the unanimous all-american and his nemesis [Marc-Gregor Campredon]

2019-20 Hoops Preview: Big Ten Tiers, Part One Comment Count

Ace October 24th, 2019 at 2:05 PM

It is time. (It is probably past time, to be honest.) Michigan hoops officially tips off in 12 days, and they haven't entered a season with more questions surrounding the program since early in John Beilein's tenure. In a Big Ten with one sure bet and a lot of uncertainty after that, Juwan Howard has a chance to make a big splash in his first year.

To start this year's hoops preview, I've separated out the conference into tiers. The general rule with tier rankings: the tiers matter more than where teams land within the tiers. Today's post covers the top half of the conference, which conveniently contains the seven teams I believe will make the NCAA tournament.

Tier I: The (Sigh) Preseason Number One

1. Michigan State

Coach: Tom Izzo (24th season at MSU)
2018-19 record: 32-7 (16-4 B1G), 3-0 vs. Michigan
Key returners: PG Cassius Winston, G Josh Langford (inj.), F Aaron Henry, C Xavier Tillman
Key departures: C Nick Ward, F Kenny Goins, G Matt McQuaid
Top newcomer: G Rocket Watts

Bah.

The Spartans are considered this year's #1 team by humans and computers alike. Point guard Cassius Winston, who had the upper hand last year after previously struggling in his personal rivalry with Zavier Simpson, is a consensus preseason All-American and a near-lock to repeat as conference player of the year. While lacking the athleticism to be a high-level NBA prospect, he's almost everything you'd want in a college point guard—an efficient, high-volume distributor with scoring chops both inside and outside the arc, largely due to his acumen at manipulating the pick-and-roll. His shooting chart shows little weakness, especially when considering only 35% of his baskets were assisted:

While State loses some key pieces from last year's Big Ten champs, there's a lot of talent waiting to emerge. Center Xavier Tillman took Nick Ward's job and developed into a force late in the year. Tillman's mobility, strength, and skill on both ends made him an instant upgrade on Ward; he provided more options in the pick-and-roll and allowed State to switch on defense, something they had to avoid with the plodding Ward at center. Ward saw the writing on the wall and went pro in the offseason, clearing the decks for Tillman to have a full-blown breakout season.

Talented and enigmatic guard Josh Langford is sidelined indefinitely with a foot injury, but that provides the opportunity for touted freshman Rocket Watts, a 6'2" combo guard, to get major early minutes, and the talented scorer may not relinquish a starting spot once he has it. Aaron Henry is a long, athletic, developing role player with a potential NBA future; the same may be said about Gabe Brown and Marcus Bingham soon. Kyle Ahrens and Thomas Kithier provide depth, and Kithier may be talented enough to nab a starting spot.

There's too much experience and talent in place here to consider anyone else for the top spot in the conference, and arguably the country.

[Hit THE JUMP for happier things.]

Tier II: The Rising Reds

Jalen Smith (#25) is a five-star who stuck around for his sophomore year. [Paul Sherman]

2. Maryland

Coach: Mark Turgeon (ninth year)
2018-19 record: 23-11 (13-7 B1G), 0-2 vs. Michigan
Key returners: PG Anthony Cowan, G Darryl Morsell, G Eric Ayala, F Aaron Wiggins, F/C Jalen Smith
Key departures: C Bruno Fernando
Top newcomer: C Makhi Mitchell

Mark Turgeon continues to build a talented, sound roster at Maryland, which has now made the NCAA tournament four of the last five years under his watch. An NBA big man leaves in Bruno Fernando; a five-star big man begins his sophomore year in Jalen Smith; a blue-chip big man enters the program in Makhi Mitchell. The formula is working for them.

Losing Fernando hurts, but the Terps bring back every other major contributor, and they should get a lot of growth from a sophomore class headlined by Smith and also featuring wings Darryl Morsell, Eric Ayala, and Aaron Wiggins, who all played well in major roles last year. Add in a solid senior point guard in Anthony Cowan and an infusion of more freshman talent and you've got perhaps the most complete team in the conference outside of East Lansing.

