Why do we care so much?

Submitted by Clarence Beeks on December 30th, 2018 at 9:25 PM

As the year comes to a close and many of us begin (or finalize) thoughts about how 2018 went, I found myself thinking a good bit during yesterday’s game about why I (and, by extension, we) invest so much time, money, energy, and caring into the outcome of a game played by 18-23 year olds.

It was a pretty metaphysical question for me, and one that has been there for me all fall in a year with a lot of life changes. What I realized is that despite all that has changed, my love of Michigan football remains and only seems to get stronger, no matter how the team actually does. Yet I am honestly not 100% sure I can put my finger on “why” beyond that it’s a connection that spans the seasons of life, and one that I hope to pass on and enjoy with my children, which really isn’t impacted that much by whether we win or lose.

With so much negativity on the board, I thought it would be a good opportunity to hear why the members of our community here all pour so much time, caring, effort, and money into the game and team we love. In part to answer my own “why”, but also to hear the inspiration of others’.

Greatgig

December 30th, 2018 at 10:11 PM ^

As a father of 3 with the oldest being a 14 year old girl, I'm just looking to escape reality for a few hours on Saturday afternoons. The escapism hasn't been great since Thanksgiving, hoping for better things next year. Cheers, happy New year's all!

Coldwater

December 30th, 2018 at 10:15 PM ^

I’ve (and my wife) asked myself this exact question year after year.   Why do I care so damn much?  Other than the health and emotional well being of me and my family, Michigan football is the most important thing in my life.  My life happiness is predicated on Michigan wins and losses.  I’m so emotionally invested. 

But why?  I don’t remotely care about the Michigan professional teams even though I’m a lifelong fan...I don’t care about my job.  I just need enough money to live.  I don’t care if I have a lot of friends or not.   I don’t post on message boards about anything else.   

I feel like I’m some guy from Texas, Alabama, Georgia where football is religion and a way of life.   It’s a sickness and there is no cure.  I want Michigan to beat OSU and win a National a Championship so bad that it consumes me.     The end.

ijohnb

December 31st, 2018 at 3:36 PM ^

“Do you love Michigan football because of the way you are, or are you the way you are because you love Michigan football?”  

 

That is is a real gem from Brian from 2006, but rethinking the question, it is weird.  I don’t think I love Michigan football anymore. I’m not even sure I like it. I don’t think I identify with most of it characteristics anymore.

 

But I am still obsessed with it.  That right there is an issue.  It is beginning to feel more like it is a bad addiction to some drug than it is genuine fandom.

uofmfan_13

December 30th, 2018 at 10:20 PM ^

My fandom comes from my pops and his father before that. Love the MGOblog community so I like to interact.

I'll be diehard blue until the end of my days. Going to UM at UMD here in DC area in march, then gonna watch blue vs UMD in baseball in spring. 

Football games are exciting but no doubt a let down, particularly 2 of the past 4 seasons when it seemed like we had legit shot at winning something big. Gonna start doing the emotional hedge next year and bet against UM in big games until Harbaugh proves otherwise.

 

ontarioblue

December 30th, 2018 at 10:26 PM ^

I miss not knowing what a 4 or 5 star had for breakfast.  With 24/7 access there is way too much info out there and that access has taken away from the fun of following your team.  I can’t imagine if I was a player that I would even have any social media because the scrutiny some put on these student athletes is beyond the level of insanity.  

mb121wl

December 30th, 2018 at 10:32 PM ^

Speaking for myself -- and even though I care a little less each year than the year previously -- I think it has something to do with the potential a football season (or span of seasons) possesses to be an unalloyed good. Everything else in life is a mix of good and bad, of ease and effort, of pleasure and pain. To be able to sit back and identify, emotionally, with something as essentially fair and merit-based as a football team's efforts is a genuine escape from the more-serious and more-important reality I have to endure.

Then there are those helmets (as OldBlueVa remarks below), the colors (at least when the maize is light enough...), and the song. Those signifiers of a community and a cause so much greater than I am as a (sentimental and aging) individual got imprinted on my emotional self at a crucial time in life: the brief passage from adolescence to adulthood. For all its uncertainties, life seemed simpler and clearer then, at least on those wonderful October afternoons when I could forget everything else and get swept up in a tsunami of collectively experienced joy and agony.

SugarShane

December 30th, 2018 at 10:47 PM ^

I reached the low point in 2014.  By the end of the year I just didn't care about Michigan football.  Only Ohio State game I have never even watched.  

 

Then we hired harbaugh and immediately reignited my insane devotion.  

 

I'm about back to 2014 levels now.  Seeing a full harbaugh season with a truly talented QB with this result has shredded any glimmer of hope I had.

TVG_2.0

December 30th, 2018 at 11:13 PM ^

To me, I’ve only really known mediocrity. Being 20 years old the earliest memories I have are the later Carr years. For me a loss has always been just a loss. Occasionally(including yesterday), I’ll go off simply because I have never seen Michigan football do a damn thing. And it’s frustrating. But for the most part I couldn’t care less after a loss. 

You Only Live Twice

December 30th, 2018 at 11:15 PM ^

No mystery.  I've been caring for all of my conscious life and that's more years than I often want to admit.  My dad started taking me to games when I was 5, and he took my son to his first game when he was 4.  Dad still pays for the season tickets, son, daughter and I attend.  My undergrad years at UM were the best years (and sometimes not the best, learned more when things were not the best). I remain grateful for the experience, decades later.

