Jim Harbaugh's Quote Board, Ranked Comment Count

Brian

The intrepid Pardon My Take gents provided a window into the rabbit-on-speed soul of Jim Harbaugh after their interview with him last week, and I have not been able to close this tab.

I have looked at these quotes. I have considered them. There are 25 of them, serendipitously. In the greatest of Harbaugh traditions I now propose to rank them, top to bottom. Then I can close the tab.

#25: Addition By Subtraction

image

PROS: May portend good things about Michigan's offensive line this year?

CONS: Unremarkable phrase frequently said by sane persons. Not a full sentence. Does not make me think deeply about how I can improve as a football player and/or person.

#24: Lead Like Truman

image

PROS: Truman was a nondescript senator chosen to be vice president largely because it wouldn't piss off too many people. He was thrust into leadership towards the end of WWII after FDR's death, and he made some brutal choices. As a "make a decision and go" exemplar there are few better.

CONS: Fred Astaire was really good at tap dancing! It was, in fact, his job to tap dance. Out of this context, telling someone they are like one of the most famous and dexterous movie stars of all time is a compliment. The whole second half of this quote is unnecessary. "Don't dither" would be more accurate and, appropriately, shorter.

#23: Fat Is The Enemy Of Speed

image

PROS: Accurate. Useful advice for tight ends and fullbacks.

CONS: Too straightforward to be profound. Not at all weird.

#22: I shouldn't have to pester or harass you

image

PROS: I mean, yeah. Spelled "harass" correctly, which I can't do on the first try.

CONS: There are a number of fairly-interchangeable scolding help-me-help-you quotes on the list that we're about to knock out in a row.

#21: I'd like to help you

image

PROS: "Now that's important" at the end is kind of weird, right? It sort of feels like you're in a room with your coach and he says something to you and then he starts talking to himself.

CONS: see above

#20: I actually know what I am doing.

image

[ED note: assumption is that the second sentence is "When are you going to figure that out?"]

PROS: Michigan has a football coach who can say this in front of a room full of people without that room bursting into laughter.

CONS: see above

#19: A fundamental prerequisite of high integrity

image

PROS: Well, yeah.

CONS: uppers and lowers are all over the place.

#18: Got where I am by rolling up my sleeves

image

[Editor's note: assumption is that this quote reads "Got where I am by rolling up my sleeves, delegating nothing, taking everything personally"]

PROS: While the delegation part can't be true, the taking everything personally damn sure is. Leaving out the "I" gives the sentence a brusque vigor.

CONS: "Personnally" typo.

#17: Change the "I" to a "E"

image

PROS: Scare quotes. A+ somewhat cheesy motivational quote.

CONS: Cheesy even in the coach motivational quote genre, right?

#16: We can't create, invent, or pioneer

image

PROS: Underline and big bolded INTERESTS provide focus on the meat of a veritable thesis statement. Excellent philosophy to keep moving in front of an ever shifting football wave. Advice literally every politician ever would be better off for taking, except then they'd get voted out of office unless everyone took the same advice.

CONS: Kind of wordy.

#15: My soul is happy wherever my body takes me

image

PROS: Pairs with item later on the list as a general philosophy of being places.

CONS: fills me with an ineffable sadness

#14: Do you usually get what you are asking for?

image

PROS: Second-best thing to say to a child on this list.

CONS: What if they say "yes"?

#13: Transform fear into anger

image

PROS: This is the best way to get rid of fear.

CONS: Stuck in a box with another, clearly separate quote. Not great advice if you find yourself surrounded by sharks.

#12: Solve your problems with aggression

image

PROS: Foundational document of Michigan's #1 defense from a year ago. Indicates that Harbaugh and Don Brown are bros to the quote-board level. Sacks!

CONS: Stuck in a box with clearly separate quote. Hopefully holds up with young safeties.

#11: HARBAUGH PYRAMID OF GREATNESS

image

PROS: Might say "TEAR GAS, ACCOUNTANTS, CONDIMENT, CONFLICT, TRUST." Is a Pyramid of Greatness. Explicitly states that conflict is aspired to within the program.

CONS: Might say "TEAM GOALS, ACCOUNTABILITY, COMMMITMENT, CONFLICT, TRUST." Which is fine, I guess.

#10: Don't make somebody a priority

image

PROS: Works equally well as romantic or crootin advice. Pithy. Kind of sounds like something Oprah would say.

CONS: Kind of sounds like something Oprah would say?

#9: Insecurity explains most of life's failures

 image

PROS: Probably the most correct thing on this list.

CONS: The letters  i and e appear in this sentence as both upper- and lowercase in the middle of words. There are two words with all uppercase I/E, one with an uppercase E and lower i, one that is all lowercase. It makes me think I am going crazy.

