Michigan 10, Northwestern 9 Comment Count

Ace

De'Veon Smith broke the scoreless tie with 6:49 left in the third on a three-yard plunge, ruining the aesthetic, but this will forever be known as The M00N Game:

If it involved futility, this game had it. Northwestern lost on a failed two-point conversion with three seconds left when quarterback Trevor Siemian rolled out, saw Frank Clark, and fell over. That was just the final pratfall in this slapstick, however.

It started right away, with Northwestern taking an illegal formation penalty to negate a third-and-one conversion on the game's first drive. Devin Funchess returned the favor by dropping a third-down pass on Michigan's opening salvo.

The two teams proceeded in such fashion for the duration of the game. Michigan's final three possessions of the first half started inside Northwestern territory. They netted 29 yards and zero points, failing in three different ways: a punt, a pick, and a blocked field goal as the half mercifully expired.

The Wildcats pulled the same trick in the second half, missing a field goal, turning it over on downs, and punting on a negative-28-yard drive on their three possessions beginning on the Wolverines end of the field. The teams finished with a combined 504 yards; 256 for Northwestern, 248 for Michigan.

Somewhere in the middle of all that, Devin Gardner threw a second interception when he stared down Jake Butt, Michigan lost a fumble when Jack Miller's snap bounced off a motioning Devin Funchess, and defensive tackle Matt Godin picked off Siemian after Clark tipped a pass.


Bryan Fuller/MGoBlog

We should all be thanking Pat Fitzgerald for his fourth-quarter decision-making. After punter Will Hagerup pinned Northwestern just outside their goal line, Siemian engineered a 19-play drive that covered 95 yards, only for Fitzgerald to call for the field goal unit on fourth-and-goal from the four. The field goal cut Michigan's lead to 7-3. The Wildcats had literally just doubled their yardage total in one drive. Under seven minutes remained on the clock. He kicked anyway.

Michigan nearly managed to ice the game on the next drive, chewing up 4:16 and all three Northwestern timeouts on a 54-yard drive that ended with a Matt Wile field goal.

The Wildcats marched right back down the field, cutting the M lead to 10-9 on a three-yard throw from Siemian to Tony Jones. Fitzgerald, slightly more bold than before—or perhaps just wanting the game to end—sent the offense back on the field. Michigan's pass rush had landed home all night, sacking Siemian six times, and they anticipated the Northwestern call to roll the pocket right; Clark shot past two blockers and Siemian slipped in an effective but fruitless attempt to avoid him.

One kneel later, the game ended. Nobody was sad to see it go.

Comments

Waves

November 8th, 2014 at 8:24 PM ^

I'm at a loss for words to describe this offense. It's incomprehensible that we could be this bad. DG is horrible, we have no speed at the skill positions, and our #1 receiver can't catch. And so S-L-O-W.

His Dudeness

November 8th, 2014 at 8:34 PM ^

Coach Manning tweeting something to the extent of "a win is a win is a win. proud of this team."

I do agree that a win counts whether you win by 2 or by 20, but man I would have a long talk to this team after that performance and "proud" wouldn't be the preferred word used.

The coaching is Charmin soft. My goodness.

DG is mentally broken and I think that's Hokes fault with the yanking routine he has played with DG all year.

Funchess has quit on the team. I would seriously bench him. I truly would. "Have a nice life" (TM) in the NFL, guy.

The slowness is because that's how Hoke tells the OC to coach them so the defense has time to rest. He honestly thinks time of poss is a meaningful stat. Blows my mind.

Anywho. #WooParty #AWinIsJustAStatistic #AWinIsAWinIsAWin #M00N

 

My Name is LEGIONS

November 8th, 2014 at 9:11 PM ^

Yanking routine? This is by far the worst thing ever posted. hoke has kept Gardner in more than any other coach would. Gardner deserved to get benched twenty times over. And by not doing so its making him bigger than the program.

His Dudeness

November 8th, 2014 at 9:37 PM ^

Yea DG is now. There was a time when DG was good.

Now he is broken because Hoke has pulled him twice this year and then put him back in.

If youre going to bench your 5th year senior QB for a RS sophomore, that has to be the end of the line. By yanking  DB in and out he has broken the kid. I feel bad for him honestly. If he needs to be benched then bench him and that's it. Hoke is so stupid he doesn't even know how to coach a kid.

DG thinks he is going to get pulled after every bad throw. Leading to more bad throws. Not to mention he is not healthy at all.

 

Mo Better Blues

November 8th, 2014 at 9:56 PM ^

With respect, I think benching a player is supposed to be a tactic to help pause an individual player's negative play, insert proper coaching and instruction, then reintroduce the player with new perspective and enhanced motivation. It's not supposed to be a strategy to declare a player's career dead and buried. Benching Gardner should have been used more--judiciously, but definitely more--not less and then permanently. 

snarling wolverine

November 8th, 2014 at 11:00 PM ^

Is a bad QB supposed to never get pulled?

