SIAP: NYT on Mr. Brightside

Submitted by Swayze Howell Sheen on December 6th, 2023 at 3:23 PM

Article: here

Key paragraphs:

At a 2017 University of Michigan game against its rival Michigan State, in the midst of a torrential downpour, the song came over the loudspeakers at the end of the third quarter and everybody in the sold-out stands (capacity: 109,901) kept singing a cappella after the D.J. cut the music. Belting “Mr. Brightside” has been a third-quarter ritual ever since. You can even buy “Mr. Brightside” Michigan-themed merch.

“It’s a weird song to have be a college football anthem,” acknowledged Alejandro Zúñiga, a Michigan alum who covers his alma mater for 24/7 Sports. “The subject of the song is not related to sports, and it’s not a fight song,” he added. “But it just had so much momentum that it became what it is.”

 

UNCWolverine

December 6th, 2023 at 3:24 PM ^

I graduated in May 1998. I do not believe that we had a song like that for that championship season. Maybe Fly by Sugar Ray or Tubthumping by Chumbawamba could have caught on.

rob f

December 6th, 2023 at 3:39 PM ^

+1000 for you if I could. 

"Sweet Caroline" is so very overused. Besides the Red Sox wearing it out over the years, hearing it at Michigan Stadium (and other venues too) way too many times, and now on an overplayed beer commercial, I now cringe every damn time I hear the chorus "so good! so good! so good!" 🤢🤮

And truth be told, I still enjoy the original Neil Diamond version on those rare occasions I hear it played.

Tozmo

December 6th, 2023 at 4:09 PM ^

As an event DJ, I refused to play that or Gettin Jiggy Wit It. I tried my best not to play Electric Slide either, but ended up having to cave to one of them.

Please, for the sake of your children, teach them early that these songs are not acceptable to be played over a speaker.

WeimyWoodson

December 6th, 2023 at 3:28 PM ^

Interesting that that it happened in 2017. I was at games early in 2018, and they were not doing it, but I remember in the 2018 season, when we were blowing out Penn State, they played it, and the stadium sang along when coming back from a commercial. I thought that was the first time it happened.  

Swayze Howell Sheen

December 6th, 2023 at 3:35 PM ^

Related: The Jump Around story

Article: here

"Jump Around” first happened during the 1993 football season with the men’s swim team smuggling in a megaphone and Discman and playing the song to rile up sections O and P.  In 1998 it became a regular tradition.

Say what you will about the Badgers, but Jump Around is cool and college sports at its finest.

 

BallsoHarb

December 6th, 2023 at 3:46 PM ^

Wife and I were at this game, her first one. I didn’t know that was the night it started, but I remember us laughing and singing it. Too bad the way that night ended.

Booted Blue in PA

December 6th, 2023 at 4:03 PM ^

This was my youngest son's first trip to the Big House....  What a memorable night (sadly, the game was terrible)...

We were all Mr. Brightside, hanging on hope that after almost two decades of bpone our Wolverines wandering through the proverbial desert of dispair....they would soon find the promised land..

Low and behold..... just four years later, it happened!

RealElonMusk

December 6th, 2023 at 4:07 PM ^

It's a fun new tradition-  some may not love the song or the topic it deals with but the resigned semi happy semi melancholy spirit of the song seems to match our experience as Michigan football fans since 2005.

Michigan State seems to draw power from direspekt!

Michigan draws power from:  infinite pain!

 

Yahtzee

December 6th, 2023 at 4:22 PM ^

I was at the 2018 Wisconsin game, 2019 Notre Dame game and do not recall Mr. Brightside being played at the end of the 3rd Quarter (could have been the booze)?

First time I heard it was 2021 Washington, and was a sight to see with the Maize Out!  Still watch the video I took often.

Mark McBoneski

December 6th, 2023 at 4:41 PM ^

The earliest I remember Mr. Brightside being played in the stadium was 2016 Wisconsin. The song made a return later that season against Indiana (the snow globe game). That was pretty cool, but belting it out while being drenched in a night game is what takes it over the top for me.

And while I don't recall at what point in 2017 MSU the song was played, I do know that subsequent playings did not occur right in the 3rd quarter break. Sometimes we'd be deep in the fourth quarter, or like in 2021 OSU, midway through the third.

BlueMk1690

December 6th, 2023 at 4:59 PM ^

It's peak millennial and as that generation will make its march into middle age and then old age, the song will probably stick around as a song played at Michigan Stadium.

The question though is what happens If it's only the dads in the expensive seats singing it, will it survive as a song where people can claim 'the whole stadium is singing it' (it's in reality probably never been more than 10%, but that's a lot of voices at Michigan Stadium)? There's usually a critical mass required for a song to keep that singalong momentum.

Dixieland Delight has survived a long time at Bama, but then there's also a local pride element to that which creates a lasting connection to the fans no matter the age and whether they've ever listened to an Alabama song in a different context. Sweet Caroline is maybe more comparable, but you could say that it has entered the American standard repertoire as a celebratory tune played at all kinds of events, so it will forever get recognized by enough people to get that critical mass of people singing.

At this point I think it could still fairly easily fade into the background in a few years. The main problem with the song is that as catchy as it is, its primary emotional mood is 'despair', which is hardly suggestive of a long future as a sporting event song for a winning team.

SFBlue

December 6th, 2023 at 5:24 PM ^

There was not an anthem in 1997. I was a sophomore. Wyclef was the jam at that time, in all house parties. I retroactively designate “Gone til November.”

Piston Blue

December 6th, 2023 at 6:12 PM ^

I was a junior in '17 - we sang it every home game that year (Brian wrote about it I think in the Cincinnati game recap) but that game just reached a different level. IIRC UM was still undefeated and ranked in the top 10 - but was already down Speight. That game, football wise, was so terrible. Absolute classic Dantonio game, but it was a one score game basically the whole way. At a certain point in the 3Q it began raining harder than I've ever seen in Michigan before, and there was no way anyone was leaving before the 4Q. Only thing left to do in the student section was to belt that song and try to lift the team in any way.

Even though both the actual game and results sucked, that was probably my favorite game I attended in my time at UM. I remember walking back to my house on Division St. and taking my shoes off and realizing they were completely full of water. Good times.