Michigan 18, Penn State 13 Comment Count

Ace


Eric Upchurch/MGoBlog

Throw out the records. Ignore the lack of offense. Forget that Penn State's offensive line looks eerily like Michigan's 2013 O-line.

Michigan won a game tonight in front of a packed house of genuinely excited fans, and it felt damn good. Maybe not for much of the game, an ugly slog in which the two teams combined for just 470 yards of offense, several Wolverines went down with injuries—including Devins Gardner and Funchess—and both coaching staffs seemed intent on out-bungling the other, but come that final drive, it felt like Michigan football should.

The stars of this game, without a doubt, were on defense. The Wolverines limited PSU to just 214 yards, with a paltry 65 in the second half after Michigan came out a little flat against the run. Six different Wolverines accounted for the team's six sacks. Jourdan Lewis came up with a critical second-half interception when the defensive front nearly got to Christian Hackenberg again, forcing an ill-advised throw across the field. Mike McCray anticipated a fake punt and displayed tantalizing athleticism in hawking Grant Haley to blow it up two yards behind the line.

When Penn State needed a field goal to tie with 3:44 left, the defense came through with their biggest possession of the night, as Jake Ryan and Frank Clark sacked Hackenberg on consecutive plays to force the Nittany Lions into punt formation from just outside their own goal line. PSU coach James Franklin bizarrely called a timeout to avoid a delay of game—one that would have cost his team about half a yard—before making the correct call to take a safety and go for an onside kick.

What happened next perhaps made up for the blown call at the end of last week's Rutgers game. Penn State recovered the initial kick, but a questionable flag for offsides negated it, and Blake Countess fell onto the ensuing re-kick without any trouble to effectively end game.


Bryan Fuller/MGoBlog

In feelingsball world, however, the star of this game was Devin Gardner, who recovered from a bad interception and an ugly-looking ankle injury to engineer the game-winning field goal drive. Gardner's numbers didn't look great—16/24, 192 yards, 1 TD, 1 INT—but without him on the field for two second-half drives, the offense looked helpless with Russell Bellomy at quarterback. Gardner may be inconsistent—yes, often infuriatingly so—but there's no question he's by far the most capable leader of this offense, and it showed most tonight during his brief absence.

Devin Funchess scored Michigan's lone touchdown of the evening in the first quarter, somehow chasing down a Gardner moonshot and snatching it away from PSU safety Ryan Keiser, who looked like he was preparing to field a punt—after a bobble, Funchess secured the ball and streaked towards the home sideline, arms raised in triumph.

That turned out to be the only touchdown the Wolverines would need, with Matt Wile providing the decisive points on field goals of 45, 42, and 37 yards.

Granted, the running game proved non-existent, the offense remained relatively ineffective, and Brady Hoke gifted Penn State a Hail Mary attempt at the end of the first half by inexplicably taking a timeout with three seconds left on the clock. Those are concerns, to be sure, but they're concerns for another day.

Tonight, we celebrate. Hail to the victors, valiant.

Comments

PAproudtoGoBlue

October 11th, 2014 at 11:26 PM ^

Hail! I don't know maybe a moment of silence, or at least we can stop booing at games. Yea we won, we don't have to be thrilled about the trajectory of this team, but lets enjoy this. Let the kids enjoy this. Maybe we shouldn't get in the elevator with James Franklin and one of the TV broadcasters and announce that an M 'fan' wants to see the team lose so we can fire the coach. CRAZY that's a story told on air tonight. I'm more worried about the trajectory of our  fan base than the team. I love M and I'm not satisfied but I'll be damned before I wish a loss on our Wolverines.

aiglick

October 11th, 2014 at 11:54 PM ^

Our fan base should be and is rightfully recognized for the support tonight even if the leaders in many of our minds are not the right ones to lead our program. Not the fan's fault the comments were broadcasted. Didn't want the team to lose but can understand that unless this team goes undefeated the rest of the way there is no way this staff and AD should be back next year.

PAproudtoGoBlue

October 12th, 2014 at 12:00 AM ^

You can understand an M grad/student/fan wishing a loss on the team? Well I guess you're in a much different place than I am.  I said we shouldn't be satisfied I guess that's not enough for you? You think it's okay to het in an elevator with the opposing teams coach and wish him a W in our house, in The Big House? Okay then you're why I worry about the fan trajectory.

