OSU deal with the devil?

Submitted by MGoStrength on January 1st, 2019 at 6:39 PM

After watching the frustrating Peach Bowl game and now watching Haskins & OSU control the game against Washington I can't help but wonder how have things gone so well for OSU the past 10 years and so bad for UM?  Is there some fundamental flaw at UM that continues to bring in coach after coach that seems to come up short and OSU the opposite?  Both Tressel and Meyer dominated UM and Rich Rod, Hoke, and Harbaugh struggled against OSU.  Prior to RR coming to UM who would have thought he wouldn't be successful?  Prior to Tressel coming to OSU who would have thought he'd be so good?  Prior to JH coming to UM who would have thought his offenses would struggle so much?  And, who would have thought Meyer's QB would be one showing uncanny accuracy and ability to find the open receiver whereas our QB whisperer's protege, a former 5-star talent, struggled in our bowl to hit open receivers.  I sit and watch Dwayne Haskins just drop dimes everywhere and I go back and look at the recruiting rankings only to find our own Brandon Peters and Shea Patterson ranked ahead of him in the same class.  I find this incredibly frustrating. 

 

I keep thinking this thing is cyclical and eventually things have to turn around, but every time there seems to be an opportunity to do so (Tatgate, JH hire, ZS saga, the trajectories of the two teams prior to our meeting this season, etc.) it always seem to work out in OSU's favor.  I want to believe that Meyer retiring will be good, but it's hard to believe things will change when they never seem to despite multiple coaching changes on both sides.  I know part this is just frustration talking on a message board, but it's really uncanny how bad of luck we've had in relation to OSU in the post-Carr era.

Alumnus93

January 1st, 2019 at 7:51 PM ^

I'll say it the millionth time... historically we had success beating Osu by taking one of their own in order to beat them.  Bo and then Mo....   We got Bo just to beat Woody because he was the one guy who could and could compete for the Ohio talent.  

Fast forward to 2005 and Dantonio is sitting there waiting for call, as the one guy who can surely beat Tressel, his former DC.... The call never came.  BO used to call Tressel the snake in the grass as in cheater, and Id bet he influenced a non hire from that tree. The rest is history.  

gustave ferbert

January 1st, 2019 at 8:01 PM ^

It's not bad luck.  Your Post title is appropriate.  They did sell their soul.  The major difference is that when it comes to OSU football, the protection the institution is provided at the state level is like a moat.  

Michigan doesn't have that luxury because our state is shared with Sparty.  Everyone in Ohio is for Ohio State.  Chris Spielman said so.  

This recent scandal, when they are going so far as to alter police reports so that they would not be subject to FOIA is telling. 

They cheat and can get away with it because they are protected.  There isn't a powerful enough apparatus that will take them down.  Especially when they are estimated to be a $1 Billion franchise. 

 

PsyWolv

January 3rd, 2019 at 9:52 PM ^

Really hate it that we have to resort to conspiracy theories to explain away the difference between our program and theirs. I know it makes us feel better about playing second fiddle to them but it A. Probably isn't true and B. Is a bad look for us. 

And if you subscribe to that theory than how are we ever supposed to beat them? I mean apparently it's rigged against us right? 

 

C'mon man. Don't be that guy. 

True Blue Grit

January 1st, 2019 at 8:04 PM ^

Simple.  OSU as a program, school, and state want to win football games more badly than Michigan does.  They will do whatever it takes to do that and Michigan won't.  They'll spend whatever amount of money on recruiting, facilities, and staff it takes.  They don't have the highest academic requirements for athletes, so they can get players in that Michigan passes on.  They will look the other way when their coaches commit fireable offenses.  It goes on and on.  If Michigan wants to be at that level, they have to make the total commitment to do whatever it takes.  I don't think the administration at Michigan will do that.  So, my advice is live with it.  

Coldwater

January 1st, 2019 at 8:50 PM ^

If I’m the AD I give Harbaugh  carte blanche to do anything humanly possible to beat OSU.   Anything.   It has to be THAT important to Warde Manuel and the Football program.  Wins are he only thing that matter.  Hell, give each coach a 1 million dollar bonus each time they beat the Buckeyes.  They can afford it.  

MGoStrength

January 2nd, 2019 at 8:35 AM ^

At least you're honest.  Unless you're an alum, most fans probably don't really care about academics.  As long as the staff is not committing blatantly illegal and/or immoral violations we'd prefer to just win versus be morally and/or academically superior.  

cp4three2

January 1st, 2019 at 8:08 PM ^

It’s not a secret. Tressel announced on the basketball floor that he was going to ramp up the rivalry and Michigan didn’t respond. He locked up Ohio recruiting. They’re playing modern football, we’re still talking about Bo. 