There's some Ewing Theory potential with this team. While Fernando was an interior force, the fit with 6'10" Smith mostly at power forward proved awkward at times and also limited minutes for the talented young wings, especially Wiggins, a 41% three-point shooter. Having a senior point guard to pair with their potential first-round big man puts them just above the next team on the list for me.

3. Ohio State

Coach: Chris Holtmann (third season)
2018-19 record: 20-15 (8-12 B1G), 0-1 vs. Michigan
Key returners: G Luther Muhammad, G Duane Washington, F Musa Jallow, F Kyle Young, F Andre Wesson, C Kaleb Wesson
Key departures: PG CJ Jackson, G Keyshawn Woods
Top newcomer: PG DJ Carton

The Buckeyes also bring back nearly every major contributor, and given how inconsistent CJ Jackson played at point guard, they're likely in for an upgrade at the position—top-50 freshman DJ Carton, who Beilein went after hard, is expected to start right away, and Florida State transfer CJ Walker should at least keep the floor at "no worse than CJ Jackson."

The star will remain big man Kaleb Wesson, whose 6'9", 270-pound frame belies his skill; he's a strong post player, a very willing passer, and he expanded his range beyond the three-point arc last season. If he keeps his turnovers down, which isn't a given, he's got a good shot to be first-team all-conference despite not being a major defensive presence. Wesson is becoming an analytics geek's dream—pretty much all his shots last year came at the rim or from beyond the arc:

Chris Holtmann seems to get more from his teams than the sum of their parts, and this team has plenty of interesting parts. Duane Washington has gunner potential if he can rein it in a bit; Luther Muhammad is a bulldog; Kyle Young has been a very efficient garbageman when healthy; Kaleb's brother Andre Wesson is a senior glue guy with skill. There's a wide range of potential outcomes for this team—that'll become a trend—but I like Holtmann's chances of getting them towards the top end of that range.

Tier III: My Favorite Non-Rivalry Isn't Dead

The Painter/Beilein War is over, let the Painter/Howard battles begin. [Campredon]

4. Purdue

Coach: Matt Painter (15th year)
2018-19 record: 26-10 (16-4 B1G), 0-1 vs. Michigan
Key returners: G Nojel Eastern, F Aaron Wheeler, C Matt Haarms, F/C Trevion Williams
Key departures: PG Carsen Edwards, G Ryan Kline, F Grady Eifert
Top newcomer: G Jahaad Proctor (High Point transfer)

This is where human predictions start to detach from the computers. Purdue is the preseason #7 team to both KenPom's and Bart Torvik's algorithms. They both project the Boilermakers to have a top-ten offense.

Meanwhile, Purdue loses Carsen Edwards, last seen willing this team to the Elite Eight by averaging 35 points per game in the tourney, unless you also watched him put on long-distance fireworks shows for the Boston Celtics in summer league and the preseason. Matt Painter hopes to replace some of Edwards's scoring punch with High Point transfer Jahaad Proctor; he's a similar player but it's very difficult to see him bending defenses like Edwards.

That's problematic for a team that also lost two of their best outside shooters, Ryan Kline and Grady Eifert. Purdue has two excellent post options in giant Dutchman Matt Haarms and sophomore breakout candidate Trevion Williams, but those two need space to operate. Hybrid point guard/wing Nojel Eastern is a superlative defender who can make plays in the paint, but he's got one of the funkiest shots in the country (57% career FT shooter) and doesn't even attempt three-pointers (0-4 last year).

Sophomore Sasha Stefanovic, a 41% Just A Shooter™, can step into Cline's role as an extreme three-point gunner, but unless Haarms can stretch out his range a few more feet, I'm skeptical this offense can come close to last year's output. That said, defense should be a strength, and Painter is an excellent coach—there's little doubt he'll find a way to at least squeeze 20 wins out of his squad.

