Michigan 29 Minnesota 26 Comment Count

Seth

barron

A wall.

Michigan had their hands on it all game, and it kept slipping through their fingers. Peppers dropped a pick-six after jumping a WR screen. Dymonte Thomas and Jarrod Wilson both dropped interceptions they had two hands on (Dymonte’s was then caught by a Gopher). Jourdan Lewis and Jeremy Clark probably could have grabbed a pair of Leidner ducks they played with Connor Cook-level respect. Thomas also let a perfect Blake O’Neill punt bounce through his hands for a touchback. Each time the Gophers capitalized.

For its part, Minnesota held on like men who don’t know what they’d do with their lives if they couldn’t run around in goofy armor for a chance to win some painted old pottery. On 4th and 5 on Minnesota’s last drive, K.J. Maye had one inch to catch a slant against perhaps the best cornerback in the country, and  didn’t drop it. Neither did his receiver mate Drew Wolitarsky, who on the ensuing 2nd down beat Channing Stribling with a double move and hauled in a pass at the 1 inch line.

With the clock running Mitch Leidner moved his pieces around to set up a winning TD, but the Michigan defense chased him out of his pocket. That left 2 seconds for either a field goal attempt to force overtime, or a play to win. An average team against an average defense should get that QB sneak 9 times out of 10. But Minnesota was no average offense; they had a true freshman at center and other replacements all around him. And Michigan was no average defense. For one, Ryan Glasgow was the guy right over the ball. For two, D.J. Durkin was making the calls.

Glasgow won the battle he’d won all game, the rest of Michigan’s goal line defense closed around him, and together they grasped the life out the old rival. For that they get to hold the Jug again.peppers

While the Minnesotasphere will spend the next week replaying final scenarios (and the choice to play for a field goal at the end of the first half), Michigan fans will try to unpack all of the misfortunes and misplays that almost made the Little Brown Jug miss the flight home from its year abroad.

So much about Michigan has changed since then that it’s hard to remember this is still a team put together by Brady Hoke and held together by Harbaugh’s ingenuity. You can’t blame the old coach for everything, but Michigan’s recent history was all over this game.

Those weren’t all bad things. The interior defensive line was its magnificent self. Jourdan Lewis was. Chesson dropped one earlier but held onto his horizontal touchdown, and Darboh’s hands made sure it was 3 points, not 1, that Minnesota needed from our 1.

Hoke also left Jabrill Peppers, who, finally, was the answer one too many of Michigan’s questions. Need an athletic nickel to neutralize the spread? Peppers. Need a strong safety? Peppers. Cornerback. Kick returner. Punt returner. Running back. Slot receiver. Quarterback?

So yeah, this week we’re going to talk about the Morris-or-bust plan, because early in the third quarter Jake Rudock went to slide, and a defender tried to separate his head from his shoulders. It was the third time (the second was earlier in this game) this season he was clearly targeted with no call.

With Michigan down 23-21 at this point Harbaugh inserted Wilton Speight, whose play was about what you expect out of Wilton Speight. He did finally get his feet under him on the final drive, with his last two passes of the game the touchdown to Chesson and the two-point conversion to Darboh. Let that be the final word on wither Shane Morris.

(Rudock was on the sideline trying to throw after being examined and just about everyone noted Michigan informed the press it was a shoulder injury rather than, you know, making it a thing.)

Desmond Morgan did not have a good game, giving up a long run when he got out of his lane, getting caught too far inside on a long wheel route, letting Brandon Lingen sneak behind him for a long pass at the beginning of the 4th quarter, and letting Rodney Smith shuck him to give up a crucial 3rd and 17.

That and the dodgy score and the Halloween candy had Michigan perilously close to vomiting up a Hoke game in 2015. But they ultimately held it down, and the feeling will pass with time.

Comments

J.

November 1st, 2015 at 1:12 AM ^

After the Oregon State game, Harbaugh said that Morris was the backup QB but that it would be disrespectful to put him out there (burning his redshirt) in a game that had been decided.  Seth alludes to it toward the end of the post, but either Harbaugh was lying or Speight has won the job.  And, considering that Wilton Speight has now had one successful 40-yard drive in his football career, I expect it to be Morris who transfers at the end of the season (or who finishes his degree at Michigan while taking garbage time snaps, if he so chooses).

