OT: Diaspora?
Last night and this evening, the Tigers are playing the Pirates at PNC Park, and I've seen A LOT of Tigers gear on people walking through my city the last couple days. It got me thinking.
We Pittsburghers loathe when national TV comments about "how well Steeler fans travel" because most of those fans DIDN'T travel; they live in those cities now as a result of the diaspora (as some of us call it) created by the collapse of the steel industry throughout the 1970s. I'd be a lifelong Pittsburgher if not for my father losing his job as a part of the early 80s economic collapse here causing us to move away for a few years. We Pittsburghers are well represented in the DC area, down through Charlotte, and into Atlanta, across the Sun Belt, and even in Denver.
Before Googling this, I talked with some Tigers fans downtown today and heard a story about father-son ballpark trips before school started, students attending Pitt & Carnegie Mellon, etc, but figured I'd cast a wider net here. Am I seeing the result of some Detroit area/Southeastern Michigan movements as a result of some of Detroit's recent economic issues and the changing economy in Pittsburgh? Am I reading far too much into this? Or was it just that random groups of Michiganders sought a long weekend in Pittsburgh?
(The Red Wings fan base is also represented quite well at Pens games; yours' is one of our favorites to interact with for a myriad of reasons, like the memories of the hard fought 08-09 Cup Finals, your passionate and largely knowledgeable fans, and you're not giant douches like the Flyers fans.)
Colorado was so awesome before everyone moved there. Beaches are kind of a bummer though.
Moved to Texas on my own volition as a young college graduate, however, there seem to be a ton of people from Michigan down here, many I've met who moved after 2008.
I took "Africa and its Diaspora" for my race and ethnicity credit at Mich. Interesting class..totally hammed it up with Manny Harris, DeShawn Sims, Donovan Warren, and Kevin Koger.
Cool story I know.
Pittsburgh is rocking right now. One of my favorite places to go on business.
August 8th, 2017 at 10:04 PM ^
August 8th, 2017 at 10:08 PM ^
August 8th, 2017 at 10:18 PM ^
August 8th, 2017 at 10:21 PM ^
August 8th, 2017 at 10:21 PM ^
August 8th, 2017 at 10:21 PM ^
August 8th, 2017 at 10:24 PM ^
In Canada, I am not sure we recieved a significant number of migrants after the collapose of the steel industry. Yet, my beautiful country is littered with Steeler fans. Along with Dallas and Greenbay, they're one of the classic franchises that have fans everywhere for whatever reason.
August 8th, 2017 at 10:25 PM ^
August 8th, 2017 at 10:42 PM ^
August 8th, 2017 at 10:52 PM ^
August 8th, 2017 at 11:12 PM ^
On a side note, Lightning games against the Red Wings are darn near a 50/50 split. Tampa people get very angry and I've seen some pretty good verbal exchanges and security escort some folks from the arena.
I've probably yelled "Go Blue" at you once or twice down here.
August 8th, 2017 at 11:33 PM ^
I see a lot more people dressed in Michigan caps and shirts than I see from Red Wings, Lions, Tigers or Pistons.
August 8th, 2017 at 11:51 PM ^
August 9th, 2017 at 12:17 AM ^
for one, Detroit to Pittsburgh is a relatively easy and short trip and Pitt's new stadium is a desired location. Detroit and Pittsburgh play every year now and often in a 4 day 2 home, 2 away format. Easty trip to plan
Modern professional sports fandom is much less dependant on geography mostly due to the cable television phenomenon and the oversaturation of games on TV. You can become a fan of just about any team now days without even making a huge finacial commitment to root from a team 800 miles away or more.
Americans move and have moved around more in the last few decades than any time prior to the settling of the "West" probably. You grow up maybe around Detroit you love the Tigers set out on your own and find a job in North Carolina or Pennsylvania or somewhere else but your love for the Tigers doesn't fade and boom you're a Tigers transplant. Again cable television helps solidify ones fandom, you can now live in Pennsylvania and watch every Tigers game if you choose.
I would not doubt you are seeing a lot of former SE Michiganders who've moved on to newer and better things jobs wise. But I think a lot of things are at play here.
And btw, the many Tigers fans in Florida thing isn't new. I remember people talking about all the Tigers fans than ran into down in Florida after moving there in the 80's. Seems many retirees from Michigna chose to live in Florida. Who knew.
