And Then You Win: Te'o And The Media Comment Count

Brian

I've been a little out of it the last few days. Not enough to not see every Manti Te'o fake dead girlfriend joke in the world come through my twitter feed, but out of it, more given to trying to keep various fluids in my nose than trying to figure out any deep takeaways from the fact that Notre Dame's star player had a fake internet girlfriend who fake internet died.

I had to get one in a hurry when I went on WTKA this morning, because everyone in the world is talking about it—I hopped into a minimart to grab something to eat and it was on, like, CNN. CNN 2012 is to CNN 1994 as TLC 2012 is to TLC 1994…

161812_slide[1]

cracked

…but it's a big deal when your fake girlfriend turns out dead, I guess. So the brain went and processed and came out with these things.

THIS IS NOT SURPRISING, PART I. We are talking about a Mormon guy from Hawaii who turned down USC to attend a Catholic school in South Bend, Indiana, that had not ever been remotely competitive in a BCS game because of… nice grass or something. A mural on a building. Whatever causes people to go to Notre Dame minus the "I'm Catholic" angle. He left Hawaii for South Bend, Indiana. Clearly this is a gullible man.

THIS IS NOT SURPRISING, PART II. What percentage of massively credulous undergraduate population of Notre Dame do you think has an internet girlfriend? All of them. Every last person participating in the annual Dillon Hall tickle fight has an internet girlfriend they have never met.

She is a princess from Sub-Saharan Africa currently in boarding school, and she doesn't care that by even communicating with Wallace Anglerson The Third she risks her inheritance—her very place in society—as long as you keep talking about how bad the last season of Battlestar Galactica was. It's love. Her name is "Angel," except in one of those clicky languages. Here is a picture of her.

black-cat[1]

Te'o would tell his friends about his internet girlfriend, and they would say "my internet girlfriend is hotter." Jimmy Clausen had two, the cad. Six weeks after graduation it gradually dawns on them that some of the men they hung out with were actually girls.

It would be weird if Manti Te'o didn't have a fake internet girlfriend hailing from somewhere far away from South Bend. If Notre Dame's nickname had been updated to reflect changes in student demographics they would be the Fightin' Lonely Credulous Nerds.

THIS IS NOT SURPRISING, PART III. As Jonathan Chait points out, it wouldn't be an inspiring story about a Notre Dame hero if it wasn't fiction:

Fake, schmaltzy inspirational tales are the essence of the culture of the program. The inspirational story of Knute Rockne and his dying player, George Gipp, became a famous movie that helped enshrine Notre Dame football in the culture. In reality, Rockne was an ethically dubious sports gambler, Gipp a pool hustler, and the main events of the story — Gipp’s dying wish to “win one for the Gipper,” Rockne’s inspirational halftime speech —never happened.

Likewise, Rudy is the inspirational story of a walk-on who overcame the odds to play football at Notre Dame, but the story is also filled with falsehoods. Rudy, by the way, turned out to be a stock scammer.

The only thing that's strange about this is that Te'o's grandmother is not only hale and hearty today but also manipulating Vegas lines with his grandson's collusion.

THIS IS NOT SURPRISING, PART IV… ACTUALLY THIS IS A LITTLE SURPRISING. For a while now Deadspin has been a weird mélange of athlete dong pics, Drew Magary trying to one-up himself until his columns are just lists of insults followed by exclamation points, and the best dang investigative journalism around*. (They've cut down on the wantonly-screwing-people-no-one's-ever-heard-of-in-a-petulant-fit since the departure of AJ Daulerio.)

The best example: A couple years ago Tommy Craggs published internal MLB financial documents that revealed small market teams—including the Marlins, recipients of a new publicly-funded stadium—were simply pocketing revenue-sharing money instead of using it to improve the product they put in front of their fans. This pissed MLB off so much they tried to sue the insurance company they came from to find the person who leaked the documents so they could sue him. When's the last time something a newspaper wrote caused a major league to go on a suing vendetta? I can't recall.

Anyway, the jarring thing is this story comes immediately after the baseball writers refused to vote anyone into the hall of fame for using the PEDs they studiously ignored for a decade. Meanwhile the following Legitimate Media Organizations ran with Te'o's Fake Dead Girlfriend:

1. Us.

2. You (Jack Dickey and Timothy Burke excepted)

3. Sports Illustrated.

4. ESPN

5. The South Bend Tribune

6. Bleacher Report

7. The Chicago Tribune

8. The Chicago Sun-Times

9. The Sporting News

10. USA Today

11. The Boston Globe

12. CBS Sports

13. The New York Post

14. NBC Sports/Notre Dame

15. Yahoo

16. The Associated Press

17. The Palm Beach Post

18. The Miami Herald

19. The Tampa Bay Times

20. Grantland

21. The Los Angeles Times

Go home newspapers, you're drunk.