YoOoBoMoLloRoHo

October 11th, 2014 at 11:27 PM ^

turmoil. Hoke definitely hasn't lost the team. Too many injuries and inconsistent performance to be a highly competitive team, but the guys played hard. Gardner battled. Needed this one badly. Go Blue.

Clarence Boddicker

October 11th, 2014 at 11:30 PM ^

Better to win an ugly slog than to lose one. Gardner was a true leader. out there Seeing him scream at the D near the end to hold that lead was moving. Glad too that the attendance was a legit 113,000. However you feel about DB and Hoke--and I have a negative regard for both--the team needed that.

J.

October 11th, 2014 at 11:30 PM ^

From the NCAA rulebook:  http://www.ncaapublications.com/productdownloads/FR14.pdf

Rule 2 (Definitions):

Page FR-33:

ARTICLE 5. A restraining line is part of a vertical plane that limits a team’s alignment for free kicks. The plane extends beyond the sidelines  [emphasis added]

Then, again, page FR-35:

Offside

ARTICLE 2. After the ball is ready for play [...]

Offside occurs when one or more players of the kicking team are not behind their restraining line when the ball is legally free-kicked (Exception: The kicker and holder are not offside when they are beyond their restraining line) (Rule 6-1-2). 

The call is indisputably correct; the player's head was offsides, as shown in the screen capture above.  It's not clear that the announcing team understood the rule, which certainly didn't help things.

BornInA2

October 11th, 2014 at 11:46 PM ^

Once again the announcing consisted largely of buffonery. At one point they blathering on about how PSU played Rutgers last week.

I sure wish I could figure out a way to easily sync Brandstatter with the video feed.

Ponypie

October 12th, 2014 at 2:49 AM ^

showed it even more conclusively: the Penn State player's head and torso were across the restraining line before the kick.

Furthermore, as one NCAA official explained it, there is no real enforcement on a normal long kick, however, " Conversely, on an on-side kick or short kick officials are very strict and enforce the restraining line restriction" (http://en.allexperts.com/q/College-Football-2792/2011/3/offside-kickoff…).

So, no gift was given, even though it may have seemed a rather close call.

GoBlueNorthside

October 12th, 2014 at 9:11 AM ^

I've heard a few people argue that he was "not that far offside, maybe just an inch". But, how do you call the rule then? Is 6 inches enough to be offside? Or is it a foot? How do they judge that?

It makes sense to not enforce it much on long kicks, though

CompleteLunacy

October 12th, 2014 at 2:13 PM ^

I've seen a defensive lineman barely get across the LOS and the offense got a free play out of it.

I guess what I'm saying is it doesn't matter how close it was...offsides is offsides. And yeah it was close, and yeah nobody would have noticed if they didn't throw the flag. But a penalty is still a penalty.

gobluenyc

October 11th, 2014 at 11:31 PM ^

after each of the last 3 weeks, I really wanted to not care, not watch. 

But I watched what was one ugly ballgame, and damn if it didn't feel good to see DG cheering on the sidelines while barely being able to stand. (I do wonder if his accuracy is better when he can't run.)

So proud of these kids for getting up for this game, making some key plays and just winning it.

vulture

October 11th, 2014 at 11:42 PM ^

Blue!  I'm watching them again on The Final Drive and they just look better and better.  I resolve we wear these blue uniforms for ever ever ever and fire Dave immediately.

 

 

Thisisnotmichigan

October 11th, 2014 at 11:47 PM ^

The Minnesota loss isnt looking as totally sucky as it did before.  They beat the Northwestern team that beat Penn State and looked good doing it.  I know I am deluding myself, but any ray of light looks good.

 

Huntington Wolverine

October 12th, 2014 at 7:48 AM ^

Sitting Devin, while costly in the short term, may bear fruit longterm. He seems more zeroed in and I'm seeing less of the sloppy mechanics (they've still been their on the ints against Rutgers and PSU). Admittedly I'm no QB coach but the first couple games it seemed like DG was just willing the offense and that got us into trouble against halfway decent defensive plays.