super seniors? [Marc-Grégor Campredon]

Basketbullets Ponders 2021-22 Return Comment Count

Ace April 5th, 2021 at 11:43 AM

I'll get to analysis from the tourney run—later. For now, I'm ready to take stock of the roster and look at the many different possible ways it could shape up for next year. Let's start with next season's scholarship chart with zero projected departures, which I'll say right now isn't gonna happen, but it's a good jumping-off point.

Remember: every senior has the option to return because of the COVID year exemption. Juwan Howard says they're all welcome back. Michigan could technically carry 18 scholarship players because returning seniors won't count against the 13-scholarship limit next season. But again, this isn't gonna happen:

Scholarship 2021-22 2022-23 2023-24 2024-25
1 B. Johns (Sr) F. Wagner H. Dickinson I. Barnes
2 A. Nunez (Sr) H. Dickinson J. Howard K. Bufkin
3 F. Wagner (Jr) J. Howard Z. Jackson F. Collins
4 H. Dickinson (So) Z. Jackson T. Williams M. Diabate
5 J. Howard (So) T. Williams I. Barnes C. Houstan
6 Z. Jackson (So) I. Barnes K. Bufkin W. Tschetter
7 T. Williams (So) K. Bufkin F. Collins  
8 I. Barnes (Fr) F. Collins M. Diabate  
9 K. Bufkin (Fr) M. Diabate C. Houstan  
10 F. Collins (Fr) C. Houstan W. Tschetter  
11 M. Diabate (Fr) W. Tschetter    
12 C. Houstan (Fr)      
13 W. Tschetter (Fr)      
OVER/EXEMPT C. Brown (Sr*)      
OVER/EXEMPT E. Brooks (Sr*)      
OVER/EXEMPT A. Davis (Sr*)      
OVER/EXEMPT I. Livers (Sr*)      
OVER/EXEMPT M. Smith (Sr*)      

Michigan is right at the limit for 2021-22, though attrition is generally a guarantee. There's no way the team is going to carry 18 scholarship players; even if professional careers weren't under consideration, playing time would be. Today, I'm going to go through the upcoming decisions and how they'll impact the program's outlook for next season. Later this week, I'll toy around with potential rosters and lineup combinations.

[Hit THE JUMP for decisions, decisions, decisions.]

The Decisions


Wagner is a probable lottery pick [Campredon]

Listed in approximate order from least to most likely to return, based on the current vibes and available info, and broken into categories.

COME TO TERMS WITH THESE

Franz Wagner. There's been little to no buzz about Wagner possibly returning for a junior season. He's worked his way from a fringe first-round prospect into a potential top-ten pick (ESPN has him 8th, The Ringer 9th, and the lowest I've seen him is 18th on Sam Vecenie's latest big board). He's not an elite athlete with superstar upside, so that's likely as good as his draft stock is going to get. A return to school would be a very pleasant surprise.

Isaiah Livers. While his senior season didn't end the way anyone hoped, Livers seems prepared to move on to the next stage. He considered going to the NBA after last season, improved as a senior, and earned his degree. He's started in an NCAA title game. He's projected as a second-round pick and his recovery timeline shouldn't scare off NBA teams—he's got plenty on tape after four years playing against high-level competition. Given he spent the tournament wearing a #NotNCAAProperty shirt and lobbied Mark Emmert for NLI compensation, he seems done playing for just a scholarship.

LOOKING PLAUSIBLE

Austin Davis. Davis has been in Ann Arbor five years, will have two degrees, and would no longer be the primary backup center with five-star freshman Moussa Diabate expected to fill a healthy number of minutes in the frontcourt. That said, Big Country isn't putting off a pro basketball career, and there's always room for an experienced center on the bench. He's a Michigander who may have different incentives than the others in this section, including one that could pull him towards staying: if he wants to pursue coaching or another administrative position in basketball, staying close to Juwan Howard could be a wise plan.

Mike Smith. Based on the current message board rumors, it feels like one of the two starting guards is coming back, whether that be Smith or Eli Brooks. Those rumors have also swung over the last month to Brooks being the more likely returnee, though Smith still isn't being ruled out. Would Howard bring both guards back when two talented freshman guards, including a true point in Frankie Collins, arrive with ambitions of seeing the court and Zeb Jackson is looking to step into a bigger role? I'm not so sure. He won't want to stunt the development of his freshmen and there are only so many minutes available. Smith, meanwhile, has a lot of options between Columbia and Michigan degrees, a possible overseas career, and point guards often making good coaches.

