Punt-Counterpunt: Maryland 2014 Comment Count

Brian

maryland-jose3030-2[1]

HeikoG_1147_thumb4_thumb_thumb_thumb[1]PUNT

By Heiko "4 AD" Yang

Today will be the last time Michigan’s seniors will be playing a football game in the Big House.

Just like the team’s record, the excitement and emotion surrounding senior day has waned over the past few years. We all remember senior day 2011: Molk, Martin, Koger, Van Bergen, et al. were regaled as heroes for pulling Michigan out of the most tumultuous stretch in program history (or so we thought), and then they cemented their legacy by beating Ohio State. Senior day 2012 was a sad farewell to Denard and Kovacs, but happily it was also the debut of Denard Robinson, Offensive Weapon. Last year’s senior day was an inevitable disappointment. Still, there were moments of – I don’t know how to describe the feeling, but when Jeremy Gallon took the first play 70-some yards to the goal line, you just felt like he deserved better, and you knew you were going to miss him.

This year, struggling for bowl eligibility against a crappy Maryland team on a cold and crappy November afternoon is a crappy but fitting way to go out. At the end of a disappointing season you should at least be able use senior day as a way to recognize the guys that did something significant to mitigate the disaster – guys who held the team together maybe made enough of a difference that the rest of the team can build on, if not for the current season, maybe the next one. Did anyone do that this year? I don’t know, man. Maybe it was Hoke’s fault for not naming captains, or it was the previous year’s captains’ fault for making it seem like leadership was a dangerously overrated thing. Either way, screaming at your teammates on the sidelines that you really want to beat Penn State isn’t that impressive.

There’s not much of a legacy to be left here. Sure, we’ll remember individual guys like Jake Ryan as being great players, but #Team135 will never be toasted at reunions or enshrined in a display case in Schembechler Hall, which is crazy when you consider that some of these guys own school records (remember Gardner’s 2013 Indiana game?). It’s hard to even credit these guys as a critical transition class, which is ironic because a lot of them were recruited during the transition between Rich Rod and Hoke. But just as they weren’t really critical to the brief renaissance in 2011, they haven’t been setting up for the future success of Michigan football either.

I’m sorry for being such a downer (just wait until you read Counterpunt), but that’s how I feel about the fact that it’s senior day and how aware but not fully aware I was about it until now. I still think this team has a pretty good shot at beating Maryland and becoming bowl eligible, especially with Maryland’s top receivers out. Not having Frank Clark is going to hurt the defense, but with the second bye week, I’m optimistic that the offense has addressed some of the brain farting to pick up some of the slack.

Yes, it’s cold and rainy, but you know what? I have a feeling this turns out to be a fun, albeit ridiculous, game. That, if anything, would be a fitting end to this senior class’s career at Michigan Stadium.

Michigan 23, Maryland 22

DSC00045_thumb6_thumb1_thumb134_thum_thumbCOUNTERPUNT*

By Nick RoUMel

      You will not be able to stay home, brother.
      You will not be able to plug in, turn on, and cop out.
       You will not be able to lose yourself in Jäger and skip out for beer during commercials.
        Because the devolution will not be televised.
        The devolution will not be brought to you by Coke, or Kraft macaroni and cheese. It will not feature Jim Harbaugh blowing a bugle and leading a charge, cutting down Urban Meyer and Mark Dantonio from their high horses.
         The devolution will not be led by the triumvirate of Jeff Long, Brad Bates, and Warde Manuel followed by an army of Michigan Men. Because the devolution will not be televised.
         There will be no instant replay of Desmond Howard making the Catch or striking the Pose. There will be no slow-motion montage of Tom Brady or Charles Woodson highlights. Because the devolution will not be televised.
           You will no longer hear the speech about The Team, The Team, The Team. You will no longer hear '70's rock songs about South Detroit, or other places that don't exist. You will not drink! drink! drink! with Neil Diamond or Sweet Caroline.
          You will hear pundits speak In low, funereal voices about Michigan football. Jim Brandstatter will say "tough game, Coach." Fans will murmur, helplessly, leaving the stadium.
        Because the devolution will not be televised. The devolution will be live.

MARYLAND 20, MICHIGAN 16

* with apologies to the late, great Gil Scott Heron.

Comments

You Only Live Twice

November 22nd, 2014 at 12:46 PM ^

Heiko, you weren't kidding!

Nick, I'll respectfully disagree.  MI 24, MD 10.  Brady had said earlier this week that Devin's ankle was improving.  See, we do talk about injuries now.... GO BLUE!

TIMMMAAY

November 22nd, 2014 at 1:22 PM ^

Either way, screaming at your teammates on the sidelines that you really want to beat Penn State isn’t that impressive.

That's a shot at Gardner, yes? 

Boo. 

ruthmahner

November 22nd, 2014 at 1:26 PM ^

Apparently bumming out the commenters, too. Usually when I pull up Punt/Counterpunt, there are about a hundred comments to entertain me. So many, in fact, that I rarely get through them all! And here I am, in the first ten. Who'da thunk?

Ty Butterfield

November 22nd, 2014 at 1:36 PM ^

People want to team to show more fire but aren't happy with Gardner for being fired up. I guess I shouldn't be surprised. People on MGoBlog need something to complain about.

aiglick

November 22nd, 2014 at 2:08 PM ^

There was hope that was the difference; we weren't amazing that year but it was a start to an amazing turnaround. After that game we ripped off something like a 6-3 record to finish something like 9-9 in the Big Ten which was starting to look like a great conference. There is a difference between football and basketball from a conference and overall sport perspective. The nice thing about basketball is that one loss is just one battle and not the war. The moment you lose in football is the moment your season starts to go bad; it may be unfair but them's the breaks. I'm not going to even go into the difference in quality between Big Ten basketball and Big Ten football. I just hope we're good again before football goes through the inevitable changes that will change the sport forever. As a sport basketball isn't going anywhere. Maybe Delaney was right all along although the Big East was destroyed so who knows. All this said I still hope we win out. Like everybody this is my team but I want them to be at the top of the game rather than a shadow of their former self.

Don

November 22nd, 2014 at 1:38 PM ^

That's the piece that launched Gil Scott-Heron to fame; at the time, it really was revolutionary. While the terms and references in it are of course outdated now, much of his satirical criticism is just as relevant today, IMHO.

U-M 23  Maryland 19

nroumel

November 22nd, 2014 at 1:52 PM ^

That piece blew me away when someone played it for me in college. To that point, I basically listened to album rock. Then I heard Gil and my jaw just dropped. Whitey on the Moon was another. Yes - Gil is still relevant.

Danwillhor

November 22nd, 2014 at 1:40 PM ^

I just don't feel good about this game. It just has that feeling of pre-osu bleghh. In a game of inept offenses and bad weather, I take Edsall. I'm sorry. Hope we can lock up a shitty bowl game but I don't feel it. Hope I'm wrong.

RJMAC

November 22nd, 2014 at 2:33 PM ^

The weather at the game will be freezing rain and wind in the teens. The ability to pass the ball will be questionable. Looks like another sludge fart game.

GoBLUinTX

November 22nd, 2014 at 2:47 PM ^

 

....but with the second bye week, I’m optimistic that the offense has addressed some of the brain farting to pick up some of the slack.
I had the same misguided thought process pre-MSU.  Silly me, Michigan rarely comes out of a bye week looking better than it went in, and this year has been no exception.  I'm ever hopeful for a Michigan win, alas of late I'm never surprised when that doesn't occur. I won't bother predicting a score because frankly, I don't care anymore.