ESPN reporting Lovie Smith to be hired as HC by Texans

Submitted by wolverine1987 on February 7th, 2022 at 2:54 PM

And my question, why? Am I undervaluing him based on his tenure at Illinois? He's 63, and there seems many other better qualified guys. 
 

xcrunner1617

February 7th, 2022 at 3:12 PM ^

Seems like Culley was supposed to be a stop-gap for them to hire Josh McCown this year, but the Flores situation changed their plans. Not a good look to fire a black coach who did okay given the circumstances, just to hire a white guy with no professional or collegiate coaching experience.

I imagine Lovie will serve as a stop-gap coach akin to Culley, with McCown on the staff to replace him when they start losing (probably a given considering the talent on the roster). 

JMo

February 7th, 2022 at 4:23 PM ^

Seems like Culley was supposed to be a stop-gap for them to hire Josh McCown this year, but the Flores situation changed their plans.

I don't think the timeline actually bears this out.

Culley was fired Jan 14. If this was simply to clear the way for McCown, they had almost 3 weeks to make their hire before the Flores lawsuit blew up. 

I think there was some recent momentum behind the McCown hire, and it may have been for Nick Caserio to have a young and impressionable coach to mold in whatever way he chose. And, I don't think you're wrong that the Flores suit/situation made it impossible for the Texans to hire a coach (McCown) with literally NO coaching experience. 

But I don't think Culley's firing had anything to do with McCown. Nor do I think McCown is lying-in-wait for next year's Texans opening. My guess is McNair is going to ride with Lovie for at least 2 seasons come hell or high water, just so they're not replacing 3 head coaches in 3 consecutive seasons. And like others have said, McCown doesn't appear to be set to join Lovie's staff.

Robbie Moore

February 7th, 2022 at 3:51 PM ^

Going back to '57, you can only add Don McCafferty to that list. How about this list of rookie head coaches:

George Wilson
Harry Gilmer
Joe Schmidt
Rick Forzano
Tommy Hudspeth
Darryl Rogers
Wayne Fontes
Marty Mornhinweg
Rod Marinelli
Jim Schwartz
Matt Patricia
Dan Campbell

That is the most uninspiring list of mediocrities ever. Of this list and the four guys who had been a head coach before, only Wilson got a head coach gig after leaving the Lions. Ouch!
 

 

Robbie Moore

February 7th, 2022 at 4:04 PM ^

I am sure Lovie is a fine man. But why him? He's been around the block several times and accomplished some things with the Bears in the 12-15 years ago. Since then...Tampa Bay was awful and he did nothing to establish Illinois as anything but a bottom feeder. You want to hire a qualified Black coach? What about Leftwich? Or Bieniemy? Or Aaron Glenn? Or Raheem Morris? Or Todd Bowles? Or Jerod Mayo? 

Or is it that Lovie, at 63, will be grateful for this last opportunity and unwilling to rock a boat that needs some serious rocking?

Gree4

February 7th, 2022 at 3:02 PM ^

Hes probably going to be the gap coach for the rebuild. Bring in an experienced guy who can help hire the right people to coach up their (assuming) young roster. He retires or they move on when most of the pieces are in place. 

Either that or his beard is hypnotizing 

I kind of assumed this was the approach the Lions wanted to take with Campbell, but he may actually be a decent coach. 

stephenrjking

February 7th, 2022 at 3:09 PM ^

What a disaster the Texans have been. I'm a Lions fan, so I'm not exactly rooting for a first-class organization, but the Texans have made some absolutely wretched decisions through several different decisionmakers. 

It's remarkable they've had as much on-field success as they have. But they're working to rectify that. 

Lovie can probably do a lot better for them than for Illinois, but still: They're just kind of circling the drain right now. 

WindyCityBlue

February 7th, 2022 at 3:13 PM ^

As a Bear's fan, I have a love/not so "Lovie" relationship with him.  He's a good coach.  But he has a "golly, gee, that sounds good" type of approach.  We'll see if this works with the Texans.

rob f

February 7th, 2022 at 3:22 PM ^

LOLvie.

While a good man and apparently well-liked, I have always thought of him as a mediocre-to-average head coach, even when he suddenly found himself (without a ticket, even!) in the Super Bowl once.  

I wish him luck at Houston, no doubt he's going to need a ton of it.

 

Goggles Paisano

February 7th, 2022 at 3:23 PM ^

And they will continue to suck out loud.  I can't believe I am saying this, but it just might be better to be a Lions fan than a Texans fan.  I think the Texans will prove to be the more inept franchise for the forseeable future.