when you're just getting started [Marc-Gregor Campredon]

This Week's Obsession: Juwan a Five-Star, What's Next? Comment Count

Ace October 18th, 2019 at 12:24 PM

THIS ARTICLE HAS A SPONSOR: If you're anything like me, you've been putting off any sort of long-term financial planning for as long as possible. This, unfortunately, is not a viable long-term financial planning strategy, and it's about time to change that for the better. Nick Hopwood from Peak Wealth Management has just the expertise you need to secure a better financial future.

If you need any convincing, Nick has a podcast in which he dispenses the type of valuable financial advice he can give you as a client. For instance, most people aren't optimizing their tax advantaged retirement accounts; in this episode, Nick has some free tips to do just that. In exchange for being so generous with his financial expertise, we've let Nick hit us with this week's pressing question.

Legal disclosure in tiny font: Calling Nick our official financial planner is not intended as financial advice; Nick is an advertiser who financially supports MGoBlog. MGoBlog is not responsible for any advice or other communication provided to an investor by any financial advisor, and makes no representations or warranties as to the suitability of any particular financial advisor and/or investment for a specific investor.

Nick's Question: Isaiah Todd happened. How does this change your outlook for the Juwan Howard era?

Ace: Pulling in Todd raises my expectations a little bit. The fear with Howard’s recruiting approach was that he’d too often lose out to the blue blood programs and end up with teams of backup plans. Todd doesn’t look like anyone’s backup plan and, in addition to finalist Kansas, he had offers from Kentucky, Memphis, UNC, UCLA, and Villanova. Five-stars tend to follow five-stars, too, so my hopes for the critical 2020 class are up as well.

David: He's just going to either fill out the class well enough or continue getting guys like that. If one/both, then, yes, I agree with Ace.

Bryan: The "momentum" part of it feels pretty important. Not only did he hit of a five-star, he hit on one of the first of his targeted guys to drop. Grabbing a blue-chipper any time is great, but this opens up the possibility for a "[TBD] Five" class.

Brian: I think it's more of an indicator of how Howard's going to do in the world of high-end basketball recruiting than a program-defining commit. Realistically, Todd's going to be... GRIII, maybe with a power mushroom? That's nice to have for a year, but it's not going to win a title.

Honestly Hunter Dickinson would be a much bigger commit, just because he's going to be around for a while.

Ace: I mean, 6'10" GRIII with a power mushroom. And possibly a three-point shot. That can swing some things.

David: And he should have Franz and senior Livers with him for his year.

Brian: I don't want to downplay Todd, but hyping up the five-star one-and-done as a program-changer is often a disappointment. See Romeo Langford last year. Nassir Little was similar at UNC, but UNC is a program; Indiana is currently not one.

Ace: I do agree that Dickinson would probably have a bigger impact on the program, also because that would be a head-to-head win over Duke instead of can’t-throw-bags-right-now Kansas.

David: And they will need a Teske Replacement/Castleton backup.

Brian: I don't think Michigan is going to recruit like Duke or Kentucky so filling in the pieces around the one and done is as or more important. A guy like Moses Moody or Dickinson, who can fulfill Michigan's traditional two-and-through model, starts getting you there.

Todd helps you get those guys, of course.

Ace: He also raises the ceiling considerably. He’ll be filling a spot where most Beilein teams would be plugging in a guy they developed from three-star range.

Bryan: And, taking a step back, it's always nice when the reported "this is how this hire will succeed" plan actually looks plausible in its first road test.

(And no, I'm not mumbling #SpeedInSpace while I type that.)

Brian: Yeah, the "Kentucky can't take everyone" approach got a strike, and largely because Howard was able to connect with a kid who has NBA dreams and a very protective mother. This video provides a lot of background on Todd:

Ace: I also like the actual basketball implications! I worried Howard might go a little too far in the 90s-ball direction given some of the offers he had out there to bigs, but Todd is a very modern power forward—he’s got some handles and you’ll see him shoot some pull-up threes on film. If he fills out he still has plenty of ability on the interior but it doesn’t look like they’ll go full-blown bully ball.

He should at least be a catch-and-shoot threat and he’ll also be a nightmare to account for at the dunker spot. Plus there’s a little bit of potential to run 4-5 pick-and-rolls with him, which would be very fun.