There have been times where it was necessary to employ coping mechanisms such as what people have described here, like detaching for a short while.  Through it all my fandom does not waver.  Whatever my faults, I am a very loyal person.  

mgobleu

December 30th, 2018 at 11:19 PM ^

Because I cared too much when it really sucked, it's about time for some karmic f-ing justice and I'm sick and tired of waiting.

Other than that I don't really give a shit.

Synful

December 30th, 2018 at 11:41 PM ^

Why?  

It all stems back to my attending UM.  If I didn't I wouldn't care about the school or any of its programs.  I started the indoctrination as a freshman and it continues to pump in my blood to this day.  I've had glorious memories both as a student and alumna and it taints every view I have, as much as I try to maintain some semblance of objectivity in criticism.  

In the end it is my alma mater and I care how it is perceived in the greater world view both in academics and athletics, as a research institution and an agent of change in society, as a cultural icon and the kaleidoscopic addition to the tapestry of life across the globe.

Maize and Blue now, Maize and Blue forever.

Synful

December 31st, 2018 at 12:43 PM ^

Blah blah blah, I'll feed the troll... have leftover cooking from holiday baking.  Guess reading comprehension is hard Pha or you'd have a better comment than some self-righteous statement with inaccuracies.

Also in a semi less serious signoff (since some in the peanut gallery crave that rather than honesty) I'd expand the word 'fan' as it is more apropos - fanatic.  'Fan' implies a more casual association.

AlbanyBlue

December 31st, 2018 at 1:32 AM ^

Interesting topic here....

I have to say I don't know why I care so much about M football. But I do, and that's why these 10-win seasons, while nice on the surface, are just so damn frustrating. That has been rehashed a million times, so I'll leave it there.

I'm a Lions fan (nominally) too, but when the Lions suck, I can still watch the game and be somewhat entertained, or at least be able to say, "well, no big deal". I can't do that with Michigan games. When I see Michigan have trouble, I literally have to turn off the game. I have so much stress over the games that I just can't watch them live. Why the HELL is it this way? Why can't I manage to re-calibrate my expectations for this team? I have done it for all the Detroit teams, as we are in a horrible period for Detroit sports in general.

Pisses me the hell off. If I could just enjoy our consistent 9-10 win seasons, I'd be much happier in the fall.

mgobobb

December 31st, 2018 at 7:31 AM ^

First, I am 76 years old.  My dad graduated from Michigan in the mid 1920s.  I saw my first UM-OSU game when I was 12 in 1954 with my best friend whose dad was an OSU alumnus and I was just shocked at all the slick, deceptive ball handling by the Michigan backfield.  UM jumped off to a 7-0 lead and drove down to the 1 foot line.  The UM fullback dove over but the referee placed the ball on the 6 inch line.  I was heartbroken.  Shortly, Hopalong Cassady ran for nearly a 60 yard scamper for OSU and they went on to win 21-7.  My buddy teased me unmercifully.

The next year the Ohio Turnpike opened and my dad and I drove to Ann Arbor on a bright sunny day.  I couldn’t believe the size of The Big House and I remember to this day the capacity was 97,239. 

I immediately fell in love with the bright Michigan uniforms and THE MICHIGAN HELMET!!

In 1973, my wife and I went to a game and met most of the coaching staff in the little bar at the Campus Inn in Ann Arbor where the team stayed the night before home games.She told them how much I loved Michigan and they immediately asked me if I’d like to recruit for them in our home area in Ohio.  I was awed as alumni and friends could help recruit on a limited basis then.

The rest is history - going to many, many games, knowing Bo, the coaches and the great Don Canham.  My heart still melts when I see the UNIFORM and HELMET!!

 

 

Crime Reporter

December 31st, 2018 at 8:21 AM ^

As I get older it becomes harder to emotionally invest when adult stuff takes up my time. I still care but football has lost its identity amid the cash grabs, blatant cheating and me mentality. I’ll be back next year, jaded as ever.

SpamCityCentral

December 31st, 2018 at 9:03 AM ^

I still care a great amount, but at the same time the outcome of a game has no direct impact on anything in my life. Wake up tomorrow and it's a completely new day. Am i still disappointed after a big loss? Of course.

I just hope before my dad passes we can celebrate a national championship together. Too young for 1997.

 

Sparty Doesn't Know

December 31st, 2018 at 9:27 AM ^

I care because this is one of the very few things that careers, a wife and kids can't take away from you.  My enjoyment of everything else has diminished on account of those 3 time suckers, but nobody can take away MGoBlog when I am at my desk (self-employed), or my DVR recording of the Michigan game that I can watch on Saturday nights.

Outside of throwing the remote and getting visually pissed off, I would say my fandom has actually increased since I was a kid.  Instant access to team news, forums and recruiting news is so much better than it was growing up in the 90's.  We never care less, we just behave more maturely, lol.

Go Blue!  Now enough with this philosophical bullshit.

Zoltanrules

December 31st, 2018 at 9:49 AM ^

I care because of Bob Ufer and had some of my best years and met some of the greatest people in A2. Definitely tribal.

Get pissed for a day after a bad loss in any sport but then move on. For football, the end of season flows right into basketball and hockey so it is easy. Beilein and his teams respresent everything a UM fan should want. The wins are very nice but it's just the humility, development of fundamentals and integrity that make me love his program from day one. Hutch is my second favorite UM coach for the same reasons.

 

 

 

Wolverine 73

December 31st, 2018 at 10:36 AM ^

Because we are all competitive and we want to win, whether it is something we are doing or something our school or home town team is doing. And because we don’t like it when people talk trash to us when we lose.