the hat dance photo came out days before the hat dance

2021 Recruiting Catchup: Linebacker Comment Count

Seth May 29th, 2020 at 1:29 PM

Previously: Offense, Defensive Line, Hello posts for WDE/SAM Kechaun Bennett, SAM/WLB/MLB Tyler McLaurin, MLB/Viper Junior Colson, MLB/WLB Jaydon Hood, and WLB/FB Casey Phinney.

Michigan's mostly set at linebacker, with four or five commits already in the class depending on where you put recent commit Kechaun Bennett (he's here for now but headed for DE). Many of the guys in this class are like that. A brief overview of all of Michigan's positions on the spectrum between pure defensive lineman and pure defensive back can be found at post's end. 

The fellas again:

Icon Name Meaning
Sad Josh The genre of player with unrequited interest in Michigan. Unlikely to receive offers; most will eventually fade off the list and go to Duke or Michigan State or something.
Nefarious Eduardo Player is a longshot. Either they've declared someone else a leader publicly or popular opinion holds that they're likely to go to another school.
Data Either no opinion or Michigan is one of a fairly even group of chasing schools. Players in this category maintain no leader or change their leader frequently. The default category for players that we don't know much about yet.
Happy Teeth Players who have Michigan in a small leading group or have Michigan as a tenuous favorite. Should be regarded as a good shot, not a slam dunk.
Mr. Blue Player is either a verbal or is expected to be one sooner or later. Players with this designation are 65%+ to be Michigan commits.

To to the dudes!

SAM/WDE/Edge

Commit
Player State Stars Schools Y/N Previously
Kechaun Bennett CT **** Michigan Hello. Discussed on pod.
Tyler McLaurin IL ***.5 Michigan Hello
Targets
Player State Stars Schools Y/N Previously
Darryl Peterson OH *** Wis leads Michigan, WVU, Bama, PSU  
James Wilborn Jr. CT *** BC, Michigan, ND  

Needs: Major. Josh Uche left for the NFL and none of the explicitly DE prospects Michigan has a good chance of landing seem like impact edge rushers. The guy on the roster getting talked up like he'll take on the role is Luigi Vilain, whose career thus far has been two medshirted seasons and another when he barely played.

Commits: Michigan recently picked up CT 4* DE Kechaun Bennett, who's already 6'4"/220, and who we believe will ultimately grow into a hand-in-the-dirt guy, but also may get into that rotation of edge rushers immediately. The Hello post ran too late to catch an excellent piece by MnB's Jonathan Simmons where he breaks down some plays from Bennett's film.

Don Brown is transitioning into a positionless scheme where standard positions are gone and everyone falls along a spectrum. …

As mentioned above, Bennett is still pretty lanky. He does have room to pack on 30 to 40 pounds, which would put him around Josh Uche territory and a little lighter than Kwity Paye. The best thing about Bennett’s frame is that he is all limbs. His arms are really long, which is essential for pass rushers to keep separation from blockers.

This play from his highlight reel (no full games available) displays the advantage of his arm length well. Bennett shoves the tackle back, extending his arms out to keep him at bay, then swipes over the top to disengage and gets to the quarterback.

Given the state of the class it's reasonable to assume Michigan plans to use swiss army knife LB Tyler McLaurin like Noah Furbush. That role leans more coverage, with some pass rush and lots of taking on lead blockers. Since his commitment McLaurin went on EJ Holland's podcast and described himself as a really fast downhill player who excels against TEs and H-backs. He didn't talk specifically about how he'll be used except the coaches love his length and want to see what he looks like after weight training. Allen Trieu also caught up with McLaurin and talked at length about how his recruitment played out.

Prospects: I wrote this section before the flood of commitments so might as well keep it, but for the record I think Bennett's pledge rules out anyone else.

