4* & 5* Freshmen WR performances across CFB this season

Submitted by taistreetsmyhero on
247 Comp. Rank Name School Receptions Yards TD
1 Donovan Peoples-Jones Michigan 12 155 0
2 Tee Higgins Clemson 7 75 0
3 Jerry Jeudy Alabama 12 208 1
4 Joseph Lewis USCali 4 39 0
5 Jeff Thomas Miami 11 249 2
6 Trevon Grimes OSU 3 20 0
7 Tyjon Lindsey Nebraska 11 70 0
8 D.J. Matthews FSU 1 12 0
9 Devonta Smith Alabama 4 79 1
10 Jhamon Ausbon TAMU 25 263 1
11 Henry Ruggs III Alabama 6 159 5
12 Tyrell Shavers Alabama 0 0 0
13 Jalen Reagor TCU 19 308 4
14 James Robinson Florida 0 0 0
15 Tarik Black Michigan 11 149 1
16 Amari Rodgers Clemson 11 67 0
17 Tylan Wallace Ok State 3 56 0
18 Jeremiah Holloman Georgia 1 7 0
19 OrTre Smith USCar 18 224 3
20 Osiris St. Brown Stanford 0 0 0
21 Mark Webb Georgia 0 0 0
22 D.D. Bowie Ole Miss 0 0 0
23 Nico Collins Michigan 1 12 0
24 CeeDee Lamb Oklahoma 33 591 6
25 Damion Miller Texas 0 0 0
26 Omar Manning TCU 0 0 0
27 Charleston Rambo Oklahoma 0 0 0
28 Jaylen Harris OSU 2 27 0
29 Oliver Martin Michigan 0 0 0
30 Hezekiah Jones TAMU 2 13 0
31 Danny Davis Wisconsin 8 170 1
32 Terrell Bynum Washington 0 0 0
33 Daquon Green Florida 0 0 0
34 Ty Jones Washington 2 14 0
35 Shamond Greenwood OK State 0 0 0
36 Manni Netherly LSU 0 0 0
37 Bo Melton Rutgers 1 48 0
38 Isaiah Hodgins Oregon St 23 223 1
39 Noah Igbinoghene Auburn 0 0 0
40 Jaevon McQuitty Nebraska 0 0 0
41 Mike Harley Miami 6 63 0
42 JaVonte Richardson Kentucky 0 0 0
43 KD Nixon Colorado 2 17 0
44 Keyshawn Johnson Nebraska 0 0 0
45 Jamire Calvin Wash St 30 266 3
46 Hunter Rison MSU 16 211 0
47 KJ Hamler PSU 0 0 0
48 Trey Blount Georgia 0 0 0

DPJ is tied for 8th/48 in receptions and is 12th in yards. In just 3 games, Tarik Black is tied for 10th in receptions and is 13th in yards.

There are only really 6-9 freshmen that seem to be significant AND productive cogs of the offense (underlined), which is a 13%-19% rate.

MonkeyMan

November 14th, 2017 at 10:09 PM ^

I knew I would see a highly ranked WR from the Sooners and a Mike Leach team (Wash St.)

All you have to do is follow Mike Leach's career and you no longer believe in the "we just got unlucky with our QB" arguments- the man produces ridiculous passing yards year in and year out with any team- bad "luck" never seems to happen to him

he knows how to spot 'em; he knows how to train 'em- there ain't no "luck" to it

J.

November 15th, 2017 at 9:59 AM ^

Either that, or his system alleviates the need for a particularly skilled quarterback.

Which of these two scenarios seem more likely:

1 - Mike Leach has some innate ability to sniff out and develop quarterback talent that is unmatched by anyone else in the nation.  Furthermore, due to his incredible skill at recruiting, nobody else is able to lure these diamonds in the rough away from Lubbock, Texas or Pullman, Washington once he's identified them.

2 - Mike Leach uses a system that makes fewer / different demands upon the quarterback than just about anybody else.

How many NFL quarterbacks has he produced?

The Air Raid offense is designed to generate big passing numbers for any quarterback who can read the defensive alignment and call the appropriate play.  (It's also worth pointing out that Leach has made his career in the defense-optional Big XII and Pac-12).

uminks

November 14th, 2017 at 10:12 PM ^

analysis on freshmen or RS freshmen QBs who are starting for the first time. And while your at it could you check out freshmen or RS freshmen RB. You would think RBs may do better as Freshmen? But may be not. So we should see major improvement in the next two years and even if we finish 8-4, it will be a good season for such a young team.

