A post best read with Rilo Kiley - A Better Son/ Daughter on blast. When we get back it is going to be so fucking wonderful.
that is nice bonus change
2003 Minnesota: trailing 14-0, Michigan has driven to around midfield. John Navarre chucks a WR screen to Steve Breaston, who throws it back to Navarre. Forty yards later, we all have beards and Michigan is within seven points.
At some point in the 2003 Minnesota game I needed to get off the couch after something enraging had happened. I was on it with my girlfriend at the time and she sort of ended up on the ground as I executed my plan. The couch was low to the ground, she was unharmed, and in the aftermath the incident seemed funny. At the time all I could do was clench and unclench my fists.
Michigan would eventually deploy an all-shotgun offense in the fourth quarter that shredded Minnesota for 24 points and win the game on a Garrett Rivas 33-yarder, but at the time it was grim. It would have been more grim but for the trick play of the decade:
In the aftermath a friend immediately called me screaming "WHAT." It wasn't a question. It was just "WHAT." That. From seven year's distance it appears to be the slowest, most awkward touchdown convoy in school history.
Eventually it was key in Michigan's comeback win and Rose Bowl berth but really it's just here for its sheer improbability. It was one thing to run the transcontinental with Drew Henson; doing it with John Navarre—and getting a touchdown out of it—is pure audacity. This, by the way, is why Minnesota bloggers will never do a Worst Plays of the Decade list.
MGoRetro: Pit Bull.
Penn State, 2006: it's second or third and long or something again, can't remember, doesn't matter, and I'm back in the pocket and I know I'm going to die. My offensive line has proven itself entirely hypothetical at this point. So I'm going to die, and it's not going to have any purpose. But this time I actually get a faint semblance of protection and I manage to find an open receiver—I'd forgotten those even existed—and I hurl it out there. And if Alan Branch hadn't driven his facemask into my shoulder and run through my tiny hoo-man body and left me in a concussed heap on the ground I would have gotten to see a first down. Which would have been nice.
But then I might have had to play the rest of the game instead of getting an emergency cup of pudding repurposed from JoePa's stash. So, yeah. I could go either direction, as long as it's 180 degrees from wherever Branch is going.
When Michigan fans are (unwisely, these days) attempting to tweak their Penn State coworkers this play, and the iconic image from its aftermath, is their go-to option. That's a meaningful statement when you've got most of a decade's worth of gloating to choose from, including another play on this list.
As for the significance of the play, Penn State had bounced back from its early decade malaise in a big way in 2005, going 11-1 with the only loss featured a bit higher on this list. By the time the PSU game rolled around in '06 it was obviously the only thing standing between Michigan and a 1-vs-2 matchup against Ohio State at the end of the season. Michigan's last four opponents would all finish with losing records; the only road game was against Indiana. When Anthony Morelli got blasted out of the game the decks were clear.
More than that, though, Alan Branch being in ur base is emblematic of the first ten games of 2006, when the Michigan defense was 1997 all over again and things were, briefly, back on course.
MGoRetro: Quod Erat Demonstrandum
Notre Dame, 2006: Late in the first quarter, Michigan and Notre Dame are tied 7-7 after exchanging terrible interceptions when Chad Henne drops back to pass and launches one deep. Pat Haden breaks the suspense before the cameraman can catch up to a streaking Manningham by declaring "oh, wide open." When Manningham finally appears he is running under a perfectly thrown ball, all alone.
Michigan entered the 2006 game uncertain of its place in the college football universe after a frustrating 7-5 season this blog nicknamed the "Year of Infinite Pain," if only to highlight how sheltered the Michigan fanbase has been in the aftermath of the last couple years. And if Alan Branch sending Anthony Morelli to his happy place was emblematic of Michigan's run to Football Armageddon, Mario Manningham getting ten yards clear of the nearest Notre Dame cornerback was the moment the Year of Infinite Pain became part of the past:
Manningham would score twice more on deep balls as Michigan leapt out to a commanding lead. They didn't look back until the second quarter of the Ohio State game.