Gardner was the undisputed starter going into the year and then played horribly against ND and Utah, before being benched, so I don't know how much of a difference that made.  He doesn't look much different now than he did in ND/Utah.  

At this point, a lot of coaches would have permanently benched DG by now.  Hoke's given him a ton of extra rope.

 

 

snarling wolverine

November 9th, 2014 at 12:30 PM ^

I agree with about that - I'm not arguing that Morris is better (although at this point, given that he's a sophomore and Gardner a senior, a lot of coaches would have just gone with him anyway to build for the future).  

What I disagree with is the notion that Gardner's confidence was shot by the benching.  He wasn't playing well in the first place, which is why he was benched.  

 

 

Mo Better Blues

November 8th, 2014 at 9:47 PM ^

Yeah, this. A million times this. The only "yanking routine" is that which was just done to my crank with that comment. I was almost surprised that--when the victory formation was called--Gardner didn't, like, trot backwards and lob the ball up in the air, just in case there was another opportunity to lose the game.

With competent quarterbacking (and quarterback-specific coaching/development/in-game usage) and we're around 7-3, and this particular game is probably about 42-7 Michigan.

klctlc

November 8th, 2014 at 10:38 PM ^

How many defenses are just saying "go ahead and pass"?  How much pressure does this put on the OL because every D is keying on the run, because they know DG will have a brain cramp 75% of the time.  The risk of him doing something good is worth it.

Yes funchess is not helping, but christ, he probably has no idea what the hell DG is gonna do .

Needs

November 9th, 2014 at 11:09 AM ^

If Funchess doesn't drop half the balls that hit his hands, how much better does Gardner look as a QB? This is a level of futility that goes so far beyond DG. Bad coaching, bad individual play, bad attention to detail. You see mistakes at every level (Smith not hitting the correct hole, Funchess with probably a 30% drop rate, Gardner throwing balls on completely incorrect trajectories). About the only high point on offense is Hayes's blitz recognition.

klctlc

November 8th, 2014 at 10:35 PM ^

What clowns did that? Your comment is spot on.  DG got yanked because he has sucked this year. He is broken. You can blame Hoke for not developing him for 4 years.  But this year is all on DG.  He ain't bad because he got pulled. If we had any kind of backup, DG would be holding a clipboard a lot.  

GoBLUinTX

November 8th, 2014 at 11:46 PM ^

are you refering to.  One game, the Minnesota game, after his numbingly brain dead Utah game.  Other than that Gardner has been on the field for almost every single play.

Let's face it, Gardner hasn't broken down so much as he never improved.  When he was a freshman he would look down receivers and was horribly inaccurate.  As a fifth year senior he stares down receivers and is horribly inaccurate.  Lest we forget, his 2012 spring practice was so bad that Bellomy moved ahead of him and he was moved to WR.

I think DG is performing yeoman service, but let's not kid ourselves, he has never been much of a QB.  Not at the college level.

aiglick

November 9th, 2014 at 1:49 AM ^

When he had to finish the 2012 season Gardner was very promising and I think he was the highest performing QB nationally using the Mathlete's stats during that period. We were salivating and yes he has not improved as you stated and he has had way too many failures and not enough dazzling moments this year but the guy has a lot of talent. We have broken the poor guy and I hope some NFL team will try to put him back together and in a position to dominate since he has the ability to have tremendous impact whatever he decides to do for his livelihood.

His Dudeness

November 9th, 2014 at 9:00 AM ^

This.

DG has been playing awful this season because of what Hoke has done to him with the yanking routine.

Hoke already started Morris over DG. That's it. That broke DG. He has no confidence in himself and worse he has no confidence that his coaching staff wont give him the hook if he makes a bad play.

If Hoke wanted Morris starting then that should have been a perminent decision. Morris got hurt, so you put in Bellomy. Once you yank a kid (who is a 5th yr senior in his final year as a wolverine) that decision should be perminent.

I'm not saying other QBs couldnt get over something like that. I'm not even saying DG isnt a bit fragile mentally,  but clearly there was a time when DG was a great college QB.

IMO the yanking around he was treated to this season was what ruined him as a college QB.

To be a great QB you have to know you arent going to get pulled if you make a bad read. You have to have confidence in your coach to roll with you a bit. DG didnt get that because Hoke is on a very hot seat. That is why you see the DG you see today, who should be benched because he is playing terrible.

 

Needs

November 9th, 2014 at 11:16 AM ^

I think this gets the narrative of improvement that suddenly stopped correct but misrepresents the turning point. Last year against ND (aside from the one brain dead play) Gardner stood in against the rush and went through progressions and played a startlingly great game... It was MSU last year that broke him. That's the point when Gardner lost all trust in his oline and just started dumping the ball to the first read, regardless of whether he was open in not.

Compound that lack of trust with a change from a first option who consistently got open with one who drops about half of the balls thrown to him and an offense incapable of generating big plays, requiring DG to hit a series of short passes into congested coverage, and an inability to escape the rush the way he did in his initial years, and you have this year's offense.

