This list only includes prospects that I think are worth mentioning at this point. Meaning that I think there's still a chance for Michigan. If you think I missed someone, let me know.
further adventures in Jed York being unsuited for his position
The Rivals top 100 came out yesterday and there seemed to be a lot of confusion about the lack of midwest prospects. The complete 250 rankings are now out and it's looking a little more balanced. Here's a look at the top 250 prospects that Michigan is still in on with a little commentary as well.
|Overall Ranking||Position & Name||State||Star Ranking||Summary|
|#1||WR Dorial Green Beckham||MO||5 Star||Without an elite QB like Zeke Pike in this class don't get your hopes up.|
|#4||DT Eddie Goldman||DC||5 Star||Goldman still lists Michigan as a school of interest, but there won't be much to go on until he visits.|
|#6||DT Ellis McCarthy||CA||5 Star||McCarthy has expressed interest in Michigan, but I wouldn't be surprised if he stayed on the west coast.|
|#8||WR Stefon Diggs||MD||5 Star||Michigan is still in the conversation, but until he visits there might not be a lot to go off of.|
|#13||DE Noah Spence||PA||5 Star||Spence lists Michigan as a school of interest, but it will take a lot for them to reel him in.|
|#15||OL Andrus Peat||AZ||5 Star||Andrus' brother Todd committed to Nebraska in the 2011 class. I would be surprised if he picked Michigan.|
|#19||QB Gunner Kiel||IN||5 Star||Kiel took a visit to Michigan recently. He's very quiet as far as media attention. I have a feeling a school like Oklahoma has a good shot with him.|
|#28||OL Kyle Murphy||CA||4 Star||Murphy has expressed a lot of interest in Michigan. They have a decent shot, but again I wouldn't be surprised if he stayed on the west coast.|
|#29||DT Tommy Schutt||IL||4 Star||Schutt hasn't mentioned Michigan in awhile. If they can get him to visit they might have a chance, but it looks like they're on the outside for now.|
|#31||OL Zach Banner||WA||4 Star||Banner has expressed a lot of interest in Michigan, and plans on taking an official.|
|#32||WR Durron Neal||MO||4 Star||Just received a Michigan offer, we'll see how much interest he has.|
|#34||OL Erik Magnuson||CA||4 Star||Magnuson is very interested in Michigan, they have a good shot.|
|#37||ATH Devin Fuller||NJ||4 Star||Fuller has been relatively quiet lately, but he has maintained that he will visit Michigan in the summer. We'll know more once that happens.|
|#45||OL Jordan Simmons||CA||4 Star||Simmons has a lot of interest in Michigan. He's taking things slow for now. He has genuine interest in Michigan, but I wouldn't be surprised if he stayed out west.|
|#48||DE Ifeadi Odenigbo||OH||4 Star||Odenigbo has Michigan on the outside of his top group that includes Ohio State, Stanford, and Notre Dame. He plans on taking a visit to Ann Arbor in June, so we'll see if that changes anything.|
|#55||RB Keith Marshall||NC||4 Star||Marshall has Michigan in his top ten, but I believe he'll end up staying down south.|
|#60||DE Tyriq McCord||FL||4 Star||Just received a Michigan offer. I haven't spoken to him yet about where he's at.|
|#61||DE Se'von Pittman||OH||4 Star||Pittman has expressed interest in Michigan, and it seems like there's a shot.|
|#65||DB Deon Bush||FL||4 Star||Early on Bush had expressed some big time interest in Michigan, but it seems like that's slowed down. I wouldn't be surprised to see him stay in Florida.|
|#67||DT Jarron Jones||NY||4 Star||Jones is committed to PSU, but recently told an ESPN analyst that he still plans on visiting Michigan in the summer.|
|#72||QB Zeke Pike||KY||4 Star||I'll just keep him on here because it's not signing day yet.|
|#74||ATH DJ Foster||AZ||4 Star||DJ just received a Michigan offer. Oregon is probably his early leader, but he said he would like to visit Michigan.|
|#86||DE Adolphus Washington||OH||4 Star||Washington recently told me that he's wide open and really likes what the Michigan coaches are about. He'll be a package deal with teammate WR Dwayne Stanford. Ohio State may be tough to beat.|
|#88||DE Greg McMullen||OH||4 Star||Ohio State will be tough to beat for Greg as well. Anything can happen though with the NCAA investigation looming.|
|#93||WR Dwayne Stanford||OH||4 Star||Same situation as Adolphus Washington.|
|#96||WR Jordan Payton||CA||4 Star||Committed to USC, but will be taking looks at other schools. Michigan is a school that he really wanted to hear from.|
|#103||OL Max Tuerk||CA||4 Star||He spoke very highly of Michigan, and it seems like they have a shot. It's California though so he may end up staying closer to home.|
|#124||RB Bri'onte Dunn||OH||4 Star||Fresh off a visit to Michigan, Dunn is watching the NCAA investigation very closely at OSU. There's a lot that could happen here.|