Jimmyisgod

November 14th, 2017 at 10:21 PM ^

DPJ hasn't been very good as a WR, but the talent is evident. Could easily be a monster next year, but route running is a weakness right now. That's why you see less talented guys at MSU having better seasons. White and Rison run better routes than most freshman.

Jimmyisgod

November 14th, 2017 at 11:28 PM ^

Maybe so, but White and Rison have made a ton of tough catches in traffic for them this year. It's not like they've been taking screen passes for long runs, both have made several highlight catches that you see from upperclassmen studs.

BroadneckBlue21

November 15th, 2017 at 6:59 AM ^

When you get 5-10 targets a game, you make some tough catches. DPJ gets 3 a game. JOK stunk it up, and they’ve been managing games with Peters youth. DPJ needs to be targeted more by Peters to show his true development. Pass protection has to improve. Peters is rolling out more because of the weakness of lone. Our run game has developed, though, because Ruiz and Brederson hit the next level. I’d love to see Ruiz at LG, Onwenu at RG, and Brederson at RT, with his mobility. Even for a drive or two against Wisconsin when we are up by 14. JBB isn’t quick footed enough on the outside to keep DEs away.

TheReal_GR3

November 14th, 2017 at 10:32 PM ^

I think it is important to note the type of offenses these guys are playing in and the quaterback play they are getting. 

Spread offenses:

-Jhamon Ausbon TAMU (25-263-1)

-Jalen Reagor TCU (19-308-4) 

-CeeDee Lamb OK (33-591-6) 

-Isaiah Hodgins OSU (23-223-1) 

-Jamire Calvin WSU (30-266-3) 

 

Pro-Style or multipe:

-OrTre Smith SCAR (18-224-3) 

-Hunter Rison MSU (16-211-0) 

I think that it stands out that freshman that play and produce early tend to play in offenses that are easier to run and easier to learn. They don't play too many different formations or line up at different spots or even different sides of the field. They also don't have to hear play calls, they get hand signals from the sideline that tell them routes, not plays. 

Jerry Jeudy, Henry Ruggs III from Bama belong on this list but they run as much spread as they do pro style. Jeff Thomas from Miami does too but I don't know their offense. 

But of the names above the only questionable QB play is from Texas A&M. Everyone else has elite to very good QB play. 

Oh Deer

November 14th, 2017 at 11:52 PM ^

Thanks for posting this. Good information. We all know young receivers tend to struggle. Not worried at all about that position group. Lots of talent there which will get better if we see improvement in the areas we should all be worried about, QB and O Line.

 

 

ZekeBulldog

November 15th, 2017 at 12:33 AM ^

MSU’s Cody White has 20 catches and 300+ yards fwiw. The 4*/5* definitely have higher upside but having that kind of production out of a freshman receiver would be nice.

mgobleu

November 15th, 2017 at 6:50 AM ^

Here's hoping these guys take that leap many sophomores do when they get to their second year. Peters included. Just kind of a perfect storm of injuries and bad situations that haven't set these young guys up very well for success. With a little OL depth abs QB consistency, these WRs will really get rolling in the next couple years.

bluepalooza

November 15th, 2017 at 7:56 AM ^

With M TE’s And elite QB. M offense will be freakishly Good over next two years. I have been watching M football a long time. Combination of talent and scheme Michigan is building a dynasty the likes we have not seen since the 70’s.

I am going to say it. Better than Bama and OSU. Why? Scheme on O and defense. Yes, Bama and OSU have a little more talent. But their offensive scheme of zone read and chuck and duck is pedestrian compared to M’s offensive scheme. The reason M offense was so ugly earlier this year was the complexity on a young team. You can see the team blossom before our eyes. Still work to do, but what I am seeing is a team with very young elite talent, elite coaching and building to elite execution. Still a ways to go but wow. Imagine an offense that travels regardless of weather, opposing defense or stadium

Gang, we got a taste of this offense the second half of 2015 with less overall talent. Do you remember how M finished the season with Rudock and destruction of a good Florida team? That’s where this team is headed only Better!