#8: What ifs

image

PROS: There is a 100% chance I say this to my soon-to-be-verbal child over and over again until he stabs me with a fork.

CONS: Got stabbed with a fork.

#7: Attack each day

image

PROS: Harbaugh classic that would be on the family coat of arms if such a thing existed. Unparalleled single-sentence description of Jim.

CONS: Lack of novelty somewhat dulls its impact here.

#6: Preaching to the choir

image

PROS: Single sentence deconstruction of the problems with political discourse in an age of disaggregation. Brutal ethering of entirety of twitter.

CONS: Could be directed at me?

#5: If you are bored you are boring

image

PROS: Man, you ever been on vacation and just been bored out of your mind and then gotten home and regretted that you did not take better advantage of the time given you in this unusual place? You ever been on a vacation not like that? I haven't.

CONS: Definitely directed at me.

#4: FOIA BURN

image

PROS: Yooooooooooooo. This is a vicious Dave Brandon burn that gets even more vicious if it's unintentional.

CONS: I can't figure out how to inject this into my soul

#3: Oh… that's as helpful as you get

image

PROS: If someone you loved said this to you in a high leverage moment you would curl up and die. The sheer quantity of venom in this single sentence is at "bless your heart" levels. Devastating weapon to be deployed sparingly, lest it shatter its target irreparably.

CONS: Needs a comma after "get."

#2: Aint hard being a football player

image

PROS: The coachiest of coach quotes. Nonsensical tautology with scare quotes around key phrase. Still makes sense, in its way. Sounds like the kind of thing old players at reunions groan in unison about. Good "aint" deployment.

CONS: N/A

#1: Who's got it better than us?

image

PROS: Hearing this out loud for the first time was a revelation. In an era when football is veritably haunted by the specter of the damage waiting down the road, it is a simple, joyous exclamation. Football has costs. Jim Harbaugh proposes that they are worth it, to be here in this locker room with your teammates, fists aloft.

CONS: N/A

Comments

yossarians tree

June 1st, 2017 at 1:33 PM ^

This is evidence as to why Harbaugh should be a college coach. College players, particularly brighter college players that we tend to recruit, will find the Harbaugh philosophy funny, arresting, quirky. Men who play pro football will probably tune it out in short order. As an English major I would not characterize these quotes as particularly eloquent, but they can be effective because they are just odd enough. They are:

1 part G.R.I.T.

1 part sugar-coated molasses

1 part reality extract

1 part Hunter S. Thompson on ether

Everyone Murders

May 30th, 2017 at 6:39 PM ^

I never got the "if you're bored you're boring" bit.

If I'm forced to watch Andy Warhol's Sleep, I'm pretty much certainly going to get bored.  How is that on me?

Now if I choose to watch Sleep and complain of being bored, that's on me.  But event then, I'm not sure that makes me boring.  It just means I made a bad decision, and don't know that I should shut up about that.

Can someone help a brother out on this one?

MGoStrength

May 30th, 2017 at 8:34 PM ^

He is so unique, unless you're considering his dad, in the world.  I am so glad he is our coach. Plus, he gives me lots of quotes to steal and give to my students...I love me some quotes.

Yost Ghost

May 31st, 2017 at 11:34 AM ^

#24 Brian may be missing the point on this one. Yes Fred Astaire was good at tap dancing, the point is you don't want to be that good when a decision needs to be made. Truman didn't put his tap shoes on.

alnigoblue

May 31st, 2017 at 10:37 AM ^

This is unexpectedly great content for this time of year.  I know it ruins the nice tidy 25 number, but there's one more, near the bottom right: "I've been known to come through on occasion"

Rufus X

May 31st, 2017 at 10:42 AM ^

Located in lower right portion of the board.  And it's pretty good - 

"I've been known to come through on occasion"

It belongs somewhere in the #8 to #13 range, IMO.  

Chris S

May 31st, 2017 at 12:05 PM ^

"Fat is the enemy of speed" - at some point Harbaugh looked at someone and this is the first thing that went through his head. I find that hilarious.

Sgt. Wolverine

May 31st, 2017 at 12:47 PM ^

"Preaching to the choir" quote might be from the tv show Blue Bloods, which he's known to be a fan of. (As used in the show it said "sissies," not "the soft.")

There's another example of his using a Blue Bloods quote in this article.

TheCool

May 31st, 2017 at 2:54 PM ^

Isn't tap dancing often used in reference to someone avoiding consequences, responsibilities, answering a question, etc. I think that is what was being referenced in the Fred Astair quote.

ahw1982

June 1st, 2017 at 5:08 PM ^

#10 - "Don't make somebody a priority who treats you like an option."

Loss to Air Force Week 3 confirmed.  Did not treat Air Force as a priority.