Coaching Candidates Part II: Other 5, Coordinators Comment Count

Brian

WELP! When you're 2-4 and a home dog to a Penn State team starting a discarded gyro and a red solo cup at guard it may be time to see what's out there in terms of possible replacements.

Previously: the Power 5 head coaches, which at this point is just DAN MULLEN DAN MULLEN DAN MULLEN.

Other 5 Head Coaches

4fe325323228f.preview-620[1]BRONCO MENDENHALL, BYU

BASICS: 86-34 in his tenth year at BYU, with a run of four straight ten win seasons from 2006 to 2009. Before that DC at New Mexico for five years and various small jobs besides. 48.

PROS: Wins many games. Lots of HC experience for age. Comfortable with running and passing QBs. Named "Bronco" so team would have to be tough I mean you'd think right. Would bring in a lot of Samoans.

CONS: Availability questionable. Mendenhall is a Mormon from Utah and is reputedly going nowhere. Has fallen off a bit after a hot start, coming off consecutive 8-5 seasons. (He is 4-1 this year.) Recruiting questions bountiful.

OVERALL: Might as well inquire but think he would be all but impossible to pry away.

512x[1]CRAIG BOHL, WYOMING

BASICS: In his first year with the Cowboys after crushing I-AA run with North Dakota State in which they won three consecutive national titles. Had been HC at NDSU since 2003 before that; during this period NDSU moved up from D-II; they had consecutive 10-1 seasons under Bohl that did not result in playoff appearances due to that. 104-32 overall at NDSU. 56.

PROS: Can beat Minnesota. Really really bald.

CONS: Age tenuous, no big time experience, just got to Wyoming.

OVERALL: Todd Graham-esque departure this would require probably puts him behind other flier candidates, as does his age.

ECarolina QBs FootballRUFFIN MCNEILL, ECU

BASICS: ECU's head coach since 2010. .500-ish his first two years, then won went 8-5 with a 7-1 nonconference record in 2012. Went 10-3 last year with a win over UNC and a narrow loss to VT; upset VT authoritatively this year. Prior to that was Texas Tech's DC for a few year, with a bunch of LB coaching jobs before that. 55.

PROS: Has ECU rolling with a modern offense. Had amazing afro back in the day.

CONS: Old-ish, doesn't have that much track record as a head coach. Highly successful OC Lincoln Riley likely to replace him so Michigan wouldn't get to import him.

OVERALL: Seems about as risky as a coordinator without as much upside.

20111213__CSU_COACH_3JL7494~p1[1]JIM MCELWAIN, COLORADO STATE

BASICS: In his third year at CSU. Took over a 3-9 team, had one bad year, and then went 8-6 a year ago. Currently 4-1 with wins over Power 5 outfits Colorado and Boston College. Alabama's OC for four years before that, Fresno's OC in 2007, one year as the Raiders' QB coach, and then various position jobs. 52.

PROS: Familiar with pro-style and spread concepts. Might have a smaller transition cost than other candidates depending on how similar his offense is to Nussmeier's. Promising start to HC career. FEI ranks of his Bama offenses: 16, 8, 3, 11. Spent three years at MSU so not entirely unfamiliar with the area.

CONS: Very short track record as a head coach. Success may be based on importing guys like Dee Hart from Bama more than any particular skill.

OVERALL: If CSU has a ten win season he's a guy who'd be logical to look at.

OTHERS

Nope. The next guy on the list was Georgia Southern's Willie Fritz.

[After THE JUMP: coordinators are waiting for your call]

Coordinators

20110304_spring_practice60_t300[1]CHAD MORRIS, OC, CLEMSON

BASICS: Texas high school legend went 169-38 as a head coach at various stops from 1994 to 2009. Hired as Tulsa's OC in 2010 for single season under Todd Graham, then snatched up by Clemson. Now makes more money as an assistant than anyone in the country; Clemson's offense has been highly productive since. 45.

PROS: A lot of head coaching experience, albeit in high school. Good at making offense go. You know it's his show for the most part since Dabo was never a coordinator. Age.

CONS: Pure HUNH proponent, which may clash (but everyone is HUNH these days). Not even the whisper of a Michigan connection, or even a Midwest connection.

OVERALL: He's going to be a head coach somewhere soon, but probably not M. Feel that Clemson's offense has been a mite overhyped of late despite having Sammy Watkins and Tajh Boyd. Pass.

osufb-notes-11-28-art-g0sprajs-1osufb-8-27-ac-05[1]TOM HERMAN, OC, OSU

BASICS: OSU's OC and QB coach since 2012. Before that held the same position at Iowa State for three years, Rice for two years, and Texas State before that. (Not that Texas State.) A small-school position coach previous. 39.

