TTUwolverine

History

Member for

4 years 5 weeks

Blog

View recent blog entries

Karma

Current value

2

Recent Comments

Date	Title	Body
6 days 17 hours ago	I mean... yeah	Sadly you're probably right.
6 days 17 hours ago	I don't buy that.	Scholarship pulled because a dude put rap videos online?  That doesn't make any sense, and if it is true, I think it is an excuse to get rid of a guy they may have regretted offering in the first place.  That is a "son, you need to remove the videos and run stadium steps" kind of offense, not a scholarship removal.
6 days 20 hours ago	Dante Booker.	Dude has an offer, but I haven't seen anything about this guy.  I'm assuming he is a Buckeye lock and/or hasn't shown much interest?  Thought it was relevant given that he is a 6'3" linebacker out of Ohio, and it seems like a guy the coaches would be pushing hard for.
1 week 3 days ago	I keed... I keed.	I admittedly took one look at the dude, and stuck him at WDE in this scenario.  I could be wrong, since I know nothing about watching film, but he seemed like he had a long ways to go to get big enough for the SDE spot.  Who knows though... Frank Clark is now 275 lbs.
1 week 4 days ago	This can work just fine.	Lawrence Marshall - WDE (Take THAT, Magnus) DeShawn Hand - SDE Malik McDowell - 3T DT (dude is almost 300 lbs) Bryan Mone - NT Not only does this work out just fine as listed, Hand, McDowell and Mone offer enough individual versatility that they could rotate positions and offer a lot of different looks.  Taking 4 DL in a small class might be a bit excessive but whateva.
1 week 5 days ago	Comment win.	"The bear had a hankerin for some Rhesus Pieces." I LOL'd at that one.  LOL'd real good.
1 week 6 days ago	"Nearly a decade"	Ugh.  Time is a bitch, man.
2 weeks 2 hours ago	It very well could be.	All I'm saying is that the decision should be with the player, not the coaches.  I don't think there is anything wrong with saying "Hey, kid.  We just don't think you've got the ability to ever play meaningful snaps here.  You're welcome to stay on the team for the full four years, but if you want playing time your best option might be to transfer."
2 weeks 16 hours ago	I apologize in advance for my language.	...but FUCK yeah.  The Wings dominated all of overtime, and to come away with a loss here would have been the end of it.
2 weeks 17 hours ago	Yeah I agree on this 100%	It's gotta go both ways for sure.  It baffles me as to why it doesn't.
2 weeks 18 hours ago	This.	You said it better than I could have.  It gives coaches a lot more leeway to recruit guys that might be academic or criminal risks as well.  Trust your scouting, and if you end up with a guy who wasn't as good as you thought, tough cookies.  That's the risk in amateur sports.  Now, if you want to give these kids a salary, the whole ballgame changes.
2 weeks 20 hours ago	There is another element to this too.	If a coaches were allowed to do the above, they should not get a reprieve from the scholarship cap.  So, if they don't want the kid to suit up, fine, but his scholarship will continue to count against the cap.  In this case, there really wouldn't be any downside to keeping the player on the team.  I think there should be exceptions made in cases where a kid is injured to the point where playing football is clearly medically unsafe or not physically possible, but not for guys who just won't be good enough to start.  Otherwise I think it offers too great of an incentive to kick a kid off the team.
2 weeks 21 hours ago	I mean, to each his own.	But I totally disagree with you here.  If the doctors clear a guy to play, even if the player is likely not going to be 100% afterward, the school should be required to honor the scholarship and allow the player to remain on the team if the player wishes to do so.
2 weeks 22 hours ago	Exactly.	Many others above mentioned more or less the same thing, but yes, this is what I was getting at.  This may or may not even be relevant, since we don't know whether or not Ringer was even offered a medical hardship.
2 weeks 22 hours ago	...	While you are correct that I did only have one data point, I also did not try to make any sweeping accusations of widespread oversigning with this data point either.  I am a random dude on the internet, and therefore I do not have any insider information pertaining to the situation that would suggest wrongdoing.  But that doesn't mean that it shouldn't be discussed, even if it ends up simply being an exercise in reaffirming that there is nothing to see here.  At the very least, the arguments below provide a handy list of reasons why this is a legitimate situation for those who may have cocked a suspicious eyebrow at this story.  I would argue that this is meaningful discussion.  And for the record, I am with you and the others that this situation is 99.9% likely to be legitimate.
2 weeks 22 hours ago	All of the above posters raise good points.	And, as mentioned above in response to CRex, the primary purpose of this post was to foster a discussion about oversigning in general.  It is no secret that Brian is a very vocal in his opposition to oversigning, as is the rest of the fanbase.  As such, I think it's important to discuss situations like this one, and to make a clear distinction between what happened here versus the rampant oversigning that goes on in the SEC.
2 weeks 22 hours ago	Fair enough.	Many of those things may very well be true, and are probably likely.  But, it is a valid topic to at least address if we as a fanbase are going to ride upon the high horse of oversigning immorality.  My tone was not intended to be accusatory, but rather to foster discussion about why this is different as opposed to just ignoring it.
2 weeks 23 hours ago	hmm...	In my mind, a medical hardship was designed for a player who is injured to the point that playing football again would be medically unsafe... NOT for a player who may have lost a step or two, but would otherwise still be "safe" to play.  When I see players offered medical hardships going to play at other places, even if it is at a lower level of competition, that strikes me as an oversigning red flag.  Should I be thinking otherwise?
2 weeks 23 hours ago	Ok, this is probably going to get firebombed.	What is the difference between what just happened, and oversigning?  Clearly the Michigan roster had one too many scholarship players, and as such Michigan was obligated to shed one scholarship before summer practices.  At face value, that fits the definition of oversigning, although obviously not to the extreme that other schools (ahemSECahem) take it to.  Clearly, we don't know many details about the situation, and it's entirely possible that coaches and Ringer both knew about this pending transfer long ago... and it very well could be mutual.  Still, I just... feel a little dirty about it.  Thoughts?
2 weeks 1 day ago	You must be a White Sox fan.	In which case, this thread could actually be an anti-jinx.  Thanks!
2 weeks 5 days ago	So what happens...	If Dave Brandon signs Twitter to an advertisement contract?  Would it be allowed?  What if this was Dave Brandon's master plan all along?
2 weeks 6 days ago	Fair enough.	That was a bit of a douche move... but only a minor one as far as I'm concerned.  I agree that  it's a little weird that he would put that out in the media too.
2 weeks 6 days ago	So...	I mean... I get the not going public about it thing... but I can't get outraged by this.  Why should the school pay for an extra semester of summer classes when the guy is planning on transferring to play for another team the following semester?
2 weeks 6 days ago	Presented without comment.
3 weeks 22 hours ago	Yeah...	plus 2010 was a 100% Rich Rod class.  MSU has been owned by Hoke on the recruiting trail since almost the second he stepped foot on campus, and 2010 isn't really relevant to what's happening now.
3 weeks 1 day ago	Woo!	Complete with two bonus baserunners!
3 weeks 1 day ago	Oh goody.	Valverde in a non-save situation.  This should be fun. [EDIT... or not.]
3 weeks 2 days ago	I will wager one dollar.	That this schedule is moot within a year due to more expansion.
3 weeks 3 days ago	I be like dang.	I be like dang.
3 weeks 4 days ago	Maybe it's time...	that the Butterfly emerges from his cocoon. Thanks... thanks.  I'll be here all night.

more