WAY OT: Suits for wedding

Submitted by WolverineNick on
Hey everyone, I am getting married this fall and was wondering what the best option is for groomsmen suits, buying or renting? I remember at one point on the board someone had posted that a Michigan grad had a startup that specialized in suits to buy for wedding parties. Is anyone aware of this and what did you do. Thanks!

MGoKalamazoo

June 4th, 2017 at 10:19 AM ^

I'd think the groomsmen would appreciate not having to buy a new suit that will be used once (assuming it has to match whatever colors the bride selects)

oriental andrew

June 4th, 2017 at 8:32 PM ^

A friend of mine (and fellow Michigan grad) also used the Black Tux. It was a decent suit, fit well, and very simple ordering/return process. I had a good experience with them.

Another friend of mine ended up just buying suits from one of those online suit sites (I think maybe Combatant Gentleman or Spier & Mackay). Not too much more expensive than renting and you get a decent suit out of it. 

Zeke21

June 4th, 2017 at 10:28 AM ^

Rent a Tux.  Make the day special. Hopefully you get married just once.

How often do where a tux.  Maybe when M plays Wisky.  Good luck.

Wolverine In Iowa

June 4th, 2017 at 10:41 AM ^

A buddy of mine got married six or seven years ago, and he told us groomsmen that we had to buy a specific suit (can't remember brand) and shirt.  It was implied that he was being directed by a higher authority, if you know what I mean.  I was the only guy outside of the DC area, and so the Nordstrom person at Tysons got me hooked up with Nordstrom near Kansas City.  After a four hour drive, dropping about $900 on suit and shirt, I got the suit tailored here locally in Iowa.  It is a beautiful suit, and it's paid for itself a few times over I think, as I've worn it to a lot of other weddings and funerals and formal events.  Point is, consider buying the suits, but keep it in the budget you think your friends have.

Edit:  Hickey Freeman was the brand.

daveheal

June 4th, 2017 at 11:26 AM ^

You can get decently constructed suits these days from direct-to-consumer brands or the private labels of department stores that aren't incredibly shitty and boxy and most of them would look passable off the rack if you buy the right size. And for $30-$100 in tailoring they can look as good as a suit 3-5x the price. 

S5R48S10

June 4th, 2017 at 11:08 AM ^

Pick a suit that people can wear regularly. A few of my groomsmen have said they use their suit for interviews, meetings, and day-to-day wear. You can buy a decent suit - especially with a group rate - for the same price as a rental, but you get to keep it.

1201 S. Main St.

June 4th, 2017 at 11:19 AM ^

Because of Memorial Day, I was looking around at different suits for myself and my 4 groomsmen.  I was really disappointed by the lack of variety from Men's Warehouse.  I was able to find a nice grey suit from Macy's that was on sale marked down to $220 from $550 so I just ordered those for everyone and told them that would be my groomsmen gift to them, the only thing they would have to pay for are if they need any alterations to the suit.  Some places have good sales sometimes, so I'd just look out for those.

daveheal

June 4th, 2017 at 11:24 AM ^

Either pick an outfit that most adult men can put together with clothes they already own or pick something versatile in the $200-300 range that your friends can afford (navy or grey). If budget is an issue, go with #1. Renting suits that you can't tailor is a recipe for everybody looking like their first chorus concert in 6th grade. 

ghostofhoke

June 4th, 2017 at 11:37 AM ^

I had a summer wedding and went with a navy poplin suit from Jos A Bank. They were super affordable, got the guy at my local store to get the price down to like $120. He took care of everything, it was so easy. My groomsmen just went and got measured somewhere--a local tailor, Jos A Bank, whatever, called him with the measurements and he ordered and shipped them all directly. I paid for the shipping and I bought nice ties from Nordstrom to go with it and that was my groomsmen gift. I really wanted to buy the suits but I had a huge wedding party and couldn't afford that. The guys really liked them, no one already had a poplin suit, it was perfect for spring, summer and I have worn it multiple times since as has everyone else. The guy at Jos A Bank loved it because most of the guys actually ordered a few other things from him and more suits since it was so easy. He crushed it. It was kind of funny because he was a Michigan St grad and the whole deal got started over talking football. Every time I went in the store for what should've been 5 minutes to grab something I ended up being in there for hours shooting the shit. I racked up a bunch of parking tickets in the process. Apparently he got fired a year or two later for cutting some unscrupulous deals--It wasn't my deal that lead to it but I could totally see him crossing some boundaries.

stephenrjking

June 4th, 2017 at 3:22 PM ^

This seems like good guidance. I have some views on this (probably will put them lower in the thread) but it sounds like you found a good price for something that worked for everyone.

Jos A Bank has very high list prices, but they set them there so that they can offer outrageous discounts that sound way better than they really are. Summer suits like that are often affordable, and it sounds like they have some room to negotiate in return for high volume sales. Wouldn't surprise me if that were ok there, given the kind of sales that they offer.

