The squad [Patrick Barron]

Michigan 21, Penn State 17 Comment Count

Alex.Drain November 13th, 2021 at 4:45 PM

An inexplicable afternoon in State College a few weeks back radically changed the perception that the layperson had of Penn State football. After Illinois ran the football right down PSU's throat repeatedly for over 350 yards and won college football's first 9OT game, the narrative quickly morphed into a belief that the Nittany Lions were bad and vastly overrated. Those who cared to scrutinize the tape noticed how bizarre and inconsistent that game was with the rest of their season's results. 

Outside of that game, PSU had just two losses, one on a Sorta Night Game at Kinnick that they were going to win handily before Sean Clifford's injury, and the other being a highly competitive game against Ohio State in the 'Shoe that they very well could have won. SP+ ranked Penn State 11th in the country entering this weekend. They are a very good football team, one with a ton of talent. Michigan just beat that football team. On the road. After taking a few punches. And in the process, Michigan's College Football Playoff hopes are still alive. 

The first quarter was the definition of "Not What You Want". Penn State dominated play, gaining 145 yards split across 2.5 drives. Meanwhile Michigan gained 5 total yards, split across two drives. PSU hit Michigan with a variety of tactics that your author outlined in his FFFF of Penn State this week: screens to stretch the field horizontally and then QB scrambles/design runs to move the chains. And tempo, which worked well to keep some of Michigan's best players off the field for several plays:

On their first drive, the Nittany Lions faced the wrath of David Ojabo and Aidan Hutchinson yet kept moving. They converted a 3rd & 17 and a 3rd & 8, and then executed a perfect fake punt on a 4th & 6. Michigan finally got off the field after a Junior Colson sack ended the drive, but Jordan Stout threaded a FG through the uprights for a 3-0 Nittany Lions lead. 

A fake FG disaster [Patrick Barron]

Indeed, the theme of that first quarter onslaught was Michigan doing their best Michigan State impression by bending, but not breaking. They gave up gobs of yards on the first two PSU drives, but the opposition walked away with just three points. That second Nittany Lion drive stalled out in the red zone, coming up two yards short. James Franklin seemed to be ascending to peak Frames Janklin when he appeared to settle for a cowardly field goal, but then ripped off the mask to reveal the real Frames Janklin by faking that field goal, a play that went horribly wrong when Michigan snuffed it out for a fumble and an 18 yard loss (!). 

The Wolverine offense was moribund on its first two drives, damaged by false starts that set them back behind the sticks. As we discussed in the other FFFF, Penn State has a strong secondary and a good pass rush. They are not a team you want to be in long down and distances against, but false starts on Stueber and Vastardis forced Michigan into exactly that. The Wolverine offense couldn't recover. 

Finally on the third possession, Michigan had a mistake free drive. Time of possession was immensely lopsided at that juncture, and a long drive to give the Wolverine defense a break was needed like a fish needs water. That's what Michigan got- 15 plays spanning 90 yards over 7:30 and ending in a TD. A brilliant play call on a Haskins slip screen, helped out by strong vision from Haskins after the catch, kept the drive going, and the senior RB bailed Michigan out again on a 4th & 2 conversion. Cade McNamara capped the drive with a laser down the seam to Roman Wilson for a 21-yard TD. 7-3 Wolverines. 

Roman Wilson: pretttttttty good [Barron]

After a quick PSU three-and-out, Michigan seemed to be poised to add points before halftime. They drove into Penn State territory, but a crucial 4th & 2 at the 38 went haywire on a run that the opposition saw coming a mile away. The Nittany Lions got good field position and moved down the field in a hurry, thanks to a 44-yard catch-and-run from Parker Washington who was uncovered over the middle. Michigan halted the drive after an Ojabo strip sack (PSU recovered), but Stout nailed a 52-yard FG. The score stood at 7-6 at the intermission. 

