NFL Freaks and Greatest Players! Who's your pick?

Submitted by NY-Wolverine3599 on
I recently got into to it with another fellow poster about their view on the NFL. They thought it was "amazingly boring". I can remember the day Lawrence Taylor broke Joe Theismann's leg as a kid, as well as winning the super bowl for my beloved New York Giants. He was by far a freak athlete, GOAT, my favorite player growing up and was definitely not boring. Who you got!? And please, we all know TB12 is on everybody's list, so pick someone else.

MGoStu

April 6th, 2017 at 11:02 AM ^

Dude was badass. Unfortunately, what I remember most about him was blowing out his knee trying to mirror a Barry Sanders change of direction. Really surprised that didn't happen to more people.

drjaws

April 6th, 2017 at 10:44 AM ^

football player of all time is Charles Woodson.  Favorite NFL player of all time is Barry Sanders.  Greatest RB to ever play the game.  In 10 years, he did what it took most normal humans 15 - 20 years, with a way worse OL and coaching staff.

 

Freaks? 

Bo Knows (he could have gone pro in just about any sport he wanted)

Ronnie Lott.

Mike Vick.  Yea yea, the dog thing was bad.  But in his prime had one of the greatest QB skillsets.  A RB with a cannon arm.

Mean Joe Greene was a fave of mine too.  Watch film of him in college at North Texas.  It's like Taco Charlton playing high school kids.

xtramelanin

April 6th, 2017 at 10:48 AM ^

Barry already adequately described above. Calvin = Freak...6'5", 235, 4.37 40. Had he played on a real team he'd be in everybody's list

Grampy

April 6th, 2017 at 10:48 AM ^

That would be Deacon Jones, a DE for the L.A. Rams in the '60s and '70s.  He coined the phrase "sacking the quarterback", in which he was equating it to putting the quarterback in a burlap sack and then beating it with a baseball bat.  From the 1964 season through the 1968 season, he had over 100 sacks.  In 14 game seasons, no less.

Jimmyisgod

April 6th, 2017 at 11:12 AM ^

Physical freaks:  

Megatron- 6-5, 240 lbs, ran a 4.33 forty, ran a 10.19 100 meters in college.  42" vertical.

Christian Okoye- The Nigerian nightmare ran a 4.4 forty at almost 260 lbs.

Bo Jackson-  Enough has been said, just a beast, he was a faster, bigger, and stronger version of AD.

Barry Sanders- People discount what a freak he was, might not have had the best top end speed (still ran a 4.4), but his acceleration between 0-5 yards when he saw a seem was not human.  No one in the history of football could accelerate like Barry Sanders.   It's what made his stop and starts so devastating, the defender would stop with him and they couldn't get back up to speed like Sanders and had no chance to tackle him.  He would brain freeze guys every game, and by this I mean put a move on a guy in open space so sick that the defender's brain would short circuit and their body would literally freeze for an insant and they'd fall over, like when a goat gets scared and faints.

Willis

April 6th, 2017 at 11:21 AM ^

Barry, Bo, and Calvin are great and obvious choices. I didn't go through every comment, but a guy I didn't notice listed was Derrick Thomas, absolute freak of a pass rusher.

OwenGoBlue

April 6th, 2017 at 11:42 AM ^

May have ended up the greatest strong safety ever if not for a tragic home robbery. 

Dude was a 230 lb violent monster in run support and absolutely dynamic in coverage. High school and college players still talk about him, which is crazy given his short career and the fact he passed 10 years ago so they wouldn't have had much of a chance to see him play. 

Also overlapped with Ed Reed (the greatest free safety I've ever seen) for a season in the Hurricanes secondary. Man those teams were stacked. 

SC Wolverine

April 6th, 2017 at 12:18 PM ^

SInce Bo Jackson is already taken, let's not forget the Juice.  Those of us old enough to have watched football in the 70s remember what a freak of nature he was.  OJ was incredible.  (Of course, I hated him for being from USC).

xtramelanin

April 6th, 2017 at 12:34 PM ^

and i won't give him any.  i'm probably one of the few people oon this list to have met him a number of times, all pre-murder.    besides, though i acknowledge he was a very good back, he doesn't make my top 10. 

m1jjb00

April 6th, 2017 at 12:55 PM ^

Bo Jackson -- tore his leg out of his hip socket, which doctors didn't diagnose right away b/c they just assumed it was impossible.

LT -- as already said.

Earl Campbell -- Light on his feet, reasonably fast, and unbelievably huge.  Try to tackle him at his thighs and you were unconscious.

 

Perkis-Size Me

April 6th, 2017 at 12:57 PM ^

Bo Jackson and Calvin Johnson immediately come to mind. But someone else who comes to mind is Warren Sapp. The guy had a gut on him that never seemed to go away, and he's a pretty awful human being, but my god that man could play. A man as big as he was should not have been able to move the way he did. He was fast, violent, disruptive, and a QB's worst nightmare. 

Grew up watching him in Tampa. Seemed like an entire offensive line could take him on and he would still break through on a consistent basis. Couple that with how good their whole defense was back in the day, and it made him even more lethal. 

RTPBob

April 6th, 2017 at 1:25 PM ^

Of those I've see: Barry Sanders

Of those I haven't seen: Jim Thorpe

Without Thorpe, there probably would not have been an NFL.  That's why his picture was on the NFL logo used for all televised games up until a year or two ago.

JFW

April 6th, 2017 at 3:25 PM ^

and UM tickets in my youth. 

For the greatest RB, at least that I've ever seen, I have to GTBTB. 

I still love watching his highlights. 

 

JFW

April 6th, 2017 at 3:35 PM ^

but I always give honorable mention to Spielman for maximizing his talent; and for being an old school LB. 

I remember one game against the cowboys that the Lions won. The Cowboys were close to the goal line and Emmit hit the los and jumped. Spielman reacted and jumped at the same time. Spielman stoned him. I always loved watching him. I'd count how many times he'd be the last guy up from a pile. 

Couple that with his story of support for his wife, and he's one of my favorite FB players ever, despite his unfortunate college choice. ;-)

Sam1863

April 6th, 2017 at 9:02 PM ^

As both a UM and Detroit Lion fan, I had to do an emotional 180 on Spielman when he ended up in Detroit. Still, it was impossible not to appreciate the effort he put into his play.

I remember one game, he either grabbed an interception or recovered a fumble (don't remember which), lumbered into the end zone, and spiked the ball with both hands. Just fell to his knees and slammed it into the turf so hard I thought it would deflate. An old school spike by the ultimate old school player.

I hated his guts as a Buckeye, but he would've looked great in maize & blue.