It's hard to see them giving up on 3* DE/OLB Darryl Peterson however. EJ Holland confirmed that getting Ohioans Markus Allen and Rod Moore helps put Michigan back in the race for Peterson, an Akron (Archbishop Hoban) prospect the staff thinks was critically underrated by the sites. Unfortunately Wisconsin has been making Peterson a priority too. He's visited there multiple times, and talked to the UW 247 guy Evan Flood about committing the same day as friend/IA 4* LB TJ Bollers, a heavy Wisconsin lean. Flood thinks if the pair aren't Wisconsin's next OLB duo it's because they're Alabama's($). Peterson still plans to visit Michigan in late June if possible. Former teammate Nolan Rumler might be of assistance.

Last is James Wilborn Jr., a Connecticut prospect who rose into various top-250s after strong camps at ND and PSU last summer($), and fell back to obscure 3* over the winter. He loves Don Brown, but pursuit from all the big schools seems to have dried up.

[After THE JUMP: Things that didn't make it into recent Hellos, who plays what position, Seth adds a Viper to the board just because].

Middle Linebacker

Commits
Player State Stars Schools Y/N Previously
Junior Colson TN **** Michigan Hello.
Jaydon Hood FL ***.5 Michigan Hello.
Casey Phinney MA ** Michigan Hello.
Targets
Player State Stars Schools Y/N Previously
Damon Ollison OH *** Wis, MSU  
Baron Hopson GA *** GT, Neb  
Deshauwn Alleyne FL *** Kentucky, Auburn, PSU, Neb  

Needs: Moderate. Michigan is rebuilding a position hit hard by attrition and graduation, and should start preparing for life after Cam McGrone and Josh Ross, with only Charles Thomas (whom they like a lot) behind them among guys on campus last year. This was well addressed in 2020 with a class featuring MLB/Viper Kalel Mullings, modern OLB/ILBs Osman Savage and Nikhai Hill-Green, and old fashioned thumper Cornell Wheeler. They still could use at least two; getting a real difference maker to serve as heir to McGrone would be ideal.

Commits: Addressed. Over the last week Michigan received commitments from two coveted prospects from SEC land to go with their thumper from Don Brown country.

We'll start with TN 4* Junior Colson. Like most of the defensive class, Colson was its highest-ranked member at the moment he committed. Unlike the rest until that point, it'll be tough to find a better. Since the Hello we got a few bits from 247. Sam & Steve & Brice's new podcast noted Colson has upside for days, and Lorenz described a big win for a national prospect, noting Colson ranks higher than Cam McGrone in the composite. They like him as much as McGrone, who was 247's #1 OLB. They also said Colson can play anything in the front seven. Marich gushed about Colson's athleticism, noting Michigan is bringing him in as a Viper to start but that his greatest upside is as a do-everything WLB or MLB.

Sam Webb got some more scouting from Colson's head coach Matt Daniels($) that suggests the kid can play anywhere in the front seven:

“He’s phenomenal in coverage for his size and strength. He moves really well, he’s got loose hips, and he likes to cover in the passing game. I know he was tested in the 4.5s in terms of his 40, and that probably would have been several months ago at this point. So, he’s one of those jacks of all trades. I would have no problem, especially at the high school level… you could put his hand on the ground. He could be a defensive end and be all over the field and in the backfield. But he’s so athletic and moves so well in space that there’s no reason to kind of limit him by putting his hand in the ground.”

He's complemented well by FL 4* commit Jaydon Hood, he of the great recruiting quote Ace highlighted in the hello. Lorenz noted while talking about Hood that it reminds him of 2018 when Michigan identified McGrone and Barrett as their top two prospects and got them. Michigan is going to be loaded at this position in a few years.

That does make you wonder what their plans are for MA low-3* Casey Phinney, who's the teammate of 4* OL target Drew Kendall, and friend of 4* TE commit Louis Hansen and 3* DE commit TJ Guy. EJ Holland saw them all in his Northeast trip, but came away substantially less impressed than he was with Guy:

Casey Phinney had the tough task of covering Hansen throughout the day. Phinney isn't built for these types of workouts. He's not a guy that's going to wow you with his ability in coverage or athleticism. To get a true appreciation for Phinney, you have to watch him in pads, which I did last fall. Phinney is a thumper in the middle and a ferocious hitter. He's a natural run stuffer and fills gaps quickly. It was great to see Phinney come out and compete even though it wasn't in a setting that played to his strengths.

