ESPN's "Way-Too-Early" All-American team

Submitted by Blue@LSU on January 24th, 2024 at 10:04 AM

While most of us are still basking in the glow of the National Championship, the rest of the college football world is already looking forward to next season. We have preseason rankings, preseason Heisman favorites, preseason All-American teams, etc. Of course, none of these really matter, but it’s always fun to look at the projections.  

ESPN has put out it’s Way-Too-Early All-American team. Here are the most represented teams (and Colorado). 

  • OSU: 6
  • Alabama: 5
  • Georgia: 5
  • Michigan: 4
  • Colorado: 2 (Travis Hunter and Travis Hunter)

Here’s the full list (I only included the blurbs for Michigan players).

OFFENSE

QB: Carson Beck, Georgia 

RB: Ollie Gordon II, Oklahoma State 

RB: TreVeyon Henderson, Ohio State 

  • Second team: Quinshon Judkins, Ohio State

WR: Luther Burden III, Missouri 

WR: Tetairoa McMillan, Arizona

TE: Colston Loveland, Michigan

The 6-foot-5 Loveland bulked up to 245 pounds and emerged as a staple in the Wolverines' offense on their way to the national championship. He finished third on the team with 45 catches, averaging 14.4 yards per catch, and hauled in four touchdown receptions while earning first-team All-Big Ten honors. There will be several high-quality tight ends around the country in 2024, but Loveland's skills as both a receiver and blocker pushed him to the top of the list.

OT: Will Campbell, LSU

OG: Tate Ratledge, Georgia

C: Parker Brailsford, Alabama

OG: Donovan Jackson, Ohio State

OT: Kelvin Banks Jr., Texas

All-Purpose: Ashton Jeanty, Boise State

 

DEFENSE

DE: James Pearce Jr., Tennessee

DT: Tyleik Williams, Ohio State

DT: Mason Graham, Michigan

Graham was an integral piece of a Michigan defense that was the backbone of the Wolverines' national championship team. He returns as one of the top interior defensive linemen in college football after earning first-team All-Big Ten honors. The 6-3, 318-pound Graham played with a broken thumb through much of last season and was at his best in the postseason.

DE: Ashton Gillotte, Louisville

LB: Harold Perkins, LSU

LB: Deontae Lawson, Alabama

LB: Barrett Carter, Clemson

CB: Travis Hunter, Colorado

CB: Will Johnson, Michigan

In 2023, Johnson went from being one of the best freshmen in the country to one of the best cornerbacks in the country. He's poised to be even better next season after earning consensus first-team All-Big Ten honors. Johnson (6-2, 202) has great size for a cornerback and didn't give up any touchdowns in 321 coverage snaps. He was the defensive MVP in the national championship game.

S: Caleb Downs, Ohio State

S: Malaki Starks, Georgia

 

SPECIAL TEAMS

K: Graham Nicholson, Miami (Ohio)

P: Alex Mastromanno, Florida State

Returner: Zachariah Branch, USC

StateStreetApostle

January 24th, 2024 at 10:17 AM ^

Big Will Campbell!  Knew the switch to O-line would pay off for him...just not at LSU

 

...ok ok downvote away but this was an admittedly subpar attempt at humor, not a 'this guy lives in a world where UM's Will Campbell apparently is NCAA-tenure-tracked'

denardogasm

January 24th, 2024 at 10:19 AM ^

I have a hard time believing Kenneth Grant won't be one of the top 4 DTs in the country next year, but outside of that at least our representation seems fair. We have a lot of confidence in the roster around here but from a national perspective there are a lot of unproven commodities. Lil' Parker Brailsford first team center though? Michael Penix Jr. might place his vote elsewhere.

Amazinblu

January 24th, 2024 at 10:20 AM ^

I'm still basking in the NC - and will continue that until game week of the opener - so, about August 25th.

This being said - I'm looking forward to the Spring game - how Michigan can maintain the culture - and this preseason recognition - especially on defense, is fun to peruse.

Go Blue!

P.S. OSU, Georgia, and Bama at the top of the list isn't a surprise.   Those three teams will most likely be the Top Three in 247's Team Talent Composite for the '24 season.