And a navy poplin suit is something that a guy can use.

ghostofhoke

June 4th, 2017 at 5:36 PM ^

Yeah lots of people have thoughts on what has happened to the quality at JAB over the last few years, etc but it was perfect for our situation. They were great lightweight suits which were perfect for spring in the south and qualitywise they were very good. Can't go wrong with a simple, dark suit--can even wear the jacket on its own as a sport coat.

samsoccer7

June 4th, 2017 at 11:43 AM ^

Not sure if this has been stated yet, but a decent suit that's well tailored can look like an expensive suit. But an expensive suit not tailored can look like shit. Go with option 1.

Jasper

June 4th, 2017 at 11:51 AM ^

Unless there's a chance that the suit can -- and will -- be worn more than a few times, go cheap.

Wedding Industry: Batshit insanity.

Johnny Blood

June 4th, 2017 at 11:58 AM ^

The past few weddings I've been in... the groom picks an outfit that most everyone already has (grey slacks, white shirt, blue blazer) and then buys matching ties for the groomsmen which ensures consistency and doubles as a good groomsmen gift.

More importantly, congrats and good luck!

WichitanWolverine

June 4th, 2017 at 12:05 PM ^

My friends and I have all done the men's warehouse rental thing and we've all been unsatisfied with the result. They usually fit poorly and cost at least $200. It's kind of a dick move to ask them to buy a suit but honestly it makes the most sense.

shoes

June 4th, 2017 at 12:24 PM ^

Excuse me for dropping it into this thread but has anyone tried one of these? Pretty pricy ($80-100), unless they are really special.

Pelinka2Voskuil

June 4th, 2017 at 12:42 PM ^

My groomsmen and I wore matching suits and I made the decision to buy. Banana Republic has nice, trim fitting suits and if you sign up for their emails, they are constantly having 40%-50% off sales. You end up getting a nice suit that'll be useful well beyond the wedding for not much more than cost of rental. It also saves you the hassle of nagging everyone for their measurements etc. and picking up/dropping off after the wedding. I waited for a sale, then emailed my groomsmen and said "this is the suit, here's the coupon code, please order yours today." Went with a classic slim cut navy suit and nobody complained.

Don

June 4th, 2017 at 5:11 PM ^

That's what I did. Seems to have worked out all right romance-wise. Still married 38 years later.

I've known plenty of people over the years who had big-ass weddings with all the trimmings whose marriages didn't make it even half as long as ours has.

stephenrjking

June 5th, 2017 at 12:44 AM ^

I'm not a fan of actual elopement (small ceremonies with close family & friends are fine) but it is true that it's not how the marriage starts, but how it continues. The fanciest wedding I've ever been to resulted in an unhappy marriage and a divorce. Relatives of my wife got married on a lawn with little planning due to pregnancy and they remain happily married nearly 40 years later.

 

Muttley

June 4th, 2017 at 4:08 PM ^

and should consist of the congregation watching the game on a big screen.

As the fourth quarter ends and Michigan wins, all in the congregation shout their do/do not question (e.g. "Who thinks it's great to be a Michigan Wolverine?") while the minister/marraige officiant is sure to ask "Do you take one another to be your lawfully wedded spouse?"

The couple says "I do" in unison, kisses, and everyone is happy.

(Oh, and drinks are served throughout the "ceremony".)

ATC

June 4th, 2017 at 1:11 PM ^

Make things easy on yourself...... be quiet, listen to her explain her rationale with her final decision (this may take awhile) and then simply nod and say ".... yup, that's what I was thinking too....". Utilize this technique with future decisions when your opinion might be different but has zero/low consequences if not complete agreement is obtained.

BlueWolverine02

June 4th, 2017 at 2:18 PM ^

suits off the rack don't fit me, so I ordered a custom suit online at Oliver Wicks for under $500. I'll be wearing it at my wedding in two months. not sure I would want to stick groomsmen with that kinda bill though.

blue4ever

June 4th, 2017 at 2:21 PM ^

My daughter is getting married in August. They decided to buy suits because renting is quite expensive and when it's over you have nothing. For the little extra that they paid for a suit the guys all end up with a fitted suit.

Wendyk5

June 4th, 2017 at 2:28 PM ^

My husband's groomsmen wore their own suits. As long as they were dark and not too crazy (like plaid or sharkskin), he was fine with it. My bridemaids wore their own dresses. Black. Got a lot of criticism for that, but we got married at night, and every woman has a black dress. 

Huma

June 4th, 2017 at 2:40 PM ^

The CEO of The Tie Bar is a Michigan grad and their product is amazing. They offer custom suits from their flagship Chicago store which is the cheapest custom suiting I've seen. Their shirts are awesome and are $55 or 3 for $140, which is great for weddings. Ties are $19 and nicer than all of the $100+ ties that I own. Clearly, I'm a huge fan of the brand and highly recommend it. They have been featured in GQ many times and have a very loyal customer base. www.thetiebar.com



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad