Brandon Statement On Morris Incident Comment Count

Brian

In Full:

Ultimate responsibility for the health and safety of our student-athletes resides with each team's coach and with me, as the Director of Athletics. We are committed to continuously improving our procedures to better protect the health and welfare of our student-athletes.

I have had numerous meetings beginning Sunday morning to thoroughly review the situation that occurred at Saturday's football game regarding student-athlete Shane Morris. I have met with those who were directly involved and who were responsible for managing Shane's care and determining his medical fitness for participation.

In my judgment, there was a serious lack of communication that led to confusion on the sideline. Unfortunately, this confusion created a circumstance that was not in the best interest of one of our student-athletes. I sincerely apologize for the mistakes that were made. We have to learn from this situation, and moving forward, we will make important changes so we can fully live up to our shared goal of putting student-athlete safety first.

I have worked with Darryl Conway, my associate athletic director for Student-Athlete Health and Welfare, to develop a detailed accounting of the events that occurred. Darryl is the person who oversees all athletic training personnel and serves as the liaison to the physicians we work with through the University of Michigan Health System and University Health Services.

It is important to note that our athletic trainers and physicians working with Michigan Athletics have the unchallengeable authority to remove student-athletes from the field of play. Michigan Athletics has numerous medical professionals at every football competition including certified athletic trainers and several physicians from various relevant specialties.

I, along with Darryl and our administrative and medical teams, have spent much of the last two days carefully reviewing the situation regarding Shane Morris. We now understand that, despite having the right people on the sidelines assessing our student-athletes' well being, the systems we had in place were inadequate to handle this unique and complex situation properly.

With his permission, I can share that Shane Morris suffered an ankle injury during the third quarter of Saturday's game. He was evaluated for that injury by an orthopedic surgeon and an athletic trainer several times during the game. With each of these evaluations it was determined that his ankle injury did not prevent him from playing.

In the fourth quarter, Shane took a significant hit and stumbled after getting up. From the field level and without the benefit of replays, medical and coaching staffs did not see the hit. Because they did not see the hit, the athletic training staff believed Shane stumbled because of his ankle injury. The team neurologist, watching from further down the field, also did not see the hit. However, the neurologist, with expertise in detecting signs of concussion, saw Shane stumble and determined he needed to head down the sideline to evaluate Shane.

Shane came off the field after the following play and was reassessed by the head athletic trainer for the ankle injury. Since the athletic trainer had not seen the hit to the chin and was not aware that a neurological evaluation was necessary, he cleared Shane for one additional play.

The neurologist and other team physicians were not aware that Shane was being asked to return to the field, and Shane left the bench when he heard his name called and went back into the game. Under these circumstances, a player should not be allowed to re-enter the game before being cleared by the team physician. This clearly identifies the need for improvements in our sideline and communications processes.

Following the game, a comprehensive concussion evaluation was completed and Shane has been evaluated twice since the game. As of Sunday, Shane was diagnosed with a probable, mild concussion, and a high ankle sprain. That probable concussion diagnosis was not at all clear on the field on Saturday or in the examination that was conducted post-game. Unfortunately, there was inadequate communication between our physicians and medical staff and Coach Hoke was not provided the updated diagnosis before making a public statement on Monday. This is another mistake that cannot occur again.

Going forward, we have identified two changes in our procedures that we will implement immediately:

We will have an athletic medicine professional in the press box or video booth to ensure that someone will have a bird's eye view of the on-field action, have television replay available and have the ability to communicate with medical personnel on the sidelines.

We are also examining how to reinforce our sideline communication processes and how decisions will be made in order to make sure that information regarding student-athlete availability to participate is communicated effectively amongst the medical team and to our coaches.

We have learned from this experience, and will continue to improve ways to keep our student-athletes' health and safety our number one priority.