Rivals also spoke to Phinney about his position, to which Phinney described his recent film sessions and discussions with Don Brown($):

“Right now, he sees me as a Will linebacker. He said Mike occasionally, but he sees me as a true Will in their system. I love what I see on film. The way they scheme, and the way everyone works together on a string, it’s art.”

Targets: Getting their favs likely means the patience of($) OH 3* Damon Ollison is going to run out. Michigan probably led at the start of the month but was clear about their priorities. Now I imagine Wisconsin should manage to shoo away MSU for the Desmond Morgan clone. GA 3* Baron Hopson and FL 3* Deshauwn Alleyne, two prospects who'd been on Michigan's radar a long time, are also pushed out unless something happens with the commits.

Happy Trails: Michigan is no longer recruiting 4* Jamari Buddin of Belleville, nor Belleville. Sam Webb has been all over the unfolding drama. If you're a 247 subscriber, it's summarized in this post($). If you're not, the interview with Buddin's dad and a discussion between Sam and Lorenz on the allegedly unrelated dustup with Belleville HC Jermain Crowell are both on their latest podcast. The short-short version as I understand it: Michigan led for a year but Penn State has several of Buddin's friends committed and MSU's new coaching staff put them back in the race over the winter. When Michigan had Hood and Colson ready to commit Buddin wasn't ready to make a decision, and that was that. Ohio State lost out on Donovan Edwards the same way this cycle. I won't touch the Jermain Crowell stuff here except to note Buddin's dad explicitly denied it had anything to do with that recruitment.

Viper

Not a Target Just a Guy Seth Likes
Player State Stars Schools Y/N Previously
Maurice Freeman VA **.5 Ole Miss  

Maurice Freeman is not being pursued by Michigan at all to my knowledge. A guy on the 247 message boards pointed him out, and I looked at the Hudl film and now I wish I had not done that. Freeman is outside the top-1000 on the composite with only Chris Partridge/Ole Miss showing any serious pursuit.

/nudge

The Spectrum:

END: This is a defensive line position that can share a depth chart with Anchor (e.g. Kwity Paye), bleed into SAMs (Josh Uche), or play any Taco or Chase Winovich in between.

EDGE: A pure extra pass rush specialist, was more prominent at BC. Can pull from the End, SAM, or Viper depth charts. Just has to be a guy so skilled at getting to the QB they can't double another rusher.

SAM: Think of your standard 3-4 outside linebacker. This is a specialty position for their three-line sets, which have become more prominent lately and figure to be more so with zone blitzers Bob Shoop and Brian Jean-Mary on staff. Ideally you get a guy like Josh Uche who's an elite pass rusher but can also carry a tight end wherever he goes or drop into zone coverage.

"VIPER": What Michigan is apparently calling the SAM position now because good words in football can never just mean what they mean.

ILB: The two inside linebacker positions share a depth chart.

MIKE: The middle linebacker. Michigan wants a Devin Bush or Cam McGrone who can diagnose, win any race to the edge, take on blocks and blitz. Must be able to take a wide zone and match with running backs in coverage.

WILL: Lately this position has begun to trend closer to the Viper, which is one reason Jordan Glasgow displaced Devin Gil last year. But it's still 85% standard linebacker (Mike McCray was here, and Josh Ross is expected to take over), matching in coverage with the RB and doing most of the things the MIKE does. Since they play him to the short side, they want a guy who can fly upfield.

VIPER(!!!): A half-safety linebacker who must set the edge of the defense, match up physically and in coverage against all kinds of tight ends, and have the athleticism to do linebacker things in safety-level space. Sometimes may be asked to play free safety in certain reactions to motions. Historically a blitzy position. This position may be trending back to linebacker-like as Michigan plays with two safeties back more often.

