Night_King

July 31st, 2017 at 10:16 AM ^

Speight

Kugler

Runyan

Hill/Washington (I think Washington v. D Long is one of the fierciest camp competitions)

Crawford/Black (with McDoom and DPJ getting a lot of involvement, obviously G Perry when he's back on the field full time)

Perkis-Size Me

July 31st, 2017 at 10:21 AM ^

Can't believe QB is really up for debate but here it goes:

QB - Speight. He has the experience. Peters doesn't. Don't care what kind of upside he has. You throw a kid in that has never played a single down of college ball against one of the better defenses in football, and they are going to absolutely tee off on him. Especially when we have nowhere close to a proven run game for a young, inexperienced QB to fall back on. 

Center - Kugler will start the season, but I think Ruiz ends it. The fact that Kugler is a RS Senior and hasn't seen a real ounce of meaningful playing time doesn't leave me with much optimism for his remaining time here. But I hope he proves me wrong and finally lives up to his billing. 

Right Tackle - I'd guess Runyan Jr. I'm sure a full offseason can only help JBB, but watching him get beat by a Rutgers DL last year didn't bode well for him. 

CB - Hill and Long. Assuming Long is fully healthy

WR - Crawford and some combo between Black/DPJ. The second WR spot will be by committee until someone separates themselves. My guess for now is that Black will get more snaps than DPJ because of his size. 

M Ascending

July 31st, 2017 at 10:25 AM ^

QB: Brady C: Molk RT: Muransky CB: Woodson, Ty Law WR: AC, Desmond, Braylon (play trips all the time) God damnit. Why'd you wake me? I was having such a beautiful dream!

BayWolves

July 31st, 2017 at 11:00 AM ^

The Dude is very happy their will be some 4 receiver sets this year and hopes we'll go 5 wide at times as well - late in the year in partcular.

Jtre1212

July 31st, 2017 at 11:06 AM ^

QB: Speight - An all big 10 QB last year in his first full year starting under Harbaugh and everybody wants him replaced already lol. Lets see him grow and get better and build off of last season. Peters will get plenty of work in the blowouts this year.

C: Kugler  - this is Kuglers last shot, and I think he showed in spring ball that he knows his back is against the wall.  Day 1 starter will be him and Ruiz will be his backup, but honestly 1 or 2 bad games will put him on the bench so he shouldnt get too comfortable.  

RT: ???? I guess I'll go with Runyon with Stueber being a close runner up. I honestly have no clue, but between JBB. Runyon, and the 3 freshman they all have their issues. I think Stueber is the most ready to jump in and play right now out of the freshman. But Runyon has been here and made and impression on the coaching staff in the spring. So i think he keeps the job up until day 1 and then we'll see how he does. This spot will probably be written in pencil all year

CBs: Hill and Long - As much that it sucks that they have both missed time over the last season and the spring they are still our 2 most talented corners right now. I think Washington really made a move in the spring to get his name in the conversation. So i can see him rotating in like jeremy clark did as a 3rd co starter on the outside. Hill probably slides down to the slot when we are in nickel and Washington would be on the outside with Long.

WRs: Crawford and DPJ- Crawford is a lock period. Tbh DPJ and Black will both play a lot. Black is currently penciled in as the starter but i think DPJ has a healthy summer and wins the "spot" back even though Black will play a ton.

chad

July 31st, 2017 at 11:16 AM ^

QB - Speight easily (he'll end up 1st or 2nd All B1G) C - Kugler OT - Steuber (sounds like he has a nastiness in him that will give him the edge) CB - Hill/Long (wouldn't surprise me if Ambry Thomas ends up starting by year end though) WR - Crawford/DPJ (I think Oliver Martin takes over slot by year end)

1VaBlue1

July 31st, 2017 at 11:23 AM ^

Chuck Filiaga...  Has everyone forgot about him?  Yeah, he had some issues during the Army game in pass pro.  But, if I remember correctly, he was moved to LT for that game after playing at RT his last season (the opposite seems more plausible, but I seem to remember this).  Either way, he played the Army game at a position he hadn't played all year - and was thrown against the best.  I'm not going to be overly concerned about some pass pro hangups in that situation.

Also, people seem to think that Crawford is a blue steel lock.  Can someone please explain why?  I get that he played well last year, in limited snaps.  He made one really nice catch (against Indiana), and blocks well downfield.  But did he show enough to make DPJ and Black slug it out against each other?  I'm not sure he did that...  

Jtre1212

July 31st, 2017 at 11:43 AM ^

He has the best combination of experience and talent on the roster right now at WR. Freshman wide receivers typically don't play well due to knowing the playbook, and being able to recognize coverages and convert routes. He was one of our best recruits last year, and he played well in his limited snaps.Something really bad would have to happen for us to trot not 1 but 2 true freshman out there for game 1. I just don't see it, which is Crawford is a lock. Sure maybe down the road, when the freshman get up to speed they could possibly overtake him but as of right now he's got a big leg up on the outside wr position.

WolvinLA2

July 31st, 2017 at 11:53 AM ^

I agree that Crawford didn't show a ton last year, but that's common for a team with two NFL-bound senior WRs and an NFL-bound senior TE. But everything he showed was very good. Everything Black and DPJ showed last year was in HS, and Crawford was a similar recruit as Black but against much better competition in what is likely the top league in the country and he's a year older, with more experience playing against college players and with the playbook. I'm not saying it's impossible for both of those true frosh to pass Crawford, but I think it's unlikely that even one of them does, let alone both. That said, WR is a position that rotates a lot and where all three can play together anyway.

WolvinLA2

July 31st, 2017 at 11:56 AM ^

I also find it funny that with freshman, some fans will focus solely on their recruiting profile (understandably, since we have nothing more to go on) but with a sophomore, their recruiting profile now means absolutely nothing if they didn't blow up as a freshman because it was a whole year ago. Sure, Kekoa Crawford hasn't had a ton of production in college, but Black and DPJ have literally none.

M_Born M_Believer

July 31st, 2017 at 11:44 AM ^

Will be multiple sets and formations, but for the poll.

 

QB - Speight - Incumbent starters hold onto their roles until otherwise the GAME performance dictates otherwise....

C - Kugler Starts the season, but Ruiz is in there before the Conference schedule starts because he gets reps in teh Cincy and Air Force games and just out performs Kugler.

RT - Ruyan starts and affords Red Shirts for the other Freshman

CB - Washington really made an impression, I think he takes one spot, Long and Hill fight it out for the 2nd, spot and I give it Hill.  Long plays a ton as a true nickel.

WR - DJP and Black.  Crawford appears to be a nice receiver, but the talent and abiity of DJP and Black are too much to deny.  Won't matter much because there will be multiple plays with a 4 wide set so Crawford, Collins, McDoom, and Oliver all getting time.

 

Rabbit21

July 31st, 2017 at 1:04 PM ^

Quarterback - Speight

-Center - Kugler

-Right Tackle - JBB will surprise here I think

-Both Cornerback spots - Hill and K. Washington

-Both Wide Reciever spots - Crawford and Black, McDoom wins the slot

yzerman19

July 31st, 2017 at 1:22 PM ^

I think Kieth Washington was the best corner on the field in the spring game so I think he starts. But I think St. Juste makes the biggest leap from the spring and is the corner by the time we get to PSU moving hill to nickel.  I don't think Long stays healthy.  Not to jinx him but he seems like one of those guys to me.

In reply to by yzerman19

ColeIsCorky

July 31st, 2017 at 1:49 PM ^

I thought Long had a healthy high school career though? I don't recall reading about any injury issues, but I could be wrong.