OT? Graduatin' Season. Who had the Worst Commencement Speaker?
My graduation speaker at UM was the creator of the Cathy comic strip, Cathy Guisewite. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cathy_Guisewite
I wasn't going to go regardless of the speaker, but she really sealed the deal.
Who can beat that?
I'll stick strictly to the contents of the speeches and say that my speaker was Rick Snyder and he decided to tell us the story of how he discovered bagels.
The next year Sanjay Gupta spoke and told everyone where on campus he was conceived and then told the graduates he would buy them drinks. I felt a little ripped off.
I searched the Ann Arbor bars. He never fricken showed. Yes, I'm still bitter.
to inflict one final jolt of pain on graduating students and their parents. With very rare exception, they're either excruciatingly dull, vapid, shallow, stupid, preeningly moralistic, or boring.
The commencement speaker for my graduation from UM's architecture school in 1978 was Walter Mondale. Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
Cathy was the speaker in 94. Bush Sr. was 93 and Hillary Clinton was 95. Ack!
Hillary was '93. Bush Sr. was '91 for my sister. But I like your world better. In your world, I'm still 39! woo hoo!!
Not from my own college graduation, but from a relative's college graduation ceremonies at Syracuse University in 2006 at the Carrier Dome (note Syracuse alum, Jim Boeheim's college rommmate, Detroit Pistons star, NBA Hall of Famer and Detroit Mayor Dave Bing seated near the commencement speaker on the left side of the screen)
Ellis Boyd "Red" Redding (Morgan Freeman) gets an honorary degree from Boston University and calls the school "one of the greatest universities on the planet" (also not from my own college graduation)
One of my sons picked up two U of M degrees.....Obama and Larry Page were the speakers. Politically, you can't do better than a sitting president and rumor has it that Larry Page didn't do too badly in the business world.
The Obama thing was a pain...had to get there early for security, and then you had to wait for his highness to fly out of there after a few thousand hand shakes.
I graduated in '91 and drew George Bush The Elder. It was a terrible speech about the Great Society that had absolutely nothing to do with anybody present. This was aside from anybody's political beliefs, it was just an awful graduation speech. Also, half the student body decided to go crazy protesting, which I found pretty disrespectful and ruined things even further.
I graduated from a private MI college in 2005 and George W Bush was our commencement speaker. He actually wasn't too bad, he even had a couple of funny jabs at himself. Of course everyone was up in arms at that time about Iraq, ect, ect, so there were plenty of protesters around but nothing too crazy. No matter what your political beliefs, it's cool to get to see a sitting president give a speech up close and personal.
His name was Abraham Lincoln...you may have heard of him?
and you and your 95 classmates win, hands down.
I went to a small private school in Michigan and my college graduation was cancelled b/c there was a norovirus outbreak on campus, so the health department said we couldn't hold an event that brings in people from all over the midwest and risk getting more people sick. So they held it the next weekend but I went to a friend's wedding instead.
I don't really get the hubub w/ graduations. They are awfully boring to sit through, with or without a good speaker. I can see it being important to a family that is seeing a first generation college graduate or something like that but man, I have loathed every one I've ever attended.
Funny. I read the title of the thread and thought, "Shit...no one can beat Cathy!" Many years later, it seems everyone from '95 is still thinking, "Cathy?"
May, 1991: George Bush the First. Such a bad public speaker.
Mine in Winter of 2003 and my then fiancee and now wife's graduation in Spring 2004.
My commencement speaker was Thomas Miller, the US Ambassador to Greece. I don't remember a word he said unfortunately, he just didn't make much of an impression at all.
My wife had Automobile Magazine's founder David Davis, who was already mentioned previously as being funny for pointing out how the student body was upset he was there as he was kind of a no-name guy. He gave a good speech though, better than mine 4 months prior.
I wish I had been at Northwestern for their speaker in 2011 though, that speech was hysterical. "Northwestern's Alumni list is truly impressive. This University has graduated best selling authors, olympians, presidential candidates, grammy winners, peabody winners, emmy winners...and that's just me!" Here's a link to the transcript of his speech, its some funny stuff: LINK
a friend of mine's lil sis went to NU and was there for that speech. I got to watch their home video of the graduation, and he killed. Funny as all hell, thanks for linking to the transcript!
This has actually been a board topic before - probably last year, I'm guessing.
Anyway, I answered 1988 Marshal D Shulman and was criticized by another MGoer, but I stand by my opinion. That dude'ss speech literally harshed my buzz.
