OT - Disturbing racially motivated locker room assault

Submitted by Hard-Baughlls on

Saw this on ESPN.  Very disturbing story about a Mississippi high school sophomore assaulted in the locker room with a noose put around his neck.  I've been on sports team and seen some hazing, but never anything this nasty or racially motivated.

Not to over-generalize a population or demographics, but I always do wonder about African American kids staying in the south / SEC to play football in college.  I understand many of these kids are from that region and want to stay close to home and that racism could exist anywhere, but I always find it strange when at Ole Miss or Bama games you see confederate flags and symbolism in the same stadiums where they cheer on their beloved team, usually with 50%+ black players.

http://www.espn.com/espn/otl/story/_/id/17879404/mississippi-high-schoo…

Edit: I caught the same story on CNN, so it's more than just a sports story now.  I think it's a horrible event obviously, but a good opportunity to have this discussion and educate young people as to why this behavior is disgusting and what it means to have empathy for your fellow man. 

http://www.cnn.com/2016/10/25/us/mississippi-school-noose-incident-trnd…

 

 

ElBictors

October 25th, 2016 at 9:08 AM ^

I went from being the only white family on our block in Chicago metro to northern Michigan where there was one black student in my grade and he had been adopted by a white family. I live now in the 'black neighborhood' (traditionally) in Denver and have had a group of friends from MS when I lived in vail. To me, there are different aspects of racism. In norther MI it was racism borne of ignorance and with only white folks around, a lot of ignorant comments and stupid things said and phrases like 'N-word City' used to describe Detroit and Chicago. The MS (and Texas) crew used to drop N-Bombs intentionally to get a rise out of me and were much more spiteful in their language and expression. And I have also traveled pretty extensively to the South and lived in ATL during the 96 Olympics and from my observations, segregation in the south is accepted and preferred by both communities. It's just a different world there and while racism is everywhere still, there is something almost eerie about traveling into the rural south and feeling like it's still 1964. What an awful story but clearly still a thing that happens. But hate has to be taught - my son wasn't born hating anyone and even at almost 10yrs old now, has more disdain - jokingly - for buckeye fans than any other group of people and even there, we talk about respect and mutual admiration for the rivalry.

Ali G Bomaye

October 25th, 2016 at 9:24 AM ^

Racism exists in the north, too, but it's different. In the south, racism is focused more on maintaining the existing power hierarchy - having white people take predence over black people. In the north, racism is more subtle, and centers around de facto segregation - white people tend to live and work in separate areas in black people. Many major northern cities, such as Detroit, Chicago, and Boston, are segregated into "white" and "black" neighborhoods far more than most southern cities are.

ElBictors

October 25th, 2016 at 9:32 AM ^

I'm not sure I agree with the last sentence but this topic and the replies are largely based on opinion and personal experience. Segregation exists everywhere and if you look at the history of cities like Benton Harbor and Muskegon, you have a much different story than larger cities in the north like Detroit and Chicago.

sheepdog

October 25th, 2016 at 9:11 AM ^

I have lived in Birmingham Alabama for over 20 years and I have never seen a race based incident in sports, much less anything else. This kind of stuff is isolated and the school administration will expel these kids, no question.



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

mgoblue0970

October 25th, 2016 at 2:17 PM ^

I had a job which took me to Birmingham and Montgomery a few times a year.  I totally agree with you about Birmingham.  A deep south city which has its shit together was really refreshing.  Montgomery is a whole other story though.