David: Matt Painter disagrees, Ace.

[Hit THE JUMP for more on the implications of landing "a pterodactyl with a Dirk fadeaway."]

Seth: What I like about it is I can't overstate how important it is to establish something Howard's program does beyond Beilein's. Fans complained for the whole run but they also went deep into the tournament and got Painter games and such.

If Howard came in and ran Beilein's program worse than Beilein, there's no way to climb out of that hole of mediocrity. This feels new, even if it's not necessarily better. People are going on posters. Other people's people.

Ace: It’s also hard to expect anyone to have Beilein’s X’s and O’s acumen, so raising the recruiting ceiling was necessary.

Brian: Also Beilein's development is unparalleled. If you go by recruiting rankings Beilein was blah, but if you look at the NBA draft Michigan was up there just behind the one-and-done factories.

Ace: Also, aside from Caris (and GRIII, I guess, since he dropped to the second round), those guys have not outperformed their draft slot. Which indicates Beilein got the most he could out of them.

Brian: You could argue DJ, too, but yes.

Seth: I'm coming from the perspective that Howard would not have been a top candidate if Beilein hadn't left when he did. This is a shot at maintaining Beilein's level, and frankly the only shot Juwan gets. If he came in and watched Kansas/Kentucky/Duke take all the guys who had high Michigan interest, and mucked about in the Minnesota region for two years, nobody would bother to wait to see how he develops. Todd is the--to visit the verboten MLB for a sec--Pudge Rodriguez whose decision makes the new thing seem viable.

Brian: But anyway the point is that to maintain the level of the program Howard almost certainly had to raise the recruiting profile and this is a big step towards doing that.

Ace: Michigan should also be getting a pretty fun basketball player for a year.

Alex: You don’t see 6’10 guys who can handle and create like him and while his best basketball will come years after he leaves Ann Arbor, nobody in the Big Ten will be able to guard him. Shot selection and aggressiveness will ultimately be most important for him while he’s here. Could be first-team all-conference and a top five pick if he’s got it all together. And the defensive potential is off the charts — he’s like a prototype 4 at the next level.

Bryan: So, does this style of recruiting increase or decrease variability from year to year? Relying on one-and-done types creates more turnover, but relying on development of sleeper-types runs the risk of having some dry spells.

Ace: Beilein would’ve been almost stunningly consistent if not for Caris’s foot. It does feel like the year-to-year changes are going to increase, along with variance.

David: And probably Irvin's back.


Todd Five!

Brian: Let's see how the rest of the class comes together. If it's Todd/Zeb/Dickinson/Jace/Moody that's four guys who are going to be in the program a while and then the one-and-done. (A while in this context equals two years, I guess.)

Seth: That class would need a ____ Five name.

Brian: Hooray! Todd Five!

Seth: Frankly Incredible We're Still Alive Five

David: No Spare Scholarships Finally Five

Ace: This is a bad gimmicky top five.

Brian: I'm leery of having the recruiting model be a bunch of one-and-dones just because I don't think Michigan is capable of getting them as consistently as true blue-bloods, but having scholarship #13 go to a one-and-done annually is a thing I could get behind.

Seth: I don't even think that's possible. There are FAR easier places to set up your 1-and-done factory than Michigan.

Brian: One slot is the Dave Kingman slot and the others target guys in that 30-70 range that make up big chunks of the best teams in CBB annually.

Bryan: (This is a Michigan blog. That's the Rob Deer slot)

Ace: Man, Howard’s first commit was a five-star. I think he can pull one a year. They’re still in on multiple others!

Alex: We’re shooting for the UK / Duke model. Definitely room for that in the B1G and while there are drawbacks to that model, it generally helps to be way more talented than your opponents!

Seems like those types of teams can be foiled by poor shooting (or maybe that’s just Cal’s problem specifically) but pursuing Moody is a positive sign in that regard, that Juwan doesn’t just want guys who are like “oh yeah that dude looks like he’s going to the NBA” without specific considerations to fit at this level.


WOULD BE NICE.

Brian: If he's able to pull Jaden Springer all bets are off.

Seth: Until you're winning championships you always get your best class in the first one, when you can sell guys on the vision of creating a new legacy for the program, and your opposition doesn't yet know how to recruit against you. (First one being your first whole cycle.)