Comments

Humen

September 30th, 2014 at 1:49 AM ^

Brandon needs to go before Hoke does. Look at how the man treats his subordinates. Brandon needs to go now--12:49 central time. It would only be fitting. I'll release a statement on my Twitter and we will all be done with it.


Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

GoBLUinTX

September 30th, 2014 at 2:19 AM ^

that Brandon is taking the heat for Hoke.  Brady Hoke was at the dias telling what he knew to be the truth and to deflect all medical questions to the forthcoming statement.  Apparently, and with an objective reading of things, Hoke was not privy to the results of the later testing of Morris.  

Since medical protocol on the sideline will now be changed, apparently the medical personnel are also conceding that they are in part responsible.

By the way, WTF is a "probable mild concussion?"  Wherein the range from zero to one does "probable" lie?  Is that like saying, " a little pregnant" or is it closer to not actually knowing but better safe than sorry?

GoBLUinTX

September 30th, 2014 at 2:52 AM ^

The lines where medical personnel will sit quietly by and have Brandon misconstrue that to which they agreed to say?  "Probable mild concussion" could only have come from the Neurologist, he's the only one qualified to make that statement, and we both know he not only wouldn't lose his job if he didn't agree to that diagnosis, but that he would be lionized for publicly contradicting Dave Brandon.

No, "probable mild concussion" is from the medical community, that only makes sense.  How they came to that deterimination is anyone's guess short of them answering direct questions.

jballen4eva

September 30th, 2014 at 6:52 AM ^

"Probable" is a lawyer word.

Disclosure: I'm a lawyer.

Seriously, doctors can use the word "probable" if something is 99% likely.  Otherwise they could be accused of misdiagnosing symptoms if further evidence shows that the cause of those symptoms differs from the diagnosis.  At times this accusation is totally unfair, because a reasonable and experienced doctor would make the same call every time.  

I'm guessing the medical peoples involved sighed and rolled their eyes over the use of the word "probable," but wouldn't say "no" to it because they are used to dealing with weenies from the legal/admin/PR world, as well as people expecting their reasonable conclusions to somehow be infallible.    

 

umumum

September 30th, 2014 at 9:59 AM ^

there is no reason to believe the medical people were even asked to sign off on the term "probable".  In fact, I doubt they were.  I suspect that lawyers concluded that "probable" was fair (meaning, a term they think they can get away with) based on what the doctors told them.  

Now the only risk is that one of the medical people says something differently.  Unless they start to take heat, I doubt they will.

rob f

September 30th, 2014 at 2:54 AM ^

from what Brian posted just above, that his "dropping the word 'probable' " statement means Brian's 'source' has direct inside information that the concussion diagnosis is a certainty.

rob f

September 30th, 2014 at 4:47 PM ^

That bastard Brandon failed him.  And it really doesn't matter whether the messanger is Brandon, one of his aides, or the medical team---only that Brandon has to do what it takes to make sure Hoke goes into that press conference midday Monday with complete up-to-date knowledge on the injury status of Morris.  Shame on Brandon for allowing Hoke to be left hanging out to dry on that podium!

Appleseed

September 30th, 2014 at 1:53 AM ^

The actual description of what happened seems reasonable and believable. At least to me. It also seems to me that there was no reason this statement couldn't have been released Sunday afternoon. If everyone had just been open and honest from the start we'd be in a much better place. Too bad that seems to be the last resort for the athletic department.

pearlw

September 30th, 2014 at 5:56 AM ^

Im not sure about that...but the poor handling afterwards surely adds a reason to be skeptical. When I saw it live on tv, I did not see the hit on my first watching of it as the camera followed the ball. I surely saw it on the replay tv showed.

I also talked to people that were there in the stands. They did not see the hit while watching the game as their eyes watched the ball. But they surely saw it on the replay on the jumbo video screen.

it is possible the coaches didnt see it live for same reason plus there are players on the field blocking their view. Coaches probably are more focused on the next play than watching the video screen to see the replays being shown. But none of that excuses what happened over the 48-60 hours if that was actually the case that they didnt see it.

