umbig11

June 2nd, 2021 at 7:43 PM ^

No way! Just not possible that someone would like to leave the 6th place in the east Wolverines. Right, Dick Snow? :)

What's the count? 18?

Qmatic

June 2nd, 2021 at 8:00 PM ^

He was a cool dude when I met him in Bloomington in 2015, that’s when he told me about JOK. That’s why he was legit when the Speight news broke. We were always cool on here, until he replied to me with his burner account and was outed by the board; now he’s always an ass to everything I post.

KentuckianaWolverine

June 2nd, 2021 at 8:43 PM ^

A couple of things.

1.  I'm pretty sure we had a scholarship count issue, and needed someone to leave....if we had any chance to sign Toia.

2.  The transfer portal is not just a Michigan thing.  It's also not some sort of indicator of failure.  Oklahoma has had 18 players enter the transfer portal, since the end of last season.  Oklahoma is one of the top 5 programs in the country.  Are you going to sit there and proclaim them as a failure, and players are rushing away from a "doomed program"?  Let's just stop with all the comments declaring the transfers as some sort of "proof" to validate your negativity.

MJ14

June 2nd, 2021 at 9:00 PM ^

The average transfer count at SEC schools right now is 12. Michigan has 6 walk-ons in the portal. Most other schools have scholarship players who were recruited to start in the portal. So yes Michigan is at 18, but 6 are walk-ons. So 12 are scholarship athletes. Right in line with where the average SEC team is. As noted above Oklahoma had 18. Clemson has double digit transfers. Michigan is looking to bring in a transfer as well. Plus you always expect some guys to not fit in a new scheme/defense. So it’s not surprising that Michigan has lost some defenders this year. 

Sam1863

June 3rd, 2021 at 7:03 AM ^

When it happens to other schools, it's normal attrition in a COVID year. But when it happens to Michigan, it's a sign of the coming apocalypse, with Harbaugh mounted on a fire-breathing steed next to the Four Horsemen, flying over the charred remains of Ann Arbor.

That's according to the Book of Rainer Sabin, Doomsayer.

HenneGivenSunday

June 2nd, 2021 at 9:04 PM ^

Ahhhh, here you are again.  How did I know you would be here?  
 

Actually, why are you still here?  It’s getting a little pathetic by now.  You don’t bring anything of value at all.  Anything you’ve brought here over the last several years is stuff someone could have gotten from any one of the pay sites or Twitter.  I guess this makes you feel like a big man?  Idk.. just sad really.  
 

I can’t say I’m sure at all why you’re still here while others who have done far less have been banned.  

matt1114

June 2nd, 2021 at 9:06 PM ^

Here are the transfers.

Ramsey Baty - let's face it, you've never heard of him

Jordan Anthony - LB - Did he play?

Kyle McNamara - WR - Yeah, he didn't play

Osman Savage - LB - Did he play?

Willie Allen* - OT - Doesn't count

Charles Thomas - LB - Did he play?

Zach Carpenter - OG - Expected Starter, so maybe he was passed. This is 1 that hurts

Will Hart - Punter - So what. We have other Punters

Christian Turner - RB - We have a packed RB room, so something had to give. Stings to have a back with experience gone, but doesn't really hurt.

Adam Fakih - LB - You have never heard of him

Zach Charbonnet - RB - This stings. But will give our new guys a huge opportunity to advance and play. 

Luiji Vilain - EDGE - Did he play much?

Dylan McCaffrey - QB - Probably should have chosen him over Milton, but who cares. 

Ben VanSumeren - LB - I feel like every time he was in as an RB the play would NOT go well. More room for the next guy up.

Adam Shibley - LB - Walk on who should not have had as much playing time as he did. This should mean he's been passed on the depth chart.

Joe Milton - QB - One season was enough, we don't need the chaos of potentially having him next year.

Hunter Reynolds - CB - Passed on Depth Chart

William Mohan - LB - Probably passed on the depth chart

Giles Jackson - WR - This hurts. The guy was a huge UM recruiter and just left. 

Gaige Garcia - RB - Was here to wrestle.

Cornell Wheeler - ILB - Passed on depth chart hopefully. 

 

By my count, there are only a few substantial losses and a bunch of inexperienced players who are just being replaced with other inexperienced players in new recruits. So 20 actually. 

 

With the covid year being a free year, something HAD to give. 

Teeba

June 2nd, 2021 at 11:09 PM ^

Carpenter’s mom has lupus. He transferred to be closer to home.

https://www.thedailyhoosier.com/how-did-iu-football-land-michigan-transfer-zach-carpenter-it-was-the-most-genuine-place/

His mother’s health ultimately made him decide that he needed to be closer to home regardless.

Carrie Carpenter has lupus, an autoimmune disease that is terrifying in normal times, but even more so in the midst of a global pandemic.

Magnus

June 3rd, 2021 at 8:19 AM ^

Bloomington to Cincinnati: 2 hours, 26 minutes

Ann Arbor to Cincinnati: 3 hours, 51 minutes

I'm not seeing a huge difference there. It's not like he was transferring from Oregon to Bloomington.

Odds are he just doesn't want to cause a poopstorm and call people out that he didn't like.

1VaBlue1

June 3rd, 2021 at 8:31 AM ^

I really - REALLY - believe that the cheap target DCaff took against Wisconsin in 2019 all but ended his career at Michigan.  I suspect he had replaced O'Korn for good in that game, until the injury knocked him out.  By the time he was ready to go again, it was so late in the season that he just couldn't catch up on the field with the playbook and execution.  For last year, I suspect the coaches saw a much stronger Milton playing well enough in practice, and figured him to be less prone to injury.  The dice roll didn't work out...

We'll never know truth from all sides in this matter.

JonnyHintz

June 2nd, 2021 at 9:11 PM ^

There’s this cool thing that college teams have called “spring practice.”

 

Not difficult for a hierarchy in practices to be determined. When younger players are getting more reps than you and are getting more reps with the 1s and 2s than you, it becomes pretty clear you’ve been passed. 
 

I see you edited your comment, but point still remains. It’s easy to gather where you stand from practices. The guys in his own class were getting more reps and hype than him. Then a guy from the incoming class is getting more reps and hype than him. It’s not rocket science and I’m sure Wheeler had a good feel for where he stood.

Don

June 3rd, 2021 at 9:53 AM ^

Even if one assumes that depth charts in June are fixed and unchanging, he's one fall camp injury from being the first backup with four years of eligibility in front of him.

I know he was recruited by Brown, and if his strengths and attributes are not what the new coaches are looking for I can understand his desire to transfer, but has that been established? Or is he not willing to stick it out at Michigan in the belief he'll be an instant starter elsewhere?