FEELING GOOD EVEN THOUGH WE'LL NEVER USE THE TERM "LOCK" IN THE OFFSEASON


thunder back? [Campredon]

Chaundee Brown. TMI basketball insider Dotman indicated on their message board that Brown is eyeing a return, as did The Wolverine's latest Inside The Fort. That'd be a major boost to a team expected to lose a lot of scoring production on the wing and at least two of their top perimeter defenders. Brown could slot in as a starter or reprise his role as a sixth man (and likely get near starter-level minutes) depending on which players return, their development, and how ready the young guards are to play big roles.

Eli Brooks. The other senior Dotman has hinted is likely to return (again corroborated by The Wolverine), Brooks could start at either guard spot depending on team need and stabilize a backcourt that's otherwise projected to be very inexperienced. We've seen time and again how important Brooks' presence is to the team beyond simple box score contributions; having him on the court to help initiate the offense and keep the defense organized would put this team right back in contention for a one-seed, in my opinion.

Hunter Dickinson. Losing Dickinson appears unlikely. He isn't listed on the top 100 Big Boards for 2021 by Vecenie, ESPN, or NBADraftNet. While he's never going to be the modern NBA prototype, there's a lot he can do as a sophomore to improve his potential draft position, from adding a functional jumper to diversifying his post moves to making quicker reads against double-teams, to name a few on offense. The NBA's glut of cheap traditional centers and reticence to use them work in Michigan's favor, at least this year. Dickinson's decision will be tougher in 2022.

OTHERS? This certainly won't come back to bite me in the ass: this doesn't feel like an offseason where there's going to be much, if any, unexpected attrition. Brandon Johns started to break out towards the end of the season and will have a major role to play as a senior. Adrien Nunez, the only other upperclassman not listed above, seems very content to be a legitimate TikTok star and Bench Mob guy who'll have a Michigan degree in hand next year. The sophomores-to-be all got playing time and the only one not to receive some high-leverage minutes is the son of the head coach. While you never know with offseason attrition, the outlook is good.

The Portal? Crootin?


transfers were front and center during M's run this season [Campredon]

At this time last year, Mike Smith was merely a guard in the portal who'd reported contact from Michigan, which seemed more focused on landing Harvard transfer Bryce Aiken, who ended up at Seton Hall. Chaundee Brown's name started coming up in mid-May, around the same time Nojel Eastern briefly committed to Michigan as a transfer from Purdue, and didn't receive his waiver to play immediately until the end of October. Josh Christopher was ticketed for Ann Arbor until his mid-April turn to Arizona State, which came in tandem with the news that Isaiah Todd chose the G-League over his Michigan commitment.

So, yeah, a lot can change. This year's transfer portal is the most packed ever and several players on it are former Michigan targets, such as Khristian Lander (Indiana), Nimari Burnett (Texas Tech), and Noah Locke (Florida).

If two of the super seniors return, though, there'd have to be some unexpected attrition for Howard to need to turn to the portal. Again, he's got talented players coming in that he doesn't want to recruit over. If he's uncomfortable with Diabate as the lone backup center other than Johns, who's needed at the four, then maybe a grad transfer center is in the cards, though Michigan's lack of available minutes at the position means it'd probably be easier to convince Big Country to stay another year.

Grabbing a sit-out transfer also doesn't seem to make much sense with a six-man freshman class coming to campus and, for the moment, limited space to fill out the 2022 class. With Howard's recruiting acumen, it'd take just the right player coming available for him to add a transfer instead of a blue chip recruit.

Speaking of recruiting, Michigan is technically still in the mix for a few elite 2021 prospects, though that also doesn't look to be a likely route to adding players. Top-30 IMG Academy center Charles Bediako keeps pushing off a decision that has long expected to go in the favor of Alabama, though big-timers lurk, including Duke and Michigan. He's kept his recruitment quiet and could make an unexpected decision; this still feels like a long-shot unless Bediako is happy coming off the bench with little chance of starting barring injury. [4/6 UPDATE: Bediako just committed to Bama.]

Another IMG center, five-star Efton Reid, will announce his decision on April 15th. Michigan has been involved but his choice is rumored to be coming down to Ohio State, Pitt, and Virginia, according to to 247's Steve Helwagen. Finally, #1 overall prospect Chet Holmgren, the lanky 7'1 center from Minnesota, is looking more and more like a Gonzaga lock if he chooses the college route.

That about covers the bases. Later this week, I'll have a post analyzing the various roster and lineup possibilities, which have been quite enjoyable to think about.

Comments

matty blue

April 5th, 2021 at 11:49 AM ^

austin davis as a sort of player / ad hoc grad assistant would be perfect.  that it would mirror juwan's last couple years in the nba just makes it more likely and appropriate.

Rubberband

April 5th, 2021 at 3:33 PM ^

As a fellow Wildcat graduate from way back, I could reach out to a few people to speak with Becky (Austins' mother) but I think I can confidently say "No", there are no more plans for the Davis basketball pipeline at Onsted.

The younger Davis has a handle for his size, still needs to fill out a little but height is not going to be an issue.

