Way OT: Military coup in Turkey

Submitted by Jon06 on

There appears to be a military coup in progress in Turkey. This is super OT, but I know there are days when I get all of my news via the MGoBoard, so I thought I'd post it. The coup attempt is frontpage news everywhere, so I'll let you choose your own sources instead of linking anything.

It'll be very interesting to see what happens. As some of you may know, President Erdogan had been fairly effectively trying to expand his power beyond the scope allowed by the Turkish constitution, while more or less waging war on Turkey's Kurdish population. For another bit of background information, Turkish F-16s shot down a Russian warplane 8 months ago, causing an international incident that could have easily had major implications for the US. (Turkey is a member of NATO, so we have treaty obligations that would be hard to ignore if Erdogan were to start a war with Russia.)

Turkey is also a key ally in the fight against ISIS, so this is worth watching for that reason alone. A step back from the direction Erdogan had been tending, including the restoration of peace with Turkish Kurds and cooperation with Syrian Kurds who have often been the most effective opponents of ISIS, would appear to be a great boon to American strategic interests. But who knows what the consequences of a military coup might be.

Gooseggs

July 16th, 2016 at 2:19 PM ^

What is an islamist? Is it someone who practices Islam? Is it an autocratic leader who people disagree with? Is it a tyrant who uses Islam and religion as a shield to do horrible things? I'm not really sure as i see it used in all these contexts frequently as a self serving term and with a presumed negative connotation. In reality, erdogan is no worst than the secular leader that predated him. The secularists would suppress pro religion media, persecute religious people by preventing them from holding public office or positions (basically all prominent jobs w the exception of street and house cleaners at the time). They really oppressed the eastern turkish population and kept impoverished and wo a voice. Erdogan had worked to reverse that and now is going in the opposite direction of trying to suppress the voice of the secularists. It's politics in that part of the world unfortunately.

Sopwith

July 15th, 2016 at 7:15 PM ^

that episode was based on a true story of a guy whose office was above a Kenny Rogers Roasters' restaurant in Manhattan.

NYT LINK

blurb:

The reason he put a hand-lettered sign saying "Bad Food" in his second-floor window on Broadway at 71st Street, he said, was because the new fast-food restaurant below his law office had surrounded the office's window with an awning, bright lights and an illuminated sign. "They made it appear as if I was their dining room," Mr. Lichtman said in an interview yesterday. Whether it was the adornments or the food Mr. Lichtman did not like about the chicken restaurant, Justice Charles E. Ramos of State Supreme Court in Manhattan ruled on Monday that Mr. Lichtman had a First Amendment right to keep his sign where it was. "Were Lichtman to stand outside Roasters, physically approach and scream at customers that they would suffer from abdominal distention after eating Roasters' food, the balance might be tipped more favorably to Roasters," the judge wrote. "However, in this case, First Amendment rights must not be compromised merely because the plaintiff may suffer some loss of profit."

Now what were we talking about?

Wolvie3758

July 15th, 2016 at 6:39 PM ^

is no friend of the US...he is a Islamist who has allowed ISIS free passage way into Syria.

His removal would be a good thing...

Jon06

July 15th, 2016 at 6:44 PM ^

I'm not sure he was positioned to give ISIS free passageway into Syria or not. (ISIS is led by Iraqis from Saddam's old army, who didn't need to go through Turkey to get to Syria.) But otherwise this is what I meant to suggest.

Gooseggs

July 16th, 2016 at 1:11 AM ^

Erdogans govt was buying oil from isis. They were supporting them to combat the muds and also the syrian govt,until they realized isis was batshit crazy. Currently the primary buyers of isis oil is the syrian govt, who has avoided attacking isis throughout their civil war and had helped empower them in order to focus their effort against the moderate rebels. The prominence of isis also helped the syrian govt argument when they claimed they were fighting terrorists and not rebel fighters.

In reply to by Wolvie3758

coldnjl

July 15th, 2016 at 6:53 PM ^

True, but to be fair, ISIS actually just bombed Ankara airport. Turkey may have more problems moving forward than the west because he let them in and build infrastructure. They can do alot of damage in Turkey.

We (The US) may be more pissed at his hostility towards our best ally in the region...Kurdistan (future tense) and the kurds...NOT the NATO allied Turkey.

wolpherine2000

July 15th, 2016 at 8:50 PM ^

He allowed us/was compelled to allow us to launch sorties out of Incirlik against ISIS, and Turkey has done plenty on the ground against them on their own.  Their relationship to the Kurds makes things very complicated, but it is misleading to suggest that they are enabling ISIS. More that ISIS is an enemy of the Turkish Government, but so also is one of the most effective groups fighting ISIS.

FrankMurphy

July 15th, 2016 at 9:13 PM ^

It's true that Turkey was the closest thing to an ally that ISIS had until recently (the recent bombings in Turkey were probably ISIS retaliation for Turkey scaling back its support for that group under US and Russian pressure), but that had more to do with the fact that ISIS opccupied large chunks of Kurdish territory and acted as a buffer to the Kurds expanding their power. Because Turkey has been locked in a decades-long conflict with its own Kurdish minority, Erdogan didn't necessarily view the emergence of ISIS as a bad thing (the whole enemy-of-my-enemy-is-my-best-friend phenomenon). So Turkey's soft support for ISIS is pragmatic and has nothing to do with Erdogan's supposed Islamism. If anything, ideologically, ISIS probably considers Erdogan to be a heretic, but even wild-eyed terrorist barbarians are not above (or beneath?) realpolitik.    

Wolvie3758

July 15th, 2016 at 6:51 PM ^

More journalists are imprisoned in Turkey than in China.....and we all know how China is run

Maximumblue

July 15th, 2016 at 6:54 PM ^

I believe this is actually good news, I was hoping this would occur, the army has a long history of doing this but to the benefit of secular values. El president has been slowly taking absolute control for some time. Hopefully this brings them back.

Maximumblue

July 15th, 2016 at 6:54 PM ^

I believe this is actually good news, I was hoping this would occur, the army has a long history of doing this but to the benefit of secular values. El president has been slowly taking absolute control for some time. Hopefully this brings them back.

stephenrjking

July 15th, 2016 at 11:59 PM ^

Right now this is a world event. No issue in North American domestic politics is directly affected. As long as people refrain from discussing potential responses of particular politicians or branches of government, the no-politics rule is ok. And it seems to be possible to discuss the secular policies of Erdogan without dipping into religious discussion. Politics and religion are needless sources of flame and dissent. Current events aren't off limits.

jmblue

July 15th, 2016 at 7:48 PM ^

I think we draw a distinction between discussing domestic politics (which is inevitably divisive) and international policy, where the two parties don't really disagree that much. If the mods want to lock this, I understand, but I think it's stayed pretty civil.

FrankMurphy

July 15th, 2016 at 9:23 PM ^

The Armenian Genocide technically happened under the Ottomans, but at that time the Ottoman Empire was being run by the Young Turks, a group of secular-minded military officers that seized absolute power in a 1913 coup and reduced the Ottomans to mere figureheads. The Young Turks were a precursor to the movement that established the Republic, which is why Turkey is so adamant about denying that a genocide occurred, despite the overwhelming evidence to the contrary.