Ace: And Howard did not get a full cycle here. That’s another part of this that’s really impressive. He had to hit the ground sprinting. Five-star recruiting cycles are, like, three years.

Bryan: And Todd wasn't one of the guys that Howard had an in on already, was he?

Brian: No, nothing.

Ace: Nobody was talking about this a month ago.

Brian: He did have an edge because of Jace:

During the opening night of Peach Jam, Nightrydas Elite played against Jace — Howard's other son — and the Mac Irvin Fire, a prominent team from Chicago. Because his son was playing, Howard was allowed to sit courtside even though the July evaluation period hadn't begun.

Wesley had assumed that Howard was watching Nightrydas Elite to scout Scottie Barnes, a five-star recruit who played at University School with Jace and Jett. As it turns out, the more Howard watched Nightrydas Elite, the more he became interested in Todd.

Peach Jam, according to Wesley, was where everything started to fall into place.

"That’s where he made the connection and started communicating with Isaiah and Isaiah’s mom," Wesley said.

Bryan: This was in a Hoops Recruitin' less than six weeks ago:

Brian: Score one for "Kentucky can't take them all."

Ace: That’s also a thing about Howard that isn’t going to change. He’s Basketball Kevin Bacon. Dude knows everyone, and everyone likes him.

Bryan: *Offer not valid in East Lansing

Brian: Yeah, bringing in the superb dude with 20 years of NBA experience and four kids who went/are going through AAU turns out to be a good move.

Ace: Basketball Dad 2.0

Bryan: So, I think what we're saying is that Howard is probably going to have the raw materials to shock the world.

Brian: At this point in Michigan's program it's more like Mildly Surprise The World.

Seth: Todd is a proof of concept. We hypothesized that knowing everybody in basketball would be an edge, but yielding results this early suggests it might even be a program cornerstone.

Brian: LeBron and Dwyane Wade shouting you out is helpful.

Ace: Yeah, we’ll see how the class finishes, but it’s hard for Howard to have personally gotten off to a better start. (Wording that awkwardly to acknowledge Zeb.)

As the GIF guy, I’m very excited for the implications of just having Todd on the team, too.

Seth: Ah yes, the fact that he's a basketball player who will play basketball. I had not fully considered this.

Bryan: If there are any transition costs from moving to a Beilein system to a Howard system, having a pterodactyl with a Dirk fadeaway in his arsenal should help.

Ace: Those were very intriguing.

Brian: So Todd has legs, Michigan gets Jace and Dickinson and adds a 2/3 from Christopher, Springer, Burnett, and Moody, and then that class joins up with Franz/Livers/Castleton next year. Sounds like a plan.

David: Hopefully/maybe/probably DDJ.

Ace: Zeb, too.

Seth: Is Franz around next year? And yeah, Johns could be a Player a year from now. I mean, the other thing Howard's supposed to be good at is big development.

Brian: and then 2021 is the ***YEAR OF CHET***

I DEMAND CHET

Ace: [SUNDAY SUNDAY SUNDAY VOICE]
CHET HOLMGREN

Seth: /slides in head first, as Chets must do.

Brian: I want the skinniest guy in every recruiting class. Caris, Castleton, Bajema: it's a plan.

Seth: The Gaunt Five.

Ace: 

CHET CHET CHET

Seth: Scraggly Cinco.

Brian: I think we're done here.

Bryan: Once players have their NIL rights, they'll just have an annual sponsorship with Maize and Blue Deli.

Ace: CHET HOLMGREN

Also, Michigan’s gonna be good.

Bryan: Secretary: [pounding her clipboard]

CHET. CHET. CHET.

Comments

ijohnb

October 18th, 2019 at 12:57 PM ^

I didn't really see any negativity. I think he was just saying that the Todd commitment, itself, does not somehow guarantee greatness.  It looked to me that Brian thinks the implication of getting a five star in the cycle means more than exactly who that five star is and what he alone could do for the program.

Joby

October 18th, 2019 at 1:22 PM ^

Perhaps I’m being too charitable, but I read Brian’s comment more as “this, by itself, will not change long-term results if there is no viable program.” Langford had a fairly underwhelming year, with high usage and low efficiency, and IU could not compensate for it because all they had otherwise was Juwan Morgan and some taped-together matchsticks. 