If you're not going to call, to confirm, to make sure someone actually exists, what do you have left? If Deadspin has you beat on the low end and the high end, what is your purpose?

“Journalism is printing what someone else does not want printed: everything else is public relations.”

George Orwell

Remember when writers at regional Iowa papers looked down their nose at bloggers and their unverified voracity?

In the new "journalism of assertion," as the report calls it, information is offered with little time and little attempt to independently verify its voracity. [sic]

I don't either. Long time ago, in a different media place. The only people still pretending sportswriters aren't PR are the baseball writers, long may they stew in their curly-haired uselessness.

IN CONCLUSION

I have met my wife.

*[With apologies to Charles Robinson.]

Comments

AAB

January 17th, 2013 at 12:19 PM ^

Only pointing this out because of the subject of the post, but I think that Orwell quote is apocryphal.  Which, in context, is kinda funny.

M-Wolverine

January 17th, 2013 at 12:22 PM ^

But I never expected to see cosplay Black Cat on here. Particuarly not on the front page.

Not that I'm complaining....

Bando Calrissian

January 17th, 2013 at 12:24 PM ^

Don't forget that George Gipp's death, if memory serves (John Bacon wrote the definitive article about this, but it's been a while since I read it for his class), came as a result of him sleeping outside in the cold after a late night of gambling, booze, and women.  

A real profile in courage.

eamus_caeruli (not verified)

January 17th, 2013 at 2:40 PM ^

Rudy was also in the Navy until he was 24, got the GI bill while at Holy Cross. It took him several years before he even tried out for the team.  The Myth and the movie are wrought with swiss cheese like exaggerations.  

Craig

January 17th, 2013 at 12:34 PM ^

So let me wrap my mind around this: Teo, a football star at a football crazy school, who could date any woman on ND's campus, instead prefers to "date" a women in California that he has never met in person. Say Whaaat?

What does that say about
Norte Dame girls?
..BOOM

CrabCakes_and_…

January 17th, 2013 at 12:36 PM ^

Hey Brian, have you confirmed the sourcing/accuracy of that Orwell quote? My 5 seconds of google-fu turned up this:

http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Talk:George_Orwell#Attribution.3F_-_.22Jou…

 

So to paraphrase you, if you're not going to do the research, to confirm, to make sure a quote is accurate, what do you have left? *Of course if you can come up with a legitimate source this post is rendered irrelevant. But if it's fake, it sure is a bit ironic given the circumstances.

 

edit: yeah, what AAB said

Anonymosity

January 17th, 2013 at 12:50 PM ^

The only thing that's strange about this is that Te'o's grandmother is not only hale and hearty today but also manipulating Vegas lines with his grandson's collusion.
I think you're missing a negative and a "her," unless you actually believe Teo's grandmother is alive, involved with gambling, and a man.

Michael Scarn

January 17th, 2013 at 12:53 PM ^

Brian, genuine question.  You're buying his (and Notre Dame's) story right now?  Maybe I'm cynical but I need a lot more questions answered before I can possibly go "wow, Te'o got duped."

Cosmic Blue

January 17th, 2013 at 12:55 PM ^

i find it really hard to believe that te'o was tricked. there are just too many contradictions in the story. how could he not know it was fake after her "death?" i can get that he couldnt attend the funeral because of football commitments, but dont you at least send flowers to the home or call the parents to share in remorse? neither of those exist either so things should have broke then.

i have a feeling it will come out that te'o had a relationship with this Ronaiah Tuiasosopo guy. perhaps they were trying to disguise it as a heterosexual relationship due to religious and/or PR pressure. then they tried to cover up the whole lie by having her "die" but that just made it worse.

even if my theory is incorrect, i need some way better explanation from Te'o before i can believe he wasn't in on it

Hannibal.

January 17th, 2013 at 1:19 PM ^

There is a South Bend tribune article from a few months back talking about how they "exchanged glances, then handshakes, and then phone numbers" after the Stanford-ND game in 2009. 

Teo never claimed that this was an internet-only girlfriend that he had never talked to on the phone.

So yes, this was absolutely 100% manufactured.  I can't see a plausible explanation other than that.

Sarasota13

January 17th, 2013 at 7:02 PM ^

  1. Where did you purchase the white roses?  How did you pay for them? Where were they sent and who told you where to send them.
  2. May I review your phone records for the last year?
  3. Were you born in Hawaii and do your have a birth certificate?
  4. Who is Ronaiah? How long have you known him? How much contact have you had with him - internet or otherwise?  By what means.
  5. May I inpsect your computer?
  6. Will you authorize the release of your twitter records and other online communiication accounts.