MGlobules

October 25th, 2016 at 9:13 AM ^

I grew up in Michigan and on the East Coast, my parents were civil rights workers who went south with the Freedom Riders; I grew up marching with them in NY and DC. And I ended up in Tallahassee, Florida. I know that Jim Crow dominated in the south, but my study of history has come to show me how much racism--especially redlining--existed everywhere, creating a situation where most of the country's most segregated cities today, starting with Chi, Milwaukee, and Philly, lie in the north. It's especially the persistent poverty of black people, as much as attitudes that keep this shit in place. And this really grows out of the least-known part of our history, where for 100 years after slavery black people suffered continued subjugation in near-slavery conditions instead of being able to exercise their supposed new freedoms. (All of this set the patterns for the for-profit criminal justice system we have today.) Not trying to accuse anyone of anything, because I am no different, but what I have come to see is that although many of my northern friends are all for integration, outraged by southern ugly (of which there is plenty), many of them have just one or two black acquaintances and live in what is effectively segregated conditions, too. My evidence is only anecdotal, but I and my family have ended up with many more black friends, in an integrated neighborhood and day to day conditions, than we ever had living anywhere in the north--from NYC to Ann Arbor to San Francisco. The modern Klan comes from Indiana; it was there, recently, that high school sports fans shouted for a mostly hispanic football team to "go home." Michigan has its militias, etc. In short, we all have a long way to go and this thing is damned complex. I still believe that things are getting better, though, and that we are becoming a culture of many cultures that will eventually sweep a lot of this away.

ElBictors

October 25th, 2016 at 9:40 AM ^

I think in some ways the more overt expression in some regions is less 'dangerous' than the covert and systemic expression in places deemed to be more enlightened. And certainly racism like the story in the OP is horrible but it's also a more traditional Black/White19th/20th Century racism. What were heading into now and the hot button folks like Trump are hitting is different and racism or bigotry against other ethnic groups is the new intolerance. Latinos, Muslims ....them.

FrankMurphy

October 25th, 2016 at 12:19 PM ^

I was born and raised in Ann Arbor and now live in the SF Bay Area. Despite its reputation as a liberal paradise, in many ways Northern California is more segregated than Michigan and probably even many parts of the South. It's extremely rare to meet an African American engineer or white collar worker in Silicon Valley. There isn't a shortage of people of color in the tech sector per se, but most of them are engineers from the Indian Subcontinent or other Asian countries who came here on H1B visas. Management and executives are overwhelmingly White, engineers and product managers are overwhelmingly White and Asian, and support staff and blue collar workers are trending towards overwhelmingly Latino. In terms of residential demographics, there are many areas in the Peninsula and the North Bay that are overwhelmingly White, and many areas in the East Bay and San Jose that are overwhelmingly Asian. There are very few spaces around here where people of different racial, ethnic, and socioeconomic backgrounds freely mix or are made to feel welcome. Contrast that with Ann Arbor, where you went to Briarwood Mall and Gallup Park growing up no matter what race or socioeconomic bracket you were a part of.

mgoblue0970

October 25th, 2016 at 5:09 PM ^

I hired a kid out of Kettering (formerly known as GMI) who is a great ME.  I was having dinner with his family one night and we were talking about the lack of AA engineers.  Dad told me how his son got bullied all the time, because in the words of Ohio State, "we didn't come here to play school".

This kid was a sellout to his peers because he studied hard and wanted to make something of himself.

I guess the bullying got pretty violent and the family had to move out of the city for the kid's safety.

Discussions about race and profession are very complex... much more than the muckrakers would have one believe.

In this case, the notion that seeing an African American engineer is rare, is understandable because inner city public schools, for example, are a mess (DPS graduates about 25% of its freshman 4 years later), for a lot of these kids, there isn't a stable home-life, and the environment doesn't support someone from the inner city going into STEM -- and if they do, they're violating group norms and get subjected to all the consequences of that.

 

Z_Wolverista

October 25th, 2016 at 2:35 PM ^

I don't have the time to fully do justice to.

I lived in the Bay Area for ten years, and still have a toehold there (am back in the Midwest now).

A good friend worked for an anti-redlining org in the Mission. 

The segregation you are seeing is the results of concerted gentrification efforts (called "development") that have gone hand-in-hand with the tech boom (& re-boom, circa Twitter's IPO).

Gender (anti-domestic violence) & sexuality (Newsom's strategy) movements have been used divisively to further gentrification / development agendas over the last six to ten years.

