OT - Best game system for kids

Submitted by username on

I did a quick search and it looked like the last time this was discussed was a few years ago, but apologies if this is a repeat of a recent topic.

I am planning to get my 8-year old son his first game system and wanted to see if there was a consensus on the board as to which of the current options is best.  The last system I owned was ColecoVision in the 80's, so I have no relevant first-hand experience on the topic.

In addition to games played while sitting, he says he also likes playing the games where you're more active (Wii, Kinnect, I believe). 

I understand there is an online component to gaming, but at his current age, we're going to try to keep that under wraps for a while and keep all interaction inside our home. 

My hope is this is a system that will last him a few years.

Any new systems on the horizon that are worth waiting for?

Thanks for the help.

 

uncle leo

July 19th, 2017 at 12:56 PM ^

Riiiiight. That's why the PS4 is continuing to roll the XBOX One Doorstop in sales.

If exclusives don't matter to you, then the only reason to prefer an XBOX is for the menu system and controller. Other than that, it's all equal.

And I don't get how exclusives don't matter? That's a really odd thing to say.

UM Fan from Sydney

July 19th, 2017 at 1:02 PM ^

They don't matter to me. Why should they? As I stated, the only one right now that interests me is Spider-Man.

Another reason I don't have interest in PS is absolutely none of my friends own one, so being able to play with them is a big deal. Also, I'm not losing my Xbox gamer score. It's far too high.

uncle leo

July 19th, 2017 at 12:41 PM ^

Who said they were outside 8 hours a day, I am calling your bluff. Yes, I enjoyed going outside a ton. But come on, new systems were absolutely revolutionary and mind-blowing throughout our youth.

You just have to find a good balance. I'll always remember the 6+ hour Goldeneye marathons with my buddies, and also playing a ton of sports with them as well. 

dcmaizeandblue

July 19th, 2017 at 12:44 PM ^

I'd go with the switch. Nintendo has some great stuff coming out for it in the next few months. If you've got a PC there's not much need for a younger kid to have an Xbox or PlayStation. You can play minecraft on anything these days.

BlueinLansing

July 19th, 2017 at 12:44 PM ^

just wanted to comment that I live in a subdivision with around 250 homes.  I was always a little surprised at the lack of kids outside and figured I had simply moved into an older neighborhood with empty nesters. (most homes here built in early to mid 90s

When Pokemon debuted last summer I was shocked at the number of kids outside wandering around.

Its been a return to another quiet summer as pokemon fizzles and it seems most kids have retreated back into their dens to play whatever gaming system they have.  In this neighborhood, probably all of them.

Please encourage your kids to play outside more than on a video game system.

 

 

uncle leo

July 19th, 2017 at 12:49 PM ^

I would honestly like to see some form of a study done on this. Because I think it is something we say in 2017, but I really do not know how much, if any truth there is to it.

When I drive around my neighborhood and other subs, I still see plenty of young people outside doing whatever, biking, skateboarding. 

Technology was very addictive back then as it is today. The big problem is that everything we do in life is interwoven into the phone. But, I don't buy that everyone was outside and playing and life was grand (at least during my youth, 80s, 90s). Color TV, intro to new systems, those were VERY addictive. The difference is that life did not depend on those things yet, so it was easier to get away. 

CarlosSpicyweiner21

July 19th, 2017 at 1:13 PM ^

This issue is 2 fold. Sure kids are into gaming more than usual, but it also is a result of people not feeling comfortable letting there kids go out and play. When I grew up you knew most of your neighbors. Today both parents work 8-10 hr days and people just don't get to know the neighborhood as much.

Drbogue

July 19th, 2017 at 2:23 PM ^

Totally agree. Growing up in the eighties and my brother and I would leave the house at 8, ride our bikes for miles, return for lunch, leave again and finally return for dinner around 6 or 7. Now I live in Florida and have two kids 7 and 9. Between the literally crazy people who live down here, the police updates on the sexual predators, local news of kids being shot, etc. I've been transformed into a classic helicopter parent. We have a PS4 that my kids use for about an hour a week (Lego dimensions has finally worn off) and they mostly play iPad for a few hours a week. But because of the above paranoia my wife and I essentially schedule play dates, beach club, and keep them in activities as much as possible. The weather makes it easier year round. All that being said, I see. Itching wrong with video games in moderation. Certainly plenty of evidence in surgery residents that it improves hand eye coordination. I do agree that PS4 is kore of a nature or teen centered console except for sports. Okay done rambling...

uncle leo

July 19th, 2017 at 7:45 PM ^

But crime has always been going on. In fact, violent crime rate since the 80s has been dropping steadily. 