|#130||OL Evan Boehm||MO||4 Star||Says he has interest in Michigan and would like to make it up for a visit. Until then I wouldn't get excited.|
|#134||WR Aaron Burbridge||MI||4 Star||Burbridge was just in Ann Arbor with now Michigan commits Devin Funchess, Mario Ojemudia, and James Ross. He will be back up with his mother within two weeks. He'll be choosing between Michigan and MSU. Michigan has a real shot.|
|#136||ATH Davonte Neal||AZ||4 Star||The Michigan coaches stopped in Scottsdale to check out Davonte this past week. No offer yet, which is surprising. I think he'll end up staying out west.|
|#137||OL Paul Thurston||CO||4 Star||Thurston actually just took a trip to Ann Arbor. I think Michigan has a very good chance here.|
|#139||DB Wayne Morgan||NY||4 Star||Morgan's coach has told me that Michigan and Rutgers are at the top of Wayne's list. Michigan has been making a surge, and I wouldn't be surprised if they have taken the lead over the hometown Scarlet Knights.|
|#140||DT Jaleel Johnson||IL||4 Star||Johnson was just offered by Michigan and plans to visit relatively soon. He's starting to gain some attention from Ohio State. I think Michigan has a real chance here.|
|#152||OL Kyle Dodson||OH||4 Star||Dodson has seen his recruitment take off with offers from Alabama and Auburn recently. He still maintains that Michigan is one of his top schools. I think they have a good chance.|
|#184||RB Greg Garmon||PA||4 Star||Garmon should be visiting Michigan in the next couple weeks. They are in the top three with UNC and Penn State, but I think Michigan is behind both.|
|#187||DB Armani Reeves||MA||4 Star||Reeves will be narrowing his list down soon, but has said that Michigan will be right in there. I think he has some schools in mind that stick out, and I also think Michigan is in pretty good standing right now.|
|#191||OL Shane Callahan||CO||4 Star||Callahan has mentioned Michigan as one of his favorites, and I think there's a good shot here.|
|#194||WR Amara Darboh||IA||4 Star||Darboh has told me that he's intrigued by Michigan, but I wouldn't be surprised to see him pick elsewhere.|
|#195||DB Terry Richardson||MI||4 Star||Terry could be deciding as early as next week. With his friends on board Michigan has a really good shot.|
|#209||OL Jordan Diamond||IL||4 Star||Diamond has been public with how he feels about Michigan. He plans on taking his time with everything, but Michigan is in great shape.|
|#222||DT Danny O'Brien||MI||4 Star||There's been a lot of questions about Danny lately and where he's at with Michigan. I think Michigan has backed off of him a little bit, but I'm not sure why.|
|#231||DT Tom Strobel||OH||4 Star||Strobel has said he wants to visit Michigan. If he does then they have a shot. Ohio State might be tough to beat.|
|#242||OL JJ Denman||PA||4 Star||Denman has Michigan in his top group and has said he really likes Michigan. I think they have a good shot with JJ.|
|#246||DT Ondre Pipkins||MO||4 Star||Pipkins really likes Michigan, has connections with former Michigan players, and still has relatives living there. Michigan has a very good chance with Ondre.|
By my count that's 45 prospects in the top 250 that Michigan is recruiting and has somewhat of a chance with. Before you ask, yes I'm surprised that Chris Wormley isn't in the top 250. That seems weird.
I think Michigan has a realistic chance with a good amount of these top 250 players. Among those are:
DT Ondre Pipkins, OL JJ Denman, OL Jordan Diamond, DB Terry Richardson, OL Shane Callahan, DB Armani Reeves, OL Kyle Dodson, DT Jaleel Johnson, DB Wayne Morgan, OL Paul Thurston, WR Aaron Burbridge, OL Erik Magnuson, and OL Zach Banner.
This list only includes prospects that I think are worth mentioning at this point. Meaning that I think there's still a chance for Michigan. If you think I missed someone, let me know.
Do you really believe Michigan still has a shot with this kid? Is he still taking visits like Dunn?
I have him in there just in case. Like I said, it's not signing day yet. I think anything can happen.
I know what you're saying, But deep down, I was hoping you'd say you knew something was about to go down in Auburn... Lol
Is he another Marvin Robinson/Ricardo Miller? I thought he was borderline 5-star?
Add me to the list of folks who really appreciate all of your hard work. This is a very helpful and easy to follow table.
Which is good. I would expect that the commitment train to slow a bit now, outside of the possibility of Richardson, just because these kids have so many offers and are trying to take all the visits and everything in. Nice to be in good position early though, and seems we should be able to pick some up eventually. And it seems that we have a shot at at least 1 RB out of the ones listed above, even if it isn't Dunn.