Kalamazoo Blue

September 30th, 2014 at 8:43 AM ^

I was sitting in the north end zone with the play right in front of me.

I didn't realize the full extent of the hit, either. But it was unmistakable that Morris had been knocked silly when the lineman was holding him up after the play. It was a pitiful sight.

I said to the guy sitting next to me, "He's concussed." I totally expected a refs whistle to blow to stop play to bring him out. It looked that bad.

I can't believe Hoke didn't pull him. The students were booing their heads off. They knew what was happening. Everybody in the stands knew. It was surreal.

Its me Dave

September 30th, 2014 at 8:46 AM ^

I've done RCA's on sentinel events.  It's entirely believeable to me.  That's exactly how these these things go down.

- Hoke, Nuss miss the hit in real time

- Hoke, Nuss miss the hit on Jumbotron

- Hoke misses Morris wobble

- Morris refuses Nuss' order to take a knee/come to sideline.

- Trainer/Ortho consult misses hit, assesses knee not head

- Gardener loses his helmet on next play.

- Bellomy can't find his helmet

- Neuro consult is late to the sideline.

Eliminate any one (or maybe two) of the above, and the whole damn thing never blows up.  These sorts of accidents always turn out to be O Henry-esque clusterfucks.

dragonchild

September 30th, 2014 at 9:37 AM ^

You know what else would've avoided the whole damn thing blowing up?

Taking precautions.

Saying you didn't see something is fine, but only as testimony.  If you're in a position of responsibility, you need to gather the facts.  The incompetence they're attempting to claim to avoid appearance of intent is staggering.  They are literally saying they had a huge meltdown because that somehow sounds better than they did it on purpose.  I really don't care.

I've been involved in incidents that escalated to senior management as well.  What's invariably missing is a lack of ownership in key chains of the process.  Some guy's responsible for making a decision but decides to not gather the facts because that, like, work n' stuff.

Its me Dave

September 30th, 2014 at 9:54 AM ^

"The incompetence they're attempting to claim to avoid appearance of intent is staggering."

Nope, it's a very common, well-studied level of incompetence, inherent in all human behavior.  Two types are particularly applicable here:

Inattentional Blindness ("didn't see the gorilla, did you")

Diffusion of Responsibility ("Kitty Genovese in Kew Gardens")

 

dragonchild

September 30th, 2014 at 10:20 AM ^

This is not a case study on eyewitness testimony or samaritanism.

We didn't just pull a guy off the street to head our football program.  This is a person in a very high level of responsibility who had to apply for the job.  You generally hire people who are not only above-average but bona fide elite when you're paying them millions of dollars.  I do not expect infallibility, but nor do I expect fundamental breakdowns in common sense protocol.

Or to put it another way, you just undermined your own defense because you're comparing the Head Coach and Athletic Director of the University of Michigan with the competence of the average human being.  In which case they REALLY have no business being there.

dragonchild

September 30th, 2014 at 11:02 AM ^

Basic procedural competence would seem divine at this point.

But don't try to wedge in here some sort of false equivalence fallacy where the fallibility of being human is the same as not doing your job when the expectation is that you're one of the best in the country at it.  If that was the case then air travel and surgery (among other things) would be way too dangerous.  There's a reason why experts undergo years of education and training before we trust them to do their jobs.

I wouldn't expect Hoke to run, say, an airfield or ER with any level of competence because in that context he's an average human being.  He would have no ability to understand what's going on around him and can easily miss critical details that a trained professional would catch.  People would die by the thousands but that's pretty much the expectation if you put a layman in a position of responsibility.  Thing is, he's a football coach employed as a football coach and he STILL shows no ability to understand what's going on around him and can easily miss critical details that a trained professional would catch.