I, like many of you was worried earlier this year. Michigan is a good team right now, not great or even very good. But greatness is coming. Starting in Bowl game and next year this team will play like one of the best teams in country.

Jimmyisgod

November 15th, 2017 at 9:20 AM ^

The frustrating thing is that WR is a huge weakness and we brought in the best WR class in the country.  So we expected Collins, Martin and DPJ to be at least as good as any freshman WR group in the conference and they aren't.  Black was on his way to a great season, small sample size, but he looked good.  It's frustrating that MSU again has a couple lower rankled guys that look "better" than our guys.  Rison and White aren't just products of a pass happy team, they have legitimately looked better than DPJ.  And that's just 1 guy, Martin and Collins were supposed to be way way better recruits than White or Rison and we are desparate for playmakers at the position.  Not that our guys shouldn't have time to grow, and I think they'll all be contributors as early as next season, but how in the heck does MSU keep finding these guys?  I mean, I know they pass a lot, but they returned a couple decent receivers so they didn't need the help as much as we did.

If we were reranking the WRs as recruits right now, DPJ would still be the #1 WR coming into the Big Ten because of his speed, but I'll be darned if Cody White wouldn't be a close #2 (he's a big WR with good athleticism and great hands) and Rison 3rd.  How the eff is that?  It would be one thing if they didn't keep doing this.  Steroids?  

Perkis-Size Me

November 15th, 2017 at 9:46 AM ^

How many of those schools are starting essentially all freshmen?

Those stats make sense when you’ve got several proven upperclassmen ahead of you. But aside from Perry, all of our guys are freshmen, and whether they’re young or not, they need to be getting the ball to have some semblance of a balanced offense.

BlueWon

November 15th, 2017 at 10:14 AM ^

that our QB's have missed DPJ for long TD's when he was wide open behind the secondary on at least three long passes that I can remember.

BlueWon

November 15th, 2017 at 10:14 AM ^

that our QB's have missed DPJ for long TD's when he was wide open behind the secondary on at least three long passes that I can remember.

MGoStrength

November 15th, 2017 at 11:23 AM ^

I'd be curious to know the make-up of the offensive lines and QBs on the teams these WRs play for, particularly the number of starts.  I know we have a young line and are on our 3rd QB who's only going into his 3rd start...not a recipe for getting the ball to the WRs a ton.  Obviously there's nothing a WR can do if the line can't protect long enough and/or the QB can't accurately deliver the ball to the WR.  I know we've missed DPJ on a number of deep balls where he was open.

 

I didn't realize DPJ doesn't have a TD yet.  We really need to get this kid in the end zone.  That probably has to change to win our next few games unless we get a major TO margin.

Ali G Bomaye

November 15th, 2017 at 12:22 PM ^

I know that some WRs in Air Raid offenses, like Texas A&M's or Oklahoma's, do nothing but run 2-3 routes and have few blocking responsibilities. That probably makes for a faster transition than playing in a more complex offense like ours.

MGoStrength

November 16th, 2017 at 7:41 AM ^

Yeah, that's interesting.  I don't know enough about the nuances of these offenses to know what makes ours so complicated.  Further, if their's is so much easier to pick up, why wouldn't we do that? 

 

It makes me a little weary when I look at how Auburn (runs an offense more similar to OSU) torched Georgia (who runs an offense more similar to ours).  It seems like our offense requires a bigger learning curve and a smaller margin for error all in the name of making it harder to defenses to figure out what you're doing.  It doesn't seem worth it to me.  Just let the athletes be athletes and get the ball in their hands.  Wouldn't that benefit us when we have more talent?  But what do I know.

Mongo

November 15th, 2017 at 2:51 PM ^

his CassTech offense was not good prep for college. He often seems confused and runs his routes either too shallow or too deep. Black was polished and had a much more sophisticated game as a true frosh. Both will be dynamite next year with DPJ probably improving the most. That WR duo with Martin at slot will be awesome over the next 2+ seasons.

ghostofhoke

November 15th, 2017 at 4:35 PM ^

Didn't some moron make a comment on here the other day saying somethign to the effect of "why can't our freshmen contribute as much as all the other freshmen in the country who are tearing it up?". This is above shows the truth and to all those who wonder why our offense isn't as effective as we'd all like it to be, get a grip, youth and inexperience have an impact. Thanks TaiStreetsMyHero, very good job compiling this.