5. Michigan

Coach: Juwan Howard (first year)
2018-19 record: 30-7 (15-5 B1G)
Key returners: PG Zavier Simpson, F Isaiah Livers, C Jon Teske
Key departures: G Jordan Poole, F Charles Matthews, F Iggy Brazdeikis
Top newcomer: G Franz Wagner

Ultimately, Painter's coaching experience over Howard and similar concerns about Michigan's shooting tipped the scales in Purdue's favor, but if a couple youngsters emerge for the Wolverines that could change in a hurry. Unfortunately, Franz Wagner's injury could hamper the team's ability to gel before Big Ten play, and I don't want to totally ignore the significant gap in computer projections between the two teams.

I'll have a whole lot more on Michigan before the season tips off.

Tier IV: Trains Passing

97% chance Brad Davison is bracing for a flop here. [Campredon] 

6. Illinois

Coach: Brad Underwood (third year)
2018-19 record: 12-21 (7-13 B1G), 0-1 vs. Michigan
Key returners: PG Trent Frazier, G Ayo Dosunmu, G Andres Feliz, F Kipper Nichols, C Georgi Bezhanishvili
Key departures: F Aaron Jordan, C Adonis De La Rosa
Top newcomer: C Kofi Cockburn

The choice here is between two programs that may be headed in opposite directions. You may be surprised to see the Illini here after Brad Underwood's tenure got off to a rocky start, going 14-18 in year one before a 4-12 (0-5 Big Ten) start to last season set off alarm bells. The defense was mostly nonexistent; more alarming, the offense was scuffling in Underwood's previously high-octane system—you may remember him as Oklahoma State's coach from the batshit 2017 NCAA tournament game against Michigan.

Illinois pulled it together, going a respectable 8-9 down the stretch that included upsets of MSU and OSU. They got the news they needed in the offseason when guard/roadrunner Ayo Dosunmu passed up a chance at the NBA for at least one more year; he's a force in transition, which is how Underwood likes to play, and he's got the skillset to develop into a dangerous three-level scorer in the halfcourt as well. He shares lead guard duties with backcourt mate Trent Frazier, a 40% three-point shooter who could be a star if he finishes off more of his drives.

Sophomore Georgi Bezhanishvili proved to be a crafty post scorer and impact offensive rebounder in his debut season. He needs to cut down on turnovers and lacks the athleticism to be a great defender, but both of those areas should improve with experience, and he's already proven he can shoulder a relatively large offensive load.

This could be the year things start to click in Champaign, and the middle of the Big Ten looks wide open for an up-and-coming team to make a run at a double-bye. They'll provide a much different look than most teams in the conference; this looks like the season that starts to become an advantage.

7. Wisconsin

Coach: Greg Gard (fifth year)
2018-19 record: 23-11 (14-6 B1G), 1-1 vs. Michigan
Key returners: PG D'Mitrik Trice, G Brevin Pritzl, G Brad Davison, F Aleem Ford, F Kobe King, C Nate Reuvers
Key departures: C/PG Ethan Happ, F Khalil Iverson
Top newcomer: F Micah Potter (Ohio State transfer)

This is Wisconsin. Even when they lose their main guy, you'd expect them to project higher than this. Program of the Bug People and whatnot.

I'm deeply skeptical. Greg Gard hasn't coached a Badgers squad without Ethan Happ at center, and even when Happ was a freshman, the offense was largely running through him—by last year, Happ took on a level of usage normally reserved for do-everything point guards. He made Wisconsin a unique and difficult team to prepare to face; in addition to being able to run an entire offense out of the post, he was a disruptive and steady defender.

Here are two shot charts. On the left/top are Wisconsin's shots (with Happ's removed) that were derived from post-ups—plays on which Happ was mostly responsible for distributing the ball. On the right/bottom are Wisconsin's shots (Happ's again removed) derived from isolation and pick-and-roll—there's still some of Happ distributing the ball in here, to be sure, but not as much.

Not only did Happ open up the perimeter, he made it easier for his teammates to find space to score in the lane. That 38.6% shooting around the rim in the chart on the right is woeful; it indicates Wisconsin really lacks players who can create their own shot and finish.

