chatster

January 19th, 2018 at 8:10 PM ^

Excluding Otis Reese (77) who hasn't signed with anyone yet, CB Myles “Spider” Sims - 152, TE Mustapha Muhammad - 171, QB Joe Milton - 179, LB Cameron McGrone - 181, DE Aidan Hutchinson - 194, OT Jalen Mayfield - 306, OT Ryan Hayes - 328, CB Gemon Green - 376, RB Christian Turner - 496

BassDude138

January 19th, 2018 at 2:34 PM ^

I think it is the other way around. They haven't outclassed us on the field, it has been self-inflicted wounds/mistakes that have kept them in the last two games and gave them the opportunity to win. Those results however are probably playing a role in their being able to regularly beat us head to head on the recruiting trail.

goblue4321

January 19th, 2018 at 2:45 PM ^

MIchigan should have won last year and this year, a few bad play calls and refs cost last year and a qb lost it this year, and kind of refs too this year if they knew how to call holding. sooner or later the coaching needs to step it up, the players michigan recruits are good enough, some of these battles for players r won by winning on the field and this is one of those cases with Friday.  

look at alabama and auburn, alabama has had #1 recruiting class 6 or 7 years in a row and auburn has won 3 of last 10, i know thats not much but more than michigan vs osu, auburn did win 7 in a row prior to that. 

Honk if Ufer M…

January 19th, 2018 at 5:35 PM ^

Everybody is shooting in the dark here and making assumptions and guesses while lacking key and relevant inside knowledge of the program.

Some of the thinking, speculating and guessing makes sense and is logical given what info you have or think you have, and based on logical and common assumptions and perceptions of the people involved and things going on or not going on in the program with the staff and players.

I too lack enough inside knowledge, to this point, to make definitive judgements, but when I put all of my data points together that I do know from  from horses mouths and other athletes, along with what I've seen on the field, especially with the bowl game added to various visible coaching flaws and mistakes over 3 years, and extensive info I gathered after that game, I've really lost faith and changed my opinion pretty drastically. 

In one way that's putting a lot of faith into one version of things regarding my change of mind on the future of the program, but in context with what I've seen and things I've heard from more guys than just the one recent one over the course of the last 2 years, everything else supports what I heard recently although each of the previous things only seemed like weird little light red flags at the times I heard them, it all looks differently in total.

I'm afraid there are major fundamental problems in the program that only one guy can cure, and until I hear or see differently I don't see any reason to have hope for needed changes. I think everybody is chasing their tails in all the speculation and that there is no way to even be close to guessing what the deal is without hearing things I haven't heard said in public and am not at liberty to say.

I thought, and maybe still think somewhere deep down, that any coaching flaws could and would be overcome with enough stockpiling of talent and things would start to run under their own steam, but now I'm wondering if all the rational seeming reasons why this has been downish recruiting year but that it will be a blip before the roaring storm of the 19 class and going forward have a lot less to do with the falloff than we thought and that it's really these fundamental problems that don't seem to be fixing and that maybe we won't be stockpiling the kind a talent it seemed like we were headed toward doing and that this whole thing is really going to fail.

I know nobody wants to hear or believe this, and maybe the guy is figuring things out, or will, & is modifying his attitude to save the ship. Hopefully the next time I can speak to someone else & they'll give me a different view of things somehow. 

Maybe we'll have a miraculous year with great qb play and greatly improved receiving and blocking, or enough of the former two to overcome blocking issues, and then recruiting will pick up despite the issues? Ugh.

 

JTrain

January 19th, 2018 at 6:22 PM ^

Dude. You write the longest, paragraph sentences EVER.

I wish I knew what or who or how or why you were talking about insider stuff without references with. It’d be really interesting to know what you were talking about. But we just don’t.

(((GO BLUE)))

DCintraining

January 21st, 2018 at 3:31 PM ^

This fanbase is honestly the worst. Michigan blew a 4th quarter lead in 2016 and aside from the first quarter of this year's game, was dominated by OSU the whole game. Enough with the refs, needed a better QB, etc bullshit. SIck of the pussy excuses

robbyt003

January 19th, 2018 at 2:26 PM ^

So i doubt Upshaw, Welschof, or Hutchinson can play DT.  Do we try and poach someone from a smaller school?  Can't imagine we take 0 DTs in this class.

JimmyFresh

January 19th, 2018 at 2:35 PM ^

I thought the same thing, but Sam Webb made it clear a few days ago on the radio that the staff wasn't too worried if they didn't get a true DT in this class.  With Mone, Marshall, Jeter, Solomon, Dwumfour, and Irving-Bey the staff feels like they have enough bodies.  He also mentioned that the staff thinks Hutchinson and Upshaw might be capable of moving inside at some point.  

Champeen

January 19th, 2018 at 5:00 PM ^

IMO the loss is more psychological than him actually being elite.  I think he is a real good player, but definitely not as good as his ranking suggests.  But shit, Michigan still wanted him and recruited him hard, led for him for a long time, then OSU comes in and snatches him up last minute.

Its more egg on the face than anything.  Keeping Otis is more important than landing Friday was.

 

Navy Wolverine

January 19th, 2018 at 6:05 PM ^

That he wasn't really a take for OSU until they had a couple of flips go against them in December. I think he was really an OSU lean all along but they didn't have room. How can a top 100 DL not be a take under any circumstance? I don't care how good your class is. Again, I think he is overrated and this isn't a huge loss. Agree that Reese (and one of the two OTs) are much more important.

DHughes5218

January 19th, 2018 at 11:13 PM ^

I’ve read on here at least a hundred times, “trust Harbaugh”. This kid was a player that Harbaugh and staff wanted. You may not be impressed with his film but our staff was and that alone makes it a huge loss. Throw in the fact he went to OSU and it’s even worse.

Maizen

January 19th, 2018 at 5:48 PM ^

Yeah, it's totally out of the realm of possibility for him to put on 20 lbs in a college S&C program and play at the same weight as Mo Hurst. If he was a SDE Michigan would have recruited him as such. That they didn't should tell you all you need to know.

Scarlatina

January 19th, 2018 at 9:23 PM ^

One would really hope that most redshirt seniors would be "light years" ahead of a high schooler, both physically and skill-wise.

What was actually being implied is that if Maurice Hurst can have success putting on weight, and being a slightly undersized DT, then there's no reason that Tyler Friday couldn't potentially do the same.

Maison Bleue

January 20th, 2018 at 3:28 PM ^

I am sorry but this is a silly argument. Sure, Mo Hurst played at 280 and Friday could potentially play at the same weight. But the chance that Friday plays as well as Mo Hurst at that weight is rediculously low. Mugsy Bogues played in the NBA at 5'3" 137lbs, so anyone 5'3" 137lbs could potentially play in the NBA, right?