The road team got the ball to begin the second half, and it was another magnificent drive. Cornelius Johnson went for 30, mostly on the strength of his YAC prowess, and Michigan managed to brush another false start (in the Red Zone no less!) to convert when it mattered. Cade McNamara put immaculate touch on a pass to Erick All that got the Wolverines a 1st down, and then a play-action pass at the goal line saw McNamara zip it to Roman Wilson, for the Hawaiian's second TD catch of the game. Michigan's got themselves a good group of receivers in the program:

Michigan led 14-6. 

It would be nearly 20 minutes until points were put back up on the board by either side. Five of the next six drives ended in punts, while Penn State saw a drive fizzle out at the Michigan 28 and Stout couldn't connect on his third difficult FG attempt of the game. The Michigan offense ran into a ditch, play calls being too predictable, the passing rhythm not quite on point, and the rushing attack banging into a strong PSU front that was keying in on the run. The Wolverine defense did well to keep the Nittany Lions off the board but you knew they were going to face at least one more charge. Indeed they did. 

Sean Clifford took a ton of hits, but he gave PSU a chance to win [Barron]

A Michigan punt from their own end zone gave Penn State the football at midfield and the Nittany Lions stitched together a methodical drive that included three 4th down conversions. Completions to Jahan Dotson moved the sticks on the first two, and then a jump ball TD to a well-covered Tyler Warren got them in the end zone on 4th & goal from the two. PSU went back to Dotson for the two-point conversion, and the likely All-American reeled it in despite good coverage from DJ Turner II. The score stood at 14-14 with 7:35 to go. 

With the game starting to shift against Michigan, their next offensive drive did nothing to stop the avalanche of momentum. Hassan Haskins ran into bodies on first down, a 2nd down passing play to Erick All was batted down at the line, and then a tremendous pass rushing effort from Arnold Ebiketie spun Ryan Hayes around like a turnstile and the DE popped Cade McNamara in the back, jarring the ball free. It was recovered by DT Derrick Tangelo at the Michigan 16. 

For those who wanted Michigan to "make plays!!!" (*engage Mike Valenti voice*), the defense did just that, dropping to one knee and hoisting up a shield to protect the team from the hail of arrows raining from the sky. They sniffed out a Clifford keeper, bottled up a pass intended for Dotson, and then blitzed Clifford out of his shoes, forcing another incompletion. A massive three and out. Stout added a FG that the fortuitous field position had gifted him, but that defensive stand immediately after the fumble single-handedly changed the game. Penn State led 17-14 with 6:00 remaining. 

Take that, pylon cam! [Barron]

With their backs against the wall, Michigan's offense finally showed a pulse on the metaphorical EKG machine. Hassan Haskins started it with his legs, picking up 28 yards on his first five carries of the drive. Facing 2nd & 9 from just inside PSU territory, Cade McNamara found Erick All underneath, who turned the corner in a hurry and was gone. The athletic TE galloped down the sideline, narrowly evading the blue shirts and then stretching the football across the goal line, just before kicking the Progressive Pylon Cam™️. Michigan led 21-17 with 3:29 left. 

Penn State got the ball and went back to the air. A deep shot to Cam Sullivan-Brown just evaded the receiver's arms, a slant picked up eight, and then facing 3rd & 2, they were unable to complete the pass to Dotson. Now at 4th & 2, Penn State went for it on their own 33 and targeted Sullivan-Brown down the field again, which fell incomplete. Michigan took over on downs. 

Needing one first down to ice the game, the Maize & Blue went back to Haskins. The bellcow back picked up 9 yards on his first two carries, and then a Cade McNamara sneak got just enough for the first down on 3rd & 1. After that, the Wolverines were able to kneel it down and salt the game away. 

