OT- New BBQ place in AA

Submitted by white_pony_rocks on

Satchel's BBQ just opened up today at 11 and I just got back.  It isn't the best BBQ in the world but it is the best BBQ in the area.  Ive been to the BBQ place in Pinkney and Fenton and this is much better.  Its next to the Whole Foods on Washtenaw

edit- so the roommate just got back from work and he stopped there on his way and said that it was dry and only ok.  I was there 7 miutes after they opened so that might be the reason, its no excuse though, if you want to be considered good BBQ you have to provide quality food throughout the day.  Still, it was really tender and juicy in the morning

Wolverine318

February 14th, 2011 at 12:47 PM ^

Yeah. It maybe good by Midwest standards but I have been spoiled by inlaws from south Carolina. I have yet to find anything in the Midwest that can replicate quality southern BBQ or even sweet tea for that matter. I should check out this new place sometime. Thank you for the tip.

Wolverine318

February 14th, 2011 at 1:45 PM ^

About as much as southern Indiana. Even then I consider southern Indiana more SEC country than Big Ten. I consider that area to have more in commmon with the SEC than the Big Ten, especially when you take into account the average number of lost teeth of the townies in Bloomington...

M-Wolverine

February 14th, 2011 at 5:14 PM ^

Because it's a zig-zaggy line, but Southern Indiana is a lot more Kentucky, where Northern Indy is a lot more suburb of Chicago-ish. And you could argue the South starts south of Toledo in a lot of parts of Ohio. The South definitely goes further north than the North goes south.

Don

February 14th, 2011 at 1:46 PM ^

by a long country mile. No other place has ever come close for me, unfortunately. It was a terrible tragedy in our house when they closed. I just wish I'd soaked my Delong's t-shirt in their sauce before they shut their doors. So does my dog.

annmsanders

February 14th, 2011 at 3:45 PM ^

finally- southern barbecue in ann arbor!  went to satchel's - just opened today- and had barbecue the way it should be.  the best i've had in these parts.  brought back memories of  pulled pork roadside joints down south...   in my mind, beats the blue tractor hands down... and also a deal.  Prices were better than I expected.

jaspersail

February 14th, 2011 at 3:49 PM ^

I never thought much about BBQ until I visited my wife's family in Alabama a couple years ago...  Fat Boy's in Prattville.  Dayum!  I could eat there every day!  We tried another place in Montgomery but it wasn't nearly as good.

On the drive home I made us stop in Nashville so I could get more BBQ.  Then at the Outer Banks we drove up to Sauls Bar-B-Que for some vinegar heaven.  I'm hooked!

Anxiously looking forward to a visit to Satchels!

 

jcorqian

February 14th, 2011 at 8:22 PM ^

I spent a summer in Kansas City as an intern, and I gotta say that barbeque puts the Big Ten portion of the Midwest to shame.  The best places were not the big names like Arthur Bryants or Oklahoma Joes, but the hole in the wall mom and pop places.  Just simply delicious, best ribs and brisket I've ever had.  Ironically, the second best bbq I've had was in Hawaii, a little place in a strip mall with just unbelievable beer can chicken.

So with somewhat of a gauge of decent BBQ, I've gotta say that Slow's is the best I've had in Michigan in my four years here of college.  Great beer selection as well, but the food is very good.  I love their baked beans with the hot peppers inside, and the mac and cheese was great too.  The ribs were very good, not great, but the brisket was the most tender (not best, but most tender) I've ever had.  Great brisket.

I went to Blue Tractor a few weeks ago looking for some good BBQ locally beacuse I got into Friday Night Lights, and that show makes me want to eat BBQ like there's no tomorrow.  I was severely, severely disappointed.  I got both the pulled pork sandwich and a brisket sandwich, and both meats were pretty dry and without a lot of flavor.  Sauces were fine, but a good sauce is no substitue for subpar meat.  Really hoping this new place is good...

aaamichfan

February 15th, 2011 at 1:36 PM ^

I had this place for lunch today, and it was just alright. They were out of brisket, so I'll probably go back sometime in the near future to try it. My main complaint is that there wasn't enough smoke flavor in the pork. It's pretty difficult to make brisket without enough smoke, so I'm willing to give the place another shot after they work the kinks out.