"VYPER": This is not a Michigan position it's what Notre Dame now calls their LB/DE hybrid, I guess because recent studies show "Drop End" doesn't resonate with the kids.

NICKEL: A cornerback-like safety who comes in as a dime back for the 3-2-6 package. Usually it goes to a young safety, but it's also been a cornerback in the past.

Comments

ERdocLSA2004

May 29th, 2020 at 1:38 PM ^

Well that went considerably worse than the last time you did a position recruiting recap.  Are there any signs that the coaches are as concerned about these numbers as we are?  Maybe we aren’t as thin as it seems but it’s difficult to read this and not be concerned.

4th phase

May 29th, 2020 at 2:00 PM ^

Why is this concerning? They got everyone they wanted and don't have to spend more time recruiting LBs. Its nice to have everything wrapped up and focus on CB. 

They got 4 last year, 4 commited now, and none on the roster out of eligibility after this year. So there could potentially be 16 LBs of various shapes and sizes on the roster next year for like 3-4 spots. 

ERdocLSA2004

May 29th, 2020 at 2:59 PM ^

I must have misread/misinterpreted your analysis of the WDE/SAM spot.  You said our needs at that spot due to the Uche departure were major, Villain is our current player who may fill in but has had injury issues.  McLaurin in a Furbush type role, and the way I read your analysis of Bennet I thought it sounded like you didn’t think he’d ultimately fit in this spot?  I definitely missed something...my bad!  If you feel good about that spot though I retract my interpretation.  

Seth

May 29th, 2020 at 4:57 PM ^

No biggie. Edge pass rush is a skill they don't have a ton of on the current roster, unless Jaylen Harrell arrives with a ton of it. They missed out on Zach Harrison and this set them back. They had Uche last year but nobody to pair him with, and not good enough DTs that they could steal the DEs away from interior gaps to get them screaming into the backfield.

schreibee

May 29th, 2020 at 6:01 PM ^

ER Doc is usually one of the more level-headed posters in these comments! This tracked like he had a very long, stressful shift and lost track of to which post he was replying?!

If one were to assume it wasn't all an elaborate ruse in the form of really low-key sarcasm, then perhaps losing out to Wiscy on players good enough that they then may lose out themselves to bama could give one pause?

I guess?

EDIT: OK, it's all about the Edge! Got it...

schreibee

May 29th, 2020 at 6:11 PM ^

Don't think of them as "Linebackers" - they're omni- directional "space backers"!

Part Jabrill, part Khaleke, part Bush, part Furbush. 

They're a bunch of Polamalus! Line em up anywhere - some cover, some blitz, some plug run gaps, and you never know which will do which from snap to snap!

getsome

May 29th, 2020 at 2:10 PM ^

im with you on freeman - hes similar to incoming frosh mohan in stature and violent downhill nature.  seems like a kid don brown would seriously consider at viper

WolverBean

May 29th, 2020 at 2:32 PM ^

Do coaches ever intentionally pursue high-work-ethic high-academic low-athletic-ceiling guys to be glue guys for your locker room / program, with the expectation that their natural position will be on special teams and they might never be an all-22 starter? Or is just always assumed that special teams positions will sort themselves out, and you go for the best player at every position for every open scholarship? (I know what most of the board would prefer, but that's not the question.)

Rabbit21

May 29th, 2020 at 2:55 PM ^

I just think there aren't enough scholarships to do that.  If you're vetting kids correctly one or two "Glue guys" should be popping up among your normal targets and even outside of that, I feel like special teams grit can also be imported from the walk-on program.  

Just my two cents.  It's a nice idea in theory, but there just aren't enough scholarships to support it.

Rabbit21

May 29th, 2020 at 2:50 PM ^

I wonder about Phinney as well.  Maybe they will bring him in as a linebacker and then transition him to offensive thumper.  Otherwise that's a lot of linebackers between the two recent classes.

