mGrowOld

May 3rd, 2016 at 11:02 PM ^

Sorry but Ruddock would just barely make my top 10 if I got to choose a Michigan QB for life.  My list would be as follows (and this based on their QB at Michigan - not as a pro)

1. Ricky Leach

2. Drew Henson

3. Denard Robinson

4. Jim Harbaugh

5. Elvis Grbac

6. Tom Brady

7. Chad Henne

8. Dennis Franklin

9. Brian Griese

10. Jake Ruddock

Wolfman

May 4th, 2016 at 12:15 AM ^

How about top M qb for past year. Interesting as well that Denard is the only qb you listed that wasn't part of a power. Personally, I would have rather seen Denard at RB and that little peckerhead from San Diego keep his shit together for 4 years. Now that would have been exciting.

rob f

May 4th, 2016 at 1:03 AM ^

but I have to ask you why you have Henson as #2 when several QB's on that list  accomplished more while Michigan's QB.

In putting my list together, I tried to look not too much at their stats but rather at their ability to both lead the offense and win within the offensive system  they played in.  Leach and Franklin, for instance, didn't have the passing stats others did, but did very well within the confines of their playbooks.   

My list is a bit different from yours:  its the top  QB's I've seen play at Michigan (been a Michigan fan since the late 60's  and going to games since the mid 70's), so nearly all the QBs on your list make my top 10, just in a different order.   

1) Rick Leach

2) Jim Harbaugh

3) Tom Brady

4) Elvis

5) Denard

6) Brian Griese

7) Dennis Franklin

8) Chad Henne

9) Drew Henson

10) John Navarre

11) Jake Rudock

12) Todd Collins

13) Steve Smith

14) Devin Gardner

15) Demetrius Brown

 

I think I probably would have ranked both Henson and Rudock higher had they been starters for more than one season.  But Henson could have been a 3-year starter and still wouldn't have outranked Tom Brady, who I ALWAYS felt had a much better command of the offensive scheme and of the team itself. 

I also love what I've seen of Rudock.  So much so that if somehow he could have played 2 seasons rather than just one with Harbaugh and his coaching staff, we'd be looking at a 2nd rounder in last week's draft.   I don't follow the Lions closely enough to know who handles their QB's, but I sure hope they don't blow it with Rudock, who I predict will be an NFL starting QB in his career.

 

 

 

Tater

May 4th, 2016 at 7:52 AM ^

Henson only started for one year.  He passed for 2,146 yards that year with a 9-3 record.  How does this make him "better" than Rudock?  

When we look at Henson, we tend to judge him more on what he could have done than what he actually did.  He had one great game against OSU, but John Cooper was still coaching in Columbus then.  

Blue Baughs

May 4th, 2016 at 9:49 AM ^

i think of how we probably blew Bradys senior year trying to shoe horn Henson into games, and how he ditched us for a non existent baseball career.

Great Michigan quarterback doesnt even enter my mind for a minute.

Wolfman

May 3rd, 2016 at 10:15 PM ^

for most TD passes in a game. We're' -  most of us are aware - that the single game record stood forever at 4 because to do otherwise would have been just running up the score. However, when forced to this year in OT, Jake had to throw for six in a game, and I thought that was why he didn't have the record. Looked it up just a bit ago and they said, List was llmited to players who had played at UM their entire career, but I don't know if that was just the wiki page or the university's stand.

Anyone know more?

drjaws

May 3rd, 2016 at 10:43 PM ^

He was sweet for the last 6 games or so. Went from a liability to a leader.

Almost like him as much as Denard now because he kept his head down and worked his tail off.

/golf clap



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

Wolfman

May 3rd, 2016 at 11:06 PM ^

Was reading Fansided and one commenter wrote, in response to Most Likely Starter(O'Korn or Speight?), that not including Morris's name means the writer had niether the knowledge of M football or the expertise to be writing in the first place. I reminded him of the article's title. .

JOHNNAVARREISMYHERO

May 4th, 2016 at 2:21 AM ^

Jake Rudock continues to impress me.   With his play and with the way he carries himself.

He is so humble and well-spoken, such a great respresentative of the University of Michigan.

It was incredible that he became the leader of the team in such a short amount of time.  

He had incredible year for the team and for himself.

His leadership, talents, and wins enabled Harbaugh and the coaching staff to be able to recruit with passion and with results in hand.

Mabel Pines

May 4th, 2016 at 8:01 AM ^

did well here, I can't help but feel for Iowa.   I hope Max B and Spike don't think the same thing as Jake....But they probably do/will.  Sad.