Michigan State, 2004: Braylon Edwards skies over yet another Michigan State defensive back, tying a game in which Michigan trailed by 17 with under nine minutes to go.
Braylon Edwards was the most frustrating great player in Michigan history, prone to terrible drops on easy throws and legendarily not "on the same page" as Lloyd Carr. But he was great, and never greater than the last eight minutes of regulation in the 2004 Michigan State game. If they gave out Heismans for a single game, they would have had to give Edwards two for this one.
It almost wasn't anything, though. In this game Michigan was driving in the third quarter, down 17-10, when Edwards fumbled around the 20. He was creeping towards the goat side of the ledger when DeAndra Cobb ran That Goddamned Counter Draw again and outran Ernest Shazor to the sideline and the endzone. But when you're down 17 with under eight minutes left, what is there to do other than chuck it up and tell the onside kick team that they should try really hard?
I remember many things about that game. I remember being cold as hell as the game dragged on and the heat fled from the stadium. I remember going over to a friend's house afterward and being told by his roommates that they had actually left immediately after the DeAndra Cobb TD. I remember another friend telling me that a State friend of his had turned the game off as soon as Michigan hit the field goal to get within 14—he didn't even wait for the onside kick. I remember turning around and jovially telling the State fans behind me that it was good that MSU missed their last-second 52-yard field goal attempt to win after a terrible PI call, because if it had gone in there was no way they were getting out of the stadium alive. But mostly I remember the shadows that gave the whole enterprise an otherworldly feel. It's without question the best game I've ever been to.
The pick here is the game-tying touchdown, as at that point victory seemed inevitable and the comeback was complete. Without it, the others are just coulda-been plays like the Mike Hart touchdown in the Horror.
Washington, 2002: Phil Brabbs hits a 44 yard field goal as time expires to beat Washington.
I've interacted with Phil Brabbs a little bit since he came down with cancer and I've read his blog and am wearing his bracelet, so I have a little insight here. The bracelet says DOMINATE and his blog has pictures of him DOMINATING various things from hospital ice cream to IVs to chemo drugs. Sometimes he makes his adorable children DOMINATE things. He's kind of like anthropomorphized Brawndo. So I'm betting that when Brabbs strolled onto the field after a preposterous sequence of events set him up with a potential game-winning field goal in the 2002 season opener, he was totally psyched to dominate himself some 44-yard field goal.
In this, he was utterly alone.
I'm sure his parents and wife tell him that they just knew he'd hit it, but after a career debut in which he missed 36 and 42 yard field goals badly enough for Michigan to send out Troy Neinberg on a 27-yarder that he shanked, no one in Michigan Stadium thought a 44-yard field goal with no time left on the clock was going in. This includes those nearest and dearest to him. I was just hoping it went forward.
Naturally, Brabbs did this:
Though Washington would end up one of the country's biggest disappointments at 7-6, they entered Michigan Stadium a top ten opponent. The moment the kick actually went through the actual uprights and everyone looked at the guy under the crossbar to make sure they hadn't hallucinated it, then looked at the other guy under the crossbar to make sure the first guy hadn't been hallucinating too, promised grand things. (That would fall apart in a ridiculous loss at Notre Dame in two weeks.)
MGoRetro: The New Math.
Penn State, 2005: With one second on the clock, Mario Manningham catches a deep slant to beat Penn State 27-25. 86 = 1, as Michigan State would learn in 2007.
Why is this number one? It didn't end up mattering, and it was already clear it wouldn't since Michigan was already 3-3 and headed nowhere in 2005. It was the end of a classic game that swung dramatically from one side to the other, but other games were better and meant more.
I think it's that :01 on the clock, the knowledge that that second was precarious, fought for by Lloyd Carr after the clock ran after a Michigan timeout, preserved by Steve Breaston's best Tyrone Butterfield impression, and ironically Joe Paterno's fault for getting his team an extra two seconds on what they thought was their game-winning drive. Michigan was living on borrowed time. It seemed like they'd been given a chance to go back and right wrongs. Scott Bakula was at quarterback.
Meanwhile, Michigan was locked in an existential crisis unknown for decades. The 1984 season could be written off as a fluke since Jim Harbaugh's broken leg threw everything into disarray and Michigan bounced right back afterwards; 2005 was entirely different. Michigan had never been 3-3 in my recollection. My brother and I spent a large chunk of the game being bitterly cynical about everything. We felt justified about it after the killer Henne fumble/botched extra point for two combination. We'd collectively decided to dull the pain by withdrawing emotionally. This was working for a while, and then the team decided to give the middle finger to the cosmic middle finger, getting off the mat twice. The culmination:
In the end, the game served as a reminder that bitterness is no fun, faith is rewarded, the kids on the field are more resilient than we are, and sometimes they can let us borrow some of that. A lot of the plays on this list were diminished by subsequent events in which Michigan failed to live up to the promise they had in that one moment, but this one has been magnified by the awful last couple of years. It promises a light at the end of the tunnel.
Drew Henson bootlegs his way into the OSU endzone to seal the win (2000) … Chris Perry puts the OSU game beyond doubt with a slashing bounceout TD to make it 35-21 (2003) … Breaston returns a punt for a touchdown against Indiana … Northwestern … Illinois … etc … Manningham's worm after the ND game (2006) … Chris Perry punches it against Penn State in to seal a win in Michigan Stadium's first OT game (2002) … Ron Zook seals the Outback Bowl by calling a reverse pass that Victor Hobson intercepts (2002) … Alain Kashama beats the Sex Cannon to a fumbled ball in the endzone, finally fulfilling four years of Canadian Reggie White hype (2002 Outback) … Jacob Stewart picks off Asad Abdul-Kaliq in the Buffalo Stampede game and returns it for a touchdown (2002) … Garrett Rivas finishes the Buffalo Stampede game with a field goal (2002) … Chad Henne hits Tyler Ecker for a game-winning touchdown against Minnesota and executes nailcoeds.exe (2004) … Braylonfest Part I … Braylonfest Part II … Braylonfest Part IV … Brian Thompson recovers an onside kick, greatly aiding Braylonfest parts II through IV … Jason Avant's catch against Northwestern (2003) … Marquise Walker's catch against Iowa (2001) … Jerome Jackson pops through a nonexistent hole against Iowa to establish himself useful, then scores the game-winning TD (2005) … the snap sails over Jimmy Clausen's head on the first play of the game (2007) … Michigan cracks open the Battle of Who Could Care Less against Illinois with a reverse pass (2007) … Manningham outruns Justin King to tie Penn State (2005) … Mike Hart drags Penn State tacklers for five of the most impressive eight yards of his career (2005) … Lamarr Woodley kicks off Yakety Sax (2006) … Prescott Burgess returns a Brady Quinn interception for a TD(2006) … Mike Hart levels Sean Lee on a blitz pickup (2007) … Arrington's catch against Florida (2007) … A ludicrous Ryan Mallett decision—pitch it backwards to Carson Butler as he's being sacked—works out (2007) … Steven Threet takes off on a 60-yard jaunt against Wisconsin (2008) … Denard Robinson fumbles the first snap as Michigan's quarterback and WOOPs his way for a touchdown (2009) … Darryl Stonum returns a kickoff for a touchdown against Notre Dame (2009) … Forcier hits Greg Mathews on a circle route to win against Notre Dame (2009) … Tate Forcier hits Martavious Odoms on a perfect seam for the game-winning points against Indiana (2009) … Forcier's mansome final drive in the rain to tie Michigan State (2009) … Brandon Graham demolishes Glenn Winston (2009) … Brandon Graham demolishes Everybody (2009).
A major reason this series came together is the tireless effort of Wolverine Historian, who put together video for almost everything on the list. Also a hat tip to parkinggod, who had HD of last year's ND game, and akarpo, who helped out with some of the clipping last year.
A post best read with Rilo Kiley - A Better Son/ Daughter on blast. When we get back it is going to be so fucking wonderful.
This made my day so much better.
This whole series has me so hyped for the season and, indeed, the next ten years! Thanks Brian.