 

Michigan is in a (mostly) better position to absorb the consequences if Todd has an unproductive season, and can leverage Todd’s commitment to raise the program profile rather than depend on him to improve the level of play on the court (obviously we all hope he does).

Farnn

October 18th, 2019 at 1:44 PM ^

Reads more like trying to have realistic expectations.   Todd isn't a guaranteed star in college.  He's got the tools to be great but needs development and that doesn't usually happen by his freshman season.  He should be very good, but he'll likely leave Michigan with tons of untapped potential if he's a 1 and done.

CTSgoblue

October 18th, 2019 at 12:56 PM ^

"Brian: I want the skinniest guy in every recruiting class. Caris, Castleton, Bajema: it's a plan."

DJ Wilson would like to know why he wasn't included in this list...

AlbanyBlue

October 18th, 2019 at 1:04 PM ^

I know I'm echoing some comments from the TWO panel here, but here's what I see and what I'd like:

First, great get by JH. That's a great nucleus and there is a chance (so there's a chance?) to reel in a monster class. That said, M is probably not going to recruit like the Top 5 consistently because of rea$ons. 

So, the kind of strategy I'd like to see is take some shots, but be solid on the top-100 guys to fill the roster and fit into The Plan, whatever that is.

I don't have doubts that Juwan will be able to relate to and coach the players up. We just have to get the talent in here. Perhaps that aspect will be a notch down from JB, but if the talent level is up a bit, it could be a wash. And, please, no autobench.

Overall, we're in as good a spot as we can be. I'm bullish.

Naked Bootlegger

October 18th, 2019 at 1:14 PM ^

I have to admit that the Todd commitment changes everything.   We still haven't seen Howard manage the team for an entire season, but reeling in a top 10 recruit after only starting the job a few months ago is damn impressive.   

remdog

October 18th, 2019 at 1:24 PM ^

There's no way to overstate the importance of Todd's commitment. Todd was the top ranked recruit in his class until he recently slipped based on numbers/production.  He's supremely physically talented.  So he could easily be the best player in this class.  He doesn't seem to have any real weaknesses. In addition, he gets the ball rolling for other commitments to follow him.  This could still be a monster class with Howard still in on multiple 5 stars.

Talent is no guarantee of success but if Howard pulls in a 5 man class as suggested above, It will be enough for a Final Four run.  His coaching ability is the X factor but he doesn't have to be at Beilein's elite level if he has elite talent.  

 

ThisGuyFawkes

October 18th, 2019 at 1:31 PM ^

Brian: I don't want to downplay Todd, but hyping up the five-star one-and-done as a program-changer is often a disappointment. See Romeo Langford last year. Nassir Little was similar at UNC, but UNC is a program; Indiana is currently not one.

I saw this comment from Brian and thought it warranted a closer look. I looked at the last 8 championship teams and found that 50% of them featured one-and-dones:

2019: Virginia - None

2018: Villanova - Omari Spellman (RS FR)

2017: North Carolina - Tony Bradley

2016: Villanova - None

2015: Duke - Jahlil Okafor, Tyus Jones, Justise Winslow

2014: UConn - None

2013: Louisville (the block was clean) - None

2012: Kentucky - Anthony Davis, Michael Kidd-Gilchrist, Marquis Teague

Brian's comment has some validity - but I would amend it to say that while a one-and-done on his own does not change a program, it can push an already successful program over the edge. For examples, look at Kentucky and Duke who always have insane recruiting classes and lately (for Duke anyways) a high number of one-and-dones - they each relied on one of their most talented freshman classes ever (Duke's probably 2nd best to last year's crop) to win their only championship of the decade. Here's hoping Todd, Springer, Burnett and whoever else wants to get on board can do the same for Michigan.

Mgthefrenchy

October 18th, 2019 at 1:59 PM ^

Yeah.

I also think like a One and Done in a "not so good program" or " middle of the mass program" will help the program to do a lot better.
But if the program is not that amazing in the other post ... They won't win a title.
Sort of look at last year. Iggy definitely help the team to perform better than expected in pre season but we did not win any title (and we were far away of MSU for example).

