Hello: Deveon Smith
March 17th, 2012 at 10:27 PM ^
Ty still has his chance.
Take your time, Ty, make a good decision...and come to Michigan.
YAAAY
LET'S GET BOMBED!!!!
Where I hear the Western fans are being very rude. But he can take it.
The hockey game is at JLA in Detroit so probably not.
March 17th, 2012 at 10:25 PM ^
behind the silly post. Because it is at JLA, besides being impractical, would it be a recruiting violation to take a recruit up the road for the host school's game?
there are 300 players on that right now. They haven't done their actual top 150 yet.
There have been questions about his game translating to other levels. I believe i recall Magnus saying Smith is more of a sure fire prospect, while Isaac has a higher ceiling but isn't such a certainty to live up to expectations.
March 17th, 2012 at 11:24 PM ^
March 17th, 2012 at 11:46 PM ^
16 year old high school students, both elite althletes and you're projecting one guy (who plays lesser competition) as better than another guy (who is pretty much his equal in the ratings). Both of them are excellent; I'll be happy with either and if Isaac chooses to go Blue then great...
Your logic related to "if you want to win NC's" you need to risk on high ceiling athletes is ridiculous. Give me a team of "low ceiling" four star players and some real depth and the National Championships will come (with some luck, lack of injuries etc.).
Calling a great high school athlete who chooses to commit to Michigan "a capituation to very good but not to the level of the best" is asinine.
Please return your three star mafia card ASAP.
We're really talking about a more philosophical debate about would you rather consistently win conference championsips, or pop up every now and again and win NCs. Would you be satisfied with another Bo era of 13 B1G chsmpionships in 21 seasons but a terrible bowl record and no NCs, or would you rather risk it all for an NC? I really don't gave an answer to that, and it's an honest question every fan base should ask.
Not to mention the fact that Auburn had Cam Newton, who was a solid 5 star on rivals when he committed to Florida. He would have given Auburn a really nice bump in the final recruiting rankings if he went there to begin with.
Why is this redundant?
Double post, don't know why that happened.
go ahead and take your low ceiling 4*, ill take the high ceiling 5* and you can watch play for a nation championship.
signed,
USC,LSU,and Alabama
Maybe I should have invited simplistic analysis to follow my comment.
The point is that nobody knows, really, if there is any actual variance in talent between these two kids. You have a small sample of recruiting analysts saying one guy is 5 star and another is 4 star. The five star plays inferior competition and *might* have a higher ceiling. He's 16, however, so in both cases there is no guarantee. I'll take 4 star depth all day and take my chances on the coaching staff figuring out which guy has the higher ceiling (as opposed to Alan Trieu and the rest of your heroes).
March 17th, 2012 at 11:50 PM ^
Not every player on a NC team is a 5* worldbeater. Our loaded defense from 1997 had one all-world guy, some solid NFL talent, and guys like Glen Steele whose NFL experience was only slightly more significant than yours or mine. Alabama and LSU played in the title game with decidedly average quarterbacks, and while perhaps their fans had the same gripe you do they seemed to be just fine for most of the year.
Couldn't agree more. I think Smith has a huge future ahead of him, particularly in a pro-style offense. I would love to have both Smith and Isaac, but now that we have Smith, I won't be disappointed if we don't get Isaac too... keeping in mind that before this year's unprecedented recruiting phenomenon, I think most of us would have be ecstatic to have Smith.
March 17th, 2012 at 11:01 PM ^
look at that picture!
March 17th, 2012 at 10:57 PM ^
The way you describe Ty Isaac, sounds like a critique of Tyrone Wheatley. I'd take 2 years of that without hesitation.
I really feel like Isaac was alwaysgoing to end up at USC. Not sure why just a gut thing though.
I'll take Smith though....I honestly never thought there was that much difference between the 2.
Cox has no bearing on the amount of scholarships we can take in the 2013 class.
He should have pulled trigger last week.
March 17th, 2012 at 10:31 PM ^
Let's disparage a potential recruit...really smart.
Ty knew this was a possibility and there is still a spot for him.
but i still want isaac watch his highlights UNBELIEVABLE!
Honestly, I have never watched highlights of prospects until they commit to Michigan, I find it rather pointless, let's be happy with who we have, Smith wants to wear the winged helmet and I like him just for that, the coaches know what they're doing, we'll see what happens with Isaac in the future, but a bird in hand is worth way more than two in the bush, I'm not really looking forward for rollercoaster recruitment in which we end up with our hands empty.
If we don't get Isaac, it will only be because he didn't want to come. There is no way the coaches would turn him down.
100% agree. The eventual position of Shallman is not in competition with what both Deveon and Isaac bring to the table.... think Aaron Shea..... or Shonte Orr.
March 18th, 2012 at 10:20 AM ^
lets also remember that these guys have their senior year left to play. i know we are bringing shallman in as an offensive player but if he just blows up on the defensive side of the ball next season the coaches would def give him consideration as a defensive commit. nothing is set in stone this early in the process
Welcome Deveon!
His film looks great, as does Isaac's. Michigan was in a no-lose situation here.
I think he'll be perfect. We need a guy that can really pound the ball into the endzone.