It has never sounded better, or least annoying, than when he said "MANNINGHAM."
I made the trip from MN to South Bend for the '06 ND game with a Domer friend, and I could just tell that something was...different. I've watched a lot of football, and I don't know if I've ever seen a more thorough asswhipping. I've seen games that were bigger blowouts (on the scoreboard at least), but M beat ND like a rented mule that day. Manningham, to this day, is one of my absolute all time favorite players, due in part to his 3TD day. That, and he likes the herb.
I think you're referring to the PSU game, in which case that was Brad Nessler with the final TD call.
I was referring to Brent Musburger saying the word "Manningham."
(But as for a single game, I'll agree, I never enjoyed hearing his name being called more than that catch.)
This, by the way, is why Minnesota bloggers will never do a Worst Plays of the Decade list.
The real reason why is because it's hard to whittle down the list to a top 50, let alone 10.
This series, from the worst to the best, has just reminded me how much I am looking forward to the fall, and to see what the team will do in the face of adversity. As much as I hate to admit it, if we won all the games, it wouldn't be as much fun.
This series has been quite a pick-me-up after the Worst Calls of the Decade. I'll be rewatching these as the season draws near. Heres to Rich & Co. generating some amazing highlights for 2020's summary!
That photo of Branch might be my favorite of all time. It should be one of those motivational posters. MS Painters/Photoshoppers?
The end of the Penn State game was the only time I have ever been in a legitamite mosh pit in a bar. There were about 100 of us (and at least 50 PSU fans, as this was Philly), when we finally calmed down to look around, all of the blue and white had already left the bar in a sulk.
I remember being in the student section with friends for the Brabbs field goal attempt. We were all basically assuming it was going to be a miss, and for it to not even be close. The ball was halfway to the posts, the crowd in the end zone started going nuts knowing it was going to split the uprights, someone said "holy shit, it's good!", the ball finished its flight, and I think we were already running down towards the front of the student section before the refs even raised their hands. Has to be the most improbable-feeling 44 yard field goal of all time.
I was also in the student section, around the 20 so I couldn't see right away that it was going in. I remember that there was a brief moment of what the hell? before everyone started jumping up and down.
I was in Row B of the student section at that game, and that was easily the loudest I can recall the Big House ever getting.
And this, folks, is why you never turn off/leave a game early. If you do, you have no right to enjoy the glory that results when we pull out a win.
If I had left the 2004 MSU game early, I would have never gotten to enjoy the tears of the obnoxious 10 year old Spartan fan sitting behind me, which began immediatley after MSU's last chance pass to the endzone fell harmlessly incomplete.
I missed all but the very end of that game, as my friends dragged me out trick-or-treating when we were already down by two touchdowns. (I was a junior in high school at the time.) Horrible decision. I spent the next hour+ fielding phone calls from my dad about how the game was going, and finally made it back by I think the beginning of the second overtime.
I don't remember most of the earlier games of the decade, but I can't wait to see recaps like this 10 years from now.
...on October 30?
Was that code for "TPing houses, egging cars, and setting fires?"
Was this supposed to be posted on the "Things you're man (or woman) enough to admit" thread?
My student tickets in 04 were the apparent buffer between a fraternity and sorority whose members spent entire games drunkenly passing back and forth in front of me. During the early part of the 4th quarter in the MSU game, the guys grew increasingly pissy, started pouting, and left moments before the comeback began. By the end, we had the row pretty much to ourselves.
Arm. Broke his arm diving for a mishandled pitch to Jamie Morris.
Worst game was losing to Iowa 26-0, and Hayden Fry calling us out for having a scheme that would embarrass most HS teams. Ugh.
Is a direct result of play #4. I was watching the 2006 ND game in my buddies basement. On Manningham's first TD, he races across the basement in excitement and starts to pound on the wall in jubilation while the rest of us cheer. The game continues to get better for Michigan and by the time Manningham scores his 3rd TD, my buddy races across the basement and does a leaping body-five into the wall, only to leave a man-shaped depression in the drywall. Six other guys are rolling on the floor, howling in laughter while his wife just stared at the dent incredulously.
