Ghost of Fritz…

January 4th, 2022 at 5:58 PM ^

Just a worthless opinion... 

I am skeptical the Michigan's culture (both University and Athletic Department) would copy what Texas A&M are reportedly doing with NIL stuff...  What Texas A&M is doing is not permitted under NCAA rules.  But no one is going to police it, so they can do it without repercussion.  

sdogg1m

January 4th, 2022 at 5:26 PM ^

Michigan boosters must begin organizing and develop a superior NIL system for our great university. 

I have read several comments that Texas A&M's record will be similar but I am willing to bet they win a national championship. Jimbo Fisher is a good coach and they beat Alabama this year. Anyone who still has trouble concluding that talent matters needs to explain how Hugh Freeze was able to lead Ole Miss to beat Alabama in back-to-back years while they were paying players.

Durham Blue

January 4th, 2022 at 5:30 PM ^

The future ESPN 30 for 30 on all the NIL stuff is going to be epic and must-see TV.  You know there will be one.  We'll get to learn about all the big time donors and how they're pissed off that they're not getting any returned value for their large investments.  There may be some success stories as well.

True Blue Grit

January 4th, 2022 at 5:38 PM ^

This ought to do wonders for team unity - where a few guys have gotten millions and the rest peanuts.  Not to mention the obvious favoritism the highly paid guys will get from the coaches and staff.  It places really negative incentives to favor the "bigger investments" on the team.  Don't be surprised to see this team badly underperform to their talent level.  

TrueBlue2003

January 4th, 2022 at 6:22 PM ^

Hm, yeah, I mean in the real world everyone makes the same amount of money.  No more no less.  That's the only way to keep things harmonious right?  That's why all NBA players make the same amount of money.  Wouldn't have team unity if that weren't the case.

And yeah, the money is definitely what will cause favoritism.  There wasn't favoritism in sports before the money.

DHughes5218

January 4th, 2022 at 5:42 PM ^

This is a great idea until these same kids think they are out performing their contracts and they threaten to sit out big games without a bonus. It’s going to get ugly. It’s the Wild West in recruiting.

njvictor

January 4th, 2022 at 5:58 PM ^

TAMU has a bunch of oil/gas baron's funding their entire program via supposedly illegal pay for play through shell companies. This is what every top program is doing and the fact that Michigan hasn't done this yet means we're behind

JamieH

January 4th, 2022 at 6:01 PM ^

I have always thought the kids were being taken advantage of, but this will get even more ridiculous over time.

I think we are almost at the point where we should stop treating them as students.  Forget making them go to school.  Just pay kids to come play for you like you are a semi-pro team.  If they WANT to go to school and get a degree, then go for it.  

I don't see this all ending any way but bad.  What we are heading to is a situation where you have the NFL, but you have no draft, no rookie contracts.  Everyone every year is just a free agent on a one-year contract and whoever pays the most for the player will win. 

IMO it is going to suck.

JamieH

January 4th, 2022 at 6:50 PM ^

Where did I say that?  

It creates an untenable situation for the sport.  There is NO professional sport that has unfettered free-agency with one-year contracts.  Why does anyone think that is going to work well in college sports?   

Any player that "blows up" will now be demanding a huge NIL payment or BAM, they enter the transfer portal.  Is that really the way we want college sports to work?

 

alum96

January 4th, 2022 at 10:06 PM ^

Bingo

Imagine if CJ Stroud or JSN went to the portal tomorrow.  How much would they be paid? It's going to be hilarious how this works out.  Guys who are elite in their 2nd year and stuck 1 more year in college are gonna get PAID big dollars buy boosters.  Caleb is going to make more next year than many NFL players.  FREE MARKETS BABY

Michfan777

January 4th, 2022 at 6:17 PM ^

Insane money if true. And as someone who lived in Texas for quite some time, this is exactly what I’d expect from aTm.

Like others have said, this just seems shitty, and while college athletics has never actually been about student athletes playing for the love of the game, this is outright pro sports money.

The way the sport has changed in the last 10-12 years is crazy, and I’m not sure it’s for me sometimes anymore.

I wish the NFL would just make a damn farm league for teams in cities without NFL teams. Give the best high school athletes a chance to go pro right from high school and let them worry solely about the sport instead of the facade of schoolwork and being a student.

BlueMk1690

January 4th, 2022 at 6:50 PM ^

It was obvious that this would happen with NIL. I created a thread last summer about this exact scenario and suggested Michigan should get ahead of it by advocating aggressively for official player compensation rather than allowing boosters at schools like TAMU to manipulate the NIL system this way.

I got like a net of 24 down votes for that thread. I think it's fair to say Michigan will be very much left behind in this professionalization process.

notinmyhouse

January 4th, 2022 at 6:52 PM ^

I hope it all collapses in on itself, then the NFL will be forced to set up minor league teams and pay for it. Those high school players that want to go play on these minor league teams, make a few dollars, aquire no education, and get cast aside when they are hurt or aren't panning out can figure out life like the rest of us. The ones that want to play football and get an education, more power to them

WholeMilk

January 4th, 2022 at 7:03 PM ^

From the NCAA website:

"NIL opportunities may not 
be used as a recruiting inducement or as a substitute for pay-for-play."

If A&M, or anyone else, is dangling NIL deals (with a dollar amount attached) in front of a recruit to gain their commitment, It seems that would cross into "inducement" territory, no?  That said, it doesn't seem any easier to enforce than when it was under the table.

WholeMilk

January 5th, 2022 at 12:13 AM ^

Oh, I know.  I was just curious where the line would be if they did care (and it was enforceable), at least according to their own policy.  And we still have a compliance office, so someone cares.

I do think it is possible for people to be in favor of the new NIL rules (at least versus the previous status quo), but still not approve of teams breaking those rules, even though it benefits the players.  If it's going to be a free-for-all, reflect that in the rules, or else it punishes those who want to run a clean program.