Simply The Repairman Comment Count

Brian

9/4/2010 – Michigan 30, UConn 10 – 1-0 

 denard-uconn
via Michigan Exposures and Spawn of MZone

First there were those two years of almost unrelenting misery. Then there was this offseason, the third consecutive in which seemingly every week saw another stomach-churning burst of negative publicity for things that don't matter very much individually but aggregate like nanorobots gone awry. Then there was all that sitting in the stadium as described on Saturday, envisioning different ways the future could play out, giving each a letter grade and having no grasp of which were likelier than others. Then there was Keith Jackson and a ribbon-cutting and a flyover and fireworks (Amurrica!). Then there was this:

There was a brief moment where I discreetly wiped my eyes and hoped no one was looking, and then there was another flyover.

By the coin toss I was bobbing up and down on an imaginary pogo stick, trying to do anything with the energy that threatened to shut my brain off. I was hyped up, yo. The only thing I can remember like it was Football Armageddon. It's probably for the best that I didn't have anything handy to headbutt.

I had no idea what was going to happen, but there were grades for all of it.

-----------------------

A+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++. Would watch again.

-----------------------

What was it like for Auburn fans the first time they saw Bo Jackson? For Georgia fans when they saw Herschel Walker? Was it like that?

I can't recall anything similar in the Michigan canon. Braylon had 80 yards against Washington, Hart 124 against San Diego State. Breaston touched the ball eight times. Manningham did once. I'm too young to remember Wheatley's debut. Defensive players are too infrequently involved, and their jobs too arcane, to have the same obvious impact. Receivers, too—even a stellar debut will see the guy touch the ball maybe ten times. It's an accomplishment for quarterbacks when their first starts don't end in flaming disaster.

It's only at running back that you can unearth some guy three standard deviations above the norm at various forms of moving, put him on the field, and give everyone the epiphany of awesome.

But even the debut of one of those Godzilla running backs doesn't compare because Denard Robinson had a Godzilla tailback debut and was one late fourth down conversion away from setting a Michigan Stadium record for completion percentage. Last year he was so clueless he couldn't run the offense, so transparently not a quarterback he went 14 of 31 with four interceptions on the season and played wide receiver against Ohio State. 

So I think this might be literally true: Denard Robinson's performance against UConn was the greatest leap from one game to the next in Michigan history. Possibly college football history. He went from a guy who could not run the offense or throw the ball to one of the greatest statistical achievements* in the history of the program.

Nothing, not even the ludicrous fever dreams on message boards that rivals fans point at and laugh, could keep pace. Expectation was left in the dust by the end of the first quarter. The reasonable best case scenario fell away on the first drive of the second half when Robinson whipped a ball over the middle for sixteen yards on third and eleven. The possibility this was all a dream gave it up on Michigan's final drive when Robinson rolled out and lofted a touch pass to Kevin Koger. Not even fever dreams have that kind of audacity.

By the end, all that was left was reality, as unrecognizable as it is. Rival fans are reduced to stammering "buh-buh-but he'll get injured" in the hopes that will happen before Robinson gets a crack at their defense; 7-5 seems… eh… doable. After last year everyone's fighting to keep their hopes in check; this is proving very difficult indeed.

----------------------------

I kept biting myself in the second quarter, just to check about the fever dream bit. You build all this up in your mind before the season, think about the way things can go, say "Anything can happen, and the wait is over," and then find out you didn't really believe it. This was not part of the anything after all the months leading up to the pogo stick moment a minute before kickoff.

Because at some point around five minutes left, the energy drained out of the stadium. When Edsall called a timeout to get the ball back it was irritating and people booed. With a minute and a half left, I thought about the cold and what I should eat. I was bored, and thanks to that now I can't stand how far away next Saturday is.

*(313 against Ohio State still wins, I think, but it's hard to come up with anything else.)

Bullets

PREBULLET SECTION OF REASSURANCE! Repeat after me: this was not last year's Notre Dame game.