So, I wanted to give kudos to Coach Harbaugh for preserving Shane's eligibility, even knowing that said extra year probably won't be at Michigan and could even be against Michigan.  Playing this season is not in Shane Morris's best interest, and it's clear after tonight that Harbaugh is only keeping him on the travel roster in case of injuries to both Rudock and Speight.  I like having a coach with character.

schreibee

November 1st, 2015 at 1:43 AM ^

I think there's both very little chance Shane is ever Michigan's starting QB and that we ever have to face him.

He will likely transfer to a lower division school that doesn't require him to sit another year. So unless we've got Grand Valley or Eastern Illinois on our schedule we're probably safe.

Alton

November 1st, 2015 at 11:24 AM ^

If he transfers to a FBS school, he will have to sit out another year, and will therefore have only 1 year of eligibility remaining.  In order to keep 2 years, he would have to transfer down.

In other words...if he transfers to a FBS school,

2013 - play (true Freshman)

2014 - play (true Sophomore)

2015 - sit (redshirt season)

2016 - sit (transfer season)

2017 - play (5th year Senior)

DrewGOBLUE

November 1st, 2015 at 1:34 AM ^

Seems a bit presumptuous regarding Morris. It's not like Jake Rudock was carted off the field, and Harbaugh obviously had a much better idea of Rudock's status well before anyone else. He may have known it wasn't likely to be a long-term injury, and thought it wouldn't be fair to Shane if he had to burn his redshirt for 1-2 games.

That's not to say Morris would've otherwise played, or that Wilton Speight wasn't the clearcut #2 QB.

But to assume Shane is so far down the totem pole, to the point that it's a seemingly foregone conclusion he'll transfer after this season or next, is unjustified.

Danwillhor

November 1st, 2015 at 4:55 AM ^

but a buddy of mine who sometimes "knows shit" (lol, he knows a lot of guys on the team and is always dead on with the info he's shared) told me before the season that Speight was "as good as already gone, he's transferring". I asked how he could be sure (I assumed but he was beyond sure) and he said he'd directly heard it from people I'll leave out of this. He said he's never really liked being IN Michigan and he knows he'll l never play here. Knows it and has said it. Fast forward to before he ever took a garbage snap and I'm told Speight is the backup and "I guess his attitude has changed a lot for the better the last few weeks. He's apparently been a completely different teammate than before the opener." I dunno? Nothing specific as I didn't say anything and then he is, in fact, the backup. I get the feeling that he could still leave but it wouldn't be out of the reasons before. Maybe playing time should O'Korn win the job and/or a younger QB step up? We'll see. Nothing "insidery" but kinda lol. I haven't heard anything about leaving but I "feel" like Morris sees the writing. The only way he stays is if he truly feels like he's wanted, has improved and has a shot to play. Those obvious things, etc. Does he? Will he? I can't even speculate with certainty but it's a feeling he'll be gone regardless of Speight. I think the staff already knows but not pulling the RS is not necessarily an indictment! He never burned the RS on Luck, IIRC. Luck as a true freshman was better than anything they had and Harbaugh wouldn't mortgage the future on immediate results. I'm not saying Morris is Luck (!) but maybe all is not lost. I just feel like he may know a change of scenery is needed, etc. Either way, I doubt the staff is caught surprised. I'm sure they have a idea already. I don't think we need rumors for that no matter how credible.

Seth

November 1st, 2015 at 7:38 AM ^

I don't think your friend was the only one who knew Speight was considering transferring. I take issue with the idea that this would be an attitude problem. Michigan brought in a lot of quarterbacks with a lot of eligibility to cover the duration of Speight's eligibility. If he transfers it seems like it would be one of those where both sides respect the decision. Not all these QBs can play. I should also note that virtually every player I have met in this job was seriously considering a transfer at some point. That is not just a reflection of all the shit Michigan has been through, which was harder on the players than the fans. Unless you are starting as a freshman and starring as a sophomore, I think everybody wonders if they'd get a better shot elsewhere. Most players who start process do not finish it. Most players who do transfer do not succeed at their new schools. Humans just naturally believe there's more opportunity on the other side of the hill.

gbdub

November 1st, 2015 at 10:01 AM ^

Eh, I kind of thought the "short term backup" meant that Shane was better, but Speight is probably getting more second team snaps to be ready to be the in game backup. Still, the two must be close for that to even be an option.

If Rudock is a no-go then I bet we see a real competition for the spot this week.