The Filmore, a traditionally African American neighborhood in SF, has pretty recently been decimated, for example.

I campaigned against efforts these -- as a feminist -- to no avail.

SF (& Oakland) looked very different in the 90's. POC friends who've stuck it out in the city are telling me they feel pretty lonely. Most folks of color have fled.

As for Ann Arbor, surrounding areas, & Briarwood, etc. -- I have heard plenty of hard stuff from black & brown friends & acquaintances. I remember being struck by a gay Black classmate's bitter statement way back when when he said Detroit felt way more welcoming to him (despite being gay) than Ann Arbor ever did (being Black).

A South Asian friend growing up just north of Ann Arbor remembers being called a "Sand N----" & other racist words & actions from her classmates at Pioneer.

So I don't think the generalizations hold, and

timing (and concerted political effort) has a lot to do with it.

Of course, "diversity" is celebrated all along...

 

FrankMurphy

October 25th, 2016 at 7:15 PM ^

Interesting background; thanks for sharing that info. 

I agree that Michigan and Ann Arbor have a long way to go on race relations (as does America at large). I personally experienced overt racism from students and teachers alike as a Muslim kid growing up and attending public schools in Saline and Ann Arbor (and it would probably be worse today, given how prevalent and socially acceptable Islamophobia is nowadays). But the most unsettling phenomenon that I noticed when I moved to the Bay Area from Ann Arbor in 2007 was the near-total absense of African Americans from professional sectors and white collar suburbs and the self-segregation of entire cities and towns. For all its flaws, Ann Arbor was a lot more diverse in that respect. My parents used to live in a fairly affluent neighborhood in the Ann Arbor-Saline Rd. area of Pittsfield Township, and they had a lot more African-American neighbors there than I've had in the four different neighborhoods I've lived in since I moved to the Bay combined. 

ats

October 25th, 2016 at 9:21 PM ^

Filmore changes weren't really an issue of gentrification or tech moving in.  By the time the original dotcom boom started, the old Filmore was largely already gone with the last remenents of what was left already pushed south of Geary.  During the heyday of the Filmore as an african american community it stretched from Geary to basically the top of the hill almost to Jackson.  The Filmore was much more a casuality of the death of the manufacturing and shipping industries in SF in the 70s and 80s with lingering effect of the military shutdown in SF as well.  There was little to anything left of the old filmore by the 90s, before Netscape was even an idea. 

As far as "development" being responsible for segregation in the bay area.  At least in SF, the distinct lack of development is the driving culprit.  The change in housing stock in SF over the last 30 years is basically nil.  That basically means that everyone who isn't in tech is getting priced out of the market.  The only viable long term solution is to build significantly more housing stock.  That is once again being blocked by those opposed to gentrification, resulting in even faster gentrification.  Having been here long enough to see multiple of these cycles play out, gentrification in SF is the result of not new bigger buildings fast enough.  Too much leading with the heart, not enough leading with the brain. 

gbdub

October 25th, 2016 at 9:44 AM ^

Mississippi is part of America too. "Rednecks" are Americans too (and many face the challenges of poverty and poor educational options we tend to ascribe to urban minorities). Maybe we ought to be sympathetic to the victim and do some soul searching of our own ("there but for the grace of God go I") rather than use this a a chance to morally preen about how much better we are than those nasty Southerners?



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

StraightDave

October 25th, 2016 at 10:49 AM ^

only white people can be racist.  

By the way, I can say that all I want because I'm half Mexican and if you call me out then you are being racist.   

Hard-Baughlls

October 25th, 2016 at 12:14 PM ^

If it was a social experiment of the mgoblog community, it showed how we could have incredibly diverse opinions on the topic yet stay civil and discuss rationally...and then you showed up.  Thanks.

mgoblue0970

October 25th, 2016 at 2:04 PM ^

Sorry, but the cogent discourse was gone before Dave showed up.