  • UConn is likely better than that Notre Dame team; they beat them last year and returned sixteen starters from that 8-5 team that was so close to a major breakthrough, which is why everyone was calling them a sleeper until the point they were no longer that.
  • Michigan won that game with ten seconds left after Charlie Weis called a first-down bomb needing just one first down to kill the clock.
  • They got a free, highly irreproducible touchdown from Darryl Stonum.
  • They were outgained by 60 yards in that ND game; total yardage Saturday was 473-343, with 42 of UConn's yards on their pointless final drive.

A quick list of downers:

  • The Gibbons/Dileo pairing had serious issues. The missed XP was definitely on Dileo and the missed FG seemed like a bad snap, too. Van Slyke's return may actually be more important than you might otherwise expect.
  • Burned redshirts have driven me crazy forever and a couple the tossed ones this year boggle the mind: Ray Vinopal played on special teams and Dileo held, though that one may have been forced. I'm not going to throw a hissy about Gardner since when Mike Forcier is saying they "knew there would be disciplinary action" it sounds like Rodriguez was faced with an unpleasant choice between doing the logical thing for your program and enforcing squad discipline, but if Michigan goes into 2014 without a redshirt senior Gardner that will be a major missed opportunity.
  • I was irritated they played Will Campbell on special teams because he could redshirt if he's not even second team at NT. This is bad for multiple reasons.
  • UConn's quick snap on fourth and goal was a little grrr aarrgh.
  • Zero sacks (though Roh should have been given one on a Frazer rollout). Michigan didn't get much pressure from the front three. They did manage to get there with some blitzes but I don't recall anyone beating a UConn lineman straight up. (Roh avoided a cut block from an RB.)

And now that we're done with that:

  • One penalty! Three fumbles is more of a downer, but add it up and that was a clean performance.
  • Offensive production was considerably understated (and defensive production overstated) by how short the game was in terms of possession. Michigan had eight real drives. I'm not sure what the overall NCAA number is but it must be pretty close to the 11.3 the Big 12 put up last year. If Michigan had 11.3 drives they'd be expected to put up 42 points, which is a lot of points. Yes.
  • I hate time of possession. It is a unicorn stat. But people might talk about it a lot this year since Michigan had two drives in this game that ate up more than half a quarter. And given their situation that ability might prove useful: how awesome was it that Michigan got the ball back with nine minutes left and essentially ended the game? How much more awesome would it have been if they were up just seven points?
  • Running back concern is overstated. Their YPC was hurt considerably by the final drive, during which they plowed into the line to run clock time and again. Also, Shaw in particular seemed like he had to cut behind a defensive lineman slanting right into the play every time he got a handoff. I thought managing to avoid this guy and get positive yardage consistently was an accomplishment. That say something in UConn's scheme or the play of the line has to be addressed, though.
  • It was odd that Hopkins never got in but as the game wore on it became clear that UConn couldn't hold a QB lead draw under five yards, let alone one. I do hope he gets unearthed in the future since those carries are usually low upside and if we're going to spare Robinson some hits it shouldn't be on first and ten. Or, you know, third and fifteen.
  • Speaking of, it was a really weird experience for Michigan to run a QB draw in that down and distance and not have that moment of hate during it. My immediate reaction was "yeah, that seems like a decent idea." This was early, though, and it had not yet been established that Denard was capable of going 9 of 22, let alone 19 of 22.
  • I have never seen two guys running wide open in as much space as Stonum and Robinson did on the late Robinson-to-Robinson connection. There was one safety trying to figure out which guy to cover and literally no one else for twenty yards. RPS +3, baby. That's the kind of thing that happens in these offenses when the quarterback is such a threat on the ground. When Pat White threw deep, most of the time he was doing so to wide open guys. It's like when Debord ran a waggle for big yardage, except the base offense's run game picks up like six yards a play.
  • Speaking of: welcome to Michigan, Terrance Robinson. May you dream shake someone in the near future. (Conversely: surprising lack of Grady, no?)
  • After Roundtree went out, there were a few plays on which the skill position guys were Terrance Robinson, Odoms, Grady, Smith, and Stonum. It looked like the Lollipop Guild had run out there, featuring Stonum as Dorothy.
  • Mouton's getting good reviews and certainly seemed to be playing well. He brought the lumber on a couple tackles. I wonder if UConn's burst of run competence was Carvin Johnson-injury related?
  • The reports on band amplification have varied so wildly that the effectiveness of it must vary significantly based on your location. From section 44 it sounded pretty bad, with a clear delay between the actual band and the speakers; I couldn't hear anything except the drums on the amplification. At least Special K was prevented from doing anything except playing "Don't Stop Believin'" after the first quarter.