BayWolves

January 1st, 2019 at 8:09 PM ^

All we need is better clock management, offensive play calling (particularly going to WRs on first down) and adjustments on defense and we will be fine. Why the changes didn't happen after the OSU debacle is mind boggling, however.

The Pharaoh of Filth

January 1st, 2019 at 8:09 PM ^

This has been an interesting thread.

You have the realists: Those who know OSU is a great school out to win football games and they do what it takes. They know Michigan is a great school who takes whomever can qualify by NCAA standards.

Vs those who love the BS--whine about cheating, cry about steroids, and think  everyone is out to get Michigan.

Fascinating, really.

TruuBluu0324

January 1st, 2019 at 8:15 PM ^

Deal with the devil? You mean making adjustments, better recruits, and not running an offense from the 1970s? Yeah.... sneaky bastards. It must of been a deal with the devil. 

Billy

January 1st, 2019 at 8:17 PM ^

Past 10 years?  Ohio st has avoided prolonged stretches of pain more than any big time program I can remember.  If they experienced a ten year run like ours, the city and school would burn to the ground. 

YoOoBoMoLloRoHo

January 1st, 2019 at 8:29 PM ^

Football factory with minimal institutional oversight that recruits like a very good SEC team with an elite coach.

Athletic program with heavy institutional oversight that recruits like a very good B1G team with a very good coach.

Those two equations produce very different outcomes,

Don

January 1st, 2019 at 8:42 PM ^

Not that it matters today, but the notion that Tressel had no track record and was therefore a complete surprise at OSU ignores the fact that in fifteen years at Youngstown St. he won four national championships, had seven double-digit victory seasons, and won over 70% of his games. He was a proven winner with deep and longstanding ties to the entire state of Ohio, which enabled him to lock down the state from a recruiting standpoint.

MGoStrength

January 1st, 2019 at 9:38 PM ^

Another way of saying that is he had no coordinator or HC experience at the FBS level nor recruited at an FBS school since the mid 80s. 

 

I think it's a big leap to assume a successful FCS HC with no FBS HC experience would be successful at a blue blood Power 5 program.

NGoBlue

January 1st, 2019 at 8:47 PM ^

Michigan...or should I say Missedagain is one of the most overrated teams every season. They’ll be lucky to win 10 games next year...you can count on another loss to OSU too. Nothing gives me any reason to believe otherwise. 

Im drunk and will go to bed now. /s

BG Wolverine

January 1st, 2019 at 8:52 PM ^

Watching recent games it's become clear to me that osu wins due to better players and schemes.  Did you see those DBs against Washington? So fast and sure tacklers. I really think our great pass defense was propped up by a great pass rush.

Albatross

January 1st, 2019 at 9:20 PM ^

OSU doesn’t settle for mediocrity. John Cooper  went into the Game undefeated and ranked in the top 2 seemingly every year and would lose to us and that was not good enough for them. They didn’t make any excuses, or tried to lower their standard. They showed him the door and went out and found a guy that could take over the rivalry. They know when you control the rivalry, you control the Big Ten.

We are far more interested in excusing away Harbaugh’s failures and lowering our standards. So in short, you get what you accept.

West Coast Struttin

January 1st, 2019 at 9:30 PM ^

Osu should have playing Georgia ...5 vs 6. Old school bowl system is outdated.

Washington sucks...but they know how to defend against Osu way better than us obviously.

CoverZero

January 1st, 2019 at 10:17 PM ^

1) OSU recruits (and cheats) better than Michigan

2) OSU has had better HC's than Michigan every year for the past 10 years.

3) Other than an occaisional blip such as Purdue this year, Iowa last year...

OSU typically plays with a "killer instinct" and Michigan only does when playing a lessor opponent. 

4) OSU coaches exploit matchups much more often in big games than Michigan does. 

4) Michigan crumbles under its own hype year after year.  They win 4 or 5 games and suddenly everyone is an All American and the team is on pace for a B1G or Natty.  Too much reading of the press clips.  Too much complacency.

 

MGoStrength

January 2nd, 2019 at 8:39 AM ^

Too much complacency.

I highly doubt JH is complacent.  He may be stubborn, a bit odd, and old school, but complacent he is not.  I guarantee he wants to win bad and is working very hard to do so and is acutely aware that he is failing to beat OSU and win the B1G.  Unfortunately, he is probably mistaken regarding what steps are necessary to do so.

Swayze Howell Sheen

January 2nd, 2019 at 12:49 AM ^

I used to think it was cyclical; now I just think a sea change occurred and we, alas, are on the down side of it. Unless OSU hires a real bomb of a coach, I don't think we'll be 50/50 in The Game in the rest of my life. We will win once in a while, but it'll be a surprise when we do.

