LostOnNorth

July 12th, 2016 at 8:31 PM ^

i make ~70% more in CA than i would for the same job in michigan, however getting married to someone who also makes money is basically a necessity if you ever want to buy. Entry level houses in an undesirable area are 650k if it's safe, 400k if you're willing to risk being robbed

MAccLA

July 12th, 2016 at 8:55 PM ^

Salaries don't fully offset the COLA. Many rent instead of buying (especially now when the cost of renting is less than cost of owning). Those with family here in SoCal find ways to leverage that benefit to the fullest before buying a home (i.e. living rent free with parents). Plus, there are few single-income households (wife pretty much has to work). Lastly, luck and timing often plays a role.

Personally, my wife and I just flat out got lucky. We moved out to SoCal in 2008, then the Great Recession hit and the housing market collapsed. We bought a 3bed/1bath $300k home in Claremont with FHA first time homebuyer financing (2.5% down) and we qualified for an $8k federal tax credit (which we were able to obtain quickly after closing by amending our prior year tax return). So all in, even got into our home with basically $2,500.

Now, we are hoping to sell for about $525k, realize a nice gain and take the cash back to Michigan for a much larger home as we consider expanding the family and getting closer to my wife's family. So this discussion is very relevant for us. We were leaning towards Birmingham in part because of the differential commute times to Downtown Detroit (where I will be working). The nice thing is I can get a transfer pretty easily and I should be able to keep my same pay, although I may not get as large of a raise this year.

bronxblue

July 13th, 2016 at 2:12 PM ^

It's the same in NYC, and really in major metro areas along the coasts.  And the pay isn't that much higher.  Sure, it's higher than in MI, but most people struggle to find affordable housing that is anywhere close to work.  There's a reason the train lines go out super-far/commutes are super-long in CA and elsewhere.  We had a friend recently buy a 3 bedroom, 2 bath house in an okay part of the Bronx for $750k, and they had to put a bunch of cash down and limited options to examine the property before the sale.  It's how it is.

 

coldnjl

July 12th, 2016 at 6:29 PM ^

Lived in Ann Arbor for 10 years (BS and grad school) and would never move back. Abismal traffic (fed from horrible road repair), poor snow removal, etc. I love living out in Birmingham, Berkely, Royal Oak, and Ferndale area. Alot to do and Midtown/downtown Detroit just 20 minutes away. Ann Arbor is one of my favorite places to visit, but no more extended stays for me

True Blue Grit

July 12th, 2016 at 6:49 PM ^

Are you comparing Ann Arbor traffic to the northern burbs?  The Detroit suburbs are plagued with heavy traffic, certainly no worse than Ann Arbor.  And bad road repair is just as bad in Oakland County, if due to nothing else other than the higher traffic there.  I have to agree however with your snow removal comment.  That's true.  The AA City Council has funnelled funds away from that for years - probaby to tacky public art. 

coldnjl

July 12th, 2016 at 7:57 PM ^

There are only so many arteries out of Ann Arbor due to geography (i.e Huron and the freeway system). For instance, 14 is closed through the summer...If you want to leave Ann Arbor via 23 North or 14 East, you need to take either Plymouth or Main. Good luck with that. At least in the burbs, you aren't dramatically limited during peak traffic hours. 94 around State street is too small and have chronic backups, there are 3 exits to the east of Ann Arbor and essentially 2 to the south. Every summer, road construction either severly constricts or shuts down traffic. Pain. 

But furthermore, I love the burbs because their are attractions everywhere...once you burn through the Ann Arbor beer/restaurant scene, there isn't much left.

bringthewood

July 13th, 2016 at 3:38 PM ^

Beating Ann Arbor traffic is often based upon your knowledge of side streets. I was raised in A2 and my father had a business that delivered to residents. I filled in from time to time as a driver and got to know the city pretty well, but my Dad who had lived there 70 years knew every street.

I am in and out of Ann Arbor on football Saturday quickly. The key? Do not use Main, Stadium or the expressways. Now with 23 construction even the side streets will be jammed.