Amazinblu

January 24th, 2024 at 11:52 AM ^

I agree.  Hopefully, OSU will be favored in The Game.   There's nothing quite like having the analysts / pundits think that Michigan doesn't have a chance.  

During this season's CFP - it was wonderful that most everyone felt "there's no way Michigan can slow down Bama or defend Milroe" - as well as thoughts about "Washington's passing game and Joe Moore award winning OL will be too much for Michigan to answer."

Looking forward to every media outlet praising the Buckeyes and their amazing roster.

The team, The Team, THE TEAM.

Go Blue!

Blau

January 24th, 2024 at 12:09 PM ^

If the transfer portal provides one positive perspective, it’s that we might see a reduction in the stockpiling of talent at skill positions across the top P5 programs, especially for players who care less about the NIL paycheck and more about playing time.

I’m honestly shocked that OSU has been as successful in their transfer pursuits as you only have so much playing time to go around and I imagine their highest rated recruits have got to be looking elsewhere.

enlightenedbum

January 24th, 2024 at 10:21 AM ^

Excuse me, but guy who couldn't get the job over Sir Can't Snap The Damn Ball is an All-American now?  (Booker)

We abused Brailsford but with some added weight I can see it.

Greatgig

January 24th, 2024 at 12:47 PM ^

I feel like it makes your list useless if you put two guys, from the same team, at a singular position, as 1 & 2 on your preseason AA list. Show me where the guys splitting snaps have ever both been AA's?! It just comes across as lazy. 

It's also satisfying knowing that Michigan's DT's worked them both

bluesong

January 24th, 2024 at 10:25 AM ^

IF Michigan doesn’t win it (I said IF) I think Georgia easily outclasses OSU. Georgia is stacked again and I think OSU is getting the benefit of having the hype train around their recent portal signings.  

goblu330

January 24th, 2024 at 10:36 AM ^

The issue with OSU is not talent, it is perspective.  Ohio State views it as unfathomable that they lose to Michigan, so they consistently overreact by making "big moves" in response to it.  Honda McCord was starting to look like at least a CRV, which..... ya know, sometimes a CRV is exactly what you need.  I think they really should have tried to hold on to him for continuity, and that shuffling the deck again is ultimately going to result in another loss.

MichiganFootball

January 24th, 2024 at 11:29 AM ^

I think the thing with Ohio State is it’s not at all clear that they’ve upgraded at QB

https://x.com/ryan_mccrystal/status/1742623671649178076?s=46&t=QbxrWtEaCS2wqoCERaDR2w

I also think they aren’t where they need to be on the offensive line.  
 

It’s also unclear how it’s going to work with Bill O’Brien calling the plays as opposed to Day.  Though I’m sort of half convinced at this point that it was Kevin Wilson who was the real brains of the offense, not Day.

Amazinblu

January 24th, 2024 at 10:38 AM ^

^^^  This.   A great comment that I agree with.

The primary question I have about Georgia for this season is - how effectively will the "alternatives" to Bowers mature.  Bowers was one of the most important aspects of Georgia's offense - both the ground and air game.  

Georgia has talent that can receive the ball.  Beck looked fine this season.   The key will be maturity and growth in the passing game.   

Georgia's schedule also has a few interesting games three of which are on the road - at Bama (which I think Georgia wins), at Texas (which should be a great game worth watching), and at Ole Miss.   They open against Clemson (in Atlanta) and will finish SEC conference play in middle November - finishing their season with home games against UMass and Georgia Tech.

Amazinblu

January 24th, 2024 at 11:48 AM ^

The Georgia v Clemson opener will draw a lot of eyes - however, I think the luster is off of Dabo and Clemson.   My guess is that Clemson will start the season 0-1, while Georgia will try to make a statement.  It could be very ugly.

Looking at the Clemson schedule - a couple of things.  Clemson is ranked 19th in ESPN's way too early preseason poll.  First - they play at FSU (preseason 16 according to ESPN), and - hosting Stanford (a new member of the ACC).   Second, their schedule isn't exactly compelling - with two other "Top 25" matchups - hosting both NC State (20th) and Louisville (22nd).

