on the move again? [Eric Upchurch]

Unverified Voracity Experiences Frenchness Comment Count

Brian January 26th, 2023 at 2:00 PM

Well, we've got a coaching vacancy. Due to Matt Weiss getting axed due to Computer Crimes, Michigan has an assistant opening. We spent a bunch of time talking about it on WTKA this morning, and we mainly discussed two scenarios:

  • Promoting Kirk Campbell to QB coach, which is probably JJ McCarthy's preferred outcome.
  • Moving Jay Harbaugh to QB coach, hiring someone else, and having Harbaugh re-assert himself as a QB whisperer.

Possibly relevant to this: Chris Partridge got cut loose by Ole Miss and is now looking for a job. He was a co-DC at Ole Miss and may have gotten out over his skis a little bit in that job. Ole Miss's D was just 50th in SP+ this year. With Jesse Minter around, he won't have a DC title if he does return to Michigan. If he's fine with that, though, he was an ace recruiter and an ace recruiter would help out considerably after a down class.

Also he might be an in with Davison Igbinosun, who was a freshman All-American CB for Ole Miss with 10 starts to his name. He hit the portal more or less as the same time as Partridge got axed, so you have to think that grabbing Partridge would bring him along. A 6'2" CB ranked #162 in the composite last year with a year of starting under his belt would be an excellent pickup. That's not a reason to hire a coach by itself, but since Partridge has a lot of experience with Michigan already and had a successful first stint… it might be a reason to make a somewhat awkward position coaching switch if the elder Harbaugh can backfill at QB coach.

[After THE JUMP: sign and fire]

Another bizarre move from the athletic department. Fired volleyball coach Mark Rosen got a five-year extension just over two months before he gets fired, as Connor Earegood reports in the Daily:

A Freedom of Information Act request submitted by The Michigan Daily revealed a five-year, $1,093,000 total salary contract that Rosen signed in October 2022. Even though Rosen’s first contract year under the deal began Sept. 1, 2022, the deal wasn’t signed by both University of Michigan President Santa Ono and Manuel until October. The contract ensured Rosen’s employment through Aug. 31, 2027. …

So far, no reason for that firing is publicly available. In the same FOIA request, the University’s FOIA office told The Daily that no termination letter for Rosen exists.

Offering a letter of termination is standard practice for terminating an employee with cause — especially a coach of 24 years at one of the biggest athletic programs in the NCAA. Manuel’s original statement also fails to give a specific reason for Rosen’s firing.

Clearly that was not a performance-related firing, so the lack of a termination letter looks like an attempt to sweep something under the rug. I doubt anything will come of this since volleyball is not exactly high on anyone's radar, but man the athletic department is just awash in decisions that don't look real well thought-out.

JOEL KLATT IS NOT AMUSED NCAA. A man has thoughts:

Looking good. Vague confirmation that Michigan has an awful lot coming back next year:

OSU and PSU, FWIW, are middle of the pack.

More draft items. Mike Morris doesn't make The Athletic's top 100, which is weird. Mazi Smith is 57 and DJ Turner 85, though Nick Baumgardner is higher than that on Turner:

Another cornerback who feels a bit low here is Michigan’s DJ Turner (No. 85). He has a shot at the second round.

I am also in strenuous agreement with Baumgardner about Devon Witherspoon being too low:

On the other side of things, the board is probably still too low on the corners, specifically Oregon’s Christian Gonzalez and Illinois’ Devon Witherspoon. Gonzalez was No. 40 on our initial consensus board in November, and he’ll likely be higher than No. 17 after he runs this spring. In terms of pure movement skills in coverage, Gonzalez is CB1 in this class. There are questions with his game, however, as is the case with every corner on this list.

Gonzalez falling to 17 isn’t impossible, given the usual variance of team-by-team preference here. Witherspoon at 36, though? That feels very unlikely. If you ask an analyst who their top cornerback is right now, you’ll get a range of names that includes Gonzalez, Penn State’s Joey Porter Jr., Georgia’s Kelee Ringo and South Carolina’s Cam Smith. But they’ll also mention Witherspoon, who is a first-round talent.

Witherspoon is one of those players who college folks are all hype about. The NFL isn't exactly turning up their nose at him but if he falls out of the first round I will cock an eyebrow.

People experiencing Frenchness. This will not go over well down in Columbus:

"The university enduring the experience of being Ohio State" has a certain ring to it. Also I believe APStylebook has civil disobedience going on. Give a copywriter an obviously inane guideline, get a canny counter-example lodged within.

