Unverified Voracity Gets Invited Comment Count

Brian

30814729775_4ce12b1aea_z

Braden invited; Magnuson not invited [Patrick Barron]

All the combine folks. 14 Michigan players will participate and even so there are a couple surprising omissions:

Braden but no Kalis or Magnuson is odd, and I thought Dymonte Thomas would be the kind of guy who could improve his stock significantly with impressive testing numbers.

That's a hell of a lot either way. Michigan's total is just four fewer than the entire Big 12. On the one hand, Michigan did not capitalize on that talent (by an inch, or a negative inch). On the other, Michigan's recruiting edits are going to be straight fire emoji in the immediate aftermath of the draft.

Speaking of the Big 12, Chris Vannini has an interesting article about the long term talent decline in the league. The state of Texas is getting raided hardcore:

The last factor is recruiting, and it doesn’t look better for the future. Only one Big 12 team signed a top-25 class in 247Sports’ rankings earlier this month: Oklahoma at No. 8. The next-closest Power 5 league was the ACC with four top-25 classes.

The league relies on the state of Texas, but Ohio State signed three of the top six players in the state. It was the first time since 2005 that an in-state school didn’t sign a majority share of the top 10 players in the state, as noted by the Dallas Morning News — and the third time since 2000 (the other two were Oklahoma). Only two of the top-10 players stayed in-state, and one of those left the Big 12 by going to Texas A&M.

Tom Herman should start turning that around—recruiting concerns about his finish at Texas should be mitigated by the fact that he landed Ed Oliver and a smattering of other four stars at Houston. It probably won't be enough to get back to parity.

"Offer" versus OFFER, part billion. I'm all for dumping on Nick Saban but this seems like a big bowl of nothing:

"LSU's welcome in my school anytime," Feaster said. "The only school that can't come to Parkway is Alabama. And there's a long story behind that, but it had to do with not being ethical in their recruiting.

"They can't come. Everyone else is 100 percent welcome."

The reason?

There is a difference between an offer and a committable offer, something he found out the hard way in the recruitment of former LSU quarterback Brandon Harris.

Alabama "offers" Harris, his coach gets persnickety about it, and then Alabama says he has an OFFER, only for that offer to be back to scare-quotes status by june:

"Napier calls me the next day and says, 'Coach, I have some good news for you. Tell Brandon to call me on this phone during this period and I'll put Nick Saban on the phone,"' Feaster said. "We do that and Saban says, 'You have a scholarship at the University of Alabama.' So, they gave him a scholarship offer. It was a committable offer.

"By the time he gets to campus in June -- and I'm not saying Brandon was going to commit to Alabama -- it wasn't an option. Basically what they told him is that we got other guys that are going to come through here, and I promised them a shot. So we have to wait and see then."

As far as malfeasance on the recruiting trail goes, this is small potatoes. Whether or not a kid is a "take" changes constantly for every school, including Michigan. Getting upset because Alabama changed their mind about a kid before he even committed is some special snowflake stuff. (Also that guy lost his job to a Purdue transfer, sooooo...)

MSU update. The gymnastics coach was forcibly retired and now faces three allegations that she downplayed sexual assault reports from Larry Nassar:

The allegation — the third made specifically against Klages — was first made in a court document filed Jan. 27 seeking to add the athlete to the federal lawsuit against Michigan State University, Nassar, USA Gymnastics and Twistars gymnastics club in Dimondale.

Those documents, filed by attorney Jamie White, didn't identify Klages, but said it was "a member of MSU’s coaching staff."

White, the attorney for the gymnast who says Nassar sexually assaulted her during medical appointments, confirmed on Tuesday that it was Klages who spoke to his client's mother.

He also confirmed that it was Klages who told his client's mother that "Nassar’s digital penetrations of (the athlete's) vagina was a proven medical treatment."

If you believe the reports sufficiently to "retire" her you should be firing her for cause.

Michigan State has suspended Curtis Blackwell, a recruiting staffer. They won't say why, but it's not too hard to draw a line between that and this:

Blackwell's suspension comes as a criminal investigation into three Michigan State football players is ongoing. Michigan State announced last week that a member of the football staff also had been suspended pending the completion of that investigation.