GoBLUinTX

November 9th, 2014 at 11:41 AM ^

the Nebraska game may have been a product of that, he started to get his mojo back against NW (w) and Iowa (L), and he certainly had it back for OSU.  Furthermore, he threw just one INT during the 2nd half of the season, and that was against MSU.  MSU might have had a momentary effect but by the end of the season, aside from his foot, he was performing well.

The irony of course is that this new fangled simplified offense seems to be more than he can handle.  Why that is I have no idea but if I had to hazard a guess I'd say Nussmeier has so filled his head with minutia he can no longer work on autopilot.

Needs

November 9th, 2014 at 11:47 AM ^

Interesting. You may be on to something there. Everytime he comes off the field after a mistake (and this may be true in general ... tv just doesn't show it) Nuss looks like he's teaching about some fine detail of what went wrong with his footwork.

I think the reality is that DG's futility this year is a combo platter of 1. physical limitations that are hampering a QB that had learned to turn to his athleticism after his first read was covered, 2. playing in his third offense in five years, 3. an offense that forces him to do things that he does badly, particularly fitting the ball into the small windows of a short passing game with no deep threat and going rapidly through progressions in a congested field, and 4. a learned practice of not keeping his eyes downfield so plays have very little time to develop.

Add in an offense that just looks badly coached, particularly among the WRs and RBs, and we have the current mess.

snarling wolverine

November 9th, 2014 at 12:42 PM ^

DG has been playing awful this season because of what Hoke has done to him with the yanking routine.

Again - this doesn't make sense because Gardner clearly had the job at the beginning of the season and wasn't pulled until the 4th quarter of the Utah game. By that point he'd already had two very bad games (ND and Utah).

I think the transition from Borges to Nussmeier has been hard on him for whatever reason.  Under Borges he was inconsistent but was fantastic when he was at his best.  We've never seen him perform at his 2013 ND/IU/OSU levels this season.

 

bleedzblue

November 9th, 2014 at 5:20 PM ^

While I agree, once you yank him it should be perminent, there is no way you can make the argument that DG is afraid to make a bad read/decision/throw in fear of being taken out. He's made bad read after bad read, bad throw after bad throw and coach Hoke is sticking with him. He was benched for one game, it's not like the coaches have had a rotating door when DG fucks up. IMO, the leash they've had on DG is far to long.

Needs

November 9th, 2014 at 11:18 AM ^

Go watch last year's ND game, he was firing balls to Gallon on skinny posts in tight windows 35 yards downfield. In Borges's offense, he pushed the ball downfield consistently on a line. Either he's damaged physically or he's been coached away from that.

1817

November 8th, 2014 at 8:37 PM ^

Glad the players get rewarded for the work they put in...but what an awful looking game that makes me wonder when we forgot how to play offense.

ChicagoGangViolins

November 8th, 2014 at 8:40 PM ^

 

Yakkity sax.  

I attended last season's game in Evanston courtesy of an investment banker NW alum and sat at the fifty through the weather to the end cheering for my beloved Michigan.  This year all of us decided to remain at a home, barbeque and drink together in anticipation of terrible gameplay.  Gawd we were prescient.  

A one-point game, I wish I could remember all of the funny things shared so I could reshare, that was the personal value of today's embarrassing exercise for both teams.  Shame on Brady Hoke for having a Blutarsky offense - something futile and we're just the guys to do it - although I was sincerely proud of special teams and even defense, mostly.  

Hoke needs to leave after tOSU, there is no mercy in these here quarters anymore.  We really do stink that bad at year four.  Bye bye Mr. Hoke.  As adversaries have said, you are a joke.

 

Manbaugh

November 8th, 2014 at 8:49 PM ^

If Hoke somehow survives. Today, against a God awful opponent, they barely won. When this is the standard and not the exception, it's just sad. 

It started with Brandon. Now finish it with Hoke. 

skurnie

November 8th, 2014 at 8:51 PM ^

A true show of journalistic fortitude to not include any of the (probably rightful) four letter words in this recap. I'm amazed by this actually but have had to do it myself (though with soccer). It's a grim task, but well done.

Blarvey

November 8th, 2014 at 9:07 PM ^

On the plus side, rIght now this team is 240 rushing yards away from its total all of last year...but it has only run for 13 TDs.

Also total passing yards to this point are less than half of all last season (1576 vs 3221 last year) and to date, the team has 8 TD passes. 8 TD passes through 10 weeks of the season.

The offense gleams on paper vs. how it looks in games. Don't mean to be a downer. It's run or die from here on out.

RJWolvie

November 8th, 2014 at 9:07 PM ^

We win. Odds getting pretty good we get a nothing bowl & the extra practice.

AND

We look absolutely putrid, inept, horribly inept, & toe sideline penalties in case message missed. So NO chance Hoke survives.

We couldn't have scripted it any better. (Well, except we had to watch that Schleck!)