Also if ND made a complete investigation of the matter, why was Reba surprised by the call from Deadspin?  Who did they contact and what was said.  It seems that relatives participated in this scheme vs. strangers. Why?

 

It seems odd that someone would not visit the love of his life, who was laying on her death bed, nor attend her funeral.  It seems difficult to believe that there was no further contact with her "family members".   If this is truly "catfishing" then, maybe some facts will come out. If it was a publicity stunt with compliant family members, then the truth will not be known.

Only the documents or inspectionsmentioned above would shed light on the situation and those will never be produced.  So the story will just fade away. 

 

 

 

turtleboy

January 17th, 2013 at 2:21 PM ^

He definitely lied, whether he masterminded the entire hoax, or he lied after he found out because it was extremely embarrassing being already all over the media. I have a difficult time believing the former, and I guess I can kind of understand the latter. I can't see any point to him orchestrating it to his whole family and killing it off right when his grandma died, and it just makes more sense lying to cover it up because he'd be crucified for it after all the press, and charity stuff being set up. Still, some of the gross overreactions are almost as disheartening to me as the hoax itself.

Everyone Murders

January 17th, 2013 at 12:57 PM ^

Chait nails the Notre Dame mythology with his closing statement (between Chait and Bacon, our school has some damned fine writers representing it!):

If Te’o's dying girlfriend story had been invented 80 years ago, it would have been memorialized in film and people would still believe it today.

I'm still trying to figure out to what degree T'eo's been complicit in this, but what a Charlie Foxtrot this has been!

Hardware Sushi

January 17th, 2013 at 12:58 PM ^

Great post. It went from hilarious to insightful. I'm glad it wasn't a bunch of condemning Teo as an outright liar and therefore evil person, which is my only issue with the way everyone is looking at it.

 

CompleteLunacy

January 17th, 2013 at 1:53 PM ^

I'm not condemning the guy but there are waaaay way too many holes you can poke in the story that simply do not make sense that it was a simple "online dating only" relationship hoax. 

Who calls themselves "boyfriend/girlfriend" without ever at least skyping to see each others' face? What about all the stories published about meetings with each other?

There's more to this story than meets the eye. It's certainly plausible that Teo was duped the whole time, but I find that much less likely than any scenario where Teo knew and was in on it (for reasons that are obviously not clear right now).

 

jg2112

January 17th, 2013 at 12:58 PM ^

The only reason I like George Gipp is because the movie Airplane! spoofed it with a character George Zipp, and Leslie Nielsen tells a story for the "boys to win just one for the Zipper."

DonAZ

January 17th, 2013 at 1:04 PM ^

I look at the news about T'eo and I find myself unable to muster much care.

Nothing would surprise me -- T'eo duped or the whole thing a planned PR thing or both.

What a circus ... and ultimately, who cares?

champswest

January 17th, 2013 at 1:17 PM ^

how exactly did Te'o find out that his girlfriend was dead? Will this story ever go away without an in-depth interview that isn't afraid to ask all the right questions?

WolverineRage

January 17th, 2013 at 1:20 PM ^

Honestly, very little shocks me anymore in the sporting world.  Lance Armstrong being doped registered as a "Oh well, that's a shame".

 

The Te'o thing though, really surprised me.  To me, he came off as a stand-up guy and as much as I despised Notre Dame, I really found it hard to get snarky at him.  Instead I got snarky with the media that made it seem like he was the only one to suffer personal tragedy ever.

 

That being said, I admit that I allowed the media to bias my opinion to the positive about a man I had never met, which happens all the time.  For the most part, we barely know these people.  We see prepared packages about them and interviews where the players have been coached how to respond.

 

I don't feel stupid for having believed what was reported as truth.  I feel stupid for being surprised and shocked.

 

On the believability front, I think this is the snap judgement reaction: A lie has been exposed so therefore everything surrounding said incident must also be a lie.

 

I think Brian's article sums up pretty well that the story should not really be surprising and any outrage should be directed towards MSM which has turned into narrative building and story telling for ratings as opposed to actual journalism.

DonAZ

January 17th, 2013 at 1:23 PM ^

"... narrative building and story telling for ratings as opposed to actual journalism."

Those who wave the banner of "journalists" are the least likely to actually practice the craft.

"Bloggers" are maligned, yet they consistently produce the most insightful commentary ... sports or otherwise.  Not all bloggers, but many.