Could Michigan win tomorrow with me as the QB?

Submitted by 1464 on

Seeing as Jake Rudddock may or may not be healthy enough to start tomorrow, I felt this would be an appropriate question.

If I were to start as the QB for Michigan tomorrow and play the entirety of the game, would Michigan still win?

I guess in this exercise, my abilities as a QB are probably pretty inconsequential.  For a random person off the street, I'd be a 8.5/10 in terms of QB abilities.  You probably wouldn't mind having me on your flag football team, but I wouldn't wow anyone either.  In terms of a college QB, though, I would be a -6/10.  I don't know the scheme.  I haven't played organized football in 13 years (and 50 lbs).

The real point of this post is to determine whether people think that Michigan can pull off a win despite any and all shortcomings at the QB position.  Should we be worried if Jake is in street clothes, or should we still be able to shrug it off and expect a comfortable win?

SMart WolveFan

November 6th, 2015 at 10:56 AM ^

But I have the utmost confidence that Speight, Morris, Malzone or even Dan Cleary, scratch that, especially Dan Cleary would lead Mich to victory tomorrow.

 

The good news is that Rurgers wouldn't lose musch worse if you where THEIR QB.

Leaders And Best

November 6th, 2015 at 11:04 AM ^

Michigan would line you up at QB every play, but then motion you to split out to keep your dumb ass from screwing up the play and run Peppers as wildcat QB. With an average athlete with average football IQ, I think we could pull it off. Based on this stupid question though and the fact you spelled Rudock with 3 D's, I don't think we could pull it off with you. So the answer is no.

Ty Butterfield

November 6th, 2015 at 11:02 AM ^

I honestly wish they would sit Jake for this game and let him rest up. I still think he has some sort of ongoing injury/issue. It would probably really help for him to sit a game.

EGD

November 6th, 2015 at 11:31 AM ^

I have to agree with this sentiment. Yeah, Rutgers isn't great to begin with, Caroo looks like he won't play, and their program is going through a bunch of turmoil at the moment. But they did beat M last year, took MSU to the wire, and have a handful of really good athletes who could give us problems if at the top of their game. I do think M will win and that it won't be close, but posting questions about "could M win with 1484 at quarterback?" doesn't really sit well with me.

Naked Bootlegger

November 6th, 2015 at 11:18 AM ^

Yes.

Just approach the line of scrimmage, confidently scan the Rutgers defense, yell "Omaha, Omaha" a few times, then hand off to the RB du jour.

Also, please practice the quick-hitting FB dive play ad nauseum.

MeanJoe07

November 6th, 2015 at 11:20 AM ^

1484:

Height: 5'10"

Weight: 275

40 Time: 3 Days, 4 Hours, 7 Minutes and 39 Seconfs  (0 Fakes out of 5)

Offers:  Please go away here's $5

YMRMFPSA:  David Cone or Jobba the Hutt

Why David Cone? If you cut off David Cone's Legs and Arms and strapped a 300 LB sack of sand to his back you would basically have 1484.  His vision is great, but there is the no arms caveat.

1464

November 6th, 2015 at 11:26 AM ^

1484:

Height: 6'4"

Weight: 285 (you underestimated)

40 Time: The are probably 3 players in the NFL I would beat in a footrace at this point in my life

Offers:  Had a few D3 as a soccer goalie

YMRMFPSA:  Blake O'Neill attempting a fake punt

David Cone does not apply.  He is a far superior rapper to me.

DeBored

November 6th, 2015 at 11:22 AM ^

Needs more evaluation, please answer the following questions:

1)  Do you get 8 hours of sleep or more a night?

2)  Do you drink milk, WHOLE milk?

3)  Do you drink enough water?

4)  Do you have a robust vitamin regimen, including STEAK?

Ah hell.  As long as we get about 10 plays with Peppers at Wildcat we'll be fine regardless.

1464

November 6th, 2015 at 11:30 AM ^

1) No.  Not even close.

2) No, but I eat a lot of cheese.  Not that 2% shit either.

3) Actually, yes.  Coffee, water, and beer are the only liquids that get into this temple...

4) Steak, yes.  All the others no.  Been eating a lot of Starburst since the kids went Trick-or-treating.  Do those have Vitamin C?

Wisconsin Wolverine

November 6th, 2015 at 11:24 AM ^

I'll bet I could lose the game for UM if I was quarterbacking.  I would find a way.  I'd say there would be a 1 in 3 chance every play that I turn the ball over if I'm asked to throw, and only a 1 in 10 chance of an actual completion - deep balls and anything remotely challenging are not on the menu for me.  I'm sure Harbaugh would game plan for this and make me hand it off every play, but I would still deliver a sub-optimal handoff probably 3 out of 4 times because I don't know where the RB is going and I'm not used to how quickly the play develops.  I'd estimate a 1 in 5 chance of me fumbling the handoff every play.  So our offense has become slightly less than 1-dimensional, and our 1 dimension is handicapped significantly.  Our blocking and running is decent, but is it enough?  If it didn't violate the rules of this thought exercise, I'm sure Harbaugh would have me motion to the receiver position every play and let Peppers take snaps.