The speed: still not in space. JJ McCarthy finished the season with the second-fewest screens (at least as defined by percentage of attempts behind the LOS) in the nation, pipped only by Wake Forest's Sam Hartman. Amusingly, Northwestern managed to place QBs on both the "most" and "fewest" lists: Ryan Hilinski never threw screens and Brendan Sullivan had almost half of his attempts at or behind the LOS.

Etc.: Bomani Jones explains crypto. Orji on RGIII's TD call. Hockey, softball, basketball, and baseball can have a real live third assistant now. Love to play Minnesota and get guys injured and have all the majors called on Michigan. Love it. Stu Douglass discusses Jett Howard's draft prospects. Marc-Gregor, a man experiencing Frenchness, spotted in the wild.

Comments

DonAZ

January 26th, 2023 at 2:17 PM ^

Regarding screen passes ... I recently asked ChatGPT, that AI chatbot thing that's all the rage, if wide receiver screens ever work out well.  I got back a rather interesting answer that boiled down to the play can work, but a lot has to go right for it to work well.  My eyeballs tell me defenses seem to cue in on screens fairly well nowadays. 

MadMonkey

January 26th, 2023 at 2:23 PM ^

"Orji in the endzone". 

A "what if" moment about what might have been if we ran him on the goal line against TCU rather than Mullins after the Wilson touchdown reversal.

Carpetbagger

January 26th, 2023 at 2:27 PM ^

The French made me laugh out loud. There may be something to the civil disobedience angle.

English is most certainly an evolving language, but the real evolution is pushed by the masses, not on the masses.

If Jay at QB coach would assist us in filling the McCarthy shaped hole we have in the future, I'm all for it.

Sopwith

January 26th, 2023 at 2:38 PM ^

I'm confused by the AP style guide. How do I refer to the French? People experiencing Frenchness? Snortsnortsnortsnortsnortsnort

Still going to use my favorite expression "sweating like a Frenchman."

Carpetbagger

January 26th, 2023 at 3:42 PM ^

They would likely have found using the actual offensive terms they were actually referring to offensive. So in order to not be offensive to the actual people it would offend they make a global rule everyone will hate because it's stupid and automatically ignore the rule. Genius.

I haven't heard any of the terms you are referring to in many years, (and never the "the queers", is this some city thing?)

 

 

Carpetbagger

January 26th, 2023 at 5:08 PM ^

That makes sense on the latter. My sister-in-law is prone to making snarky comments about some of the people who think she automatically agrees with them just because she is gay.

I should add the caveat that I've heard the other terms sarcastically as well, but it's been at least 20 years since I've heard it uttered any other way.

trustBlue

January 26th, 2023 at 4:31 PM ^

Referring to "blacks", "gays" or "jews" is not offensive by itself. Its perfectly fine to use "jews" when referring to jews. But when you start using "the jews" or "the blacks" its almost always intended as a slight. It's the addition of the unnecessary "the" that makes the implication pejorative. 

Nine times out of ten, you will find politicians will add a "the" when referring to members of the opposite party. Democratic politicians will refer to Republicans as "the Republicans", while fellow Democrats are simply "Democrats." Likewise, Republican politicians will almost always refer to "the Democrats", but never "the Republicans."

Journalists who want to maintain an appearance of impartiality will almost never use "the" in front of either party's name. But partisan pundits and talking heads will frequently use "the" to imply their disdain for the party they are critiquing. 

Needs

January 26th, 2023 at 4:06 PM ^

To give some logic to the suggestion, those kinds of constructions are poor usage because of the way they suggest some kind of singularity among people with a lot of diverse perspectives and experiences. You often still see them reflexively used for Native American nations ("the Navajo," "the Lakota," "the Choctaw," etc) and it's bad in those cases for the same reasons.

Alton

January 26th, 2023 at 3:04 PM ^

I am not trying to criticize Connor at the Michigan Daily, who did amazingly good work on the Pearson situation, but that article leaves off an important detail--Rosen was on sick leave from 09 November through the end of the season, and did not return to the team before he was fired.

It seems like the sick leave is interesting enough and possibly pertinent enough that it should have been mentioned in the article.  The timeline went like this:

June 26, 2018:  Rosen signs 5-year contract effective September 1, 2018 to August 31, 2023
June 17, 2022:  Rosen signs "memorandum of understanding" that the last year of the previous 5-year contract will be replaced by new contract from September 1, 2022 through August 31, 2027.
October 6, 2022:  Rosen signs contract based on memorandum of understanding.  Signed by AD Manuel on October 10 and President Ono on October 31.
November 9, 2022:  Athletic Department announces "University of Michigan head volleyball coach Mark Rosen will take a temporary leave of absence for health-related reasons"
December 20, 2022:  AD Manuel statement:  "Following a thorough review of the program, I have decided that Mark Rosen will not return as our volleyball coach." 
 