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

BrightonB

November 1st, 2015 at 1:17 AM ^

This was not the same Gophers.  Coach Kill just had to retire out of nowhere.  The Gophers wanted this game.  They played their hearts out.  Our team played flat but to say it wasn't a tough hard fought game (and some of the flat play due to the good play and luck of the Gophers) would not be true.  We were very lucky to be able to have a shot at the end of the game.  That goal line stand was just awesome.  Bottom line I think many of us would say ... Miracle loss ...... Miracle win ... back to back.  I am glad luck was on our side tonight.

It was an important win and the team we played tonight was no cream puff.  They wanted that win very very badly.

Next ..... glad that one is over !

BrightonB

November 1st, 2015 at 11:43 AM ^

I totally agree.  I meant we got some luck at the very end with the last 16 seconds or so with all the odd play calling at the end and them not kicking to tie it and such. I felt it (luck) swung a little our way finally after they had a lot of luck (with what you said) all game.

It's just a big .. sheeeeeeeew..... ahhh we won type of thing.  =)

 

freejs

November 1st, 2015 at 1:18 AM ^

I mean, seriously, what the fucking fuck. 

Fucking patty cake that does nothing IS targeting, try to separate our quarterback's head from his shoulders, NOT targeting. 

I just want to focus on we get the jug and forget everything else that could have gone wrong there but didn't, but this targeting madness, what the hell. 

 

Goggles Paisano

November 1st, 2015 at 6:33 AM ^

That sure looked like targeting and the vicious variety.  Shame on Blackledge and Nessler for not even mentioning it.  After his helmet was launched I kept looking for the flag.  That rule is far too subjective sometimes and also far too literal at others.  They need to eliminate it as they just cannot get it right  and the penalty is just too harsh with the ejection.  

Glennsta

November 1st, 2015 at 8:01 AM ^

When I first saw it, I thought the first guy came in helmet first but Eudock wasn't down and didn't get hit high hit enough.  Second guy didn't come in helmet first but Rudock seemed defenseless by then.

Operable part to me is that the rule says that "when in question, it is a foul."

I didn't think it a violation until I actually read the rule. It's more a question of defenselessness and intent. You don't actually need to use the helmet.

http://www.afca.com/article/article.php?id=2342

 

jackw8542

November 1st, 2015 at 12:45 PM ^

Look at the replay.  The second guy lowered his head to insure helmet-to-helmet contact.  He easily could have (and had time) to make sure he had minimal contact with Rudock and, instead, attempted to decapitate him when he was clearly defenseless.  The second he sees Rudock starting to slide, he has to be looking for a way to avoid any unnecessary contact.

Compare this to when the ref threw a flag when a leg of one of our players brushed (at most) the Minnesota QB.  The flag was picked up, but at least someone thought that barely touching a QB by a player obviously trying to avoid contact might be enough to justify a penalty.

Big Boutros

November 1st, 2015 at 1:44 AM ^

With Michigan down 23-21 at this point Harbaugh inserted Wilton Speight, whose play was about what you expect out of Wilton Speight.
Is this a joke? Speight won the game. He was 3-3 for 30 yards and a touchdown with under 5 minutes to go on the road in his first real action of his career. Then he added a nails 2PT conversion that allowed us to stuff Minnesota at the goal line instead of lose on a chip shot field goal. Speight killed it tonight.

Bertello NC

November 1st, 2015 at 1:00 AM ^

Ya with all the Halloween jerrysota hoopla and coming off a bye week after a loss which was stolen from us by a one in a million play and refs who should be suspended for half a season I think we did what we had to do to win a tough ball game against a team who was playing out of their mind. Don't get me wrong our D surprised me a bit but still with JR going down after a non targeting call for Speight to come in and after a shaky first series, I thought did a commendable job. He did everything he was asked to do and then some. It would've been tough for any team to go in and win that game. For JH to do it in year one with Hoke's players and have a BACK-UP QB go in, in a pressure situation and win the game is a testament to his coaching/preparation ability.

UM76

November 1st, 2015 at 1:54 AM ^

Wilton Speight's performance tonight needs to be appreciated for what it is. He came in cold and put together a winning drive on the road against a team that was playing their best. What more is it we're asking of this student athlete? How can anybody trivialize this level of play?