The reason everyone has this false mindset is because there were MUCH fewer options to report back then. We now have access to information all the time. 

EGD

July 20th, 2017 at 5:19 AM ^

Part of this is self-fulfilling though. In my generation (born in '75), there were always lots of kids playing outside without supervision and so you had safety in numbers. Nowadays parents keep their kids indoors, so if you're the one parent who sends your kid outside to play then (i) there probably won't be other kids for yours to play with, (ii) your kid is probably the one target if there actually are any creeps or predators around, and (iii) your kid probably won't know how to handle any dangerous situations that do arise because your kid isn't accustomed to being out there without an adult around. I find this endlessly frustrating but it is what it is.

ericcarbs

July 19th, 2017 at 12:46 PM ^

The Wii is the best system for "movement" games. And it is a generation old so should be $100ish used. Games will be like $20 used so good deal.

However for a new system, the switch might be good by end of this year but only 1 great game on it at the moment. Also cool to play at home and on the go. Then it's just the Xbox vs PS debate. Overall, there isn't a huge difference, just exclusives.

stephenrjking

July 19th, 2017 at 12:47 PM ^

The best games for PS4/Xbox tend to be rated M and feature a lot of mature content. There's other stuff there, but the money is in the teen-adult market and that's what the manufacturers produce. The best games for Nintendo (including the new Switch) tend to be aimed at all ages. There are fewer of them, but they are high quality. For kids, it's an easy choice for me. YMMV. The one exception: sports games are few and far between on Switch. PS4/XBox are clearly better choices if you like to play those. I have neither but continue to use my 360 for this purpose and the 360 is better supported than any Nintendo system.

poseidon7902

July 19th, 2017 at 12:59 PM ^

This is only true if you are talking about AAA titles.  In other words, the big game releases announced at E3 with movie quality trailers.  Those are going to be geared toward the COD/GOT crowd.  

If you get past those though, the Xbox and PS4 both have amazingly good Indie Developed games. These are always much cheaper than their AAA couterparts (When your development budget is 1/1000th that of a AAA it kind of goes without saying) and are usually clean and a ton of fun.  Lots of side scrollers (Think Contra) or puzzle games etc...  

if you have to buy only the big release titles for the system, then the Switch is the only one I'd recommend for any kid.  

UM Fan from Sydney

July 19th, 2017 at 12:48 PM ^

Probably the Switch, which I want. I am also an avid Xboxer. The Switch seems awesome, though. I'd love to get my hands on the new Zelda and Mario Kart games.

Idzerd

July 19th, 2017 at 12:51 PM ^

Magnovox/Philips Odyssey^2

(Somewhat seriously)

sports games better than the 2600. Arcade games hold their own. O^2's version of Pacman infinitely better than the 2600's!!!


RioThaN

July 19th, 2017 at 1:07 PM ^

If it were for you I'd say wait for the Xbox one x, or buy a nice pc if you're willing to spend at least 1500 dollars but for a kid as young the switch is the answer, I like to use my consoles for streaming content and the like and the switch sucks at that plus the games are mostly targeted at youngsters so he'll love it.

RioThaN

July 19th, 2017 at 1:42 PM ^

I meant something with a 1080 that will be better than the Xbox one x out of the box, but a 1050ti or a 1060 are more powerful than an Xbox one or a ps4, is just that for the price the Xbox one x is better, if you count out the whole having a pc that can run word and all that

Wendyk5

July 19th, 2017 at 1:07 PM ^

Screens are either A) the ruination of civilization or B) what rock 'n' roll was to the 50's - all the adults who didn't understand it thought it was the ruination of civiliation, but it turned out to be a progressive period in music that gave way to other genres, and still maintains its popularity today (without having ruined civilization). 