I'm still a little worried about DT though, which is a huge position of need and some interest, but everyone DT is almost always a need for every school, so it's very difficult to get a good number of those guys in as that many more schools are vying for them.
With Beckham, I find it kind of odd that he would only come if we had an elite QB commit this year. He'd most likely end up catching passes from Gardner, who was an elite QB last year and by all indications will be a good one.
Otherwise, I'm very happy with our class thus far and the prospects we're after. Hoke is going after top flight talent. Great post, Tom. Very informative and interesting.
Who isn't a fan and has probably around a hundred offers or more. He probably doesn't see that side of it and there are probably a lot of schools telling him the same things. It's probably easier for him to just go in with an elite QB, one who is going through the process at the same time and probably seems more relatable to him at this stage.
Devin is going to be two years ahead of him by the time he gets here. I would be concerned as to who would be throwing me the ball in my Jr and Sr years. If he is thinking about going pro, he would want to have another highly touted QB throwing him passes. I can see the appeal of coming in with a big time QB recruit if you're a WR.
This is a very good analysis. At first glance, it looks heavy on lineman (both sides of the ball) but very light at the offensive skillled positions. Any need for concern? I'd really like to see an elite WR join this class. They might have a little time to wait for an elite QB and RB in 2013.
what's the deal with wormley not being included? overhyped?
EDIT: not being included on the 250.
There are at least two other services on the Internet that follow Michigan recruiting and football that had questions about Wormley's junior year performances on the field. Perhaps that is why he's not ranked.
Thanks this was awesome, nice to see where you think we stand with a lot of these guys. Just two quick questions though. First, does your list at the bottom suggest that you think it is more likely that OL Jordan Simmons will stay out west than the other OL's you named?
Second, I am very curious as to what you think our chances are with the Washington and Stanford combo. I guess I am just wondering what your "2nd list" would look like if you were to make one.
I didn't include Simmons because I don't think he knows what he wants to do yet, and the fact that I think there's a chance he stays out west.
Thanks for the info Tom. One typo though for #96 Jordan Payton state is listed as WR... should be CA unless the USPS is coming up with new state abbreviations that I'm behind on.
Tom, it seems like we are in good standing with Wayne, Richardson, Reeves, and Standifer. I assume that a spot stays open for Richardson no matter what because he is in-state, but I am assuming we only take one more after him. Is there a preference or is it just first come, first serve kinda thing?
Well Terry might be deciding next week, Reeves will decide later on, and Morgan will announce at one of the All American games. If they all want to pick Michigan I think they would try to make room, to be honest. The spacing of when they're all announcing might naturally spread everything out though, we'll see.
Standifer said that the coaches want to take 3 cornerbacks. I'm assuming they would like one of them (Standifer, perhaps) to double as a potential safety.
Wow so the coaching staff wants 3 CB/S, 6 OL, 3 TE, along with already having 4 LB, 2 DE, and probably wanting maybe another 3-4 DL, as well as a WR and QB? And that's not counting if we get an elite running back too. That's not leaving a lot of room unless we clear out a lot of space with transfers or not renewing scholarships for seniors.
I don't know, that's just what the recruits have been saying.
BTW, Josh Helmholdt said that the coaches have been recruiting all along with a 22-person class in mind. So they're definitely expecting some more attrition.
So how would you rank those 4 CB/S overall? Even though he's not highly ranked, I think Standifer would be a great get. He seems like a ball-hawk in his highlights. And his recruiting is starting to pick up, he just got some new offers, one of which from ND.
A lot of people here probably have differing views, but I really like Standifer's versatility and Morgan's just kind of so-so to me. I don't think Morgan's a bad player, but he's kind of a safety/corner tweener and I'm not sure where he would fit. Standifer's a bit of a tweener, too, but I think he's a boundary corner or a free safety.
Everybody has their own opinion on who we should sign at each position. When it comes to DB, I really like Standifer and Wilson. I'm not saying they are better than anybody else we could get, but I just really like them for some reason.
It looks more and more to me like the fifth-year eligible guys will really need to impress this season.
Consider this list:
As crazy as it sounds, 5 or even 6 of those guys may not be asked back. Looking at that list, I can see four who could easily be replaced if they don't shine. If Coach Hoke is deciding between an elite 4 or 5 Star versus a guy struggling to make the two deep, the recruit will win.
Cox = possible starter
Robinson = okay, maybe you're right
Roundtree = we need receivers
Moore = need the depth
Barnum = possible starter
Mealer = okay, maybe you're right
Omameh = probable starter
Khoury = probable starter in 2012
Demens = probable starter
Kovacs = eh . . . he's been starting for two years and probably soon to be three. I don't know why he wouldn't get a fifth year
Floyd = okay, maybe you're right if he doesn't play much this year
Morales = isn't on scholarship, anyway
I know how much you like Cox as a RB, but if he gets stuck behind Rawls, Hopkins, Shaw, and/or Fitz and doesn't produce much this year, can you really justify giving him another year?