PROS: Ohio State offense seems like a slightly good idea at the moment. Ohio State's QB coach seems like a slightly good idea at the moment. Had Rice tenth in total yardage when Iowa State scooped him up; likely to be very much running the show there with Meyer trying to find that ol' work-life balance. Previous Meyer OC hired away has worked out pretty well. SMRT: he's in Mensa! 2013 Rivals Big Ten recruiter of the year, too.

CONS: Still has peach fuzz on his cheeks. Can't decide whether he wears  glasses or not. Combination of OSU and spread means high chance of transplant rejection from crotchety program alumni.

OVERALL: I wouldn't mind. Herman's rapid rise up the ranks is going to result in a head job pretty soon, and I think a smart guy would be nice.

1386811257000-AP-Broyles-Award-Narduzzi[1]PAT NARDUZZI, DC, MSU

BASICS: Dantonio's DC since 2004, Broyles winner last year after Michigan State's defense… sigh… propelled them to a Rose Bowl win. Before that was an assistant at various MAC schools and Rhode Island. 48.

PROS: Hooray witheringly effective aggressive defense. Hooray not having him at Michigan State anymore.

CONS: Uncertain how much of MSU's defensive success is him and how much is Dantonio. May be distasteful to fans, increasing chance he's bounced early. Might be hiring a double agent sent to destroy the program.

OVERALL: How do you know we don't already have one of those at AD?

TIM BECK, OC, NEBRASKA

BASICS: Has been Nebraska's OC since 2011, before that coached everywhere in the Nebraska/Missouri/Kansas area from high school on up. 48. Youngstown, OH, native.

PROS: Has a modern version of the Bo offense, an option-based system that uses the QB as a runner and has all kinds of folds and tricks up his sleeve. Once caused Hoke and Mattison to shrug resignedly when he pulled out a double pitch option.

CONS: Experience, possibility he won't be able to properly utilize a QB who can throw. Offense has never been amazing. Just got head stomped in by gentleman directly above.

OVERALL: I like his offense but doubt he'll be seriously considered.

673573[1]SCOTT FROST, OC, OREGON

BASICS: Former Nebraska QB and NFL DB took up Helfrich's spot as the OC after Chip Kelly departed. Before that was the WR coach at Oregon for four years; was co-DC at UNI for a year before getting snapped up by the Ducks. 39.

PROS: Suffused in experience with all manner of option QB-running schemes from his college days and Oregon experience. If he works out would be a very long term solution. Smart guy who transferred from Stanford way back when. Would recruit Nebraska like a mofo.

CONS: Total flier pick. Mom doesn't like us. Might lose him to Nebraska if and when Pelini is done.

OVERALL: This would be a Rob Deer swing for the fences, and I'm okay with that. Once you get down here it's all risky anyway.

5272724b9b54a.image[1]JOSH HUEPEL, OC, OKLAHOMA

BASICS: Oklahoma's OC for the past five years; before that their QB coach for five years. Heisman finalist as a Sooner QB in 2000, with brief NFL career afterwards. A mere pup at 36.

PROS: Head coach is a defensive guy, his show. Supporting evidence: most recent OU OC to get a head job, Kevin Wilson, has been reasonably successful and very successful in his area of expertise. Might be Batman.

CONS: Inexperience, again not even the whisper of a Michigan connection. Would be obvious candidate for OU job when Stoops retires—at 54 that's probably far enough off that it's not a disqualifying factor. Might not be Batman.

OVERALL: Identical candidate to Frost, except with a picture that will haunt him until he dies.

9171396-large[1]KIRBY SMART, DC, ALABAMA

BASICS: Saban's DC since his arrival in Tuscaloosa, with all that that implies both good and bad. Before that a position coach various places. DB at Georgia as a player. 38.

PROS: Scott Frost, the DC. Except he's been absorbing the tao of the master since 2008. Saban got rid of Nussmeier pretty abruptly so Smart must be doing something right.

CONS: Who has any idea whether he's at all responsible for Saban's Ds. Talent overwhelming, coaching same. Has never ventured north of Georgia as a coach, possibly in his life.

OVERALL: Cultural issues and even more total uncertainty about how he'd do on his own make him a nah.

kiffin1[1]LANE KIFFIN, OC, ALABAMA

BASICS: you would take this compared to right now I guarantee it

PROS: just think about that

laaaane kiffin

you'd do it

think about it

CONS: but not too hard

OVERALL: stay safe out there, kids

OTHERS

There are a butt-ton of coordinators out there but not many stand out as consistent overachievers other than the guys above. Bud Foster is a VT DC lifer. Stanford OC Mike Bloomgren, mentioned only for manball demanders, has only been in the job two years but before that was their run game coordinator and then an assistant OC for the Jets for three years. Stanford's offense sucks this year, BTW.

