Grantland: Dear Jim Harbaugh: Just Go to Michigan

Submitted by mgoblue99 on

New article from Grantland.com regarding the Harbaugh situation (apologies if that has been posted already; I searched and did not see that it had been):

 

From the article: "What amount of money makes life in the NFL worth it? He can go to Ann Arbor tomorrow and be a king."

 

http://grantland.com/the-triangle/dear-jim-harbaugh-just-go-to-michigan/

Billy Ray Valentine

December 17th, 2014 at 12:43 PM ^

 

Harbaugh’s not well liked where he is. Staying in the NFL, with the Niners or another team, just means he’ll face the same pressure every year, along with a constant wave of new challenges that come with fighting to stay dominant in the parity era — juggling cap numbers with a front office every spring, and micromanaging adults who don’t want their lives micromanaged.

 

Thanks OP for posting.  Good read.  This is one of the few pieces I've read that adeptly argues against the maxim that NFL Head Coaching is the end-all-be-all, especially when ones considers the personlaity type of our former All-American QB.

Blue In NC

December 17th, 2014 at 12:44 PM ^

At this point, I am not sure even Harbaugh can live up to our expectations.  It's like everyone assumes he will come, we will have the #1 ranked recruiting class, every starter will be a #1 pick and Michigan will win the national championship (Obvs).  Michigan does have a few holes in its roster let's not forget.

But it it's not him, there is going to be a huge letdown.

Jmilan

December 17th, 2014 at 12:54 PM ^

I see what you are saying about some peoples ridiculous expectations but he is a proven winner. We as fans need to realize that the process may be longer than expected. First he has to develop the talent that is already at Michigan, while simultaneously recruiting developable talent. This doesn't mean all 5 stars necessarily. Then we need to see the team play well, especially against rivals. I can live with a 9-10 win season if the team looks consistent and improves each week. While I would love for Michigan to thrash msu and osu every year that's just not realistic. Beat one or both of those on a consistent basis and we are in business. The rest will fall in line accordingly if this can happen. I can even stomach a loss to a top tier team if the game is managed well and the players are executing. There are just some times that a team is just better on a given day, it just happens. It's a tall order but my opinion is that he is the best option for Michigan and of all the other potential candidates he is the better fit.

DonAZ

December 17th, 2014 at 1:18 PM ^

I've been thinking about the expecations thing for the last few days. 

I have very little doubt Harbaugh will bring an immediate renewal of focus and intensity to the football program.

Consistent 9+ win seasons is the floor for a program like Michigan.  I think Harbaugh can achieve that.

The issue is getting to the next level -- which is where Urban Meyer is, which is where Nick Saban is.  That takes:

  1. Effective identification of talent and effective recruiting
  2. Effective development of talent
  3. Effective utilization of talent

As I look at that list, I'm struck by how Hoke (sadly) failed at #2 and #3. Meyer and Saban seem to hit on all cylinders.  Harbaugh's time at Stanford suggests he's capable of all three cylinders firing as well.

not TOM BRADY

December 17th, 2014 at 12:51 PM ^

Did anyone see what Kawakami said about Harbaugh? Someone asked him why he's so confident about Harbaugh to the raiders. His reply was basically that he wouldn't say confident and that it just makes sense.
Media knows nothing.

mgowill

December 17th, 2014 at 12:47 PM ^

Now that's a money quote.  Great article and what he envisions for a Harbaugh led Michigan are within the realm of reality.  

As an aside, 49ers players should be glad he is willing to be their alarm clock.  Just ask Jonas Gray if he would like to play for someone willing to be his alarm clock.

Moonlight Graham

December 17th, 2014 at 1:59 PM ^

to the Super Bowl as Jim has. However if you continue that thought, if JH goes to the Raiders or Dolphins he will be starting over with talent comparable to what Saban started with in Miami. Harbaugh inherited a pretty good roster in SF, and he would get a decent roster that is only a couple ticks worse in Miami. Oakland, on the other hand, would be a total rebuild. 

If Saban had inherited a more serviceable roster in Miami, he may have gone to an AFCCG once or twice and kept the NFL itch instead of bailing out into a feeling of "I'm not right for the pros" while the Alabama job conveniently came open.  

Go Blue in MN

December 17th, 2014 at 12:50 PM ^

I didn't think it was possible for me to want Harbaugh to come to AA any more that I already did, but after reading this article . . . whoa, Nellie.  That sounds like a hell of a college coach to me.  Pair his player development and motivational talents with our recruting and look out.