I communted to downdown Ann Arbor - near City Hall for a couple of years and also the Domino's complex north of town. Heck of alot easier getting in and out of Ann Arbor than Birmingham, Southfield or Troy - where every surface street is backed up.

Hab

July 13th, 2016 at 9:37 AM ^

The expressways around AA are really inefficient.  Funneling the north/south traffic along 23 begs for unnecessary slowdowns.  In the city, you struggle with the usual problems of a growing city over older roads and patterns.  It's not the worst, but it certainly isn't sufficient to adequately deal with the volume of traffic the University brings in.

That said, it's certainly no Seattle or Atlanta.

uncleFred

July 12th, 2016 at 7:51 PM ^

but it's far from the "best" place to live in the state. The towns on the lakes are far superior. Ann Arbor is a great college town and I can't think of a better one, but the quality of life along Michigan's great lakes put any inland town in second place.

Wolfman

July 12th, 2016 at 8:57 PM ^

but being from the w. side, Muskegon, I wasn't surprised and completely agree with the east side, especially AA, dominating the ratings. I thought Grand Haven/Spring Lake would be the first w. side area to break in, but like I said, never been to St. Joe, so I don't know what if has to offer that would make it better than Grand Haven. 

Now when they got to the Muskegon area, i think they were just guessing. JMO, but I think N. Muskegon is a lot nicer area to live in than Shores, although both are nice. It's obvious they weren't taking off for the arrogance factor, hence AA, but the small area of town is E. GR wealthy, so I could see it getting knocked down a bit for that. There are two school systems in N. Muskegon, one the larger, economically mixed Reeths-Puffer and the quite wealthy N. Muskegon district. And there is a definite difference in attitude. We never made friends with those arrogant asses until we became young adults and my son once got pulled over for going 27 in a 25. But, once you get to know the people - that's the key - it is one hell of a nice, small town. 

FieldingBLUE

July 13th, 2016 at 12:11 AM ^

I live there (well BH). It's great except for summer when it's overrun by tourists. Give me the north of Michigan. St. Joseph's second best attraction other than the lake is its proximity to GR, Chicago, Kzoo and South Bend. Not a ringing endorsement. South Haven and Saugatuck both better than SJ.



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

MGoLaw16

July 12th, 2016 at 9:32 PM ^

I don't think the towns on the lake are clearly better. I lived in the Grand Haven/Spring Lake area for a very long time, and I've lived in Ann Arbor for what is approaching 10 years. The beach towns on Lake Michigan are absolutely fantastic during the summer, but completely dead (and rather boring) during winter. GR is the only place on the west side that can rival Ann Arbor, in my opinion.



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

bringthewood

July 13th, 2016 at 3:59 PM ^

I am currently living on the shores of Lake Michigan south of Frankfort and have owned this place for 20 years. I also lived in Ann Arbor for 20 years and in the Milford area for a long time. Summer is great on the lake as I have a work from home job. I could live here 6-9 months a year easy. But for a year round location I would choose A2 because of the variety of stuff to do. Outside TC and maybe Petoskey not much happens Up North in the winter.

But the Ann Arbor property taxes are the killer besides the cost of housing.

Hoping to retire with my place in the north and Ann Arbor if I can swing the cost.

SlickNick

July 12th, 2016 at 8:46 PM ^

Serious question.... What other cities in the area would people recommend living in? I am considering a move from da U.P. to the Ann Arbor area....as AA can be a bit pricey, does anyone have suggestions on nice areas that would be a little more affordable

Bo4President

July 12th, 2016 at 8:49 PM ^

I lived in the East Coast, matter of fact right on the Atlantic Ocean in Hampton Beach, NH. I enjoyed the ocean and miss it greatly! I had mountains one hour north of me. It was a beautiful state.

But factoring in everything I would pick Michigan every time.

After leaving the Midwest and Michigan you don't know what you have till you leave.



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

cincygoblue

July 12th, 2016 at 9:13 PM ^

Anyone ever been to Erie, PA?

I know it's not Michigan but it's right on lake, I got a job offer and it would be a HUGE step for my career. Would be a 2-3 year stop.



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad