MichAtl85

September 9th, 2021 at 10:42 AM ^

Really glad he’s having success. UCLA looks pretty good on Offense and Defense. I like their “sissy” blue uniform. I’ve always thought it look sharp used to play them in NCAA. 
 

Also really like our backfield. 

Bohannon

September 9th, 2021 at 10:49 AM ^

Happy that Zach is finding success at UCLA. 

Zach will likely continue to find success at UCLA as the season progresses, barring injury. 

UCLA might end up having a good season for the first time in years. 

 

Perhaps consider celebrating this on a UCLA message board going forward. 

1989 UM GRAD

September 9th, 2021 at 11:04 AM ^

How many more Zach Charbonnet posts are we going to have to endure?

Because the subtext of each one is a criticism of Jim Harbaugh and/or the rest of the coaching staff.

Players transfer.  It happens...for a variety of reasons.  And while Michigan has had maybe a larger-than-average number of transfers over the past five years, the fact is that the vast majority transfer because of the lack of playing time...and end up at smaller schools and/or less successful programs.  

We have a stacked RB room.  Let it go.  Let it go.  Let it goooooo.  

robpollard

September 9th, 2021 at 11:25 AM ^

I totally agree. We literally have people in some threads wringing their hands about Blake Corum not getting enough touches, and perhaps needing to take them from Hassan Haskins.

Hassan Haskins is really good, averaging 5.5 yards a carry and gets tough yards. He starts for a reason.

Additionally, Donovan Edwards looks exactly like we thought he was -- hard-running, violent RB with speed.

And we're supposed to have room for Charbonnet? He's good, particularly at the second level. But there's only one football, and he was wise to go to UCLA so he could see it more.

Enough of these posts.

reshp1

September 9th, 2021 at 11:06 AM ^

He looks like a completely different player this year. Injuries must have hobbled him during his time here more than we knew.

I'm happy he's doing well and happy with our RBs, but it frustrating how uneven Michigan recruiting has been at times where we have a log jam of talent at one position but a five alarm fire at others. 

bronxblue

September 9th, 2021 at 11:35 AM ^

I'm happy for Charbonnet but it's pretty clear he'd be fighting for carries at UM so it was a smart move to head out.

I would also add that LSU's defense looked...rough in this game.  There may not be a ton of tough defenses in the Pac-12 so it may not matter but LSU definitely feels like a team under Orgeron that is going to be mediocre on defense despite having great talent.  Like, they were 124th last year in total defense and while they'll be better this year because they were absurdly inexperienced last year (almost as inexperienced as UM), they looked like the same poor-tackling team I saw last year.

kehnonymous

September 9th, 2021 at 11:42 AM ^

Several years ago, I met a lady at my college roommate's wedding who I was really sweet on, but it didn't work out largely because of loving in different states.  However she met someone a few years ago and married him and I'm really happy for her and I am gonna make an MGoThread about it if it's not too OT

Red is Blue

September 9th, 2021 at 6:58 PM ^

I met a lady at my college roommate's wedding who I was really sweet on

I'm confused.  Were you sweet on the wedding, the college roommate or the lady you met?

it didn't work out largely because of loving in different states

Sounds promiscuous.  Perhaps if you had kept your "loving" confined to one state?

Teddy Bonkers

September 9th, 2021 at 11:55 AM ^

Personally I'm a fan of hearing how the transfers are doing, so long as Michigan is winning. So long as the QBs and RBs we retained are kicking butt, it's nice to hear those who transfered out are doing well, unless they've bad mouthed Michigan. 

DetroitBlue

September 9th, 2021 at 11:58 AM ^

I’m glad he’s having success. I’d also prefer the combination of Haskins/Corum/Edwards to having those 3 plus Charbonnet. This is one of those win/win situations. 

Durham Blue

September 9th, 2021 at 12:17 PM ^

Charbonnet projected to be a very good collegiate running back.  Unfortunately things didn't materialize for him at Michigan.  I am not surprised that he appears to be taking his game to the next level now at UCLA.

BlueMk1690

September 9th, 2021 at 12:26 PM ^

I'm sure he will eventually have a bad game and all the folks who don't wanna hear about Charbonnet will be sure to let us know about it. ;)

Honestly, transfers happen all the time and it's pointless to obsess about it. But I think with Charbonnet (and with McCaffrey too), it's a simple trust issue. If you trust your coaching staff, you figure there must have been good reasons for why things happened the way they did, and you move on. If you don't trust them, well that becomes a little harder, so these transfers have to some extent become symbolic for the staff's judgment.

As with everything else, success will be the ultimate indicator though. If Michigan wins 10 games then all that will be forgotten including Charbonnet. But if we go 7-6 or something, and Charbonnet has a good season at UCLA then, fairly or unfairly, it will be seen as another nail in the coffin of the current coaching regime.

 

LDNfan

September 9th, 2021 at 4:14 PM ^

Its silly to pin transfers on coaches when no one knows anything about the circumstances. These are young men and in ZC case he was far, far from home during a once-in-a-lifetime (so far :)  ) global event that made everything in life harder. So one can assume anything..and yeah the coach haters are going to put everything neg on the coaches...but to me its just noise..unless someone brings credible info to the table. 

schizontastic

September 9th, 2021 at 1:51 PM ^

Absolutely, the era of stockpiling talent is over, except for a couple teams (like Alabama, OSU) where the RB might wait for their feature year in a National Championship run.

But even in that scenario, Corum, Edwards may develop to the point where it is clear even a successful-at-UCLA level ZC wouldn't be RB#1 next year, so would end up transferring anyway.