Good game for Hutchinson and Ojabo... again [Barron]

In totality, Michigan outgained Penn State 361 to 332, and on a per-play basis by a margin of 5.2 to 3.9. Surprisingly, despite the long first quarter, Michigan managed to narrowly win the TOP battle. PSU going 4/6 on 4th down, and ending up +1 in the turnover column (not counting that disastrous fake FG fumble as a turnover), seemed to loom large, but the Wolverines managed to survive despite it. 

The offensive effort was another ode to Hassan Haskins. He rushed 31 times for 156 yards (5.0 YPC), despite never breaking off a huge run. Erick All was the star in the receiving game, with 4 catches for 64 yards and a TD, though Roman Wilson and his two TDs need recognition. Cade McNamara put together another terrific game in a big moment, going 19/29 for 217 yards for 3 TDs and 0 INTs. He did turn it over on the strip sack fumble, but there's nothing you could expect him to do about that. The offensive line play was spotty between the false starts (four of them in total) and a rough day in pass pro from Ryan Hayes, but Michigan put up 361 yards and 21 points on a PSU defense that held Ohio State's menacing offense to 467 yards and 26 points just two weeks ago. 

Defensively, it was not a perfect showing, but there were standouts. David Ojabo and Aidan Hutchinson combined for 5.5 sacks (!!), and were held on just about every play. The referees only called it when it was so egregious that a non-football fan could notice something was up, because that's the life of being an elite pass rusher in NCAA football. The defensive backs passed an important hurdle, tackling decently well on the WR screen, but providing good coverage on a dangerous receiving corps. DJ Turner in particular had another strong game and seems to have really come on strong in recent weeks. 

Michigan is now 9-1 and will likely stay around the top five in this week's CFP rankings. They remain one Michigan State loss from making The Game in late November for a ticket to Indianapolis, and have now likely sealed a ticket to a New Year's Six bowl game, at the very least. It is the first time since 2018, and just the third time since 2007, that Michigan is 9-1 in a season. They play Maryland next week in College Park, before returning home to face Ohio State. That game is scheduled for 3:30 pm on BTN. There is no content after the jump. 

Comments

jmblue

November 13th, 2021 at 4:52 PM ^

What a gutty win.  A guy with a cast on (Wilson) caught two TDs, Haskins was a warrior, Cade bounced back from the fumble, the D got that huge stop … a complete team victory.  

Top 10 teams in football, basketball and hockey.  It’s great to be…

Amaznbluedoc

November 13th, 2021 at 5:53 PM ^

Definitely a gutty win, especially after the fumble which shifted the momentum towards PsU.  Our guys looked like they were on the ropes, but came back and fought back with tenacity and grit.  Very happy for the win, to see JH smile as he ran across the field, and for watching him give props to All in front of national TV.

SecretAgentMayne

November 13th, 2021 at 4:54 PM ^

Best part about a Michigan W is not having the blog’s server constantly crash immediately after with an army of doofuses and their hawt takes about firing Harbaugh and how much he sucks.

Coming out of Happy Valley with the W is never anything to scoff at. Go Blue!!

stephenrjking

November 13th, 2021 at 4:59 PM ^

Huge win. Huge weekend.

Offense definitely needs to learn to put the boot to the throat in the second half. But when they needed to win, they came through.

A win on the road against a good team? Huge. No qualification necessary.

This season has already exceeded expectations. Beat MD to consolidate that, and then… frosting. 

SD Larry

November 13th, 2021 at 5:00 PM ^

This Michigan football team plays with heart, grit, and major league poise.  They have all year too.  Hats off to everyone on the team.  Amazing effort today for yet another big road conference win. Love the chemistry on this team too.  Everyone contributes.  Such a pleasure to root for this team.  9 & 1.  Beat Maryland and Go Blue !

njvictor

November 13th, 2021 at 5:03 PM ^

Glad we pulled this out because we usually don't in these situations, but wow, our offense and defense had chances to put this game away multiple times and didn't. 4/5 on 4th downs I think? About the same number of 3rd and longs for 1st downs? Really frustrating given how much pressure our DL was getting

AC1997

November 13th, 2021 at 5:23 PM ^

I would disagree that it was a perfectly executed fake punt.  Michigan knew it was coming and had a defender right there to prevent the catch....only for him to inexplicably stop and look back.  It was a good play, but one Michigan had dead if not for a bone headed play.  

 

Huge shout out to DJ Turner who has really come on since the bye.  He played well and his PBU on that big third down needs mention.  Gray was iffy but overall the D did well.  

 

Kudos to MacDonald for bottling up their passing attack and dealing with tempo.  I bet he goes to bed at night begging for a do-over against MSU.  He's also doing it with a true freshman at S and LB.....and DTs/CBs that none of us felt good about in the offseason.  

Teeba

November 13th, 2021 at 6:46 PM ^

It’s weird though that Penn State didn’t realize that tempo works a lot better against us when you don’t substitute. For the Penn State fan who wrote the 10,000 word diary defending Franklin, that’s what we mean by him not being a great coach. That, and all the field goal attempts and weird trick plays to show you are trying.

ca_prophet

November 14th, 2021 at 5:50 AM ^

TBF, Franklin has proved that he's good or better at the top 90% of a college coach's job:

1.  Get talent in the door.  PSU is generally 3rd behind OSU and Michigan, with bounces above us.

2.  Coach/develop the players you have and put them in position to succeed.

    a.  Get a staff that works together, knows their jobs and gets the best out of the talent you have.

    b.  Put your stamp on things where you think you make a difference, and delegate where you don't.

The in-game tactical flaws are visible but not as significant as recruiting Clifford, Dotson, Mustipher, etc. and getting them in position to make plays in the first place.

 

crg

November 13th, 2021 at 6:26 PM ^

Watching this season, I still am mostly critical of MacDonald. Our defense hasn't looked spectacular against the better offenses on our schedule (of which, there are not many) and they keep getting burned by the simpler "college stuff": tempo, qb reads/scrambles, etc... moreso than we see from other defenses around cfb.  I feel that part of this is his grounding in NFL mentality, but another is just his relative inexperience.  I still find it hard to believe that a program at this level has a DC (and OC) that both have zero prior experience in that position and are somewhat "learning on the job."  It could work out, but it seems rather risky.

RAH

November 13th, 2021 at 8:53 PM ^

The defense was horrible last year and not much better the year before. It was in a prolonged slide.

The staff was mostly new to their positions and each other. (some were also new to the team)

The talent was universally regarded as weak. Other than Hutchinson the front 7 was thought to be a major problem. Other than Hill the back 4 was regarded as dangerously weak.

The new coordinator had to install a new system that was completely outside the experience of all the players.

Despite all that the defense has become one of the best in the country this year. 

So the facts lead to an inescapable conclusion: The new defensive coordinator is a bad coach. 

Don

November 14th, 2021 at 11:49 AM ^

Despite all that the defense has become one of the best in the country this year. 

So the facts lead to an inescapable conclusion: The new defensive coordinator is a bad coach. 

Perfectly said.

An ideologue is somebody who stubbornly sticks to his narrative even if the facts on the ground run completely counter to that narrative. MGoBlog is full of ideologues.

 

Durham Blue

November 14th, 2021 at 12:32 PM ^

Considering that everyone appeared to have decided that the players on this defense were mostly terrible after last year, and considering that this is--by both stats and the eye test--one of the best defenses in the country, I'd say MacDonald is doing an OK job

This right here.  If this website were not so difficult to use I would find my exact post that predicted the defense this season would be bad.  I am eating crow big time.  Tastes like shit but I wouldn't want it any other way.

WFNY_DP

November 13th, 2021 at 7:47 PM ^

With respect, if your takeaway from today’s game is “our DC isn’t good” then I don’t know what to tell you. Penn State does one thing well: get the ball to Dotson. They try to bait you into singling him by literally putting everyone else on the other side of the field, even to the boundary.