If you're talking about social experiments, I think the notion that people are more focused on the demographics of an entertainment  event rather than simply enjoying the show is pretty damn telling.

Z_Wolverista

October 25th, 2016 at 2:51 PM ^

B.S.

People of color can be prejudiced. Call it racist, fine. I've encountered plenty of ish from other people of color -- we learn about each other from the mainstream, after all. Plus. At least you get to be American, if you're here. So there's incentive for being xenophobic, both for folks of color & poor whites.

But the weight of history & the power of institutions are still largely colored by white supremacy.

And here in the middle of the country, mainstream culture is pretty white too, in a way that often excludes those of us who aren't (gotta love how the local paper still assumes its readers -- the "us" it addresses -- are white Americans, for example, deciding what take to assume re: "them" -- whether immigrants or BLM'ers). That's just one example.

p.s. and no, being mixed race does not make you immune from being called out for idiotic, sarcastic comments that don't really contribute to the conversation.

 

 

 

Mr. Yost

October 25th, 2016 at 5:05 PM ^

Don't feed him.

Should be banned for trying to ruin what I'd argue is the best thread we've had on this site in months.

I will say this though. People use "racist" and "racism" too much when they truly mean "bigot." One could also be both. Then you also have "prejudice."

I'm no English major, clearly. I'm terrible in that aspect, but I DO think if you're going to discuss sensitive these topics you need to know the difference because the person you're communicating with may know the difference.

I find that it helps to get over yet another communication hurdle when trying to talk about these things...and anytime you can easily move a hurdle in these instances, you have to do it, because there's just too much to work through (with these topics) to not take care of the easy stuff, IMO.

 

L'Carpetron Do…

October 25th, 2016 at 11:20 AM ^

A lot of those southern teams seem way more than 50%+ African American. 

I've noticed this in the past but its been bothering me a lot more lately.  A lot of these southern teams seem overwhelmingly black, but the entire coaching will be white and of course the crowd is overwhelmingly white.  I feel like its very rare to see black fans in the stands or student section.  And then you hear stories about how horribly racist the student body is (Exhibit A: Missouri 2015) and you wonder what is going on there.

I know Michigan's football and basketball teams are predominantly black.  But there seems to be a difference between Big 10 teams and those southern schools.  I tend to believe ALL student athletes are exploited but I think its worse for black kids, especially at SEC schools (I also like to think that kids at Big 10 institutions get a better education than most but I could be wrong).  Maybe that's just the liberal Yankee in me. 

Also - does anyone else think its a little weird when certain white coaches recruit strictly all black dudes?  Is that weird?  I mean, I guess there's nothing wrong with it but I think its weird.  I think too much.

mgoblue0970

October 25th, 2016 at 1:54 PM ^

does anyone else think its a little weird when certain white coaches recruit strictly all black dudes?
Bobby Bowden said 20+ years ago he recruits speed first. You can make your own conclusions... and there was a lot more to that interview that would be considered highly offensive by today's standards. So no, it's not weird.

Mr. Yost

October 25th, 2016 at 5:19 PM ^

There are white coaches who "recruit strictly all black dudes?"

Who?

...as for the rest of your post. I don't completely agree or disagree. In the sports you seem to be referring to (football and basketball, cause it sure as hell ain't golf or tennis), I don't think you can make a generalize about majority black teams without looking at who's playing the sport before they get to college.

So what's the breakdown of the starting pool? If it's majority black, then obviously you're going to get majority black college teams in football and basketball...right?

You also have to take into account who's excelling in your starting pool. Why? Because college football and basketball are competitive, so even if your starting pool is 50/50, but those who excel are majority black...well, once again, you're going to end up with majority black college football and basketball players.

So that covers the student athlete side.

As for the fans...I think one thing you have to take into consideration in addition to your comments is the economics for that particular team. Who has the money to pay to see the black football or basketball team? Tickets aren't cheap and many have been passed down from generation to generation.

So again, that's not the ANSWER...but I'm saying you have to take these things into consideration.