1986 Javier Perez de Cuellar
Ughh. Yes I went Ohio being an Ohio boy and couldn't afford Michigan tuition. It was 1997, and my feelings were, I got to listen to this blow hard talk about his Heismans again? Thankfully right when he got up to the podium, it started pouring. They canceled the rest of graduation and I picked up my diploma in a Michigan shirt later in the day. I was wearing a Michigan shirt under my gown in the shoe too. Ticked off my classmates, so it brings back good memories!
Some old african american woman droning on about "she-roes". I ask any of my friends that graduated with me that day. No one can remember her name. We just remember the LSA president made a comment in the daily that the administration could have done better. . .
I helped set up a conference here on campus she spoke at recently.
I had to look her up. There was nothing memorable from her speach.
What a special day.
For the most part, you don't really remember much about the graduation speech cuz a lot of them have the same message. "Take on the world" "anything you put your mind to, you can accomplish" "nothing is impossible" that type of message.
However, you remember who spoke at your graduation. We had Governor Snyder. I thought he had a pretty good speech, but it wasn't memorable at all. Meanwhile, the year before had Obama. Obama's speech was pretty awful, since he talked about the need to put partisan difference aside rather than inspiring the class like he did during his first presidential campaign. STILL, those kids got The President at their commencement. The year after was Sanjay Gupta. This year was Dick Costollo. When you look at some of the past speakers, Snyder is one of the most underwhelming from a name perspective. That's why I'd contend Snyder, and it has nothing to do with his speech.
But at least you remember.
I would doubt 50% of the class from 1996 remembers who spoke.
Lawrence Kasdan:
Any Workaholics fans out there? If so, you'll love to know that Anders Holm delivered one of the keynote commencement addresses at UW-Madison this year. He's a Wisconsin alum (former swimmer, too?), so there's a definite connection. My favorite snippet from the local Madison newspaper:
He specifically welcomed the “Badger grandmas” and told them “it’s mind blowing to think that just 50, 60 years ago you guys were pioneering the walk of shame.”
Basically, "I got blown up in Iraq, buy my book."
But I graduated on the Diag, bitches.
Law school was some famous int'l arbitrator. He spoke on all his famous accomplishments and how great he was and how he was flying to Europe after the speech.
I graduated in Dec. (1980) with a BS in Computer Engineering, so we had a small commencement ceremony for the Engin school in Hill Auditorium. That was the good part. The bad part was the speaker was Coleman Young who was in his early years as mayor of Detroit. He was a snooze and a half.
Best an all star guy....GO BLUE
...Johnnetta Cole was just awful. Here I am, graduating from the University of Michigan, and my graduation speaker is: the president of a small women's college that I've never heard of?
I actually went into it with an open mind, thinking "hey, if they brought her here, she must be really interesting." She wasn't.
and our grad speaker was the late David Halbestram. I know he was a respected journalist and author but, quite frankly, I found his speech the opposite of memorable. I went to graduate school at Syracuse and we had Bill Clinton who, whether you agree with his politics or not, gives great speeches. I think it has a lot to do with his charisma. Whereas Bill is very upbeat, David Halberstram was along the lines of Kissinger.
Mine was Javier Perez de Cuellar, Secretary General of the UN. The year before it was Gov. Blanchard and the year after it was Mike Wallace from 60 minutes. Here's a list: http://bentley.umich.edu/research/guides/commence/. I think I would have liked Jeff Daniels' the best.
I had Obama.
His speech was pretty much about how we need to be nicer to and more open-minded and tolerable of people with opposing views and methods, i.e. the Republicans were giving him a hard time.
Granholm briefly spoke before him, and she just kissed Barack's ass, probably in the hopes of securing a cabinet position at some point. I was embarrassed for her but everybody else seemed too caught up in the hype.
I knew the student speaker, Alex Marston, and that was the coolest part, so the whole thing was pretty memorable.
Forget who it was, but for December 2002 graduation we had a poet laureaute who kept talking about how well he knew "Mary Sue Johnson." It was Mary Sue Johnson this and Mary Sue Johnson that. And someone finally leaned forward and tried to whisper (but it got picked up by the mic anyway): "It's COLEMAN!"
April 30, 1988
Dr. Marshall D. Shulman, UM '37
Began by describing the conditions in the Soviet Union in 1937 making the grads restless immediately. Shortly, the boos and beach balls came out. Dr. Shulman stopped his speech to admonish us for our lack of respect and to tell us we were an embarrassment to the university.
April 29, 2016
Michael Bloomberg, Billionaire
Warmed up the crowd mentioning the usual A2 hotspots and cliches like Zingermans, the Diag, Brady, and "...so help me Harbaugh." He challenged the "safe spaces" as sheltering students from the difficulties of the real world. He took his whacks at demagoguery, both parties, but also lauded the students for the anti-islam protests.
Solid.