It's time for a new Michigan

Submitted by StoneRoses on

I was at the 2007 Michigan-Appalachian State game with my dad, brother, and friend seven years ago on Labor Day weekend. I remember so well that that was supposed to be OUR YEAR. We came so close the year before we lost to a superb Ohio State team in one of the most heartbreaking games we may ever see, and although we lost in the Rose Bowl a couple of months later, it seemed the program would be sustainably successful and continue to win and win big.

We all know what happened and some of us, like myself, were present for some of these embarassing and mind-blowing losses that some of us never thought were possible. Ironically many years later, in a season which also featured a game against Appalachian State to begin the year, it is clearly beginning to emerge as a year that the football program suffers through an unprecedented, but unfortunately long-needed period of seismic change. How did we get here? I truly believe that we need to self-reflect before we look to hire a new athletic director and staff of football coaches to lead us into the future.

This may have been unspeakable or unthinkable before, but we need to move on from Bo Schembechler's shadow and rebuild Michigan football from the ground up.

EDIT: I forgot to mention, the transition to Bo required Michigan football the rethink itself way back in 1969. We had a history of success before Bo, we can have just as much success going forward if we are ready to move on. Not forget, but move on and look for new influences to rejuvenate this program.

TheRonimal

September 30th, 2014 at 2:08 AM ^

I'm young enough that I don't really have any strong connections to the past other than the last three or so years of the Carr era. I probably have an easier time with the program moving in a new direction than some people. I don't know what that means/how that works exactly, but I'm game for anything at this point. Most of my real Michigan Football memories involve subpar teams. I'd like that to change soon.

flashOverride

September 30th, 2014 at 7:16 AM ^

As someone who remembers the last years of the Bo era and thus all of the Mo and Carr eras, I'm perfectly fine with moving on as well. There's cherishing tradition, and then there's being a slave to it. There isn't just one way to do things. Michigan can fully embrace this (not just go through the motions of doing it like with the RR hire), or can cling to the 1970s and continue losing and being lost in today's changed landscape. 

Wolverine Devotee

September 30th, 2014 at 2:12 AM ^

Let the next coach build the program from the damn near ashes it's in now in his image. I'm talking uniforms, style, mantra. Everything.

BlueHills

September 30th, 2014 at 2:17 AM ^

I'd like to see our University own up to its many errors made prostituting itself at the altar of greed and marketing. The President of the University should step up and make a statement that what has happened recently will never happen again.

I'd like to see Dave Brandon not only be fired, but be too embarrassed to be seen on campus ever again because his lies, greed and bullshit have been outed.

I'd like to see the Clueless One, Brady Hoke, politely shown the door.

Finally, I'd like to see some integrity and class restored to the Athletic Department and to the University.

UMxWolverines

September 30th, 2014 at 2:20 AM ^

We need a complete change of culture in the athletic department. First it was covering up the Brendan Gibbons thing, and now this. Lie after lie. It's bullshit and we need to clean house. Also at this point I would really like someone hired to be the next head football coach with ZERO ties to Michigan.

Tater

September 30th, 2014 at 4:52 AM ^

I would love to see Michigan go outside the good ol' boy network, but what if they pull another LC job on the next coach?  What if so-called "Michigan men" go around telling HS coaches not to send their players to Michigan again?  

Michigan is going to have to clean house, but they are going to have to do it without pissing off the "Michigan men" who still have influence.  It's going to be a tough balance.  

Then again, maybe the next AD can hire a coach from outside of the Michigan coaching tree and tell everyone who doesn't like it to support the program or fuck off.

 

 

Muttley

September 30th, 2014 at 7:28 AM ^

is that we had a realistic shot at Les Miles (or someone similar) but not Nick Saban.

It's long been a defacto Michigan policy not to get into bidding wars.  That may damn well have to change.  $10M/year would go a long way to attracting the next Nick Saban (in performance, not style), as long as the right candidate can be competently identified.

Monkey House

September 30th, 2014 at 2:57 AM ^

I agree with most of your post, and I might be alone on this, but us nor Ohio state were that great in 2006. that season showed everyone what a fraud the Big Ten is. both teams were good, but not great.