    Unfortunately, I think that might be an artifact of the jam-packed dedication festivities. There's no time for that old time rock 'n' roll when you're running down the top five plays in Michigan Stadium history (which by the way: no Wangler to Carter? WTF, internet?), introducing a bunch of program icons and Greg Mathews, and so forth and so on. Unless they continue to fill those gaps with stuff, Lose Yourself threatens a return. They should just pick a top five list every week: top five catches. Top five runs. Interceptions, fumbles, comebacks, etc.
  • Also: Slippery Rock scores return. I credit Brandon.

Elsewhere

AnnArbor.com photo gallery. Ring of terror. Denard as QB EAGLES. The HSR takes a look at some stats. MVictors has some extra stadium details and bullet points on the goings-on, plus an outstanding SNL reference:

My Q&A session would have gone something like this:

chris farley rich rodriguez that was cool

Me: “Do you remember when…umm, Denard ran up and down the field a bunch of times?”
Rich Rod: “Yes.”
Me: “That was so cool.”

The Hoover Street Rag riffs on the B-25 flyover, pulling out the WWII analogies:

The B-25 Mitchell bomber that flew over Michigan Stadium Saturday as a part of the rededication ceremonies was a similar model to the one flown over Tokyo by the Doolittle Raiders. The Doolittle Raid was an audacious plan by an unconventional man who felt a strong sense that, in the wake of Pearl Harbor, America had to do something to strike at the heart of the Empire of Japan, so what better than to design a crazy, shouldn't work on paper, never been tested plan that would break the Japanese of their long-held belief of invincibility, and boost American morale...

If it worked.

Braves and Birds is thrilled he's not the only one anymore. Denard is apparently a P-38 Lightning.

Every offensive snap? Every offensive snap:

drooling_homerThe UConn take:

In UConn's only chance to showcase itself against a name-brand non-Big East opponent this year, the Huskies looked more like one of Michigan's typical September MAC cupcake opponents.

And also:

The good: UConn will never have to play against Denard Robinson again, and thank God for that. A few weeks ago I drew the ire of Michigan fans by saying I felt the Huskies had more talent than the Wolverines. Clearly, I was wrong. After yesterday, I'd say that on-balance, for every position but quarterback, the teams are pretty equal, maybe with Michigan grabbing a slight edge. But holy hell what a difference that quarterback makes. Video I had seen of Robinson didn't even come close to doing justice to the monster that he was yesterday. I don't care if UConn always struggles against mobile QBs, Robinson is something special.

Same post:

The good: Michigan fans and Michigan Stadium. I can't say enough good things about the Michigan fans I met in Ann Arbor yesterday. They were a fantastic, friendly and knowledgeable bunch that created an incredibly welcoming and fun atmosphere. Inside the stadium I think the contingent of Husky fans acquitted themselves nicely, but they were completely overwhelmed by the size and passion of the Wolverine crowd. A fantastic experience all around.

