Your unpopular music opinions

Submitted by Monkey House on

Since the sports thread was really fun and interesting I thought a music one might be as well. There seems to be a wide age range on there so it should be pretty fun.

OccaM

February 14th, 2015 at 2:45 AM ^

Unpopular music opinion: Kanye is overrated rapper and his last 3 albums are overproduced garbage. 

Stupid music opinion: Kanye is the downfall of pop music

Read his other posts. Dude writes off a whole genre of music for no reason while trying to come off intellectual on the same topic he wrote off. 

HANCOCK

February 14th, 2015 at 2:46 AM ^

What is so complicated about music that makes Kanye West some undercover genius that only the musically gifted can recognize? 

 

In my opinion, he sucks. His songs are boring and hard to listen to. They used to be decent though, then he decide he was the 2nd coming of Jesus Christ or something and all of his songs got really weird. 

 

I guess if you are really into Kanye, it might be decent stuff, but Id rather just listen to a song and know what the guy is talking about

OccaM

February 13th, 2015 at 4:37 PM ^

I despise people who think you have to play an instrument to be a musician. Not all musicians came from middle to upper class families who could afford the shit to satisfy your elitist view of music. 

Also hate people who think sampling is "stealing." The original artist gets paid too. 

Eminem is the only hiphop most people in Michigan ever listen to. 

Radiohead kinda sucks after OK Computer

 

 

03 Blue 07

February 13th, 2015 at 4:51 PM ^

I get your point and generally agree with you, but your statement that to play an instrument you have to be middle-to-upper class is simply not true. Just like you don't need a baseball glove to play stickball. Some examples: Robert Johnson, Leadbelly, Kurt Cobain (was homeless at various times). In the case of drums, you literally only need your hands to play, or some sticks you can find in a dumpster. In the case of guitar, if you have to, you can use a single string and a broomstick, like many blues musicians have done. In sum, a lack of nice musical instruments does not mean you can't be a musician. 

pescadero

February 13th, 2015 at 6:03 PM ^

Not all musicians came from middle to upper class families who could afford the shit to satisfy your elitist view of music.

 

My wife grew up with a single parent, lived in a trailer (not a manufactured home, a 1969 Detroiter), and spent significant amounts of time on welfare...

 

...and she plays several instruments, all she picked up during her youth.

 

It's quite possible to learn to play instruments and read/write music even if you're dirt poor. You think lots of Delta Bluesmen were rolling in dough and living a middle class lifestyle?

 

 

OccaM

February 14th, 2015 at 3:23 PM ^

Lol yeah you say that now... flip back the clock to the 70s and 80s when turntables etc first started gaining traction (aka actually scratching records) and you'll be shocked. Nice job broadening your definition of instrument to fit your argument. 

MC5-95

February 13th, 2015 at 4:37 PM ^

Out of all of the 2014 inductees into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, Hall & Oates were the best. (Hall & Oates > Nirvana, Kiss, Ronstadt, Cat Stevens, E Street Band, Peter Gabriel, etc.)

justingoblue

February 13th, 2015 at 4:37 PM ^

Not just music, but with anything artistic, I really dislike the idea that "the best" and "favorite" get conflated. I don't look at, watch, or listen to something because I necessarily think it's the best, I partake because I enjoy it, and I don't see the problem with that. Art in general would be very boring if it was nothing but a skill contest.

TL;DR version, even admitting Kid Cudi is probably not a top-10 artist doesn't stop me from listening to the MOTM series more than I listen to a lot of "better" artists/albums and don't see why it should.

03 Blue 07

February 13th, 2015 at 4:38 PM ^

I actually respect Taylor Swift as a musician. Why? Because she writes her own stuff. The difference between playing music and writing music is hard to overstate and/or explain to a non-musician, but writing something and then playing and singing it is significantly harder than playing something someone else wrote.

DonAZ

February 13th, 2015 at 4:55 PM ^

It's just like the reaction to the late 70's Disco and Bubblegum ... Punk emerged (Sex Pistols, Clash).

By the late 80's the hair bands and the synthesized pop stuff was big ... and Grunge emerged (Nirvana, etc.)

New things are almost always in response to existing things.

ldd10

February 13th, 2015 at 4:41 PM ^

Coldplay has some bad songs, but the majority of their music is good - and in fact some of it is great.  They do about as good of job as the "biggest band in the world" can do to generally produce solid music.