On the other hand the one and done that came into a good program (Not even a top) will make help boost the program enough to probably win something more. Without maybe not as obviously than in smaller team / program. Because he just won't be alone in the court.

MichiganTeacher

October 18th, 2019 at 1:40 PM ^

A relatively minor quibble with Seth saying, "If Howard came in and ran Beilein's program worse than Beilein, there's no way to climb out of that hole of mediocrity." I would just say that there is a LOT of room between Beilein's program and mediocrity. Conceivably Juwan could come in and run Beilein's program worse than Beilein and yet still be very good. 

But that's a nitpick. Good stuff as usual. Very excited for hoops this year and next.

Champeen

October 18th, 2019 at 2:14 PM ^

Realistically, Todd's going to be... GRIII, maybe with a power mushroom? That's nice to have for a year, but it's not going to win a title.

Couldn't disagree more.  Todd is quite a bit better than GRIIIa at the same stage.  Quite a bit. But yeah, probably not tipping the scale on a title.

 

Honestly Hunter Dickinson would be a much bigger commit, just because he's going to be around for a while.

Couldn't agree more.  This is spot on

Drew Henson's Backup

October 18th, 2019 at 2:38 PM ^

Seriously.

Brian, stop being afraid of success. The only thing that will stop us from being a 1-and-done factory is if the NBA starts taking H.S. kids again. At that point, Juwan will have to learn the new landscape along with everyone else.

dragonchild

October 18th, 2019 at 2:29 PM ^

Recruiting, development, scheme, game management. To be successful, you need all four.

This is a great start to the first step.  That's not bad news!  But it is what it is.  The engine sounds great and that's never a bad thing, but this is a 1000-mile roadtrip and we're barely out of the driveway.  That said, the alternative outcome to Howard's approach was to pull a Drevno, miss on all these home-run swings and recruit a bunch of air.

outsidethebox

October 18th, 2019 at 2:44 PM ^

Basketball is such a complimentary reliant game. Increasingly you have to have 5 players that the defense has to account for-that can space the floor for you. Here, with a three-some like Dickinson, Todd and Burnett alongside two snipers and or slashers/finishers is a combination that is very difficult to defend. My dream class here is these three and Moody then either Springer or Christopher. And I would say that, given the dynamics here, this is not out of the realm of possibilities.  

AC1997

October 18th, 2019 at 2:58 PM ^

A couple of thoughts beyond what the guys shared:

  • Howard needed something to buy patience with the fans given all the BPONE around here.  If we scuffle this year a bit and he didn't pull in any recruits it would be a rough start.  Todd buys him time to learn how to coach and build a program.
  • I really like the Todd is similar to Howard himself - size, position, skills, good-at-lots without being great-at-anything, etc.
  • Why are we automatically assuming he's a 1-and-done?  He feels a little like McGary in that he was top-5 and will end top-30. While he has the physical skills of an NBA guy and likely leaves after a year....McGary and Jaren Jackson didn't.  Nor did Maryland's Smith.  I think there's a non-zero chance he splits time with the guys already on the roster and decides to stick around a 2nd year.
  • I am also leery of a full NBA factory and think the glue of the class needs to be Beilein 4-stars.  My only concern with the targets on the board would be finding the scorer and the shooter.  None of these guys are known as great shooters and none of them are alpha dogs on offense.  

Michigan4Life

October 18th, 2019 at 3:19 PM ^

The fact that there's strong rumor of Todd looking to go oversea as part of his option pretty much tell us that he's a for sure 1 and done unless he had a season ending injury or disastrous freshman season. The sooner you accept that he's likely a one and done, the better because he's likely projected to be a lottery pick for 2021 draft

troublet1969

October 19th, 2019 at 3:34 AM ^

Chet Chet Chet!  

What the heck is going on around here?  All this optimism is a breath of fresh air as we are about to go to Happy Valley for an all important game...let’s get it!

 

 

Wolverine In Exile

October 19th, 2019 at 11:22 AM ^

Let me throw out a different model for Howard.... He's potentially basketball Red Berenson. Solid pro career, reputation as above board, pro coaching career to get feet wet, capitalize on pro experience and connections to get high end talent for the next 10-15 years. That model work for Red for a long time (until he lost his recruiting credentials and the help he needed in the x & O's)