Comments

evenyoubrutus

September 6th, 2010 at 11:31 AM ^

I went back and watched a couple of big plays by UConn's offense to see what really happened, and there was one in particular in the 3rd quarter on a pitch to Todman where Mouton was in perfect position to make a play and force a 3rd and +10 when the RT most definitely blocked him in the back and Todman ripped off about a 20-yard run.  I think that the tackle even paused for a second like he was waiting for a flag but never got one.  I'm curious to see Brian's comments in the UFR.

Not trying to make any complaints about the refs or anything, just something I noticed.

Durham Blue

September 6th, 2010 at 11:34 AM ^

watching that "every offensive snap" video was such a relief.  One penalty all day with all that motion and blocking?!  I loved the pace of the offense and the north-south flow to the offense was incredible.  There are definitely opportunities to play better but wow, what a start!

Phinaeus Gage

September 6th, 2010 at 11:38 AM ^

So much credit for the Robinson breakout must go to the coaches. Rod Smith, Calvin Magee and Rodriguez have done a spectacular job with a raw, albeit extremely talented young man. The play calling was superb. Our offensive RPS has to be a high number. Robinson, of course, has put in the work, but kudos to this coaching staff for that performance Saturday. They placed those kids in a position to succeed time and again.

ForestCityBlue

September 6th, 2010 at 1:49 PM ^

Denard Robinson is exhibit #1 that Rodriguez can identify talent and that he--and his staff-- can coach.  It really feel like the program is on the verge.  I just pray that our record is such that there are no voices anywhere calling for him to be fired. 

Don

September 6th, 2010 at 12:23 PM ^

Things were so bad near my seats (Sec. 3) that the stadium officials opened a women's restroom up for the guys. I didn't see any lines outside the women's johns.

I know there were always lines outside the men's johns pre-renovation, but I don't recall them being so long or so slow-moving.

I attribute it to getting rid of the troughs.

brandanomano

September 6th, 2010 at 12:39 PM ^

Is it possible that WIll Campbell could have been given the Tate treatment? I don't know if any of this was true, but I think he was one of the guys who were out of shape going into camp.

The Man Down T…

September 6th, 2010 at 1:00 PM ^

The good: Michigan fans and Michigan Stadium. I can't say enough good things about the Michigan fans I met in Ann Arbor yesterday. They were a fantastic, friendly and knowledgeable bunch that created an incredibly welcoming and fun atmosphere.

 

It's good that they felt welcome.  I had the chance to attend the UConn/Wake Forest Meineke Bowl a couple years back and my tickets were in the UConn section as my daughter wanted to sit in the "puppy" section.  They were very friendly and classy.  I've been a sort of UConn fan since.

TheOracle6

September 6th, 2010 at 1:05 PM ^

Great post Brian.  I've never seen the Michigan offene more efficient in my life.  They simply could not be stopped.  To only punt the ball once all game against a team with an above the middle of the pack defense, is insatiable.  The offensive line played great not giving up a single sack, and only incurring one penalty, which was on the first drive of the game.  Special teams have me a little concerned, but I'm willing to chalk their performance up to poor wind conditions.  Hopefully they get the center/holder exchange down before it costs us vital points in a close game.  All in all an incredible first win for our maize and blue.  Bring on Notre Dame.  They couldn't stop us last year, so I don't know how in the world they're going to stop us this year.  As long as we keep mistakes at a minimum and don't turn the ball over I think we're 2 touchdowns better then the Irish.  GO BLUE

lunchboxthegoat

September 6th, 2010 at 1:15 PM ^

My favorite play of the day was the robinson-to-robinson connection. Great pump fake and it just shows how much of a weapon he is. I like to think that going forward that play will maintain its effectiveness as this offense is based on getting players in space and bubble screens are a great way to do that... (hence the set up).

Blue since birth

September 6th, 2010 at 2:10 PM ^

"Zero sacks (though Roh should have been given one on a Frazer rollout). Michigan didn't get much pressure from the front three. They did manage to get there with some blitzes but I don't recall anyone beating a UConn lineman straight up. (Roh avoided a cut block from an RB.)"

