bronxblue

December 21st, 2021 at 2:46 PM ^

But that wasn't your argument.  We're talking about how testing helps identify people who may have the disease and, along with vaccinations and mitigation efforts, try to minimize hospitals being overwhelmed.  Your response was flippantly stating that testing hasn't helped and that's there's a whole world outside of western Michigan that, by implication, wasn't being overwhelmed.  You've since been trying to dig out this hole and it ain't working.

If your point was that testing of athletes is excessive then so be it; I don't have a strong opinion either way.  But the fact it took you 3-4 responses to get to that point makes me think that wasn't your original intent.

TheDirtyD

December 21st, 2021 at 5:07 PM ^

Wrong I never made a point to begin with. I asked how is preventing it working out? No one answered. Someone brought up western Michigan all I said is there’s a world that exists outside of western Michigan, like texas and more! I then made a point which I’ve made in other posts, not that I need you or expect you to look that far though. Testing college athletes and them only despite being symptomatic or not is insanity. 

BahamaMama

December 21st, 2021 at 2:23 PM ^

And it’s just as bad in southeast Michigan. My elective major surgery has been postponed because there are very few open beds. The surgeon is hoping things calm down enough to get it done in February. Between Covid and staff leaving for declining the vaccinations, our hospital systems are stressed to the max.

BlueinKyiv

December 21st, 2021 at 9:51 AM ^

We may eventually get there, but as a society we are not yet ready to knowingly accept non-symptomatic covid-positives in our public activities. I also disagree that bowl games will change their dates or move what are massive public undertakings by the host cities that really don't care if a few starters are missing from the visiting participants. 

Watching the NFL/NBA right now where suddenly the other team's best player is out after testing positive, I imagine we will have at least one major missing piece going into the game. All the more reason, we are blessed with two quarterbacks.  

That said, it is 50-50 that we are the beneficiaries in facing a depleted Georgia or Alabama team because of COVID. Frankly, that is not a bad position for an underdog to be in.  If I am coaching this team, they are practicing and doing the PR events with masks and get a spray-down of their hands with anti-biotic every 15 minutes up to that last COVID testing round. 

nerv

December 21st, 2021 at 10:15 AM ^

I wouldnt bet on a depleted Georgia or Alabama. I just don't see those schools making the choice to test and then sit out important players. Texas A&M isn't playing for anything, just another bowl game. If they were in line for a possible championship appearance I think this scenario plays out a lot differently.

Hab

December 21st, 2021 at 10:38 AM ^

We may eventually get there, but as a society we are not yet ready to knowingly accept non-symptomatic covid-positives in our public activities.

I may be missing something, but are you in favor of such a proposition?  I think at this point we all realize that being asymptomatic is not the same thing as being harmless.

ldevon1

December 21st, 2021 at 9:53 AM ^

I say this before it gets locked, which it will, but why are they treating athletes different than the general population at this point? I go to work everyday and no one tests me. Spiderman had the 3rd largest grossing weekend of any movie ever, so the theaters were packed. The stadiums are packed and they aren't testing fans. Why are players being treated differently at this point?

HateSparty

December 21st, 2021 at 9:56 AM ^

Employees and the general public have different rules and have for years.  I can go to the bar and make misogynistic and or racially charged statements.  I can still grow my tab.  I try that at work and I lose my pay.  Is it clearer now?  Seems like it should be obvious.  why is COVID so hard for a minority of this country?

Edit:  Student athletes are employees, make no mistake about that.