Jack Be Nimble

May 29th, 2020 at 3:01 PM ^

The relative surfeit of linebackers, coupled with the relative paucity of traditional interior defensive lineman, seems like a pretty strong indication that the defense is changing a bit. More 3-3-5, less 4-2-5. We saw it happening on the field last year.

Michigan played a lot of 3-3-5 formations, and I would only expect that to increase.

OkemosBlue

May 29th, 2020 at 6:01 PM ^

Thanks for your efforts to keep the old-folks up-to-date on new football schemes.  I admit to great skepticism about "positionless" defensive football.  It seems to me that what's happening is that bigger people usually play along the line, in-between size players in between, and smaller players in the backfield.  They are being asked to different and more than previous generations because the offenses have become increasingly diverse, sophisticated, and above all, able to pass well even in college   The change in duties requires a change in athletic profiles and skills.  It also changes who is on the field.  That a big change, but whether it should be called positionless, I don't know.

Seth

May 29th, 2020 at 8:29 PM ^

I wonder if I could make a sharpies out of this. The DL are still DL and you need at least one or two linebackers who can stack and shed a block. That wont change unless someone invents an offense where the OL are all under 200 lbs. Which, who knows, maybe someday?

What this means is that teams are replacing all of the optional spots with a safety. For example last year Clemson was struggling to stop OSU from their 4-2-5 base defense, mostly because their 4.5-star true freshman DT was getting pasted (sound familiar?). So in the 2nd half they went to a 3-2-6 dime. That lineup:

  1. NT Nyles Pinkney. A muck-'em up DT like what you'd expect George Rooks to grow into.
  2. WDE Justin Foster. 6'2/265. An Aidan Hutchinson/Kwity Paye sort
  3. SDE Xavier Thomas. 6'2/265. Rashan Gary basically.
  4. MLB James Skalski. 6'0/235, a Phinney. All-Academic, multi-sport star, middling 3-star. Downhill plugger with better than average athleticism.
  5. WLB Chad Smith. 6'3/240, a 4-star. Like a Gedeon or a Josh Ross except a 5th yr senior who didn't start until then.
  6. SLB Isaiah Simmons. 6'4/230, Khaleke Hudson.
  7. WS Box Safety Nolan Turner. 6'1/195 walk-on. Kovacs.
  8. SS Box Safety K'Von Wallace. 5'11/205 low 3* out of VA. Was a QB in HS. Thomas Gordon.
  9. FS Tanner Muse. 6'2/229(!). A huge deep safety. Thorpe semifinalist. Was a meh 3*, and 6'3/207 as a recruit and headed to Michigan until Hoke's regime fell apart.
  10. CB Derion Kendrick. 6'0/190. 5-star cornerback. David Long.
  11. CB AJ Terrell. 6'1/190. Top-100 cornerback. Leon Hall?

That right there is the type specimen of what coaches mean when they talk about "positionless" defense this offseason. But really it's a standard three-man DL, a plug-ugly linebacker, two standard cornerbacks, and then five guys on the linebacker-safety spectrum. "Positionless" isn't even half of the guys out there.

Michigan can field defenses like Clemson's on aggregate, give or take a richer (Hurst on the 2nd team) or poorer (Kemp is your NT) season. A Hinton-Kwity-Aidan-Ross-McGrone-Barrett-Solomon-Dax-Hawkins-Ambry-Gray lineup is basically the same thing.

thisisnotrandy

May 29th, 2020 at 10:38 PM ^

I like where you're going with this position-less football Seth.  So basically if we can just get all the following players on the team at the same time we should be able to counter OSU buying the premium version of the Sega Genesis controller, selecting "turbo," and button mashing us to death with the same attack repeatedly right?

 

1.) Mo Hurst

2.) Rashan Gary

3.) Chase Winovich

4.) Josh Uche

5.) Devin Bush

6.) Jabrill Peppers

7.) Khaleke Hudson

8.) Jourdan Lewis

9.) Lavert Hill

10.) David Long

11.) Daxton Hill

JonnyHintz

May 30th, 2020 at 10:57 AM ^

I wouldn’t say you need THAT. 
 

First of all, you have to understand that you aren’t ever going to stop OSU from moving the ball and scoring. If you luck your way into a few turnovers and can move the ball yourself, you can somewhat limit their scores. OSU still put up 516 yards on 85 plays (a hair over 6 yards per play). Their two turnovers hurt them, and Clemson’s ability to move the ball and sustain drives hurt OSU’s ability to score in quick succession. The realistic goal isn’t necessarily to STOP them, it’s to slow them down enough to give your offense a shot. It’s going to be a race to 35 or 40 points 9/10 times. You’re not trying to get into a 20-17 slugfest, because they’ll get a good bounce or two (like JK Dobbins fumbling the ball and it bouncing right back into his arms without him breaking stride) and the next thing you know, you’re being boat raced.

 

But yeah, you don’t need an All-Star cast of Michigan’s best defenders of the Harbaugh era. Kwity/Aiden are capable replacements for Winovich/Gary. McGrone is a capable replacement for Bush as a few examples. But Michigan IS missing a few key components to be able to slow down that OSU offense. You DO need great DT play. Kemp is solid, but he’s overmatched in his current role. Maybe Hinton or Smith grow into a capable replacement. We DO need a great corner to play opposite Ambry with some athleticism. 
 

Yeah, having the lineup you listed would be ideal. But it can also be done with a lot of the pieces we have now. We just have a few holes that a team the caliber of OSU (and Bama) can exploit because they HAVE so many weapons.

MaudyMacht

May 31st, 2020 at 1:50 PM ^

Didn't the Giants have what they called their "Amoeba" defense for a few years? Can't remember which years or who the DC was. Almost everyone but the NT was standing, moving all around, faking wherever they wanted. Actual coverages we're pretty standard except it was as positionless as you can get. 

MaizeBlueA2

May 29th, 2020 at 11:08 PM ^

I think Bennett plays the Uche role or WDE.

Colson plays WLB/WILL.

Hood plays MLB/MIKE.

Phinney plays MLB/MIKE and eventually is used on offense as a situational FB. Basically Ben Mason, but a MLB instead of a DT.

McLaurin plays SLB/SAM aka Furbush's role.

Also think this is a solid class and we're done at LB and LB types.

MaizeBlueA2

May 29th, 2020 at 11:42 PM ^

QB (1):
JJ McCarthy

RB (1):
Donovan Edwards (4* - ovr: #38)

WR (2):
Markus Allen

Cristian Dixon (4* - ovr: #166) OR Xavier Worthy (4* - ovr: #208)

TE (1):
Louis Hansen

OT (2):
Giovanni El-Hadi
Garrett Dellinger (4* - ovr: 80) or Tristan Bounds (3* - ovr: #633)

OG (2):
Greg Crippen
Drew Kendall (4* - ovr: #110)

OC (1):
Raheem Anderson

OL/DL ATH (1):
Rocco Spindler (4* - ovr: #44)

RUSH END (1):
Kechaun Bennett

WDE (2):
TJ Guy
Quintin Somerville (4* - ovr: #102)

NG (0):

DT (2):
Rayshaun Benny (4* - ovr: #191)
George Rooks (4* - ovr: #202)

SDE (1):
Dominick Giudice

WLB (1):
Junior Colson

MLB (2):
Casey Phinney
Jaydon Hood

SLB (1):
Tyler McLaurin

VIPER (0):

CB (2):
Ja'Den McBurrows
Ryan Barnes (3* - ovr: #550)

FS (1):
Rod Moore

SS (1):
Donovan McMillon (3* - ovr: #432)

K (0):

P (1):
Tommy Doman

King Tot

May 30th, 2020 at 9:49 AM ^

Michigan is in on a lot of good WRs (Dixon, Anthony, Thomas, Styles, Worthy). Worthy is obviously a top target and it seems Michigan has recruited him the longest/hardest but I have a got feeling this could turn into a Dallas Turner type recruitment.