Der Alte

November 1st, 2015 at 9:41 AM ^

"remember a time in recent history when an M backup [QB] did that." You and the rest of us remember Russell Bellomy and Shane Morris entering a game and pitching INCs and INTs and M ending up on the short end of the score. Neither you nor the rest of us remember a coaching staff evaluating and developing QB talent to the point that a backup QB could enter a game and still win it.

I'm probably still basking in the afterglow, but 'ol Wilton's rifle-shot TD pass to Jehu was about as good a throw as any Jake made all evening. And Wilton's presence of mind to flip to ball to an open Amara for the 2-pointer was a great play as well. Even if Jake isn't ready to go this Saturday, M should still be in pretty good hands. I mean, Jake's 13-21-1 for 140 yards and 1 TD isn't all that high a bar. I'd still like to see Jake start, but if he doesn't it's not the end of the world.

And by the way, barring absolute catastrophe, does anyone else agree that Shane Morris might have already played his last down for Michigan?

MC5-95

November 1st, 2015 at 1:53 AM ^

But if Shane was the clear #2, Harbaugh puts him in there because the goal is to win the game, not save Shane freakin Morris some games two years from now. Now it may be that Speight and Morris are pretty even in Harbaugh's mind, so maybe he leaves Shane's redshirt in that case, but that's not because Shane's the #2. It's because Speight is close enough to #2 that it doesn't matter.



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

ThoseWhoStayUofM

November 1st, 2015 at 1:49 AM ^

You're not wrong, but you're also not doing yourself any favors after the "refs are the reason Michigan lost to MSU" post either.  I feel for you, because you open yourself up to criticism when you tell the truth like this...  Just be thankful you're expressing the truth to a widely Michigan-oriented audience.

ca_prophet

November 1st, 2015 at 1:20 AM ^

Just before he starts to slide, the outside defender who was coming in at his waist shifts down and hits with his helmet on Jake's left upper arm.  That shoves his head right in to the helmet/neck of the inside defender (#99), who is running with his head up.

Bolden got ejected for less than that, but I wouldn't have called targeting on either of these hits.  (The helmet to the chin strike is a different story.)

kehnonymous

November 1st, 2015 at 3:19 AM ^

Bottom line is that we played poorly and missed out on most of the 50/50 situations... but found a way to win. To some extent, yes it does matter *how* you found a way to win as this certainly wasn't pretty.  But even more important is that you do find a way.  These are 18-22 year old kids and they're not going to be a well-oiled death machine every week.  Every team gets outplayed by a generally worse opponent at least once per season.  But again, we found a way to win that we wouldn't have managed with the previous coaching staff is games against non-Northwestern opponents.

SallyMi

November 1st, 2015 at 4:44 AM ^

Download Jupiter Ascending Online, memrise com/course/864357/laslicourse/thread/1525267/ Jupiter Ascending 2015 full movie online free t9ys552, Download the Film Magic Mike XXL, memrise com/course/864357/laslicourse/thread/1524993/ Watch Magic Mike XXL Online 1xyp1wm, 6 Years 2015 full online, memrise com/course/864357/laslicourse/thread/1525108/ 6 Years 2015 full movie free 0r9skxs, Watch Everest 2015 Film Free, memrise com/course/864357/laslicourse/thread/1525160/ Everest movie free iaz6koq, Download Fifty Shades of Grey 2015 Movie, memrise com/course/864357/laslicourse/thread/1524711/ Download Fifty Shades of Grey 2015 Film Free 8y23so8, Download Cinderella 2015 Movie Free, memrise com/course/864357/laslicourse/thread/1524939/ Cinderella full free 6vo5c8b, Watch free Vacation Movie, memrise com/course/864357/laslicourse/thread/1524799/ Watch Vacation free Online dgqq6al, Watch Dope 2015 Film Free, memrise com/course/864357/laslicourse/thread/1525213/ Download Dope Movie ro647o6, Download Kingsman: The Secret Service 2015 Movie Free, memrise com/course/864357/laslicourse/thread/1525055/ Kingsman: The Secret Service 2015 full movie 0ahczrv, Strange Magic 2015 online, memrise com/course/864357/laslicourse/thread/1525321/ Online Strange Magic movie 2er1oqw,

Sgarv

November 1st, 2015 at 6:01 AM ^

Your list of near picks is missing the one I thought was complete: Peppers pick 6 that wasnt.

Its incredible to me that UM played with so many errors and just plain bad luck, while the Gophers were nearly error free while catching every break, yet not only did Michigan win, but stayed in the game throughout.