Pit2047

September 30th, 2014 at 2:59 AM ^

We don't need a new Michigan, the old one was just fine but we need to realize what it truly was. The ideas of winning the right way not just in football but in life and exemplifying loyalty, honor, respect and just being an all around decent human being are still values that can hold true today. Michigan football is at its core a tough, team first, physical brand of football that does whatever it takes to win within the realm of the rule book. It's not about formations or run-to-pass ratio or big armed QB's or any of that stuff. We are the winningest program ever to play this game, and that's kind of atmosphere we need to get back to and to win you must adapt to the times, even my Pittsburgh Steelers are running elements of the spread and no huddle and the is no reason that we can't do the same. And it's not just schematics that we have to change, we have to switch the whole attitude of this program because today I see an expansion team type atmosphere, we are just another school and it seems like our players just do there four years and are done, there is no love for program anymore amongst the current program, not like before. You don't see it every other school in the country but when you mention Michigan to a former wolverine there is always a smile on his face,a sparkle in his eye and you can just feel an overwhelming sense of pride radiating out from them. That's one of the things I loved most about Michigan and why I became a fan in the first place. I don't see that anymore and really that's what losing does to you, why feel pride in a program that hasn't won as many games as Rutgers since 2007. That's what I want more than anything because I'm a child of post apocalyptic Michigan and I've heard all of the stories and seen all of these videos what it used to be like in the "before time" and it sounds wonderful. I'm 20 years old, I've lived in Ohio since 2001 and the only win against Ohio State I remember was 2011, the only B1G Championships I recall were of the basketball variety, everything before Carr's last game against Florida is a hazey fuzz (less so with the '07 season) and since that point we are 1-5 against MSU. 2007 and the App State debacle is the second best season I remember as a Michigan fan. I graduated high school in 2012, Hoke's first class, and the guys were are recruiting are remembering less and less of the before time and before long we'll be the Dallas Cowboys who I've only seen Quarterbacked by Tony Romo. Sure people talk about the team they used to be with Staubach and Landry, Jimmy Johnson and Troy Aikman and Michael Irvin but I never saw them and I don't remember being in a world where the Cowboys were good at football. All I know of them is Jerry Jones and Tony Romo, and if we don't hit a home run with the next coaching and AD hires, we will become the Dallas Cowboys of College Football. We need to remember how we got to a place where 9-4 was a fireable offense and go back to doing that.

TL;DR back to basics, evolve with the times, improve attitude, find our pride and passion again, don't be the Dallas Cowboys

LSAClassOf2000

September 30th, 2014 at 8:13 AM ^

If there is an approach which would probably be the easiest sell, if there is indeed a call for a "new Michigan", then you may have hit upon it, in my opinion. Taking the core values, the things that make Michigan what it has traditionally been, and pushing them forward into the now is probably what needs to happen within the football program. 

I said the other day that one of my morbid fears about what was going on within the program and really the athletic department in general is that a preconceived ideology of "Michigan football" was drawn up in the chaos of post-RR January 2011 and people have been asked to assume roles within it regardless of their actual talents, even down to the level of the players perhaps as it is a top-down push. 

If that is the case, then the inverse approach probably would have been less harmful by far - hire people that exude the values you seek but let them build the team around those, and if it incorporates elements which so repulsed the game's traditionalists, that's fine and you've done no disservice to your history as a program because those values should be timeless. 

Danwillhor

September 30th, 2014 at 3:16 AM ^

I've been saying this for years now. We'll never forget the man but we have a legit cult of personality regarding him. I've only seen psu do it worse with Paterno and even if that gnarly shit didn't go down it's not healthy. You have to move on, adapt, evolve and change. I'd love one of the Harbaughs but not because of their "6 degrees of Kevin Bacon: Bo Edition" link to the program. Remember him but remember that he loved winning. Our only criteria regarding a HC should be if they are winners and clean (as much as one can be in modern CFB). That's it.

CoachBP6

September 30th, 2014 at 6:31 AM ^

Michigan needs to go modern.  Brian has talked about it at length.  There is no doubt that we need to move on and bring this team into the 21st century.  We cannot continue to chase the past.  Football is a game of continuous change.  Those who refuse to change are left in the wake of the teams that embrace it.  Very hopeful that the next football coach comes in and gives us a huge culture change.  GO BLUE

Umich97

September 30th, 2014 at 7:38 AM ^

...as long as that doesn't mean basketball on grass. I still think the best path to championships is via a dominant defense. Whether it's been the West Coast offense, the read-option, or whatever new offense someone comes up with, no matter how innovative, it never makes up for a sub-par defense.

huntrt1

September 30th, 2014 at 7:08 AM ^

Until the powers that be drop this Michigan man bull shit this is what we as fans are going to get. They bring in the best men for the job and we support them to the fullest. These next hires need to be home runs and I dont give two shits where they ate from or who they were attached to previously. Im pretty sure John Beilein had 0 roots to the Michigan program and that man has done a phenomenal job. Sometimes its best to let the past be in the past and move forward. Im all for a house cleaning. From the AD all the way down to the water boy if thats what it takes to bring the once glorious and powerful team of Michigan Freakin Football back to where it belongs in the conversation of being a national contender then so be it. Right now this program is in a terrible place and only getting worse. Heres to the future and as always GO BLUE!