Austin wants to be a physical therapist last I knew and he has a Masters already.  Maybe coaching is in his future, he is a super bright young man.  I would love to see him come back, he's the pride of Onsted at this point.

jmblue

April 5th, 2021 at 12:05 PM ^

 He's projected as a second-round pick and his recovery timeline shouldn't scare off NBA teams—he's got plenty on tape after four years playing against high-level competition. 

The issue isn't that NBA teams didn't know how good he was pre-injury, but that they are likely to be nervous about his foot until he can prove it's fully recovered.   I would be surprised if he still got drafted.

That's not to say that coming back necessarily makes sense either.  After getting hurt two years in a row, I can see why he'd want to make money.  But he might be stuck in G-League limbo for awhile.

JamieH

April 5th, 2021 at 12:43 PM ^

I like Livers a lot, but LeVert was a better prospect.  Livers is going to struggle to create his shot in the NBA.  He will likely be a spot-up 3-point specialist and defender.  Which, he might have a great career with that, but there are a ton of those guys around already.  He'll have to really light it up from the NBA 3 to stand out.

Given that his chance of scoring much more than the 13-14 a game he got this year is small, it isn't likely that another year in college will help his draft stock.   Unless he came back and just had a monster year I'm not seeing it.

JamieH

April 5th, 2021 at 5:13 PM ^

Yes, with him having surgery it is possible he would want to come back and play himself back into shape, rather than counting on some NBA team to accept his rehab schedule.

Unfortunately he is going to be in a range where teams aren't overly patient with you.  Since he won't be able to compete, he's not going to get paid.

AC1997

April 5th, 2021 at 1:03 PM ^

I agree with this.  I doubt Livers gets drafted now and will have to fight his way back into the league.  Just sucks for him.  I hope he took out insurance like Jake Butt.  

This is a case where NIL would probably get him to stay.  He could use UM for rehab, make some money, show he's healthy, and then go next year.  

I doubt he stays but I don't think it is the slam dunk implied because of his six month recovery timeline.  He can call Charles Matthews and see what he thinks.  I could even see him coming back, playing in the non conference to show he's healthy, then opting out and trying to latch on to a two way deal.  

shoes

April 5th, 2021 at 2:48 PM ^

I agree, the unfortunate uncertainty as a result of the injury and the fact that he his recovery period extends to  October makes it unlikely he will be drafted. Think he's headed to the G league (which even some second rounders are likely to wind up in).

bluesalt

April 6th, 2021 at 9:47 AM ^

Yeah, it’s going to be tough for Livers to get drafted.  NBA teams in the middle or end of the second round either want players they can develop (often overseas) for a couple of seasons, or lower-ceiling prospects who can fight for a spot at the end of the rotation on a cheap deal.  Pre-injury, Livers could have been that player, but post-injury with a 6-month recovery in front of him, he doesn’t look like he’ll be ready to fight for that roster spot.  His best chance of getting drafted is probably to find a team that develops him in the G-League for a year without signing him to an NBA deal, instead waiting until 2022.  That’s still probably a better option than returning to school for a year if he can pick up endorsement money, but NIL rights for collegiate athletes might change the calculation.  The NCAA needs to change their rules by July 19th.

lhglrkwg

April 5th, 2021 at 12:10 PM ^

If we're looking for a 3rd C, I would much rather keep Big Country around than go shopping. He seems like a glue guy and is surprisingly good on the offensive end.

JeepinBen

April 5th, 2021 at 12:14 PM ^

Totally agree. He also fits the "iron sharpening iron" mold well too - between Austin, Hunter, and Moussa talk about a 3 headed monster that can all make each other better. Oh, and getting coached from Juwan.

Plus, if you've got the right match up, he's proven that he can go get you a bucket if you need it.

JamieH

April 5th, 2021 at 12:47 PM ^

Austin Davis could start for any smaller school in the country.  He is really talented on offense.  Yeah he doesn't bring us the defense that Dickinson does, but how many teams have a backup center with an offensive efficiency rating over 110?  The fact that you can usually go right to him for a couple of buckets when he comes into the game is a big lift for the team.

lhglrkwg

April 5th, 2021 at 2:22 PM ^

It really is amazing to watch him work down low. I remember seeing him get the ball against guys like Cockburn and Garza down low and thinking 'why are we trying this??' and then its often pivot pivot pivot pivot and easy lay in. I stopped doubting him after I saw him work his way around Cockburn a few times. Austin is really good at working with the physical tools he has

TrueBlue2003

April 5th, 2021 at 4:14 PM ^

We have a third center and his name is Brandon Johns.  I think the only coaching issue I had this season was that Davis played too many minutes against centers that Johns would have been a better fit against.

I've long been a defender of Davis on this blog, especially when he came in for beating after beating the past couple years.  He's been a capable backup against the right matchups and a true program guy, but we missed opportunities to play five out offense while also keeping a vastly superior rim protector on the bench when we kept Johns on the bench in favor of Davis in matchups that would have been better for Johns.

Once (well-coached) teams figured out Hunter Dickinson, Michigan had a big problem on offense.  We ran our offense through an inefficient post player, which also clogged the paint and the offense basically crawled into a whole and died in the Illinois game, both MSU games, the OSU game and the UCLA game.  Only Mark Turgeon, a 16 seed, Will Wade and Leonard Hamilton allowed Michigan's offense to get to season average performances (but not even better) in the last 9 games of the season.

I would have liked to see more of the Johns at center lineup that was so good against LSU when Michigan came back at the end of the first half.

Obviously, probably less of an issue next year.  With Livers and Franz gone, we don't really have another stretch four so Johns will likely be needed for big minutes there. Even still, I'd like to see some lineups with Houstan at four and Johns at five.  The 2016 team was best when Robinson was in at the four and Wilson was at five and Houstan and Johns could be similar.

It'll be fun to see if Dickinson can elevate his game such that there isn't as obvious of a "book" on him anymore.  To Ace's points here, that means developing the jumper, getting more post moves and learning to pass not just when a double comes right away but after he's made a move and still doesn't have a good shot.

BuddhaBlue

April 5th, 2021 at 7:51 PM ^

I know you don't mean it that way, but Austin Davis' performance on the court is in a sense the least surprising of anyone on the team. You always know what you'll get with him. His stats the past two years are remarkably consistent:  

this year - 5.4 ppg, 3 shots/game, 70.5 FG%, 55 FT%, 2.8 RPG, 0.3 assists, 0.2 steals, 0.2 blocks, 0.8 TOs, 2.2 PF on 11.2 mpg in 23 games

last year - 4.9 ppg, 3 shots/game, 69.3 FG%, 55 FT%, 2.6 RPG, 0.1 assists, 0.2 steals, 0.1 blocks, 0.8 TOs, 1.8 PF on 10.7 mpg in 24 games

Total high floor, low ceiling guy

Erik_in_Dayton

April 5th, 2021 at 12:15 PM ^

I will be giddy with giddiness if Brooks and Brown come back. That would, at the risk of stating the obvious, make an enormous impact as Michigan incorporates the young guys into the team.

Walmart Wolverine

April 5th, 2021 at 2:41 PM ^

My only worry is we might lose one or two of the new recruits who could be here for three or four years down the road

If that is a concern I think it is a trade we would gladly make, another year of Brooks/Brown for however many years of Freshman X.  Howard is proving to be an elite recruiter and talent evaluator so replacing whoever might move on may not be that difficult

Erik_in_Dayton

April 5th, 2021 at 2:57 PM ^

The guy whom I would worry most about, even if Smith comes back, is Barnes. I say that only because he is the one who would presumably struggle to find any minutes at all. I don't think Collins and/or Bufkin could complain too much if they don't start. They would still play and aren't "obvious starter from Day One" guys. But Barnes would likely be stuck behind Brown and Houstan.

Blue In NC

April 5th, 2021 at 12:33 PM ^

Exciting to think about next year's team.  IF Brown and Brooks returned, then you are probably looking at an overall defensive upgrade as a team.  We are losing Franz and Livers but getting Diabate who will be dynamic, Johns' increased role, plus more height at PG (although Smith did way better than I expected), plus more depth and experience.  Hunter will probably even improve a bit.

The only minor concerns would be PG ball handling (Brooks or lack of experience) and a somewhat lack of offensive, dribble creators but those are nitpicks and this year's team had much of the same issue.  Overall depth would be greatly improved.  Can't wait.

Teeba

April 5th, 2021 at 12:35 PM ^

I normally don’t count on freshmen coming in and contributing right away. I’ve seen too many highly touted players come in and not live up to the hype right away. Competing against other high school kids is just a different deal than competing against 22 year old, grown ass men. That said, I’m confident Houstan and Diabate will be in the rotation. Houstan’s shooting stroke and Diabate’s athleticism translate. 
I do want to pump the breaks on Diabate backing up the 4 and the 5. That’s asking a lot of a freshman. I can see HD, Johns and Diabate splitting 80 minutes, but that means Johns going back to the small ball 5 when HD sits. If any of the 3 get in foul trouble, it would be really nice to have Davis on the roster.

SteveInPhilly

April 5th, 2021 at 1:01 PM ^

I see where you're coming from with questioning a frosh learning two positions, but Diabate will have a lot more familiarity with the responsibilities of the five position, so it might make sense to maximize his time spent there. I also think Houstan could get some minutes at the 4 if there is a foul trouble scenario with the regular 4-5 rotation.