CarlosSpicyweiner21

July 19th, 2017 at 1:09 PM ^

For what you want I would say the Switch. Xbox and PS4 games are mostly for older kids. The only downfall of the Switch right now is the limited game selection. The Switch allows for sit and game, motion gaming ala Wii and it also can be a portable gaming device for those long road trips.

Goggles Paisano

July 19th, 2017 at 1:11 PM ^

We got an Xbox a couple years ago.  I grew up with Intellivision which I thought was pretty awesome when compared to Atari or Colecovision.  The Xbox frustrates me as you have to sign up with an email for each player and then constantly get bombarded with pop ups while playing to purchase Xbox Gold or some shit like that.  I'm sure it's easy to get around for the younger folks that play all day, but for the "older" parents it is really annoying.  I just want to be able to put the disc in the machine and play the game.  

/now get off my lawn

N. Campus Tech

July 19th, 2017 at 1:19 PM ^

I just bought my kids the Xbox 360 last year. there are no new titles, but there are still a ton of games. many of them used.

If we can find one, we will get a Switch at Christmas

OwenGoBlue

July 19th, 2017 at 1:22 PM ^

If you go PS4/Xbox One check out the new game subscription services.

Ex: You can give EA $5 a month for last year's Madden, NHL, FIFA, NBA Live (which sucks compared to 2k, but still) and a bunch of others. If your kid plays sports games with friends that might be more appealing than dropping a bunch on titles, and you can cancel anytime. 

Perkis-Size Me

July 19th, 2017 at 1:29 PM ^

How many jerks on here are going to say "none, make them play outside" instead?

It's all about a finding a balance. I agree that kids shouldn't lock themselves away for 8 hours a day playing video games, but there's nothing wrong with them playing it a few hours a week either. 

That all being said, I have a PS4 now and I love it. I don't play it very much, maybe an hour or two a week, but its a great way for me to relax if I've had a crappy day at work or just want to mellow out. But in a few years, I think it's going to be the new Oculus Rift. Once every game is compatible for that kind of VR technology, gaming as we know it will change forever. 

Perkis-Size Me

July 19th, 2017 at 2:07 PM ^

People were saying the same crap about TV 30-40 years ago and now we all watch it at least several hours every week. In some cases a lot more than that with "binge-watching."

Video games are becoming mainstream entertainment more and more every year. No point in fighting it. Not that hard to set ground rules with your kids on how often they can play and what else they should be doing with their lives. If you can't do that, maybe the kids or the video games aren't the problem. Maybe it's you. 

Perkis-Size Me

July 19th, 2017 at 4:40 PM ^

Agreed. I've had quite a bit of fun in the past on some late-night Halo escapades. I don't mind video games being part of my kid's lives, as long as they don't BECOME my kid's lives. 

If you play video games, all well and good by me. But you're also going to either play sports, or learn a musical instrument, or join some after-school clubs, or get a part-time job, or something else productive that gets you the hell out of the house. 

denardogasm

July 19th, 2017 at 1:30 PM ^

If you're planning on limiting his time playing video games, which I hope you are, just get him an original Nintendo. Anything new and he'll spend his entire allotted time waiting for that shit to load, and then you're gonna get a tv breaking tantrum. Nintendo is instant gratification and he can play it with another human being who's actually in the room.

The Maizer

July 19th, 2017 at 2:55 PM ^

My wife bought me a refurbished one from eBay as a gift. The seller for some reason accidentally sent two (complete with 2 sets of controllers and 2 duck hunt guns). I have a backup now if the first one ever dies (stil working fine after 5ish years).

blueinmilwaukee

July 19th, 2017 at 1:48 PM ^

It's important for kids to get early exposure to technology. That said, I'd stick with PC gaming and us an Xbox One or Steam controller. Knowledge of PCs outweighs knowledge of consoles.

BobGarage

July 19th, 2017 at 2:09 PM ^

Back in my day a kid would leave the house in the morning to smoke a cig, drink a few bottles of booze stolen from the old mans liquor cabinet, steal a few candy bars at the local grocery store, fish with some friends while smoking a little ganja, play in a condemned house held together by a few rusty nails and then head to school. While at school we would make napalm during chemistry class, take it home, coat GI Joe from head to toe & light him on fire in the driveway. My point is game systems are a good thing.