The police have requested warrants for the three players in question.

Also Demetrius Cooper was charged with spitting on a parking enforcement officer. Oh and Malik McDowell fell out of Mel Kiper's first round for reasons other than his talent. In a normal year this would be part of the rivalry pointing and laughing. This year not so much. That whole athletic department looks to be in total chaos.

Stop with the video, fergodsakes. Interesting piece on the demise of Scout media, which was accelerated by a push towards making everything a video, even the things that should definitely not be videos:

Advertisers might also have been skittish because of where most of Scout’s traffic came from. Despite a costly thrust into video, part of a massive, costly overhaul of Scout’s CMS, nearly 80 percent of Scout’s traffic comes from visits to its message boards, which are reserved for subscribers. Though the developers team claimed the addition of video in 2015 drove tens of millions of views within six months of its launch, Scout’s traffic was relatively flat or declining year-over-year from 2014 to 2015, according to comScore data.

Almost all of those videos were worthless. They're still doing it. I can't tell you how many Scout tabs I open and then disgustedly close because they're a hundred words trying to induce me to watch a recruit get interviewed for five minutes—a video that would already be autoplaying if I hadn't sought out a Chrome extension to disable said feature. ("Disable HTML 5 Autoplay," FWIW.)

Autoplay video is a scam. Person opens page, video plays, person does not watch video, counts as a hit anyway, publisher tries to leverage those numbers into high CPM video ads that no one will ever watch.

Etc.: Here's a video with athletic directors, including Warde Manuel, discussing a potential student protest. I did not watch it despite having interest in the subject matter, because it is a video.

Comments

Shop Smart Sho…

February 16th, 2017 at 4:11 PM ^

You're missing out by not listening to the podcast that Ace and Brian do.  I'm not one for podcasts, but it's generally pretty damn good.  Granted, Brian's after-game piece is generally a repeat of the opening bit of the podcast, but aside from that, it's good stuff.

Now, the MGoBlog roundtable on WTKA is another story.  Ed Fang doesn't really add anything to a show, aside from being a contrarian.  They seem to have the same 4 callers on a rotation.  Craig Ross really plays up the old curmudgeon angle.  Brian yells at clouds.

Rabbit21

February 16th, 2017 at 5:02 PM ^

I really think you are off base with the written content vs. audio content opinion.  The audio content often goes in different directions and is a great supplement to whats written.  Depending on the subject matter you can get a debate or discussion in real time that lets the subject breathe, which I think is just as useful as a longform piece.

LKLIII

February 16th, 2017 at 1:29 PM ^

On a more practical point on all of the damned videos--even if they aren't auto-play, a lot of readers online are doing so at work during the day.  It's one thing to surfe a message board & post up a few messages.  It's something else to actualy roll a video and disrupt the workplace.

Isn't very conductive for stealthy media consumption.

cbb

February 16th, 2017 at 2:13 PM ^

Autoplay videos have been the bane of my existence. I added an extension once to block them, but it blocked every single image from loading and was annoying. My life is now measurably better than it was four minutes ago.

lhglrkwg

February 16th, 2017 at 1:31 PM ^

Disable HTML 5 Autoplay plus making plug-ins a request to unblock has made the internet a much better place for me. Autoplay videos should get your website nuked

TrueBlue2003

February 16th, 2017 at 1:34 PM ^

and highly touted recruiting classes is just getting more painful than prideful.  My first thought was the same thing: 10-3 with this talent was so disappointing.  It was certainly more bad luck than underacheivement, I'd say, but man, we have to score more than three net offensive points against OSU when our defense plays that well.

Enough of the offseason victories.  Let's win some championships on the field. Have to feel good that it'll happen soon.

TrueBlue2003

February 16th, 2017 at 2:23 PM ^

make the argument that Alabama had more talent than us due to having more elite talent (Clemson probably did too).  Getting the number one recruiting class every year will do that.  There's a gap between Bama and everyone else, every year. But the gap wasn't wide: we did have insane depth of talent, as these numbers indicate.