Other than Foster it's hard to find any prominent DCs who have their teams at the top of the rankings year-in year-out, period; those who do often come with overwhelming talent or guru HC issues.

Comments

elm

October 7th, 2014 at 1:14 PM ^

He's a massive jackass and his Rutgers teams could never get over the hump to win a very winnable Big East.  (They tended to start the year slowly and/or fail to win the big games at the end.)  He is also coming off remarkable failure at the NFL level.

That said, he'd be a better choice than a lot of other people Brian is listing and could very well work out.  He was successful at a program no one had been successul at in a century, developed a lot of low-level recruits into NFL players, and recruited fairly well despite being at Rutgers in both Florida and the mid-Atlantic.  It would not surprise me at all if he's our next coach and while I wouldn't be happy about it, I also wouldn't be sad.

I also suspect, though, that Part III is NFL and other random coaches, and Brian will discuss Schiano there.

mgoO

October 7th, 2014 at 12:54 PM ^

I like Frost although he's likely to end up at Nebraska and I can't imagine Michigan hiring a coordinator with no head coaching experience.

He played for:

Bill Walsh

Tom Osborne

Bill Parcells

Bill Belichick

Jon Gruden

& coached under Chip Kelly.

Not a bad list of coaches...

He's also coached (and played) on offense and defense

Dr. Venture

October 7th, 2014 at 12:56 PM ^

Hugh Freeze? I get that he is basically the embodiment of the south, but his track record speaks for itself. 50-18 as a head coach, and 20-11 at Ole Miss. From my vantage that's fantastic.

What about some pro coaches? Greg Roman seems like a solid coordinator with a good record, downside is no HC expierence.

Mike Tomlin? He has some college coaching expierence in his early career, plus he has a Super Bowl ring*, I think that would cancle out any questions about his lack of recruiting. Plus his Steelers have been pretty average the last few years. Poachable? Not likely, but worth a shot.

*Charlie Weis used that in recruiting as well.

Dr. Venture

October 7th, 2014 at 2:01 PM ^

He's had a winning record at every school he's been at.

Arkansas St was 4-8 the two years before he took over. 11-1 his first (and only) year.

Ole MIss was 24-26 in his four years before Freeze took over, including a 2-10 recrod his final season. Since, they're 20-11, that's pretty great when you consider that they're in the SEC West.

So if he's a great guy what does it matter?

His recruiting ranking per rival have been:

2012- #40

2013-#7

2014- #19

I'm not sure I'm seeing the connection.

*Edited for spelling

Mr Miggle

October 7th, 2014 at 2:01 PM ^

find that article was not at all reliable?  A lot of his current staff are holdovers from the previous one. He'd probably bring some of them along. We would be utterly screwed, not to mention a laughingstock.

abertain

October 7th, 2014 at 1:00 PM ^

I'm much more a fan of Morris than of Beck. Beck seems like a fine coordinator but Morris has already been a head coach, albeit at the high school level, and was way ahead of the curve offensively. I also agree with the reader who said he likes to watch entertaining football games. Is anything entertaining about watching M play right now?

I also like the idea of Craig Bohl. He's obviously a proven winner and probably a good fit in terms of style and demeanor. I also enjoy his baldness.

MichiganTeacher

October 7th, 2014 at 1:06 PM ^

1. Mullen 2. Herman 3. Narduzzi

 

Except I don't know about #3. I mean, if we hired the Nard and it worked out, fine. But if he didn't work out, I'm not sure I could handle the ignominy.

0. Harbaughs of course.

 

MichiganTeacher

October 7th, 2014 at 9:17 PM ^

I mean, that 6-6 season at Pitt bothers me. That's his only stint as HC in the midwest, too.

The mercenary stuff bothes me a little bit because it's a waste of time and energy for a HC to be dogged by questions like this. Just another hurdle he has to overcome with recruits, parents, fans, etc. that he otherwise wouldn't have to. But it doesn't bother me a lot.

