Jim McElwain on indefinite suspensions: Will last “till it’s resolved.” Not necessarily through the Michigan game.

Submitted by Bambi on

Link

McElwain in a previous statement on the suspenions:

"Action has been taken -- they have missed some practice and will miss the Michigan game."

Link

Looks like McElwain is backtracking hard here to give himself the chance to play Callaway in the opener. If Callaway doesn't miss any game time that's a joke.

Perkis-Size Me

August 18th, 2017 at 2:57 PM ^

Be hopeful that he won't play, but plan like he will. 

In the end, I have a hard time believing that McElwain will re-neg on the suspension. His credibility would take a huge hit, and it would be a BAAAAAAAD PR move for him. Callaway is a repeat offender and has recently committed credit card fraud. Not a lawyer but I assume that's a felony in at least some states. McElwain could try and talk his way out of it all he wanted, but he'd get massacred in the media by anyone not named Paul Finebaum. 

And then think about if he inserted Callaway into the game and they still lost. He couldn't go back to the fans and boosters and say "well hey at least we won!" They'd still be 0-1, and that bad judgment call would still follow him wherever he went. 

Perkis-Size Me

August 18th, 2017 at 5:59 PM ^

But really, only guys like Saban, Meyer and Belichek are in that kind of position. They can be assholes and push the envelope a little bit because they win big. McElwain has won some games but he hasn't won anything big. He's on a much shorter leash than what those other three get. 

I'd like to think McElwain is the kind of guy that will be good to his word in keeping a player suspended. But even if he's not, I'd like to think he'd keep him suspended because if he brings him back, Callaway performs poorly or is a non-factor and they lose, he and his program will never hear the end of it. 

JayMo4

August 18th, 2017 at 2:36 PM ^

If the situation was reversed and Harbaugh was backtracking to let his best player play, it's all ESPN would talk about from now until game time.

jblaze

August 18th, 2017 at 2:47 PM ^

This is poor reporting by SECCountry.

The relevant bullet is:

  • To clarify, the suspension from team activities of the 7 guys lasts “till it’s resolved.” Not necessarily through the Michigan game.

If paired with McElwain's prior statement that the players were "indefinate" this just means they will be back on the team at some point (so before or after the M game, but the reporting doesn't get into that).

NFG

August 18th, 2017 at 3:07 PM ^

My bet is that they're suspended. He's just trying to play mind games with Michigan so we're forced to prepare for either situation. But then again, it is the SEC...

stephenrjking

August 18th, 2017 at 3:21 PM ^

Went to listen to the actual bit to make sure I got it right (recall I was the one asking for sources pretty thoroughly when this was announced). The actual question, if you want to hear it, is at roughly 5:30 of the video.

It was something to the effect of: "The [suspension, including from all team activities], does it go all the way through the Michigan game, or could they be back at practice sooner?" 

McElwain: "No, till it's resolved."

If any of them play in the game, it's garbage. But my existing hypothesis still looks good--he doesn't want Michigan to know that Callaway is out, he wants us to take reps practicing for the possibility that we have to defend him. Reps spent working on Callaway packages are reps not spent on anything else. 

But if Callaway plays, that's pretty junky.

uncle leo

August 18th, 2017 at 3:44 PM ^

Except for the part that "Doesn't want them taking reps for the possibility that he's in the game."

Michigan wouldn't practice any differently knowing this. In fact, if they knew Callaway was in the game, they'd probably practice even harder.

Are "Callaway packages" that much different than "WR 2" packages? I highly doubt that.

stephenrjking

August 18th, 2017 at 5:18 PM ^

If Callaway is their best weapon, Michigan would spend effort preparing to stop him. From film study to gameplanning to reps on the field, there would be a focus. Without Callaway, that focus can be diverted to other areas. 

I don't know exactly how much of a difference it makes, but it makes enough difference that Michigan's coaches and coaches from many other schools try to conceal injury and absence information until the last possible moment.

Blue from Ohio

August 18th, 2017 at 4:56 PM ^

My take exactly.  It'd be really cool if some UM fan going to the game who was savvy with photoshopping / making posters (I'm obviously not) blew up a bunch of those pictures into posters and handed them out to Michigan tailgates before the game to take to the game.  McElwaine's head would probably explode by the end of the game seeing an endless sea of shark humping posters in the crowd.

Steeveebr

August 18th, 2017 at 5:22 PM ^

It's a legal matter not a team or NCAA disciplinary issue, right?  Isn't it pretty normal for coaches to suspend a player from the team until the legal matter is "resolved"?  I think we might be blowing this out of proportion.
 

war-dawg69

August 18th, 2017 at 5:56 PM ^

All it sounds like to me is him saying they could be suspended much longer than the Michigan game. Until it is resolved. He allready suspended them for the Michigan game and they will be out until it is resolved. I highly doubt it is resolved in the next two weeks anyways. Know if this was that complete piece of shit Saban or the completely immoral Freeze well there in. Saban and Freeze are interchangeble as to who is the biggest lowlife in college football. The Baylor coach would be in there, but he resigned. I highly doubt Mcelwain is rescinding the suspensions he just laid out. He would lose a lot of respect and would not have laid out the suspensions in the first place. I am sure there are some coaches in the sec teaching morals and values to there players. Saban and Freeze are on a whole other level and anyone who has any respect for either of those two pieces of dog feces really are on the same level with them.

michfan23

August 18th, 2017 at 6:08 PM ^

I live in Florida and can attest that Gator fans are irrational and don't give two craps about if players are obeying rules or not. I'm sure there are some fans who care, I just haven't met them yet.
I was at the grocery store, wearing my Michigan stuff for no reason other than I love it, and a guy makes a comment about how Michigan is overrated because they don't play in the SEC. A bystander chimes in to say that Michigan is the winningest program in NCAA history. This Florida joker says "that's because they don't play in the SEC". I cared about September 2 before, but now I want to humiliate those clowns.
They don't care if Callaway smokes a doobie in the locker room before the game. They just care about the conference.
Also, can someone actually explain why people in the south root on any SEC team? I hate every B1G team other than Michigan because they aren't Michigan. I don't get the love for the conference thing that all morons in the south have.

Khaleke The Freak

August 18th, 2017 at 7:10 PM ^

Callaway might make it a "respectable" loss but they're getting pummeled on Sept. 2nd. Love how Coach Harbaugh is making the SEC twist in the wind.

Drbogue

August 18th, 2017 at 8:30 PM ^

I think this is an example of the beat writer taking liberties. "Till it's resolved" could easily and more likely mean that if charges are pressed that they could miss much more than the Michigan game. I think the writer is interpreting with hopefully bias.