Wow I really didn't mean for my subject line to come out like that...
I forgive you.
But my Tommy gun don't.
Home Alone love
No, you probably can't justify giving him a 5th year if he's 4th or 5th on the depth chart. But I honestly have a hard time believing that he won't get much playing time this year. He might not be *the* starter, but Hopkins is slow, Shaw and Toussaint are constantly hurt, etc. If Cox doesn't get a lot of playing time, I think we'll be in seriously bad shape at the RB position at some point during the year.
Cox is anywhere from a Possible Starter to possibly 4th on the depth chart. He's a perfect example of a player who will have to really make an impact.
The Morales case has been debated since he arrived and many have concluded that he was a preferred walk-on. Though these articles suggest some kind of scholarship.
Carr offered him a one-year scholarship with the possibility it will be renewed. Morales hasn’t decided what he will do if he’s not offered a scholarship next year.
Even if he's on scholarship now, he won't be back for a fifth year.
Starting on a bad defense doesn't impress me.
I think he'll have to play well to be asked back.
Tom - are you surprised that Pirsig didn't make the top 250? He definitely has the offers.
Yeah, a little bit. If I had never seen his film and only looked at his offer list, as an offensive lineman, this early on I would say he's a four star. I don't think it really matters though, he's enormous.
Any realistic chance with Darius Hamilton From NJ?
This is a great list: informative, functional, concise. I think it should remain at the top of the side bar until signing day.
Go Blue, recruits. GO Blue.
Its been awhile since I've seen his name mentioned. I assume this is because we've fallen behind others (ie SEC schools).
I have seen a few comments that this class is so heavy on both lines and too light at the offensive skill position players. My thoughts:
Hoke said from day 1 that winning the battle in the trenches was going to be his top priority. There is a school of football thought - to which I somewhat belong - that the effectiveness of your offense is impacted more by your offensive line than any other position. So, you could have the top QB and receivers, but if the offensive line doesn't maintain protection, the WRs don't have time to run their routes. Similarly, the QB will constantly be under pressure, leading even a good QB to throw more bad passes and picks. Along these lines, even a good RB will not be effective with a crappy line, and a merely mediocre RB can be very effective running through holes and open running lines created by a good OL.
Now, I am sure that Hoke and company are working their asses off to bring in the top OL skill position players, but they are obviously most concerned with stocking the lines with talent and depth.
If I were raising a highly touted QB, my main concern, aside from playing time, would be "how many 4 and 5* OL has the school signed?" If they are in place, the team is clearly committed to protecting the QB, opening holes for the RBs, etc-- skill players will follow... I think MI should be selling the OL commits big time; they are the lynchpin of the offense.
But whatever happened to the recruitment of Cyler Miles? I see he checks in at #160 and a couple months ago it seemed like there was a lot of interest from both parties, as noted in your Feb 14th update
Thanks as always Tom... great list!
glad to see we're in w/ so many OLs. we neeeeed mooooooar OLs.
every class should have at least 3 offensive linemen. not sure why we got away from that rule. from the looks of the list tom put together, it seems like we're going after bigger OLs than RR did, which probably signifies a full shift away from zone blocking down the road. borges has indicated that we won't do much zone blocking this year, but also that he'll play to his players' talents. i think this list shows he likes bigger road graters.
I see recruiting needs different than you, and most people here I guess.
If I were in charge of recruiting, my general rule would be this:
Figure out what my base offense and defense is going to be. (pro-style on offense, 4-3 on defense, for example).
Then, recruit one person for each position, or a group of players that could fill those positions based on who is a good recruit each year.
If that's done each year, over a four-year period you end up with 88 dudes. A few will drop off, a few will stick for 5 years. Over time, you'd be fully covered at most positions. Obviously, a kicker and punter need to find their way on the roster so the numbers will fluctuate.
Even-handed recruiting works better than any other strategy in an ideal world, but a number of factors curb its viability.
I'm sure this list, and Tom's work in general, gets picked apart and/or stolen by the rest of the college football world. MGoBlog is lucky to have this madman at our disposal.
Are you doing your off-season profiles this year?
That's a very comprehensive and solid analysis of Rivals 250 and impications for Michigan. Cannot think of anyway to thank you other than this blog + referring any top high school prospect your way.
would it be possible to edit this post to include the old smiley faces? i miss nefarious eduardo. even though he's clearly up to no good.
Great work, Tom. I didn't see Sheldon Day mentioned anywhere above. I am assuming he didn't make the top 250 list, which doesn't bother me in the least, I'm as big on the guy as ever. How do you see U-M fitting into his plans, and him fitting into ours ?