According ESPN's Way Too Early Top 25 - the highest ranked non-B1G / SEC teams are Arizona at 9th and ND at 10th.  So - the B1G and SEC are positioned to have a strong presence during the '24 season.

MGolem

January 24th, 2024 at 1:07 PM ^

I live in Georgia and am friends with a former UGA great (who occasionally passes along some insider tidbits). Georgia is the smart money next year. Yes their schedule is difficult but Kirby Smart is different. He is not Day. This guy is a proven winner and single minded in a way I think few other coaches are (think Saban but 25 years younger). He is not leaving for the NFL. He is not moving to another school for a bigger check. Returning an experienced star QB is the single biggest advantage in college football and Beck is already looking like a top 10 pick. I would not be shocked to see OSU have a great year and be in the running but I don't think they can keep up with Georgia.

blueheron

January 24th, 2024 at 10:39 AM ^

Remember, everyone: If OSU "breaks through" next year and ends the multi-year drought against UM, it will be because they obviously purchased their team (as opposed to the semi-obvious purchases they've been making since the Tressel years and probably beyond). :)

Once again, I'd like to know what sports journalists get (Hookers? Blow? Steak? All of the above?) when they travel to Columbus. There's no end to the good PR for that program.

Amazinblu

January 24th, 2024 at 11:37 AM ^

For the '23 season - Bama had 18 five star players, and O$U had ten.   Michigan had two (2).

I liked the on the field results of both the O$U and Bama games last season.

It seems probable that the Buckeyes will have more five star talent this season - than they had in '23.

As we all know - it's not only a player's ceiling - it's development - scheme - smarts - culture - and quality of execution.   

Go Blue!

JonathanE

January 24th, 2024 at 12:51 PM ^

I liked the on the field results of both the O$U and Bama games last season.

That's good and all, but Michigan isn't bringing, JJ McCarthy, Blake Corum, Roman Wilson, Cornelius Johnson, AJ Barner, Karsen Barnhart, LaDarius Henderson, Trente Jones, Trevor Keegan, Zak Zinter, Drake Nugent, Kris Jenkins, Jaylen Harrell, Braiden McGregor, Michael Barrett, Junior Colson, Josh Wallace and Mike Sainrisitl with them to Columbus in 2024. The on-field results playing O$U in 2023, may not be the same in 2024. This isn't even addressing who the head coach and say the defensive coordinator will be in 2024. 

chatster

January 24th, 2024 at 3:42 PM ^

Add kicker James Turner and long snapper William Wagner to those who won’t be playing for Michigan in Columbus next season AND . . . the possibility that Michigan will have a different head coach, defensive coordinator and special teams coach in 2024, then it’s reasonable to think it will be very hard for Michigan to beat Ohio State next season with a completely new, less experienced and possibly less talented offense (except for the only returning starter, Colston Loveland and running back Donovan Edwards).

goblu330

January 24th, 2024 at 10:34 AM ^

My son got pictures with both Loveland and Moore at Somerset.  I am definitely hanging onto both because I think they could be significant collectors items at some point.  Loveland, particularly.

50shadesofHARBAUGH

January 24th, 2024 at 10:35 AM ^

These lists are always dumb, especially this early. But question, when was the last time a team had two All American running backs? They have both Ohio st RBs. That seems extremely unlikely almost impossible? 

PopeLando

January 24th, 2024 at 10:41 AM ^

If Ohio State calls enough runs this year for their backs to even qualify…they win the Championship. 

I swear to the almighty spaghetti monstrosity that Day and Harbaugh have exactly opposite philosophy: Day will lean on his QBs and WRs to a fault even when he has NFL talent at RB. Harbaugh will lean on his running game to a fault even when he has NFL talent at QB and WR. Whoever tiptoes toward a balanced offense first wins. 

Oh, and I’m not so sure about Loveland on this list. Great receiver, for sure. But when a block NEEDED to be made this past year, we went with Barner. My hot take is that Barner was secretly TE1 basically all year.