Center Nate Reuvers is a good big man in his own right, and he provides a level of shooting that Happ didn't, but he's not going to turn into a point-center. Perhaps noted pest Brad Davison becomes a much better finisher with two intact shoulders; it's also fair to wonder if his shoulder issues will ever truly go away given how often he hits the deck. D'Mitrik Trice gives Wisconsin a solid outside shooter who can make some off the bounce, but he's also never been a guy who can score efficiently inside the arc, and as the nominal point guard he's going to have to improve his passing, as well.

The Badgers hope to get a boost on the interior from Ohio State transfer Micah Potter, whose timing is in limbo—he hoped to be declared immediately eligible but, pending appeal, the NCAA isn't letting him play before sitting a semester, which would keep him out until late December.

Ultimately, I think Wisconsin can grind out enough wins to make the NCAA tournament, but I suspect it'll be even less pretty than the usual, which is a frightening notion indeed.

Comments

MGlobules

October 24th, 2019 at 2:13 PM ^

It's just me, I guess, because there sure is a lot of time and space devoted to extemporizing pre-season about who wins what and I just can't get excited until teams have played a few games. But I like those shooting charts much better than the ones with a million dots.

Ace

October 24th, 2019 at 2:52 PM ^

They're generated by the new Synergy app. I only have two options for the coloring and the other is a blue-only gradient that I hate. This is the color gradient used above:

Color is determined by shooting percentage compared to national average, so the percentage required to hit a certain color will be different depending on the zone.

Bambi

October 24th, 2019 at 2:44 PM ^

A couple MSU thoughts/notes:

Ward didn't transfer, he went pro and is playing in Turkey now.

Ahrens isn't really a frontcourt guy. He's injured currently but when healthy he might start at the 2 in place of Langford.

Watts is also slightly injured. Tore his rotator cuff in March, currently his a minor achilles injury.

I don't know that saying Bingham has an "NBA future" is fair. It may be true in the same way that was technically true about freshman DJ Wilson, but he's not close to that point. Despite being 6'11 Bingham didn't make a 2 pointer last year (6/14 from 3, 0/7 from 2) and apparently didn't play well at all in their secret scrimmage against Gonzaga. Especially defensively. He seems a year away right now from being a good player.

Boner Stabone

October 24th, 2019 at 3:15 PM ^

I officiated a game with Bingham his senior year of high school and he was getting pushed around by a bunch of 6'2" guys from a scrub school.  He was whining at me for fouls all game.  I just smiled and thought inside, wow!! this guy is in for a rude awakening when he gets to MSU and tries to play B1G basketball.

He was able to get by with his height in high school, but I am guessing it is going to take some time for him to get used to playing a more finesse type of game.

A Lot of Milk

October 24th, 2019 at 2:59 PM ^

I think I like our MSU matchup a lot more this year. It's gonna be Z vs Winston and Tillman vs our bigs without Goins stretching out to the 3. No longer have to worry about Poole single handedly ruining our defensive strategy against McPoyle. We lost Matthews, but he didn't play in two of the games anyway. Need scoring, but we match up much better this year

bronxblue

October 24th, 2019 at 3:53 PM ^

Livers is probably a better 3/4 than Henry, but PG and C go to MSU.  At the same time, they're not SO far ahead that those matchups aren't competitive.  We'll also have to see how Tillman handles a new role in the offense; for a lot of last year they had shooters and was more opportunistic with his offense.  This year (I assume) he'll be more involved in PnR, and that could be a transition issue for him.

Still, MSU is really good.  

TrueBlue2003

October 24th, 2019 at 3:44 PM ^

I do think MSU is going to miss Goins and McQuaid a lot more than people think but Winston and Tillman are so good they deserve to be the favorites here.

I'm not sure we match up better with them this year, per se, since the show is still Winston and Tillman vs. Simpson and Teske. Winston gives them the edge there.  Both teams lost key wing players and I'll call that a push.