From seven year's distance it appears to be the slowest, most awkward touchdown convoy in school history.
It appeared to be the slowest, most awkward touchdown convoy in football history then as well. Nothing has happened since to change my mind.
I lucked out and was sitting in about the 5th row, just behind where Manningham caught that game winning touchdown against Penn State. That was electric and probably the best finish I've ever seen.
I'm surprised that Breaston's performance at the 2005 Rose Bowl didn't at least get an honorable mention. I know it wasn't a single play, but he was lights out that entire game.
how many days 'til the opening kickoff?
Thank you for ending the week on this. After the dong-assault that you called "the 10 worse . . ." this was a well needed dong massage.
I am so blessed to have been able to witness the top three plays in person, all of which were great memories of mine.
OK, this MORE than makes up for the worst 11 posts
Damn. I was at that Washington game when I was 10, and unfortunately I somehow don't remember the actual game. I can remember a "Huskies, lick your balls" sign and my uncle talking about what a great game it was, but I can't remember the actual game.
Man, you missed a good decade of football in the 90s. My earliest memories are from '89. I was in third grade at the time.
Freshman year, about to leave, saw the catch from the section tunnel.
Never left a game early, and never will. Thanks Brian, in combination with getting paid today (woo!) this is setting me up for an amazing weekend
Great series fellas - love this blog. Thank you.
I love that this play earned a (deserved) honorable mention.
the snap sails over Jimmy Clausen's head on the first play of the game (2007)
Jim Harbaugh had a broken arm, not a broken leg, in the less-than-awesome 1984 season.
I've followed this blog for a long time, but I had to make my first post on this one. First, this is what makes college football so damn great. You watch these plays and feel the same rush of the same emotions you felt years back watching them live. Of course, it's also why I will not watch the "worst" as those emotions have been burried somewhere, never to be seen until the next horrifying moment....hopefully not this season.
That 2004 MSU game brought back great memories. We were watching it at my house with a large group of friends, some of whom are a bit less intelligent and, thus, Spartans. Literally 10 seconds before Cobb busted off that GODDAMN COUNTER DRAW to put them up 17 I bet my less fortunate Spartan friend Eric $100 we would come back and win. Long touchdown follows, I storm out of the room, my wife writes a check to Eric immediately for $100 stating in the memo line "Mike's Stupidity." Anyway, I collected my money at the end of the game and Eric still has that check, framed in his home office. I smile every time I see it.
I still remember it perfectly. I looked aver at my dad and said, "Notre Dame defense not appearing in this portion of our telecast."
*father of Blazefire places hands on son's neck, begins to shake*
Of all the times we ran the transcontinental pass, (Breaston to Navarre, Woodson to Griese, Johnson to Henson and Walker to Gonzales) Navarre was the only one who scored on the play. Truly ironic.
Though Griese was pretty slow too and he made it to the 1.
If you had like, retro-historic betting odds on it finally scoring, Navarre would have been off the board. You could have gotten better odds on Jake Long scoring that TD.
Can I just say this sentence is amazing? Well done Brian!
"In the end, the game served as a reminder that bitterness is no fun, faith is rewarded, the kids on the field are more resilient than we are, and sometimes they can let us borrow some of that."
"The 1984 season could be written off as a fluke since Jim Harbaugh's broken leg threw everything into disarray and Michigan bounced right back afterwards."
....but Harbaugh broke his arm in 1984, not his leg. He was diving forward and his arm was extended and exposed. Damn Sparty!
I believe Jamie Morris fumbled the ball and Harbaugh broke his arm when he dove to recover it.
the Scott Bakula reference!
...making a "Quantum Leap" this year...
I'm just gonna assume Brian planned this for my birthday.
Took my girlfriend at the time to that game. It was her first michigan game despite being an Ann Arbor native. I remember thinking it was a horrible first game to witness because it was 3-3 at halftime and defensive struggles don't exactly captivate newcomers. Lloyd and Mario sure fixed that.