San Diego St. coach talks about what he saw on film, UM vs. Air Force

Submitted by Away Goal on

From today's Rocky Long show, his weekly in-season appearance on local sports talk show.  SDSU plays Air Force this weekend.  Odd audio player doesn't show the time but the Michigan / AF talk starts just past the halfway point, at about the 53% mark.

https://www.iheart.com/content/2017-09-20-the-rocky-long-show

His thoughts:

  • Michigan O got frustrated in first half by the aggressive AF D.  Missed some big plays by not breaking tackles.
  • simplified blocking schemes in 2nd half, went zone.

Then he gets into the difficulties of playing against an option offense and how they are preparing for it.  "The best offense that has ever been designed."

 

*my first ever thread start, please light on the roasting.*

EGD

September 21st, 2017 at 6:18 AM ^

There are probably several reasons why only a few teams run the triple option, but I think the main two are: (1) the offense does not appeal to WRs and good passing QBs, thus making those kinds of players very difficult to recruit, and (2) the offense is not very amenable to two-minute drills or other come-from-behind situations.

ST3

September 21st, 2017 at 11:35 AM ^

With all that running, you are putting your QB at greater risk of injury. Another problem is with all that split-second reacting and pitching, you are at a greater risk of turnovers from fumbling, so you have to rep the heck out of the option game, leaving you little time to install a passing game.

consultant22

September 21st, 2017 at 1:59 AM ^

Two primary reasons teams don't run the offense: 

1. Can't recruit because it doesn't translate to the NFL

2. If you fall behind early, it's almost impossible to get back in the game 

Georgia Tech is a team I follow outside of Michigan and they have suffered in recent years from both of these issues (along with a poor defense). 

160 IQ

September 21st, 2017 at 3:03 AM ^

Yeah it's late on the west coast, and yeah I've had a few Lagunitas, but can I get an amen that we have coaches Harbaugh and Brown?  Man M football is in such good hands.  Really glad these men have dedicated themselves to Michigan football.  Thank you.

mgobleu

September 21st, 2017 at 6:30 AM ^

Does he mention how frustrating it is watching Michigan's O because they just run crap and save all the good stuff for later and don't put anything on film? /s /maybe not

LKLIII

September 21st, 2017 at 9:53 AM ^

Dumb question about the triple option offense.

If it's so awesome, why don't more teams employ it? Imagine that offense executed by 4 & 5 star top talent athletes.

Wouldn't it be unstoppable?

It's like we see every single defense shake in their boots at the prospect of playing the triple offense. You'd think eventually the "market" for offensive schemes would move in that direction if it was truly that effective.

LKLIII

September 21st, 2017 at 11:36 AM ^

Follow-up dumb question:

Why wouldn't it translate to the pros?

I understand why 4 and 5 star guys wouldn't want to play it in college if the NFL also didn't use it.  But again--if the triple option is so incredible, why haven't a few NFL offensive coordinators adopted it?  

I mean, homo sapiens are still homo sapiens in the NFL.  It isn't like NFL defenses are suddenly stacked with dudes who are 8 feet tall or who have 4 extra limbs or something. Presumably the talent jump from college in the NFL on the offensse is about proportional to the talent jump from college to the NFL on the defense.  The biomechanics are the same at both levels.

So if triple option works at the college level, presumably it'd also work at the NFL level as well. And at that point, if a half dozen or a dozen NFL teams used triple option principles in their schemes, you'd then think that any college team employing the similar scheme would no longer be at a disadvantage--thus lowering the barriers for more college teams to adopt it.

Is it just that NFL offensive coordinators don't want to have to start from scratch to spend the time & energy to teach their NFL offensive rosters how to run it?

 

 

mgoblue0970

September 21st, 2017 at 10:46 AM ^

Ga Tech is a better comparison.  Yeah they're not pulling down top 10 recruiting classes but they do have better athletes than AF.  It's a bitch to scheme against them too.  Why more people don't run it?  Some thoughts:

1.  How many 4 and 5 stars with their sights set on the NFL want to go to a triple option shcool.

2.  How many coaches are there who have the expertise to run it like AFA or Ga Tech?

I think the answers to both are "not many"... which is why it's probably not more widespread.

The triple O is a vehcile which allows lesser (and I don't mean that as a slight) teams to compete better.

Ali G Bomaye

September 21st, 2017 at 12:02 PM ^

The triple option is an equalizer. If a group of lightly-rated recruits executes that scheme well, they can compete with teams that are a lot more talented. But it leaves a team one-dimensional. Good defenses can take away the triple option, as we saw Michigan do to Air Force, and if that happens the offense doesn't have a way to counterpunch.

You see this with Georgia Tech somewhat, as the only P5-conference flexbone offense. Sometimes their offense looks like an unstoppable machine, and sometimes they flounder around helplessly.

arrowhead

September 21st, 2017 at 12:34 PM ^

My 2 cents. Rocky Long is considered by his peers as one of the very best defensive minds in the game. He was the reason Brady Hoke looked so good at SDSU (duh) and Hoke tried to bring him to AA without success. That man knows football.

Don't forget Air Force has to play Navy, both tripile option schools. That should be good.

Nebraska won with the triple option and a bus load of convicts. So of course the good Nebraska voters sent the ring leader to Congress. 

 

 

arrowhead

September 21st, 2017 at 12:34 PM ^

My 2 cents. Rocky Long is considered by his peers as one of the very best defensive minds in the game. He was the reason Brady Hoke looked so good at SDSU (duh) and Hoke tried to bring him to AA without success. That man knows football.

Don't forget Air Force has to play Navy, both tripile option schools. That should be good.

Nebraska won with the triple option and a bus load of convicts. So of course the good Nebraska voters sent the ring leader to Congress. 

 

 

arrowhead

September 21st, 2017 at 12:35 PM ^

My 2 cents. Rocky Long is considered by his peers as one of the very best defensive minds in the game. He was the reason Brady Hoke looked so good at SDSU (duh) and Hoke tried to bring him to AA without success. That man knows football.

Don't forget Air Force has to play Navy, both tripile option schools. That should be good.

Nebraska won with the triple option and a bus load of convicts. So of course the good Nebraska voters sent the ring leader to Congress. 

 

 

The Fan in Fargo

September 21st, 2017 at 1:26 PM ^

No doubt the AF game was a confidence booster for them. Wouldn't be surprised to see them have a good year.