If you’d told me yesterday we were going to hold him to 61 yards receiving—especially after what he just did to Maryland—I’d have taken that all day every day. After the first two drives, it felt like PSU had pulled out all of their stops and we were down 3-0. Total win for the defense.

MacDonald is, in some ways, learning on the job. He’s not perfect, and I can’t say he’s going to be great long term. But, he’s clearly improved as the season has gone on. 

GoBlueZ06

November 13th, 2021 at 9:12 PM ^

Couldn't disagree more. I don't think anyone could've hoped, let alone predicted, that the defense would preform at this level this season given the perceived holes and wholesale staff changes. He has done an OUTSTANDING job, full stop. Gave up 17 points today and didn't break despite being on the field the entire 1st quarter and having to come in with their backs to the wall and only 7 minutes to go in the game. We completely contained Dotson after a whole week of fretting what he would do vs our secondary.

Sure conversions are annoying, you know what matters more? Points. One TD today (and that came against inch-perfect coverage) and only 17 points is job well done. 

crg

November 14th, 2021 at 8:26 AM ^

They were continually out-schemed it terms of the tempo and qb play.  We were fortunate to come out with the win since psu still has relatively little talent at OL & RB right now.  I just watched the replay this morning and we were downright *lucky* that psu didn't score 40+ yesterday.  Granted, our offense also did fall asleep too much - yet our defense should have done more (the Frames factor also helped us - he cost his own team some points).

Don't get me wrong though - I am ecstatic about how the team has done versus initial expectations... I just think that the coaching staff is still showing their inexperience in obvious ways.  If we had played osu or Purdue offense yesterday... I fear we would have been blown out.

1VaBlue1

November 14th, 2021 at 9:50 AM ^

"I just think that the coaching staff is still showing their inexperience in obvious was."

Agree here...  But this is a top 10 defense!  And really, is allowing 17 points with only 61 yards to one of the best WRs in the country, getting out-schemed?  PSU has an offense that was running Iowa off the field until Clifford got injured.  If he's healthy, they average near 40 points/game - and he's clearly more healthy now than he's been since the injury (well, maybe not any longer, after Hutch and Ojabo ate him).

Yeah, if we had played Purdue or OSU we certainly would have been blasted.  Scoring 21 might keep us close in the first half...  I mean, Purdue just put 31 on OSU - and wasn't close!  If Gattis' outfit doesn't put 40 on the board next week, it won't matter how good a game MacDonald schemes...

Blake Forum

November 14th, 2021 at 10:01 AM ^

We had a bit of luck, but this defensive performance wasn't about luck overall. The defense made stands and pulled out big impact plays like strip-sacks--which weren't fluky; they've done that all year--to keep PSU out of the end zone. That's what great defense looks like in 2021. You're simply not going to force all but the most wretched opponents into continual three-and-outs. What you do is exactly what Michigan did in this game: Force your opponent to continually make difficult play after difficult play, under the theory that most teams will screw those up and be unable to assemble many long touchdown drives. Which precisely describes this game, in which PSU's only touchdown required three nail-biter fourth-down conversions

I don't know what MacDonald's career arc will be, but he's turned in one of the great one-season turnarounds of a unit I've ever seen. Let's give him credit for that, and more importantly, let's give this defense credit for what they've done this year

MarcusBrooks

November 13th, 2021 at 10:35 PM ^

After hearing all week that psu running game was trash I thought they did a nice job breaking some plays against us that they hadn’t broken against the better defenses.

Really the most boneheaded play call was the fake FG, their offense had moved down the field twice and had momentum, keep you offense on the field and try to score, the QB wasn’t beaten half to death at that point and a 10-0 lead would have been huge, but Franklin decided to get cute and it backfired spectacularly on him. 
was surprise that at the end we had out gained them by 30 yards, felt like they moved the ball better than that but in the end The TEAM won this game

D held after a huge fumble and it felt like we had a shot and plenty of time, once we scored I was hoping the S could hold one more time and they did, we were able to run out the clock behind the OLine and Hassan picking up hard fought yards at the end.