I'd certainly take him over a lot of other candidates. He's probably hovering just outside my top 5 (not including Harbaughs in the top 5 because pipe dream etc.).

elm

October 7th, 2014 at 1:09 PM ^

Why no mention of Hudspeth?  Or Rod Carey?  (Or, for that matter, Dave Doeren.  He had a horrible first year at NC State, but they're off to a solid start this year.  If they finish 9-3/8-4 that's a pretty impressive performance in his second year and he had a couple of great years at N. Illinois, albeit with Kill's players.)

elm

October 7th, 2014 at 1:27 PM ^

3 consecutive 9 win seasons for a team that hadn't won more than 6 in twenty years plus the first three bowl wins in team history.  Plus a very successful stint in Div II.  Someone is going to hire him soon, probably this offseason.

It probably won't be Michigan, since the northern-most place Hudspeth has coached is one year as Navy's OC.  My money is on Mississippi State hiring him to replace Mullen who leaves for Florida.  But, I also would have liked to see what Brian had to say.  And I'd prefer Hudspeth to most of the names Brian has mentioned.

Michigan4Life

October 7th, 2014 at 1:09 PM ^

they hate Josh Huepel. They think that offense could be so much better than it is right now and doesn't always utilize the talent they have at disposal. Take it FWIW

DFW_Michigan_Man

October 7th, 2014 at 1:13 PM ^

Can we really afford to take a flier on an assistant coach with no head coaching experience considering the current state of the program? Not saying I would not be intrigued by some of the names you have listed, but are those names that former players, current players, students, almuni and fans can rally around?

mgohusker

October 7th, 2014 at 1:27 PM ^

Craig Bohl played at Nebraska and was their LB coach from 95-99 and DC from 2000-2002.

Frank Solich fired him after the 2002 season and hired Bo Pelini.  

He seems more of a small town guy, and is probably better suited to places like Fargo and Laramie.

I'd say most Husker fans are happy that he's gone to be successful at NDSU, but I don't think there would be much interest for him to replace Pelini.

 

 

 

los barcos

October 7th, 2014 at 1:24 PM ^

how the shittiness of this list changes the equation re firing Hoke.  If he can somehow salvage this season (big *if* caveats apply), does a new AD take a look at the potential coaching candidates and say "fuggit - I'm not risking MY ass on these guys."

EGD

October 7th, 2014 at 3:32 PM ^

It's probably moot since a significant turnaround appears unlikely.  Nonetheless, I never think it's a good idea to fire the guy you have just because you are fed up with him--you should only do it if you are confident you'll get an upgrade or if you need to stop the bleeding of some kind.  

With Hoke, earlier in the season I figured we were headed for another year of underachievement and that Hoke would need to be replaced eventually, but that he was at least recruiting well and we could afford to hang onto him until the right candidate came along.  But now, with all the 2015 recruits jumping ship (whether because of the losses or because of concussiongate or both), I don't think that's true anymore.  Maybe if the turnaround were truly monumental (e.g., he betas MSU and OSU, gets M to a bowl game, and wins or loses in a competitive game against a very good opponent) I could see keeping him--but the fact that he's basically shown himself not to be capable of winning those kinds of games is precisely the reason he needs to go.  With a moderate turnaround (say, a 6-6 finish and a respectable post-season performance) Hoke probably still needs to be replaced simply as a matter of damage control.  

 

flashOverride

October 7th, 2014 at 1:33 PM ^

I'm sure it's been said, and I hate feeling it, but man, these candidate analyses really give the sense it's Miles/a Harbaugh or we're screwed. And I don't feel rosy about the chances of any of those three.

maize-blue

October 7th, 2014 at 1:37 PM ^

I'm going to guess the 2015 coach will be Les Miles. LSU seems to be having a down year and maybe trending down. It looks like a good time for him to get out. Dan Mullen now looks like a good choice, although the Florida rumor probably has some smoke behind it.

umfanchris

October 7th, 2014 at 1:44 PM ^

I hope we make a push for Chad Morris and not really sure why Brian thinks their offense has been overrated. Here are their stats:

 

2013: Offense was 11th in the nation in YPG and 9th in the nation in PPG.

2012: Offense was 9th in the nation in YPG and 6th in the nation in PPG.

2011: Offense was 26th in YPG and 24th in PPG. And that’s with a first year starting QB in Boyd and a Rookie Sammy Watkins. Also his first year so he was still installing the offense.

 

Doesn’t seem to have any M or Midwest connections and more of an open offense which might hurt him with some of the old crotchety alumni. But overall I like him more than any other offensive minded Coordinator.

MartinHD

October 7th, 2014 at 1:46 PM ^

Head coach at WMU.  Stints as college and NFL assistant.  Worked under Kill, Schiano and Tressel.  He could bring MIke Hart with him.  Great recruiter.  One of only two current FBS coaches to have both played and coached in the NFL.  No crazier an idea than some of the other names being thrown around.