Monocle Smile

October 24th, 2019 at 3:04 PM ^

It's pretty silly how State manages to hold on to annoyingly good players for so many years. It's almost like Izzo deliberately develops his people into non-NBA types.

A Lot of Milk

October 25th, 2019 at 9:35 AM ^

Kept Draymond for 4 years, Winston for 4 years, Appling for 4 years, Gary Harris for two years, Bridges for 2 years. Only player I can think of that was a true 1 and done was Jaren Jackson. They had some 5 star player they kept on the bench his whole freshman year and he just said fuck it, and left for the draft anyway. But I don't really count that. Can't remember his name

TrueBlue2003

October 24th, 2019 at 3:38 PM ^

If Michigan is even decently coached, they should absolutely be on that second tier. 

Maryland has a ton of talent and if they were well coached, they could challenge MSU, buuuuut they're not well-coached.  Which means they're a bit of wildcard and a decently coached Michigan team has a good chance of making up for a talent deficiency and being better than Maryland.

OSU is well-coached but they aren't more talented than Michigan.  So a decently coached Michigan team should be right there with OSU and a well-coached Michigan team should be better than OSU.  Carton does provide a little variance there, though.  If he's a world beater as a freshman that changes the talent equation but I'll believe that when I see it.

TrueBlue2003

October 24th, 2019 at 3:29 PM ^

I'm not sure you can just remove Happ's shots to determine what Wisconsin will look like without him.  I know he played a lot but what does their shot chart look like without him on the floor? And what was their efficiency when that was the case?

I feel like there's Ewing theory potential here a little bit as they played two bigs and kind of seemed to rely too much on him at times.  A true pick and roll oriented offense between Davison and Reuvers with shooters around them seems dangerous although Davison may not be the creator to dominate the ball that way and they may not have a true creator. 

They'll certainly be able to run a much more open offense.  Whether anyone can take advantage of that...we'll see.

bronxblue

October 24th, 2019 at 3:48 PM ^

I'll say this now - MSU will look worse this year than people expect.  I've watched Izzo long enough (damn he's been coaching a long time), and he's best with a veteran team full of scrappy try-hards who started off as 4* kids without huge NBA dreams whom he ground down to a fine paste and then stuffed into his system.  He had that last year and it paid off; this year they really will be rolling out a number of players at key positions. McQuaid was an all-conference defender and Goins was the requisite 5th-year senior who suddenly learns how to do things like shoot 3s and defend at a very high level.  They'll be short Joshua Langford (which sucks for him), but he's the type of guy who would have emerged to fill this gap a bit.  Tillman will be really good, so we'll see if he can take the next step to being a major focus of the offense along with Winston.  But I wouldn't be shocked if MSU lost a couple of games and Izzo drags players in the media come mid-season.  They'll still win the conference, but I don't think they run roughshod.

Maryland should be the second-best team in the conference, but I could see Painter and Purdue leapfrog OSU.  OSU has a lot of pieces back but those pieces scuttled at the end of the year while Purdue, even show Edwards, is always competitive.

Michigan at #5 feels right, though if they struggle generating offense without Wagner it'll be a long season and I could see them slide down below Illinois.  Michigan's floor with the defense they have will likely still be a tourney contender, but they have to find offense on this roster from one of the guys who didn't play much last year.

 

JakefromStateFarm

October 24th, 2019 at 5:36 PM ^

I hope some of Bajema,Johns,Dejulius,Nunez, or brooks turn out to be good players or this is going to a rough year. With Beilien as the coach I wouldn’t be as worried and believe we would easily be a 6 or 7 seed. However, JH is an unproven commodity and if some of these players I listed are not atleast serviceable I could see us not making the tournament. Our defense should be very good but we don’t have one proven scorer this year besides kinda Sorta Livers. Hoping for the best though!!

HireWayne

October 24th, 2019 at 11:31 PM ^

I'd put Illini, Purdue, and Wisky ahead of Michigan in that order.  

Basketball wins come from putting the ball in the basket.  I'm not convinced Michigan has players to do so on a consistent basis.