It seems clear that Hackett is willing to do what it takes.  Now JH just needs to make up his mind (or maybe he already has, if the favorable internet chatter is true).  Are the stars actually aligning in our favor for a change?  Please??  If I whine louder will it help?  

taistreetsmyhero

December 17th, 2014 at 12:51 PM ^

“My opponent is going to have to die. But does he have to kill me too? He is killing me. But he has a right to. I have never seen a greater opponent than him. I do not care who kills who now.”

I feel like that article was written by Brian's mainstream counterpart.

"It’s like a pep talk ghostwritten by Ra’s al Ghul."

Kalamazoo Blue

December 17th, 2014 at 12:54 PM ^

I wonder how many other college football fans are hoping Harbaugh comes to Michigan?

I've seen writers on teams from other conferences opine that they hope Michigan returns to being consistently good. Having big games played in the Big House for all marbles is good for the game in general.

Dubs

December 17th, 2014 at 12:57 PM ^

 “My opponent is going to have to die. But does he have to kill me too? He is killing me. But he has a right to. I have never seen a greater opponent than him. I do not care who kills who now.”

 

My wife wants our house littered with little quotes on the walls in different rooms.  I am going to fight like hell to get this one up...perferably in the bathroom.

alum96

December 17th, 2014 at 1:35 PM ^

I liked this one better

“I will be your alarm clock and wake you early,” he said. “It can be a great temptation to rest on the field and let the opponent have a play without making him pay for every inch. I must hold his pain where it is. Mine does not matter … The punishment I inflict, his fatigue, and that he is up against something that he does not comprehend is everything.”

Unicycle Firefly

December 17th, 2014 at 12:57 PM ^

Another good profile of Harbaugh's college coaching methods can be found in the little-known book "Rags to Roses" about the rise of Stanford football.  Bottom line, the guy is every bit as intense and incredibly asshole-ish as he comes across in the Grantland article, but he clearly has an incredible ability to motivate and develop players and cares about his players on a deep personal level.  We hit the jackpot if he comes to Ann Arbor.

uminks

December 17th, 2014 at 1:05 PM ^

If not, then he's agreed with a trade the 49ers will propose to another NFL team. So,  until 12/30 I remain quite optimistic. If this goes into the the New Year with no Harbuagh, then I will be hoping for a good plan B coach.

charblue.

December 17th, 2014 at 1:07 PM ^

writer and the evidence he lays out for Harbaugh's return. Quite honestly, I don't think Harbaugh really wants to come back to college, and I think the very challenges that he faces with teams that clash with him over his dorky micromanagement of detail and motivation, are not really big concerns to him. He doesn't want to be loved, he just wants to win, on every down. I mean this is one obsessive guy. He needs to win on the highest level to feel -- whatever you feel when you reach the highest point on any mountaintop -- then look down and see how far you've come. And then you realize you still want to make that climb again.

He might fit better in the Ann Arbor setting and with college kids who will long remember his tutelage than pro players simply looking to get ahead and then get out with some career success behind them whether they reach a SB or not and no crippling injuries brought on in part by a gung-ho guy whose only real mantra is win the game by adopting some Asian warrior indoctrination requiring 24/7 alert status to enemy mirroring. College kids can dig that, pro players not so much, especially in the fourth season of an SB or bust tour. And now things are bust in SF and its decision time.

And I just don't get the sense he really wants to come back and fight at this level. If Bo were alive, no question he'd be right back. But now, who knows? The fire burns bright but you either accept the idea that winning is a matter of football perception, and that changing lifestyles and circumstances is worth uprooting family and professional career goals, or you just want to bury those who you weren't good enough.

I can see him making the leap back, and I can also see him deciding that, and then deciding it's not what he really wants to do -- at the last minute. We will never know the push-pull of this decision, unless he chooses to stay in the Bay Area where he's only produced near-champions. At Michigan, he would be the comeback King if he returns.

So, here's to him returning. We just need to feel good again.

 

 

DrewGOBLUE

December 17th, 2014 at 2:06 PM ^

Harbaugh must at least realize there likely won't be another opportunity in which the timing works out this well to take the reigns at Michigan. So it seems like a pretty logical decision would be to come back to Ann Arbor for the foreseeable future, while bearing in mind that the NFL will always be there. That way he can be the guy to get Michigan Football back on track, potentially win a NC at the college level, and if after 7-8 years or so he still can't resist the thought of winning a SuperBowl, maybe give the NFL another shot.