Interesting topic personally because I have connections to both Pittsburgh and Ann Arbor so lots of memories. My dad was a professor and he taught at Carnegie Mellon from 1980 to 1986. I was just a little kid but Pittsburgh still holds a certain nostalgia for me even though it was going through a rough time in the 1980s with the 82 recession and massive layoffs. People in Pittsburgh were friendly and our street was a lot more of a community than any other place that I've ever lived. Not sure if that was a product of Pittsburgh, or an older era, or combination of the two, or something else. Good times, or at least that's how I remember it. It seems smaller, older, somewhat neglected whenever I have visited since. I've not been back in a while.
We wound up leaving so my mom could go to grad school at UT in Austin and then transition from a stay at home mom to working now that we were older. Originally we planned to move back to Pittsburgh in 88 but we wound up going to Ann Arbor instead because the job offers were better for my parents. Some randomness to that, but it probably also reflected the weakness of the Pittsburgh economy.
Thus we landed in Ann Arbor where I spent the rest of my youth and then went to U of M from 94 to 99. Sports wise, I definitely considered myself a Steelers, Pirates, Penguins fan and never got into the Detroit teams. Left after college for the West Coast and have lived in Bay Area or Seattle ever since. There are things I miss, like cheap housing lol, friendlier people, the college town vibe. For me leaving Michigan was just a question of needing to move on after college. So in that case, I don't know that the economy played into it really. I suppose it could be a factor in never moving back. But not really, because I just think it would be weird to live in those places again. Thomas Wolfe was right, you can't go home again because that time and those people are gone. Otherwise, I could see objectively how Ann Arbor would be a very nice place to live although I don't think I could ever give up the mountains we have for the Midwest.
Anyway, a few people at an event wearing this or that t-shirt probably is just random. But definitely there is a real trend of the hollowed out Rust Belt refugees dispersing across America to newer more vibrant cities. The data on that long-term trend is pretty clear. And I think most people do still identify with some of those cities. I guess it's been 31 years since I left Pittsburgh and 18 for Ann Arbor but I still think of those as my 3 homes along with Seattle. Those places are forever part of your personal story, even if you move on.
Interesting discussion
Didn't think the thread would evolve into cultural appropriation but I like it
My dad and I try to see a Tigers game in a new ballpark every year, goal is to see them all. We've been to many and PNC is still my favorite (of the newer parks - can't really compare PNC and a Fenway experience though, two different beasts). We were not one of the folks you talked to in Pittsburgh, but I think that is a common quest.
Love the city of Pittsburgh - beautiful geographic location, good sports and yall really know how to eat (Got a sandwich the size of my head at Fathead's Saloon).
August 9th, 2017 at 10:48 AM ^
As a Detroit-area resident, I've made the trip to Pittsburgh to see the Tigers play on the road because the drive isn't that bad and PNC Park is a pretty good place to watch a ballgame.
That said, the idea that Detroit natives are transplanted across the US because of Detroit's / Michigan's recent economic woes is a real thing.
August 9th, 2017 at 11:39 AM ^
I mean, I live in Virginia. I grew up in Flint but left for college and still live within half an hour from my college a few years after graduating. To some, they could look at my situation and say "he left Flint because everyone's leaving Flint and there's more opportunities in Virginia." When in reality, I left Flint because my parents were in Flint and I wanted to get away for college. And then I found a full time job in my field two months after graduating. And then I got married to a local girl. I'd move back to Flint (re: Burton...not actually Flint) in a heartbeat, but now I'm essentially a "Virginian" despite the fact that I still call myself a Michigander and root for/keep track of all 4 detroit teams and UM.
I come from a suburban Detroit family of 7 children. 4 UM grads, 2 UofD & 1 Sparty. At one point one lived in IL, one in NY, one in MS, one in TX, one in OR, and one in Norway. Only one remained in MI. It was a long time ago and mostly driven by the lack of economic opportunities in the Great Lake State.
Personally I was born in Pittsburgh, grew up mostly in Ann Arbor, and now live in Asia by way of California. Consequently am a fan of the Steelers, Pirates, Red Wings, Tigers, (Lions, Pistons and Penns to a lesser degree) but most of all, the University of Michigan.