I seem to recall Martin (as well as Roh) getting pressure on the QB on several occasions early in the game... Until they started double teaming him.

M-Wolverine

September 6th, 2010 at 2:34 PM ^

The question is, is U-Conn better than THIS year's Notre Dame team...?

Why would Dileo even be involved in the snap/kick process? Isn't that usually a QB or someone? Though it does make me wonder what kinda fake we could have out of that...

Redshirts - till QB gets solidified as a position, Rich may just be getting his back-up QB some real playing time in the event that his 29 carry QB inevitably gets hurt, whether for awhile or just a couple plays.  Till Tate has for sure become a long term QB on the team, after Denard there's Devin, and then.....?!?  Because a position that was supposed to be ultra deep could be just about non-existent with a transfer.  Sucks long term, but can Rich afford to look to 2014?

Will is more confusing. Unless they really believe they can whip him into a contributor by the end of the season.  In which case, I can see games where he would have some value in say, November.

4th and Goal we need the TO. Didn't need to take them to the locker room, that's for sure.

Time of possession has value, depending on the situation. In general, it will for us, because our defense scares us a bit. But when you have a big lead, the ability to do that is gold. I love that they rarely passed because they HAD to, but rather, because they wanted to.

Running back - I wonder when we get back (hopefully this week) "Mike Hart with Speed" if we'll have that gamebreaker everyone is saying "woe, we don't have".

Band was seemingly louder in section 18.  Not monstrously so, but "hey, I can hear them". And more highlights, less RAWK is ok with me.  

And Slippery Rock, yes.

SysMark

September 6th, 2010 at 3:54 PM ^

Herschel Walker is probably the best comparison.  I remember when he first appeared as  freshman and took the college football world by storm.  From day one he was considered by most pundits the best running back ever to take the field.  I will always remember Bud Wilkinson, generally not prone to hyperbole, stating flat out he was the best he had ever seen, and this was halfway through his freshman year.

No previous Michigan player was anywhere close to what we saw Saturday.  The quarterback has the ball on every play - something no receiver or running back can do no matter how good they are.

What this reminds me of - comparing impact and not specific skill sets - is when Doug Flutie first appeared at BC.  They were nowhere on the college football landscape, and no one knew who he was, but he started winning games for them every week on his ability alone, pretty much creating a weekly one man highlight reel.  Then he throws the legendary Hail Mary pass to beat  Miami and wins the Heisman.  It could happen here with DR.

Not a Blue Fan

September 7th, 2010 at 1:37 PM ^

He reminded me of Maurice Clarett in his debut. Mo had a dominating stat line: 21 carries for 175 yards (8.3 YPC), 3 touchdowns, 4 receptions for 30 yards (7.5 YPC). It's usually obvious when a player is going to be very dominant: they're just head and shoulders better than everyone else on the field.

ErikS

September 6th, 2010 at 4:21 PM ^

it was voted in as #7, behind Desmond's diving catch vs. Notre Dame.  "Johnny Wangler to Anthony Carter, will be heard until another 100 years of Michigan Football is played!!!"

mikoyan

September 6th, 2010 at 11:26 PM ^

As the creator of the Denard picture, I want to say thank you for posting it here.  It has really helped my blog although I hope that people will poke around and look at some of the other stuff as it deals with more than Michigan Football....

ca_prophet

September 7th, 2010 at 5:07 AM ^

... Anthony Carter taking a punt back for a touchdown the first time he touched the ball in college - I remember thinking he couldn't be any bigger than me, but he was clearly a lot faster!

Still as others have noted, WR don't get the ball every play.  I was present for Butch Woolfolk and Tyrone Wheatley debuts and those might have compared in impact.  (The most memorable Wolverine performance I attended was probably Wheatley's two 4Q TD runs in the 1993 Rose Bowl.)