And we had the most talented team in the Big Ten.  It was absolutely a disappointing season not to win the conference championship and be one of the four playoff participants.  Even worse to go 10-3, not win a bowl and end up on the fringe of the top 10.  We had  much better talent than that.  Again, more bad luck than underacheivement but at some point...

Blarvey

February 16th, 2017 at 3:05 PM ^

I agree. Clemson's win just showed everyone that the talent gap isn't that wide and that even with the most talent, one weakness on your team can be the big difference. For Michigan, that was the OL. For Alabama, it was QB. 

The B1G and playoffs were there for the taking and this team and the coaches couldn't pull it out. That is now 12 season without a conference title and no matter how you spin it, that is massive underachievement. 

TrueBlue2003

February 16th, 2017 at 3:24 PM ^

yes, 12 seasons without a conference title is massive underacheivement for this program but the first 10 of those were for reasons that don't exist anymore.

I certainly wouldn't call this last season a massive underachievement, but it was disappointing with some underachievement mixed in.  The future is bright but I'm just sick of all these offseason "wins" in the talent dept that haven't translated to championships yet.

2018, here we come.

Blarvey

February 16th, 2017 at 3:53 PM ^

Whatever the reasons, it still means the kids being recruited now were 5 or 6 when Michigan won their last conference title. The successes sprinkled in since then are not as prominent to recruits as Saban's rings and Clemson's recent success. 

I personally think that our fan base was numbed by that stuff and made it easier to find victories in things like recruiting and moral superiority. That doesn't change being 2-13 (*14) against your biggest rival since the start of the new century. Last year should have been the year that we saw some of those green shoots and we had to settle for wins over MSU and Wisconsin. 

As holy as Harbaugh is to this fanbase, I sure hope he can deliver next year (especially against OSU) because if not, it will begin to appear that his hiring was one of those offseason "wins". 

zh2oson

February 16th, 2017 at 1:50 PM ^

I hate the auto-play scout videos.  I'll be reading in bed and click on a link, only to have the auto-play video blast at a volume that scares the pants off of me and wakes the Mrs.

Booooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo.

CWoodson2401

February 16th, 2017 at 2:21 PM ^

I don't have the points to start a thread but Brian's pronouciation of Jameis Winston this morning was amazing. I have heard this name on TV over 1000 times I would guess, but never the way I heard it today. Kudos to Brian for moving the verbal paradigm. 

Bodogblog

February 16th, 2017 at 5:30 PM ^

It's just an obtuse way of looking at things.  OSU and FSU were two of the last four games, one of which was in Columbus and the other a virtual road game in Florida.  One playoff team and the other a top 10 team.  Lost the first in OT with every questionable call going against M.  The other a 1 point loss due to an unbelievably over-matched OL.  Iowa sucked, but just about everything that cold go wrong there did. 

If OSU and FSU games were spaced differently, the whole "didn't finish well" would be bunk.  Oh, you mean a team didn't win as often against the top teams in the country as it did against lesser teams?  Sparkling observation there lad. 

CRISPed in the DIAG

February 16th, 2017 at 3:59 PM ^

Autoplay videos piss me off. Especially when at work when the sound blasts a 5-second commercial before the actual video starts.

I rarely use video content anywhere unless I'm killing the internet on youtube.

 

Bodogblog

February 16th, 2017 at 5:25 PM ^

Scout videos were terrible.  I wondered if that was going to be a new thing and actually reading an article would old school.  Glad to see the reactionaries win here.  Videos take 5 minutes to liston to when the written summary can be read in 45 seconds.  There's no contest there.  Very rarely would I want to see faces or hear voices that a video would provide. 

Reader71

February 17th, 2017 at 1:57 AM ^

When a recruit uses the thing we call language to communicate with a coach and the coach uses a word in a way in which no other speaker of that language does, I don't think the recruit is a special snowflake for being upset. Do only snowflakes expect language to provide sounds with meaning? An offer is an offer. A non-committable offer is not an offer at all. At best, it's an "alternate offer". Just because we do it now doesn't mean it's right, or that the kid is wrong or a special snowflake, or that the foundational understanding of language isn't important.