_in_Dayton

December 30th, 2011 at 2:47 PM ^

A school doesn't have to sign transfer papers.  Of course, a school - like, say, Alabama - can pull your scholarship after one year, but a player cannot transer w/out a school's permission and still have a scholarship at another school the next year.  The school owns the player's rights, in a sense...Why the players' union agreed to this system, I'll never know.

dahblue

December 30th, 2011 at 2:58 PM ^

Hold on....Dooley said it's ok to transfer to a MAC school but not ok to transfer anywhere that Tenn recruits/plays.  Let's look at the schedule to see how that works out...

Tennessee played Buffalo this year and plays Akron next year...both MAC schools, and it's ok to transfer there?  How do you explain that hypocrisy to a kid with a sick parent, coach?

Willhouse

December 30th, 2011 at 3:47 PM ^

This is really shameful behavior from Tennessee. That "win at all costs" mentality is at it again in the SEC. I hope we beat the SEC's asses this year in the bowl game.

Perkis-Size Me

December 30th, 2011 at 4:31 PM ^

can arnett plead his case to the ncaa and try and get a transfer that way? or even to michigan or msu directly? not sure how exactly the latter would work, but i'm just curious. regardless, this just seems like a low-blow, scumbag move by dooley.

i don't see how dooley can deny the kid the right to be near his sick father while still wanting to compete at a high level.

magnus_caerulus (not verified)

December 30th, 2011 at 7:25 PM ^

Doesn't Braylon have a scholarship associated with the #1? Can't the coaches give him the number and have Braylon help with Tution in year one, and then he goes on scholarship in year two?
<br>
<br>I would imagine a wr meeting to explain this rare situation for giving someone unproven the number but the team may understand how unique of a situation this is and would be for it to help the team the next few years.

Two Hearted Ale

January 2nd, 2012 at 10:32 AM ^

Braylon can pay for a kid's school but it still counts toward the NCAA limit so it wouldn't really help Arnett.

My guess is he ends up at WMU given their history with wide receivers or CMU which is closer to Saginaw.

Edit: My phone auto corrects "Saginaw" to "vagina" which, as a WMU grad, sums up my feelings toward CMU.