BlueGoM

September 30th, 2014 at 7:24 AM ^

We need Harbaugh.  John,Jim, doesn't matter.   Pay Harbaugh whatever he wants, give him lifetime free Zingermans, lifetime free AATA bus passes, whatever it takes.

 

MGoStrength

September 30th, 2014 at 7:45 AM ^

Change is hard for UM because of it's strong ties to the past successes.  While it seems some change is neccessary I highly doubt the program and the fans want to forget about all the great traditions and legends of the past.  But, it's one think to remember the past it's quite another to try and relive it, which is what Hoke seems to want to do...be Bo.  We all loved Bo, and while we will never forget him, we need our coaches to be their own unique individuals who aren't trying to be someone else.  I think UM went too far way from it's tradition with RR, then went too far the other way with Hoke to overcorrect.  The fact is we probably need some middle ground.  Someone that understands UM, while at the same time doesn't neccessarily have a previous history of coaching or playing there.  Unless we can get one of the obvious big name, proven coaches, but I don't see that happening.

stetgor

September 30th, 2014 at 7:46 AM ^

initially referred to the ideals that Michigan stood for, not that he was connected with the University at some point in the past, whether within a short or long-term tenure.  If that's correct, we don't have to forget the past, we should embrace it and appoint coaches whose value set reflect that (and you know, actually be able to coach) - regardless of whether they've ever worn Blue before, or not.

Year of Revenge II

September 30th, 2014 at 8:46 AM ^

We should not, and need not, forget Bo or his contributions to UM's traditions and legacy to move on.  

I am just one person, and just guessing, but my 57 years of UM fandom (I was 4 when I went to my first game), my UM degree, and my knowing in what esteem my grandfather and father before me held UM principles and tradition, all tell me that Bo would not have supported the chicanery and incompetence that passes for UM football leadership in 2014.  

And you do not have to invoke Bo's name, or pledge to move on from him whatever the case may be, to see the writing on this wall.

It is past time for real leadership at this University to release DB back to the world of corporations and profits where he seems to flourish, and to release BH and his minnions to the MAC, high school, or the Cartoon Network.  No disrespect intended, but these people have to start respecting themselves before they can earn it with anyone else.  

If Bo had a fault, and we all have them, it was loyalty to a fault. I agree it is way past time to leave Mo, Carr, their grad assts or line coaches (eg, Brady Hoke), their end-of-the-benchers (eg, Dave Brandon), to posterity, some good, some very bad.  

It is hard to imagine a worse state of affairs than what exists on Tuesday, September 30, 2014 with respect to the University of Michigan football team and athletic department.  In the name of all who have gone before them, and all who will follow them, thank DB and BH for their service and let them go, TODAY, if possible, but as soon as reasonably appropriate for the University, its football team, and the individuals involved.  

Start with a new AD, and a new coach.  Forget this "Michigan Man" BS.  It was coined by Bo to get past the shenanigans of his then appliance-salesman coach Bill Freider, who bolted to ASU on the even of the NCAA tourney and expected to stay on through it at UM. Nothing more, nothing less.  Michigan Men attempt to live up to certain principles in my humble opinion, not just pay lip service to them.  If DB and BH are the Michigan Men they claim to be, they would resign for the good of the University's football team and athletic department.  We shall see what they are made of, but it does not look good.  

The University is bigger than its football team or athletics.  It stands for much more than that.  However, its football team and athletices have for the most part been reflective of the standards of excellence of the University as a whole.  It is time to recognize how far we have gotten from that state of affairs with these people at the controls.  Lets rebuild the house on a firm foundation, and that can only start by clearing the site.

Blueballs

September 30th, 2014 at 9:22 AM ^

I've followed Michigan Football since the mid ten-year war as kid. Over the course of that time ive never seen the program so mishandled, so unglued and a coaching staff that is so horrible. They are getting worse every day.

How did no one on the staff not seen that hit? Especialy the QB coach and back up QBs? And this third stinger Bellemy who pulled a Thurman Thomas and couldnt find his helmet. What kind of coaching is that? Embarassing.

I used to look forward to Michigan games and have been to seveal dozen over the years because I knew Michigan would compete, win or lose, they would always compete. Now... the last ten years have just been painful to watch a once stong school of tradition, pride and competitiveness slip down the ladder to... this... I dont even have words for it.

With recruits acting like rats leaving a sinking ship, a cluless head coach, a coaching staff thats not watching players (but watching the game), an embarassing ad of giving away tickets with Coke... is this rock bottom? If not I hate to see whats next.