The coaching comment you made, I have nothing to add to that. The only thing I can think of is that when these sports were really "started"...you didn't have black coaches or quarterbacks. I'd be interested to know how many (white) D1 football coaches either played QB or are a son to a former coach.

The QB position is starting to change, but you still can't get little black kids wanting to grow up and be a footall or basketball coach like dad if there aren't very many black head coaches. 

ANYWAY...

I don't think you're 100% off, I just think it was too much of a generalization and didn't take into account some very obvious factors. It sort of paints this picture of the gladiators of Rome and a bunch of white people cheering on a bunch of black men bashing their heads in and playing a sport for their entertainment...and that's obviously overkill.

bronxblue

October 25th, 2016 at 11:28 AM ^

Can we all just admit this is terrible and could happen anywhere?  I'll knock the South as much as anyone, but people doing racially inappropriate things, especially kids, is sort of universal.

Ezekiel2131

October 25th, 2016 at 1:12 PM ^

Honestly, this doesn't surprise me. I played high school ball in the gulf coast of Mississippi. Can confirm that most teams there are redneck trash. The talent down there isn't that great either, which is why the highly touted QB Myles Brennan has inflated passing stats. 

The Legion

October 25th, 2016 at 1:16 PM ^

It gets too cold for most of the players to come up here to play football. At least that is what they are told by SEC coaches' negative recruiting pitch for why to not go up north to play football. 

Wendyk5

October 25th, 2016 at 2:46 PM ^

We live in Evanston which is racially and economically mixed. It's probably close to 50/50, but if you look more closely, there are many latinos, eastern european immigrants, muslims, and sikhs that round out the diverse population. My son is starting to look at colleges and one of his criteria is diversity. I've had to tell him that he will not get the kind of diversity he's used to at Evanston Township High School. His friends are mostly of color, but there is self-segregation as the kids move through grade and middle school. But I think they learn to respect each others' differences. My son is somewhat shocked if I ever say anything even remotely biased. I certainly don't know how to fix the race problem, but being next to each other in every day circumstances day in and day out helps. It's difficult not to have biases; but it shouldn't be that hard not to have this kind of hate.  

Wendyk5

October 25th, 2016 at 4:41 PM ^

Black/white. It's probably more like 40/40 black/white, and then 20 other. They enacted a law back in the 70's that no grade school can be more than 60% of one race, and they zoned with that in mind.

 

Edit: I checked on the website and there's a growing Latino population. The breakdown is:

43% white

30% black

16% latino

4% Asian

7% other 

1975Blue

October 25th, 2016 at 5:52 PM ^

What about the "disturbing" attacks that happened after the recent Temple football game ?  Groups of "teens" attacked students, and several white students received beatings.  Guess who the "teens" were.   Don't mention one story witout the other.     

Fenrir the Righteous

October 25th, 2016 at 7:43 PM ^

I remember as a tween in the nineties people saying: this will all die out once the real racists age out of power/die. Now I'm wondering if that was 100% delusion particular to my all white part of New England, or if it really is another surge whereby it's "fashionable" for (some) people in high school today, most obvious with fans cheering or players hazing in us/them scenarios. Some initial comments from school officials in this case make it clear they were NOT prepared for this to go national.

Yessir

October 25th, 2016 at 7:56 PM ^

UC Berkeley wants, or some students want, 'no white people zones'?  Just people of color are allowed?

This country seems to be in a mess. 

cali4444

October 25th, 2016 at 8:28 PM ^

happened to this kid, but thousands of kids all across this nation we're bullied or worse today.  Kids are targeted for being black, white, fat, weird, skinny, special-needs, loners...you name it.  As a white kid who spent two years in a predominantly black high school i can promise you I knew nothing but intimidation or just plain being ignored.  The later of the two was a "good" day. You won't hear about this in the news though. This is not meant to belittle what this kid went through...its inexcusable and my heart goes out to him.  With that being said, I'd take my chances as a black kid in a white school as opposed to the opposite.