I don't know anything more than this, but I'm curious about that leave of absence.

EDIT--Wait.  I do know one more thing.  November 9, 2022, was also the first day that National Letters of Intent could be signed in Division I Women's Volleyball.  Which may or may not be a coincidence, I guess.

AWAS

January 26th, 2023 at 3:27 PM ^

My thoughts exactly. I'm not sure Rosen was "fired" in the sense of "for cause".  The medical situation may have resulted in a (potentially mutual) determination that he couldn't/shouldn't return.  This is where conspiracy theorists might want to review the concept of privacy.  There are certain situations where we are not entitled to detailed information, and they aren't always nefarious situations.

Blue In NC

January 26th, 2023 at 5:05 PM ^

Fair point but donors to the athletic department might wonder why a 5 year contract that was to end in Fall 2023 was re-negotiated so as to start a new 5 year term in 2022, then the coach was "fired" under the new 5 year agreement only a few months later.  I have no inside info at all but one could view that as a handshake deal to give a $1M gift to a retiring coach.

Colt Burgess

January 26th, 2023 at 3:11 PM ^

Best, and funniest, explanation I've heard about crypto. Like Bomani said, your money in the bank is already digital ones and zeroes. It's better to turn cash into assets. Keep enough cash to pay bills and taxes.

Kudos to Joel Klatt! Does there exist a more butt-hurt fan base than Sparty? They're obsessed with all things U of M.

Yooper

January 26th, 2023 at 3:26 PM ^

Surprised to see Brian refer to Weiss having been “axed due to Computer Crimes”. Maybe I missed it, but has Weiss actually been accused, let alone confessed to or been convicted of a crime?  If not, then the statement is out of bounds. 

Sopwith

January 26th, 2023 at 5:06 PM ^

But usually we do wait until someone has actually been arrested, charged, etc. with something before assuming they're guilty.

I suspect that will never happen here. The local prosecutors will announce they've completed their investigation, no charges are being filed, and will have nothing further to say. The University has already said they will have nothing else to say about it. 

dnak438

January 26th, 2023 at 11:54 PM ^

I actually think that allegedly is overused. I see things like "Man accused of allegedly stabbing woman multiple times" -- that's wrong. He's being accused of stabbing, not of allegedly stabbing. You don't accuse someone of allegedly doing something, you accuse them of doing something.

That's all irrelevant to what you're saying here, of course. Still, I don't think that it's very useful to talk about the "fashion" of the presumption of innocence. I'd be curious to know when was the Golden Age when it was the case that everyone (or even most people) assumed that people were innocent until proven guilty.

BiaBiakabutuka21

January 26th, 2023 at 3:28 PM ^

I think my ideal situation on the Weiss replacement would be the following:

  • Tee Martin or Jimmie Dougherty added as PCG
  • The NCAA adds another on field coaching position and Kirk Campbell gets promoted to QB Coach
  • Greg Roman is added as an offensive analyst

RobSk

January 26th, 2023 at 5:09 PM ^

>Moving Jay Harbaugh to QB coach, hiring someone else, and having Harbaugh re-assert >himself as a QB whisperer.
also
>if the elder Harbaugh can backfill at QB coach.

This confuses me. Was "Jay Harbaugh" ever known as the QB whisperer? Isn't Jim Harbaugh the elder Harbaugh?

Did Brian mean to suggest that Jim should be the QB coach, or Jay? 

I haz confusion.

   Rob

DonAZ

January 26th, 2023 at 5:27 PM ^

My reading of that was that Brian was suggesting Jay Harbaugh fill the QB coach role and carry most of the coaching responsibilities there, but have Jim Harbaugh provide a behind-the-scenes, as-appropriate "whisperer" role, particularly for the starter.  Then they'd hire someone else to backfill Jay's current role as special teams coach.

(There's something like -- what? -- six or more guys in the QB room, so I would imagine being QB coach involves a lot more than just nurturing the starter.  I'm thinking the idea here is that Jay shoulder 95%+ of that burden.  Jim then serves as Yoda to the main guy.)

Michigan4Life

January 26th, 2023 at 7:20 PM ^

FWIW, Devon Witherspoon is still highly regarded in the NFL circle. It's the media who are slow to pick up on Witherspoon mainly because he plays for Illinois and wasn't a household name. There's a good chance that he could be the first CB taken in the draft and the Lions at 6 is probably his top end range of the draft. 

OldSchoolWolverine

January 26th, 2023 at 8:59 PM ^

Somehow I don't remember the recruits that Partridge landed, that stuck around, other than Gary.   And am remembering the Ahmir Mitchells and Solomon's. Can someone remind me who he brought in that stuck around?