DakotaBlue

September 30th, 2014 at 8:16 AM ^

I never wanted Morris to start to begin with, I certainly wanted Gardiner back in after halftime when the game was still winnable, and I was furious that Morris was still in once he started hobbling around. But the idea that everyone in the stadium knew he was concussed is just BS.

Who watches the quarterback after he throws the ball? I certatinly didn't. One wants to see what happens to the pass. Yeah, I saw Morris hobbling around after the play, but I had no idea that he took a hit to the head, and I'll bet only a small fraction of the people in the stadium knew that.

If you were watching on TV, then of course you knew what happened. There were several replays and the announcers went on and on about it. For people watching at home, or people watching video replays after the fact, it seems obvious that he was concussed. At the time, I just wanted Morris out because he was (a) ineffective and (b) hobbling on his ankle.

I am not excusing what happened on the sidelines. Hoke should have been informed, but I believe that neither he nor the trainers saw the hit.

True Blue Grit

September 30th, 2014 at 8:27 AM ^

I was in the stadium and did not see it.  Just the aftermath.  But, the first poor judgement by the coaches IMO was not taking Morris out of the game much earlier.  He should not have even started the 2nd half as you say based on being so ineffective. But after he started hobbling around while continuing to screw up, this should have been a no-brainer decision to put in a healthy 5th year QB.  It's very sad that Morris was ever put in the position that he was by the coaches.  

Appleseed

September 30th, 2014 at 2:25 AM ^

Let me clarify, I was talking about the description of what happened on Saturday.

I would say that "Unfortunately, there was inadequate communication between our physicians and medical staff and Coach Hoke was not provided the updated diagnosis before making a public statement on Monday." is obvious and total bullshit.

 

2427_Couzens

September 30th, 2014 at 8:35 AM ^

Unless Dave Brandon made absolutely sure that he couldn't.  And I can completely believe Brandon is capable of doing that being as corporate as he is.  Brandon knows Hoke can't tell the truth if he doesn't know it.  It's Corporate CYA 101.  And if anyone knows how a corporation reacts to things like this, it's Dave Brandon.

Jon06

September 30th, 2014 at 3:16 PM ^

If I were Hoke, and indeed he got hung out to dry like I think he did, I'd be in Schlissel's office with one sentence to share: Dave Brandon just tried to end my career, and if he's not fired in the next two weeks, I quit.

MI Expat NY

September 30th, 2014 at 9:51 AM ^

I agree.  The series of events in that two and a half minute span are reasonable.  If this explanation was given early sunday, it probably nips everything in the bud.  It still looks bad on Saturday, but that gets explained by a failure in procedure where the team doctor in charge of head trauma had to actually get to the field to assess the problem and there being no direct contact between him and staff on the sidelines to take immediate protective steps.  

Hoke probably still looks like an ass in his post-game press conference if he gave the same answers, but that was a problem that was going to bite him eventually.  He's been an ass all season when it's come to giving out injury information to the press, and he stuck to it when just being a little forthcoming immediately keeps this from becoming national news.  

The problem now is that you feel like Hoke and Brandon are lying, at worst, or that Hoke is simply completely incompetent at managing the football program.  That the word concussion made it into the official statement tells me he knew or should have known about it sometime after the game at the very latest.  Everything since then has been hiding the truth for whatever reason.  Taken together with everything we've seen on the football field over the last 14 or so games, it's painfully obvious that coaching Michigan is above his capabilities.  

I'll also throw this in here instead of adding a separate reply.  It was clear that from the moment the "medical staff statement" got significantly delayed that the AD was trying to get them to sign off on a statement that was not true.  That's despicable and should be grounds for Brandon to be immediately relieved of duties.  

samsoccer7

September 30th, 2014 at 1:53 AM ^

I think it's clear that Hoke is just in over his head. Michigan is no ball state or sdsu. There's just too much going on all the time. Delegation without oversight or accountability is just decreasing workload and is not productive.