Team victory 

well done, onto Maryland 

m_go_T

November 15th, 2021 at 11:43 AM ^

The defense has had one bad game, and really one bad half.  They've withstood almost every punch that that's been thrown their way.  Is it good enough to hold OSU to under 20 points, probably not.  But I don't think there are many of those in the history of College Football.  Can they hold them to under 35 points? Nebraska, Penn State, and Oregon have all done that, two of those being in the Shoe.  So we shall see. 

On the flip side, OSU's defense has been its best when it forces a lot of turnovers.  If we keep the turnovers down, I think this is a closer game than a lot of the haters are predicting.  We still haven't seen Michigan play its best game.  Here's hoping to it coming on September 27th.  

RJWolvie

November 13th, 2021 at 8:35 PM ^

Agree with AC: coaches had them ready for that fake, and that kid was exactly in position to make the play, until he inexplicably flubbed it. Was one of seemed like a half dozen plays in first quarter where we were so close to the huge play only to have Clifford make the play instead. Hat tip to that guy: by end he could barely stand and was still playing great gutty football. Too bad for him our guys played even better & guttier by the end

RAH

November 13th, 2021 at 9:27 PM ^

It would be hard not to admire the guy.

He not only showed great personal courage and the ability to play through pain but he was carrying the offense on his back. He's a good, maybe very good, passer even under great pressure. But what really stands out is his ability to use his legs to make positive plays under great pressure. With any normal good passer, their offense would have been utterly stuffed. Only his abilities to scramble and complete passes and to make key yards with his runs allowed their offense to function at all.  It wasn't just the actual yardage and 1st downs he made but the threat of those that opened up other parts of their offense. 

1WhoStayed

November 13th, 2021 at 5:25 PM ^

Ok. This is the 2nd week in a row I noticed this. May have happened more but I usually limit my reading to the board…

Odes it seem weird to anyone else that author Alex Drain quotes (and pastes) tweets from no less an authority than… Alex Drain? Just seems weird. Never noticed anyone else doing that.  

TheBursleyBus

November 13th, 2021 at 5:55 PM ^

think AD must be under 23 years old and is very enthusiastic, somewhat green, prone to sportswriting cliches (one of his first recaps this season actually featured the expression “holes so big you could drive a Mack Truck through”) and still retains the self-referential tendencies (“your author” and his own tweets) that is fairly common among very young writers slightly dizzy with having their own columns.  You’d see this at the Daily a lot.  I think he’s getting better, less hackneyed, as the season progresses, and there’s no doubting that he’s True Blue.  In a few years when he’s seasoned by life and has written many of these he might be at Brian level.

M-Dog

November 13th, 2021 at 5:27 PM ^

It was huge that this was not a white-out night game. 

I have attended many games in Happy Valley and this was one of the most listless crowds I have seen when the game is still on the line against a big opponent. 

A quarter of the stadium just up and left early while PSU was still in it, including students.  The weather was not good, but Penn State fans are used to that.  It should not be a factor.

Clifford and Dotson deserve better for their gutty efforts, frankly.

 

MGoBlue24

November 13th, 2021 at 10:03 PM ^

Yep. I was also there. They’ve just kind of given up. The fans around me were pretty jaded, particularly about their head coach and running game. There was a time in the third quarter after Michigan scored their second touchdown where the stadium was so silent that I heard Michigan’s defense being communicated with from their sideline, on the opposite side of the field from me. After the game, one of the Penn State fans kept yelling “LSU LSU LSU.” When the team departed the stadium in buses to go to the airport, they were followed by the equipment truck, which honked its horn repeatedly. No response except from Michigan fans. A raw day in central Pennsylvania was made a whole lot better by the Michigan win.