The whole mystery about Meyer's "loyalty" to Zach Smith, btw, I find pretty funny. Let's say you're Urban Meyer, a "top" recruiter in this time of relatively dirty college football recruiting. We can either believe that (a) Meyer is somehow the most convincing son of a bitch there is or (b) he too finds a way to "play the game". Cue Zach Smith, the biggest douche bag on the planet, and an alleged wife beater to boot. Somehow, Meyer is supremely loyal to this douchebag. Now why would that be? And somehow, this douchebag is also a "good recruiter". 2+2 makes 4 here, which is this: Zach Smith knows how OSU recruiting actually works. If Meyer cut him loose, some of the truth might get out. Instead, Meyer feigns loyalty and Zach keeps mum. Ah, fuck all of them.

buckeyejonross

January 2nd, 2019 at 10:34 AM ^

How people can't comprehend Meyer's loyalty to Smith is baffling to me. Smith was one of Meyer's good friends, had been in his life for 20 years, and on top of all of that, Smith was the grandson of Meyer's coaching mentor.

Listen very carefully. Meyer didn't think Smith was abusing his wife. That's it. Simple as that. No one condoned anything. Urban Meyer listened to a "he said/she said" story between a friend he is extremely biased toward, and that friend's wife, saw that the police didn't intervene, and chose to believe the fried over the woman. Very simple. 

People here act like Meyer watched Smith beat his wife and look the other way after. That's crazy. If Meyer actually thought Smith was beating his wife, he fires his ass on the spot, and if I wanted to be cynical, probably makes a public spectacle of it to cash in on the goodwill for being zero tolerance of DV in the #MeToo era. How do I know? Because that's literally exactly what happened after it became public that Smith had a court date in July of 2018! Meyer fired Smith immediately. 

There's many different arguments to be made on whether Meyer was right to believe in Smith in 2016 (or as far back as 2010). But at the end of the day, Meyer took the word of Smith over the word of Smith's wife. Add to that the lack of police intervention until 2018, and you get what you got. 

BlueinLansing

January 2nd, 2019 at 7:59 AM ^

Ohio State was one 3 yard pass completion from losing to Maryland and potentially their whole season and future collapses into a burning heap of rubble.  Michigan goes to Big Ten Tiltle game, perhaps the Rose Bowl and everybody is looking at both programs differently.  Maybe we even beat an infighting OSU who no longer believe in their coach.

butuka21

January 2nd, 2019 at 10:09 AM ^

They have recruited better football players then Michigan has, and have had a better college football coach since Tressel. That is why they are better.  It’s really not hard to figure out.

jaccherry

January 2nd, 2019 at 1:15 PM ^

Exactly. Try having a top 5 recruiting class for 4/5 years in a row and all the other excuses will go away. 

Enough of the “this guy was higher ranked than this guy though” argument. These are 85-100 man rosters we are talking about and OSU has better players and roster every year for past decade. Not hard to figure out. 

The academic standards for student athletes excuse for losing recruits to OSU is just not legit either  There are very few of these players when it comes to recruiting against OSU. OSU just “gets” better players that have no interest in Michigan. Players Michigan recruits that have no interest in OSU don’t choose Michigan enough for many reasons. The reason people on this site refuse to acknowledge is that Michigan is just not the “it” school when it comes to football. These kids are familiar with the last 10/20 years of college football. 18 year olds have no idea nor care how good Michigan was in 70’s, 80’s, or 90’s. They would have to be told by their parents!

Again, recruit better and all this delusion goes away. The question is, what is it going to take to recruit better? There may be no answer to this question. 

Nemesis

January 3rd, 2019 at 10:59 AM ^

A few thoughts:

 

1)  Ohio is a very good high school football state.  On par with many Southern states.  OSU can just about fill its roster with 4 star guys from Ohio. 

 

2)  Related to number 1......OSU does NOT have to share in state recruits with another big Ohio school.  Michigan has MSU.  Hell, Florida, Texas and California are jam packed full of schools.  Number 1 and 2 together put OSU in a unique position.

 

3)  Years of winning have given OSU a better national brand.  Young people today do not really know a Michigan as a power.

 

4)  Higher admission standards hurt us.  Rumors say that Van Jefferson could not get into UM with Shea.  That dude torched us in the Florida game.

 

5)  OSU got a once in a generation coach in Meyer.  And Meyer knew how to recruit the South and Florida in particular.

 

6)  It is only my uninformed opinion, but OSU seems to take the rivalry more seriously than we do.  We seem to want to tone it down and they seem to want to ramp it up.  Probably has to do with their winning.

 

7)  My uninformed opinion again.  I like their offensive and defensive philosophies better.